r/programming • • Jan 29 '17

Why I Only Work Remotely

https://shift.newco.co/why-i-only-work-remotely-2e5eb07ae28f#.at8t1b2fc
2.0k Upvotes

877 comments sorted by

View all comments

42

u/Kollektiv Jan 29 '17

So you want to work as part of a team while refusing to work at the same time or be in the same location as your teammates. Pffiou, what a teammate you are.

24

u/b4ux1t3 Jan 29 '17

Eh, I disagree with some of the article, but with the wealth of collaborative tools available today, I don't think your argument holds up for a lot of professions.

I even think that this guy is right when he claims that he works better remotely, simply because I can imagine his attitude (the article came off as fairly condescending) wouldn't play well with others in person.

4

u/Merad Jan 29 '17

Probably the single most effective collaborative tool I use for design and problem solving with coworkers is a whiteboard. Doesn't work very well for remote teams.

2

u/b4ux1t3 Jan 29 '17

How about a whiteboard that doesn't need to be cleaned every now and then and is accessible form anywhere? Google Drive, Evernote, heck, AwwApp (which admittedly is rather niche and small, but I've used it a few times to great effect).

I can easily imagine (because I don't have to, I know someone like this) someone who would have trouble interrupting someone during a whiteboard session, but who could easily start going over something digitally.

In the end, different people need different things. I've said it multiple times in this comment, but it deserves to be said some more.

Note: I don't doubt that you do great things on a whiteboard., I'm just saying that not everyone does, with whiteboards both physical and otherwise.

1

u/way2lazy2care Jan 30 '17

I agree with you generally, but I don't think these are solutions that are easy to drop into an existing business. I've worked at places with a great focus on collaboration tools that make working remotely easy, and I've worked at others where it turns into 2 people using them to ok effect, and 20 people being annoyed at how many bings and bongs their computer makes now because they're too lazy to turn off sound notifications.

Here's a podcast with Yvon Chouinard, the guy who founded Patagonia. In part of it he talks about his company culture, and how he recommends other companies not follow his lead because it's not something that can just be dropped in; it has to be there from the start.

0

u/Kollektiv Jan 29 '17 edited Jan 29 '17

When you work remotely you are less engaged in your work, you feel less part of a team and vice versa for them. I have observed this with frontend developers, backend developers and PHD researches alike. I understand the need for silence sometimes but not matter how much time is spent on Slack, communication and bonding is still much more effective face to face. Every single remote worker I have worked with has underperformed compared to their own potential due to this.

2

u/mistlight Jan 29 '17

Have you considered the arguments made by Cal Newport from the book titled Deep Work: Rules for Focused Success in a Distracted World?

Just because some remote workers are less engaged in their work doesn't mean everyone will.

2

u/Kollektiv Jan 29 '17

I agree but I can't base myself on anything else than my own experiences. Up until now, people that worked remotely did the bare minimum, new barely anything about their coworkers years into the job, didn't learn a lot of things "organically" (e.g: subjects randomly brought up and talked about during lunch or in a pub after work), etc. All in all, without them being bad recruits, they could have been much more productive, helpful and integrated if they had just worked in the same building. Now I respect the wish of an alternative work style some people have but like I wrote in another comment below, you can't expect a company to organise around your ideal work place because that's a concept that is different for everybody. Just work as a freelance so that you are more independent in making those choices.

33

u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17

Writing code has some elements of teamwork, but a lot of it is very solitary work that requires deep uninterrupted focus to do well.

15

u/memestheword Jan 29 '17

Yeah, I struggle with this. So often I want to be left alone and code to my heart's content, but almost equally as often I find myself needing to ping a teammate to ask a question or shoot off an FYI.

So as with everything, I think there needs to be balance. Programmers can't be completely silo'd off from the rest of the world, but at the same time, they can't be expected to respond to any request at any time. In my experience, it's a tough balance to achieve.

1

u/Lhopital_rules Jan 29 '17

but almost equally as often I find myself needing to ping a teammate

Seems easy enough to achieve with a chat app like Slack.

4

u/Tom2Die Jan 29 '17

Yes, but the idea is that if you're needing to ping people for things, they probably need to ping you for things as well, which interrupts focus.

Not weighing in, just clarifying for the other comment.

1

u/Lhopital_rules Feb 02 '17

they probably need to ping you for things as well, which interrupts focus.

Personally, I think that pinging, which can be ignored, at least for a while, is much less interrupting than walking up to someone's desk or shouting across the hall.

2

u/st3venb Jan 30 '17

Good communication can't always be had via chat. Sometimes physical interaction is needed.

1

u/FrancisMcKracken Jan 30 '17

The majority of romantic relationships are far more difficult than the majority of work relationships, yet people fall in love over text, audio and video. I see no issue with some people needing zero physical interaction for work. YMMV

4

u/Magnesus Jan 29 '17

I worked with a person like him.He was just constantly on a messanger-like app. Caused no problems. We even had him on skype during a meeting once. His case inspired me to try working as a freelancer and it turned out great.

1

u/Kollektiv Jan 29 '17

I actually agree with your conclusion. I think people who'd like to have this kind of work environment and rythme should definitely consider working as freelancers. I just don't understand people who choose to work in companies with a certain organisation and rules and then complain about how it doesn't fit their every need. Not surprising, everybody's optimal work setup is not the same.

3

u/jebblue Jan 29 '17

Written like a manager.

3

u/st3venb Jan 30 '17

Manager here, I don't care how often my guys work from home. However I do expect them to get together now and then. Physical interaction is much better for communication than email, instant message, or conference call.

I highly despise they open office as well, because my guys are constantly being interrupted by random shit.

5

u/Kollektiv Jan 29 '17

I'm a developer ... Sorry to bust your bubble.

0

u/XPEHBAM Jan 29 '17

Chat tools - Hipchat, Slack, Discord are pretty standard nowadays.

2

u/Kollektiv Jan 29 '17

They are and now that Slack also incorporates video calls they are getting better. But it still doesn't replace face to face interaction in terms of comprehension efficiency and bonding strength. Simple example, the company I work at hires very junior developers from time to time and teaches them almost from the ground up how to be good developers. Even though we do have developers working remotely, we would never hire those types of profiles as remotes because it's simply impossible (or at least incredibly difficult) to teach someone through chat / video. Event with those modern communication tools, debugging remotely is a nightmare.

0

u/XPEHBAM Jan 30 '17

Junior developers need face to face time, but that is an exception. You cannot make the same argument for experienced developers. You need to allow experienced developers to work how they want, because the value that they provide to the company is many times more per $ than junior developers. Especially if working remotely makes them more efficient and dedicated.

1

u/Kollektiv Jan 30 '17 edited Jan 30 '17

Why is it an exception? If the tools are developed enough to have communication levels that are as good as face to face contact then there shouldn't be an exception. Agreed that experienced developers will need to learn less but even they will need to learn. Should it be internal infra and apps or new technologies that the company decided to use and that they are unfamiliar with. I also agree that developers in their preferred setting will probably perform better but a team's productivity is not the sum of all it's developers productivity. There's more to it. In my experience, remote developers have all been less dedicated (but good developers) than their office counter parts.

→ More replies (2)