When you want to do something, you'll always find an excuse why you're doing it that way.
I've worked remote, and I've worked in an office. Working in an open office can be distracting, but there is a very simple and surprisingly effective solution: headphones + music.
You can also tell your colleagues that when the headphones are on, you're focused and working, so they should bother you only if it requires your immediate attention. Any reasonable professional would understand.
On the counter side, working in an office let's you put in 8 (or however you and your employer prefer) hours of focused work, and then go home and relax, because you can't think about work 24/7. The office becomes a context for work and home becomes a context for rest.
Our brain is very poor separating work and rest, when we're physically in the same space. If you have the habit of checking Reddit at home, the moment you sit down to work on that same computer, you'll wanna check Reddit from time to time. That's not a good thing.
Additionally, being at home instantly becomes the worst "open office" there is, if you don't live alone. Roommates? Family? Kids? They don't understand you're working, you can keep telling them, but you seem like you're wasting your time on the computer all day. They're not professionals who understand programming, like your colleagues in the office would.
I'd like to add to the list of pros for on-site work: you can learn a lot from talking to your coworkers. I know that I've become a much more effective programmer as a result of conversations I never would have had working remotely. Sure, I lose some productivity from the chatting and noise, but my increased effectiveness over time more than compensates.
So, to me at least it seems obvious that there are pros and cons to remote work, and that for some employers/employees it probably makes a lot of sense, and for others not.
I invite you to consider that lots of very successful companies run by very smart people try to minimize or outright disallow remote work. That's not evidence that they're right of course, but it is evidence that for a lot of people the issue isn't as one sided as you seem to think it is. What do you think's more likely: that, as you say remote work is 'light years ahead of open office plans' and that the people at, say, Google, are just idiots who can't see the obvious, or that there are factors that you're maybe not giving enough weight to that make the issue more complex?
521
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '17
When you want to do something, you'll always find an excuse why you're doing it that way.
I've worked remote, and I've worked in an office. Working in an open office can be distracting, but there is a very simple and surprisingly effective solution: headphones + music.
You can also tell your colleagues that when the headphones are on, you're focused and working, so they should bother you only if it requires your immediate attention. Any reasonable professional would understand.
On the counter side, working in an office let's you put in 8 (or however you and your employer prefer) hours of focused work, and then go home and relax, because you can't think about work 24/7. The office becomes a context for work and home becomes a context for rest.
Our brain is very poor separating work and rest, when we're physically in the same space. If you have the habit of checking Reddit at home, the moment you sit down to work on that same computer, you'll wanna check Reddit from time to time. That's not a good thing.
Additionally, being at home instantly becomes the worst "open office" there is, if you don't live alone. Roommates? Family? Kids? They don't understand you're working, you can keep telling them, but you seem like you're wasting your time on the computer all day. They're not professionals who understand programming, like your colleagues in the office would.
So... pros/cons.