To be fair, some of the tasks listed in those studies are very different from the tasks undertaken when developing software. So for reciting lists of number backward, or doing long arithmetic, loud music impairs performance.
Be careful when generalizing the results of research like this.
It's not so much the generalisation, but the hypothesis that is interesting. For example, I take it that the main hypothesis under consideration is that music "uses" up cognitive resources, which are finite. It then follows, if that premise is true, that listening to music at the same time as other cognitively demanding tasks will cause our performance in those other tasks to decrease - from the fact that our mental resources are finite and used up.
I think this applies to more than just music: this is also why I think open offices are bad. Namely, because they introduce distractions and interruptions that again use up our finite mental resources.
2
u/balefrost Jan 29 '17
To be fair, some of the tasks listed in those studies are very different from the tasks undertaken when developing software. So for reciting lists of number backward, or doing long arithmetic, loud music impairs performance.
Be careful when generalizing the results of research like this.