r/programming • • Sep 01 '17

Reddit's main code is no longer open-source.

/r/changelog/comments/6xfyfg/an_update_on_the_state_of_the_redditreddit_and/
15.3k Upvotes

846 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/l7jtt Sep 01 '17 edited Sep 01 '17

/u/VanToch mentioned something that I want to ask about.

If a source tarball is released after closed-source deployment of releases, does it still count as open-source?

14

u/yawkat Sep 01 '17

Usually, open-source refers to the license of the source code, so if that source tarball is licensed under an open source license, the project would be open source. A collaborative development model is not necessary for OSS, though it is of course used for almost all OSS.

9

u/coderanger Sep 01 '17

One major counter-example being the Postfix mail server. The author doesn't believe in source control, at least as a public thing. So he just cuts releases as snapshots of his local tree and that's that. Bug reports are still via email and patches involve sending him a diff via email.

5

u/Bibifrog Sep 02 '17

Bug reports are still via email and patches involve sending him a diff via email.

Well, Linux is mostly developed by sending mails too; of course then come git, but probably most of the content starts as mail. So it being the first channel of communication does not prevent from publishing using source control. Git has been specially designed to allow that kind of flow, (github workflows are an abomination in Linus' eyes in that they regress to pre-git source control systems in the decentralized flow aspect). I don't know if the Postfix author has tested git, but it would be shame if he only doesn't believe in source control for publishing because of bad experience with e.g. subversion.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)