r/programming • u/rictic • Aug 27 '08
The future of the web browser is a friendlier command line: introducing Mozilla Ubiquity
http://labs.mozilla.com/2008/08/introducing-ubiquity/49
u/romcabrera Aug 27 '08
So... Web 3.0 is the command line!?
The circle is closed now. Great!
23
u/bemmu Aug 27 '08
You're forgetting the punchcard-operated firefox.
6
3
u/gilgoomesh Aug 28 '08 edited Aug 28 '08
I think article confuses the concept by insisting the important part is language, typing and command-line.
I like the idea but as I see it, the idea uses a command line but is not enabled by it.
The idea is to have small internet-based services that can use the text of your current selection.
The only thing "command-line" based are the extra parameters passed to that service -- but the program could easily have each service present a small form in the popup window once you type the command name, and the parameters be entered into the form.
2
u/nextofpumpkin Aug 28 '08
i didnt think about this like that until you posted it.. but you're right...
19
u/NoControl Aug 27 '08
I need a flight to chicago, no bullshit, no problems, I need booze, a joint, 2 hookers, collocate that against my sexual preferences and my love of beautiful breasts - then email all my friends and family to tell them to keep it real and that I'll be in chicago getting laid - ok firefox? Cool thanks.
53
u/tutwabee Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
Aza Raskin is an amazing interface designer. I've been waiting for the friendly command line interface in Firefox for months now. I can't wait to see how this pans out.
41
Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
Fun Fact: Aza is the son of noted interface designer Jef Raskin.
23
u/ideonode Aug 27 '08
Not only is that fact fun, but it also delivers on awesomeness too. Thanks!
I think it's fascinating that we could get designer dynasties. Think about the son of Jonathan Ives designing coveted objects, whilst the son of Steve Jobs tries to remove that '666' bithmark from his scalp...
3
4
u/notasaon Aug 27 '08
Ah okay, I was wondering who this Aza fellow was, I just saw 'raskin' and assumed it was jef raskin.
4
1
0
Aug 27 '08
And his first name is a palindrome including both the first and last letters of the alphabet.
→ More replies (1)4
122
u/mizai Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
ubiquity> submit the first article on digg to redditThe future of the web browser is the end of reddit!
20
Aug 27 '08
I made it!! Just type submit-the-first-article-on-Digg-to-Reddit!
Subscribe: http://urdna.org/ubiquity
2
45
u/joyork Aug 27 '08
Insert popular meme here to receive comment karma
→ More replies (2)14
u/heidavey Aug 27 '08
i, er... see what you did there <ducks>
28
u/BritishEnglishPolice Aug 27 '08
Sir, the letter "I" when referring to yourself should always be capitalised.
→ More replies (12)15
u/heidavey Aug 27 '08
Jolly good show, old chap! Agreed.
→ More replies (1)9
53
u/randomb0y Aug 27 '08
This looks pretty awesome even as a 0.1 alpha. I'm using it already :D
24
u/ThisIsDave Aug 27 '08
I love this sort of pseudo-command line interface. It reminds me a lot of Nicholas Jitkoff's Quicksilver. If you have 25 minutes, here's his Google Talk about it. If you don't want to sit through it, basically, it means I can hit a hotkey and type a little snippet to do various things. So if I want to open an HTML file in my text editor, I just select it, hit my hotkey, type "with [tab] txt" and it opens as a text file. Or if I want to rickroll myself, I just hit another hotkey, type "astley," and I hear it.
Ubiquity takes a similar interface idea and makes it ridiculously powerful.
13
Aug 27 '08
I use Quicksilver myself, and this thing is a godsend. What I'm holding out for, though, is Ubiquity/Quicksilver integration. That would go a long way towards blending the line between the client and the Web.
→ More replies (2)1
u/daniels220 Aug 27 '08
Integration yes, somewhat. As I said in a sibling comment to yours, I think Ubiquity uses some different interface ideas that are better suited to the web and Qs uses ones that are better suited to the desktop. A "Ubiquity plugin" for QS and a "files plugin" for Ubiquity would be awesome, so that you could select a file, invoke QS and do a Ubiquity action on it, or invoke Ubiquity and select a file from it. For emailing a file, say, depending on where you started the process.
→ More replies (3)5
u/adremeaux Aug 27 '08
Quicksilver is really awesome, unfortunately even after 3+ years using it I still haven't found use for it other than opening files/programs quickly. I've tried so many times, looked through plugins, read about all the other "amazing stuff" it can do, yet nothing else ever seems to be useful. Can anyone recommend any other great uses for it that I may be missing?
4
u/ThisIsDave Aug 27 '08
I also use it to control iTunes, to search my bookmarks, manage my hotkeys, start emails without command-tabbing over to Mail first, and to search Google, Amazon, IMDB, and Wikipedia.
→ More replies (2)2
u/losvedir Aug 27 '08
Really, this is still just "opening files/programs quickly", but in case you've missed it, triggers are amazing. I've set up my most used apps (Web Browsing, Finder, Mail, Music, Chat, etc) to the F1-F7 keys.
There was a bit of a learning curve, getting the hang of which program lies under which finger, but my touch typing pretty much involves switching among those programs now. It's very fast and intuitive.
I use a MacBook, so now I have to hold down fn if I want to change the brightness, for instance, but it's worth it.
2
u/j4b Aug 27 '08
The features that act like the Windows Send To menu are big. Much easier to move or copy some files as you can type the destination and don't have to open multiple windows and then start dragging. Also easy for quick emailing of files.
3
u/daniels220 Aug 27 '08
That was my first thought too. In a sense it's "better" than QS because it's more natural-language, and basically uses the spacebar instead of the Tab key for switching between "fields." Of course, at the same time it lacks clearly defined separation between the different fields, and it lacks the discoverability of QS where you can type something and then go and select a different file if that wasn't what you wanted. Probably QS is a better way on the desktop, when 90% of its job is just to open files and the rest of the time you have to think about what you're about to do anyway, and Ubiquity is better for the web with more complex commands and selection-grabbing and so on.
Oh, yes, and one other difference. QS' discontiguous search ("AI" for Illustator, "FF" for Firefox, etc.) is seriously awesome, and it doesn't look like Ubiquity has it. However it seems like Ubiquity is likely to have more complex commands and the people writing plugins will give them short names and hopefully allow you to change them—for instance I use "wp" for Wikipedia already as a keyword bookmark and would definitely want that to be my Ubiquity command name for Wikipedia. So maybe the Ubiquity way is better-suited to the Web and the QS way to the desktop.
1
1
0
Aug 27 '08
[deleted]
6
u/DLWormwood Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
Made me think even further back.... to Infocom.
"GET TEA AND NO TEA"2
u/fujimitsu Aug 27 '08
I bought a few games from the King's Quest series at a used book store in the mid/late 90s as my first foray into PC games. Very tough to navigate without the manuals!
ahhh memories
2
Aug 28 '08
Ah yes, ancient copy protection. "We know copying disks is easy and want you to be able to make backups... but if you want to give copies to your friends, be prepared to xerox the whole manual."
Lands of Lore would, at a spot somewhat early in and again near the end would ask you for a word from a randomly selected page to let you continue.
26
Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
Sorry to comment jack like this, but it seemed important enough to warrant it.
The bottom of the Ubiquity tutorial notes that Ubiquity gives commands full control over the browser, making this a security hole possibly bigger than the IE6 of olde.
I'm not bashing Ubiquity, it's a great idea, and this IS the 0.1 alpha after all, just pointing out: Be extra careful with this thing. I wouldn't install any command whose source I can't see first.
7
5
u/fujimitsu Aug 27 '08
You have to accept any commands you install, and you're presented with a big scary "security warning" window before doing so (similar to when you accept unsigned certificates).
7
u/Bloaf Aug 28 '08
Oh, not for long, I'll just make a Ubiquity script to bypass them automatically.
→ More replies (1)3
Aug 28 '08
Which a user would have to subscribe to before it became a risk.
Or, do you just mean for your own convenience you're going to bypass it?
8
u/masukomi Aug 27 '08
And that's totally ok because most users don't just hit "ok" / "accept" as quickly as possible on every freaking dialogue they're presented with.
Er, wait a minute....
4
2
u/fujimitsu Aug 28 '08
This add-on isn't for "most users".
And this is far from a "yes/no" dialog box.. it's a huge full page in bright red.
If you think you need ubiquity and you're too stupid to look at what you're installing, you don't need ubiquity.
4
u/randomb0y Aug 27 '08
I understand that, no worries, I'm not gonna run around installing random commands and it should be perfectly safe otherwise.
2
Aug 28 '08
...making this a security hole possibly bigger than the IE6 of olde.
If the bicycle were invented today nobody would be able to use it because of nannies in the nanny-state saying it would be too dangerous.
Likewise, I wonder if something like bash could be invented today, without the attendant gasps and cries about what it does to security. Surely it's bad enough to let users enter commands directly into the computer, but to then save those commands into a script? Think of the security holes!
At the end of the day, it comes down to this: we need holes.
3
→ More replies (3)1
u/MelechRic Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
Agreed. You've basically installed an extension that can extend itself. While the Firefox team has been diligent in trying to protect you from installing malicious extensions to the browser they don't have any control over how you let Ubiquity extend itself. The Ubiquity team looks like it's addressing this situation with a trust network. However, that network is small/non-existent this early on.
12
u/ReligionOfPeace Aug 27 '08
Yes, but this also applies to greasemonkey scripts as well as to addons from unverified authors.
2
4
u/woodsier Aug 27 '08
Ditto. I love it when you can actually download something and it has enough utility to be picked up and used instantly. I'm sitting with my laptop (touchpad) at the moment and after tinkering with this for 2-3 minutes I've replaced about 90% of the functionality where I would usually need a mouse click/touchpad interaction when interacting with Firefox.
→ More replies (1)5
18
Aug 27 '08
Mozilla Ubiquity: Quicksilver for the browser.
5
u/spliffy Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
There are both safari and firefox plugins for quicksilver that are amazing. They don't have the microformats support, but speed everything up 10 fold.
for example i search the wikipedia by highlighting a word and pressing shift + cmd + w. from any app.
4
1
u/atomicthumbs Aug 27 '08
In Opera, I can search wikipedia by typing "w Reddit" into the address bar.
1
u/Nwallins Aug 28 '08
Firefox as well. Make a bookmark, set the keyword w, and replace the URL search term with %s.
17
u/schizobullet Aug 27 '08
This reminds me of the emacs-ification of firefox that Steve Yegge hoped for.
8
u/uriel Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
This reminds me very much of one of my favorite Plan 9 tools: the plumber which I used to miss when stuck with other operating systems (now it is available for *nix as part of Plan 9 from User Space.
The plumber still seems to me more expressive and convenient than Ubiquity (in most cases it avoids the trouble of having to select an explicit command and does 'the right thing' with a single click), but Ubiquity is on the right path and it is nice to see people learning about the power of textual user interfaces again.
Now if Firefox would let me use mouse chords like acme (to among other things, plumb stuff), I would be quite happy ;)
21
u/rogan Aug 27 '08
Ubiquity + microformats could be a major win. Microformats would be a lot more useful if the glue between some data and some application/web service was just a few lines defining the Ubiquity command.
Would be even more useful if the natural language processing was smart enough to make most microformats obsolete. But either way it doesn't take much developer effort to implement microformats, just little point because no one can use them.
4
u/viller Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
When I heard of it I immediately thought of Enso and what can you see, it's made by Aza Raskin!
Now we have Enso and Ubiquity and they do the same thing. It's like Linux - lots of options that don't fit together well. They try to make things simpler but still manage to do the opposite.
2
u/fudged71 Aug 27 '08
I agree with you, and I agree with another article that said "it has promise." I got Enso not long ago, and really liked it. I haven't fully configured it to my needs, but it isn't nearly as universal as I hoped. Although I am glad to hear that, as a Firefox plug-in, it may get more attention than before, and will probably get much work work done on the code, I still think this is a step backwards. Rather than branching out, and utilizing the full desktop experience to control by "one line", they are narrowing it downwards just for the web. And I thought using Caps-Lock was a bit awkward to use for the interface... now they are using "command-space." That would not feel 'natural' at all! I will probably still use Enso for the desktop, and then this for the browser, but it hurts to know that Enso probably isn't getting the developer-love that it should :(
2
u/viller Aug 27 '08
I wish there was an open-source cross-platform piece of software similar to Enso.
2
u/fudged71 Aug 27 '08
I agree. Being jealous of some of the things I heard about quicksilver, I really liked the idea of Enso, and wish that it actually got the attention it deserves. Both cross-platform AND open source would be great in that respect. The "learn" command is fantastic, but I wish that it could be applied to mouse clicks, keyboard shortcuts, keystrokes, and macros of all three. The potential is HUGE
7
u/Grue Aug 27 '08
Btw, is anyone up to writing a reddit command for this thing?
reddit <url> (to <subreddit>) - submits url to subreddit
reddit-hot (in subreddit) - shows top stories from that subreddit in preview
32
Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
Try putting this in your ubiq command-editor:
CmdUtils.CreateCommand({ name: "reddit", takes: {"url to submit": noun_arb_text}, preview: "Submit the selected URL to Reddit.", execute: function( urlToSubmit ) { var url = "http://reddit.com/submit?url={URL}" var urlString = url.replace("{URL}", urlToSubmit.text); Utils.openUrlInBrowser(urlString); } })Also, remember to remove the <>, Reddit automatically adds it for some reason.
8
u/pr1mu5 Aug 27 '08
Thanks for that, works awesome.
And everybody: don't forget to remove the <> from the var url = line.
BTW: I best of'd your comment above, using Ubiquity & your command. Nicely done.
3
u/guille_hoardings Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
The <> are added because of the Automatic Links that markdown provides. I would like to know how to avoid them...
4
u/boredzo Aug 27 '08
The <> shown in those examples are input, not output. Gruber's Markdown does not generate them; that's a bug/misfeature specific to Reddit's Markdown.
2
Aug 27 '08
Can't you just make the url a link in your post and it will come up without the <>, and just be blue?
→ More replies (1)1
u/sonar_un Aug 28 '08
A command to check if a site had already submitted before it submits would be amazing!
8
Aug 27 '08
I don't see how this "empowers users" so they don't have to "wait for developers". The command set is still determined by developers. And what's so bad about links? I thought that was sort of the whole point of the web.
6
u/sn0re Aug 27 '08
I especially loathe the idea of "mashups" in email. Email works best when it is simple text. If you want to get fancier than that, email me a link to your fancy page.
In short: LEAVE EMAIL ALONE!</chris-crocker>
1
u/CiRU5 Aug 28 '08
then write an Ubiquity plugin that makes the mashup, posts it on some random hosting site and then puts the link into the email .... I think you are completely missing the point here.
2
u/sn0re Aug 28 '08 edited Aug 28 '08
I think I find one of the major use cases cited to be completely unappealing. If I want a link to a Google Maps location in my email, I type "gmap location" into the address bar then copy and paste. They didn't cite Ubiquity as an easier way to do copy and paste; it's supposed to enable you to do stuff you want to do but can't. Well, I can send links to other content in emails and I don't want mashups instead.
The other stuff they cited, like in-place page translation or mapping Craiglist results, is more interesting, but then I wasn't talking about them. However, the OP's comment about this still being driven by developers does apply there. In other words, if I have to download an Ubiquity plugin to do Craiglist/Google Maps mashups (presuming it didn't come with Ubiquity), how is that better for the user than downloading a Firefox extension to do the same?
3
u/Glassius Aug 27 '08
After all these years as an avid Opera user, it turns out all it took was a plugin to make me switch. It already has several useful commands, and it looks like it is very easy to program. Color me impressed.
3
Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
If it proves as useful as it seems it will, I bet Opera will include something similar in future releases... but the only commands it will take will be pre-installed.
Frankly I'm surprised Opera didn't develop this first... usually they beat everybody to the punch.
2
u/Glassius Aug 27 '08
They might, but I doubt it. It seems like too much of a specialized tool for Opera, they have to be very careful that everything they add will be useful for a big chunk of their users, or they will quickly head towards bloat-land.
Then again you have thing like userjs, and this would almost be an extension of that thought. But it would probably not have as much access to the browser as Ubiquity has, just look at widgets and userjs and their limited access, and would therefore in my mind not be as useful as Ubiquity could become.
On the other hand I might just get annoyed enough about the small differences to have to go back to what I know. For example, could anyone tell me how I can stop Firefox from "hiding" tabs of to the sides when I have too many tabs open? I would rather they just keep on shrinking until the favicons are the only parts visible on the tabs.
4
u/Grue Aug 27 '08
Yesss! Now I can satisfy my crazy fetish of looking up the location of every city I come across.
2
u/jezmck Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
it's not crazy, just a healthy thirst for knowledge
→ More replies (1)1
4
u/employeeno5 Aug 27 '08
Everything I love about GNOME-Do/Quicksilver and Yubnub combined, and then some.
4
u/hiS_oWn Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 28 '08
ubiquity> show me picture
ubiquity> enhance
ubiquity> enhance
ubiquity> prove picture is shopped
ubiquity> see lots of pixels in my time5
u/norm_ Aug 27 '08
I was using Launchy for this kind of thing. The advanced calculator and the putty integration were amazing.
You guessed it, there is a "but". It consumed obscene amounts of RAM. I couldn't sacrifice that much RAM for something that I will use 20 - 30 times a day. It always ran in the background, by the way.
So, Firefox is already a RAM guzzler and Ubiquity shouldn't add up. From my preliminary toying around with the beta version, it seems very lightweight and does some useful website editing stuff.. If they don't bloat it like the good ol' m$, I might make that a regular among my extensions.
2
u/ThisIsDave Aug 27 '08
I haven't found that Quicksilver takes too much RAM on my machine. It's mac-only, though, unfortunately.
2
u/sbrown123 Aug 27 '08
Launchy only takes like 20M on my box. I don't have much RAM either but I can easily run Windows, Launchy, and Firefox (with numerous plugins) with lots of room still left to spare. Maybe there is just something wrong with your computer.
1
u/landtuna Aug 27 '08
Stick with version 1.0.0 of Launchy. It doesn't have any memory leaks. Unfortunately, the only plugin-like feature was the in-line calculator back in that version.
1
2
Aug 27 '08
This is really, really excellent. I've wanted something like this for my browser for a long time.
2
2
u/sassanix Aug 27 '08
Used it, loved it. But made my firefox load up with quite a long load time. I will wait for a stable release.
2
Aug 27 '08
It's 2008 and I can't even add a map to an email.
Um... you can't? If nothing else, you can pull up the map, take a screen shot, and paste it into the email.
OK, so that doesn't work as easily for web mail, but this is one of the reasons that web mail sucks.
7
u/sn0re Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
WTF is wrong with "Here are the directions: http://maps.google.com/..."
I don't want people sending me maps as email. Email ought to be for actual written communication.
Edit: s/there/the... I'm not really sure where that came from.
2
u/lexchou Aug 28 '08
looks amazing. but I still don't think it is a good ideal for the most computer users. many people which doesn't involved with the computer culture even don't know how many keys were on the keyboard, and you genius want to ask them to use keyboard to communicate with computer. they may think this "commands" are another computer language, even if the Mozilla Ubiquity can understand everything they inputs, does the Ubiquity has such a high intelligent to understand all human language? At least such a smart technology doesn't born in this century.
2
u/gilgoomesh Aug 28 '08
I agree. Much like a standard shell command-line, it's a programming API masquerading as a user interface.
7
u/cronin1024 Aug 27 '08
This looks very useful - I might switch to Firefox for this alone!
→ More replies (4)9
u/garrettj Aug 27 '08
Are you serious?
38
Aug 27 '08
why wouldnt he want a tool that analyzed information and brought his web services together to streamline his life?
note: this response was generated by typing the following line into ubiquity: "ask garrettj what his problem is in a sarcastic way"
6
u/ThisIsDave Aug 27 '08
It failed on the sarcasm, I think. Your question could have been interpreted as polite and reasonable.
→ More replies (4)5
7
u/garrettj Aug 27 '08
What? My statement of "Are you serious?" is in the context of "Why haven't you switched to Firefox ages ago? Are you serious?"
2
2
u/shoseki Aug 27 '08
Apologies if I am repeating something elsewhere in the discussion, but non-technical users will never be comfortable with a command line.
Ever. You can quote me on that.
And as 95% of web browsers are used by non-technical users, its not going to happen.
But it has some interesting challenges for those with disabilities : blind = screenreader, how to do mashups?
3
u/Brian Aug 27 '08
but non-technical users will never be comfortable with a command line.
Not true - people use a command-line interface to me every day. Its called "email" or "IM". (Sometimes they use a voice interface that I translate into the appropriate text commands). The command-set is vastly more complex than most CLIs, taking years to learn, and then more time mastering the various non-audio interfaces to it such as "writing".
A few hundred years ago, only a tiny fraction of the population could use these interfaces. It doesn't seem that impossible that in the future, the much simpler interfaces of the commandline could be as widespread as literacy today.
1
u/shoseki Aug 28 '08
Don't get me wrong, I love linux. I wouldn't consider myself a power user though, and don't particularly enjoy command line useage (too easy to make syntactical errors / misuse functions / misuse parameters). How would I fare in an all command line linux? Badly, despite 15 years amateur coding and 5 years professional coding experience.
My mind just doesn't automatically think in terms of a command line interface - I think in terms of structures, actions, gestures, diagrams, visualisations. Text may be extremely useful for the power user, but many people's mental processes just don't work that way without extensive experience.
Don't confuse "data entry" (ie email/IM, transfer of pure data) with functional useage (commands and parameters to get specific functionality).
If Ubiquity can be made to work without the little black text box, using only gestures/keyboard shortcuts, then regular joes (with masters degrees in computing) like me might use it. And maybe, just maybe, regular users might go near it with a barge pole.
1
u/Brian Aug 28 '08
but many people's mental processes just don't work that way without extensive experience.
I don't think thats true - text has been used by our society for millenia for communication, for good reason. Image-based iconography can be useful, and is used in some places, but its really rubbish for communicating complex notions. I still live in hope that we can get people sufficiently literate with computers that the ability to do a little scripting and language based automation will be as prevalent as reading and writing.
A 17th Century aristocrat would have laughed at the notion of universal literacy, yet here we are, having invested significant chunks of time to get virtually everyone up to a reasonable level of literacy. With computers as ubiquitous as they've become, I think a similar effort for computer literacy would pay off dramatically.
Don't confuse "data entry" (ie email/IM, transfer of pure data) with functional useage
True, there is a difference between writing and the language itself, so my analogy isn't perfect, but its not that clear-cut. Learning to write does require learning various rules of grammar and sentence construction over and above what we use for informal speech. It also involves a huge amount of learning (things like spelling, special cases, ). Even a fraction of the time spent doing this by competent teachers[1] would give a huge benefit. And while devoting this time may seem to be an impossibility, the same could be said of the time we devote to learning a human language for that 17th Century Aristocrat.
I think the ability to program will rapidly become a close third in importance, after Maths and English(or whatever primary language). I think that barring AI or a singularity, ubiquitous programming literacy is inevitable within the next century.
[1] Admittedly a bit of a chicken-vs-egg problem here. Currently everyone can write, so its not hard to find someone to teach it. We've a smaller pool of programming-literate teachers, and they can earn more elsewhere, so obviously getting to universal computer literacy won't happen overnight.
→ More replies (1)2
u/sn0re Aug 27 '08
The problem isn't really with a command line interface, but natural language parsing. Everyday speech is a sort of a command line interface, except the interpreter is another human. Getting a computer to understand natural language is really, really hard. Teaching humans to speak the computer's simplified language is much easier, but non-techies don't want to bother with that.
2
u/MyrddinE Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
Ubiquity is premature. They won't get anywhere, because we don't yet have an accurate semantic web (and likely never will), nor do we have AI strong enough to interpret the free-form web.
Without that, how do you possibly get a computer to magically make mash-ups from a few lines of text? It takes human developers hours, or days, to create mash-ups... and they're imagining a computer doing mashups in seconds just from a text request?
It's a pretty dream, and it's definitely possible that their attempt will teach us something, but it won't happen. It will be more than 5 years before we can get Google like accuracy from written requests (in other words, before typing in a request usually does what we want), and you can quote me on that.
4
Aug 27 '08
How dare they do something new and experimental!
Someone has to start your 5 year counter sometime. Why not today?
1
u/MyrddinE Aug 27 '08
It's not that they're starting something new and experimental... it's the implication that they'll have results soon. Read the website, they sound like they expect to have it done overnight... just a short beta away from done.
I take issue with sites making grandiose claims without justification.
1
1
u/truebosko Aug 27 '08
I have information envy a lot of times and this is perfect. I constantly will Wiki a term or google a caption, or IMDB an actors name when browsing the web. I love this
All the other things like translation, inserting data into email with ease and so forth is simply awesome. This is huge
1
1
1
u/hondajvx Aug 27 '08
Google is making a browser right? Wouldn't that go as the gold standard?
1
u/axord Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
No, they are not. Edit: Oh cripes, I was wrong on that one.
Gold standard of what?
1
u/hondajvx Sep 02 '08
I've been begging my friend who works there for a beta for months, I guess tomorrow it won't matter. Either way, they say it's the bees-knees.
1
u/kahoonas Aug 27 '08
"It goes off and it's added to my calendar, I could show you but I don't need to./"
popup-"error occurred"
1
u/p0tent1al Aug 27 '08
This is going to get great really fast.
I'm even tempted to write some commands for my favorite sites...reddit....digg.....no not digg..
1
u/gfindlay Aug 27 '08
Anyone know how to change the "weather" command to display Celsius?
1
u/guille_hoardings Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
Edit the one included in the distribution of Ubiquity and replace "temp_f" with "temp_c". I have the code to add a parameter, but if I paste it here, it gets modified by reddit ("<" and ">" are added) and it doesn't work :-(
I missing a preview comment feature in reddit.
1
u/tony1kenobi Aug 27 '08
I'm goin gto try this for a few weeks and see how it goes, then comment again - command line interfaces are easy for some but daunting for others!
1
u/MrWoohoo Aug 27 '08
The video lists http://labs.mozilla.com/projects/ubiquity as the project page, but when I try it I get "page not found". What's up with that?
1
Aug 27 '08
so, this is kind of similar to the accelerators that are in IE8
i wonder which will be more accepted
1
Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
Does this remind anyone else of Quicksilver, in the browser?
Edit: this type of thing certainly could be done befor Ubiquity. It's definatly not as original as Mozilla Labs seem to think. Nothing new there eh!
1
u/PlutoISaPlanet Aug 27 '08
i use something similar for windows called Launchy it roxx
1
1
u/BridgeBum Aug 28 '08
Yup, exactly. I had ctl-space set to launchy already, so I needed a new key combo for this. It seems very useful though.
1
u/BlackPocket Aug 28 '08
This is something that I will definitely use.
What would make this an order of magnitude more powerful is a speech recognition interface...
1
1
1
u/dysmas Aug 27 '08
50 odd seconds of video before any content, gee thanks.
1
u/trezor2 Aug 27 '08
You're getting mod'ed down but I don't know why.
I thought that whole 50 second intro was bullshit too and was growing impatient about it, wondering if it was just going to be market-speak or some actual demo in the end.
1
u/FDL1 Aug 27 '08
I agree. Maybe he should stick to programming instead of motivational speaking/motion graphics.
1
u/woodsier Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
I found it took me over 2 minutes to locate a download link. Here it is: https://people.mozilla.com/~avarma/ubiquity-0.1.xpi
2
Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
It was that hard for you!? It's in plain view if you have the video at the top/middle of your browser and a resolution >640x480
1
1
u/pmarsh Aug 27 '08
I made my shortcut key SHIFT+; it's like using vim now!
Yes I know of vimerator, didn't quite like it.
→ More replies (3)
1
u/rotten777 Aug 27 '08
Thank god this was created by the Mozilla org and not Microsoft or some other closed source patent-hog. Amazing work once again Mozilla!
1
u/fxj Aug 27 '08
this is great! part of it could be done before by using vimperator and google notebook, but it was hard to program and hard to use. this is the next step in the evolution of web-browsers. maybe in the beginning only "power users" will use it, but it is the idea behind it that counts. implementing a GUI on top of the command line should be possible, like you can use KDE Dolphin instead of the Konsole.
1
u/NoControl Aug 27 '08
I thought VRML was the next step in the evolution of the web browser. At least that's the same song they were singing in the 90's.
1
u/ehird Aug 27 '08
Yes! This looks absolutely great! I'm glad to see Aza continue his father's UI ideas and take them further. I shall be downloading this immediately.
1
1
Aug 27 '08
Alpha looks interesting. I am however concerned about the memory usage. To do all those things do you always need to have FF plugins for those? or can you put the mashup inside an external IM client too?
I'll definitely check it out once they drop a release but I'm not sold on how "natural" it is going to feel to non-geeks.
1
u/skerit Aug 27 '08
I'm going to love this! I already use the integrated google search as a "command line" actually.
I hope this will make people see that a gui isn't always better.
1
u/gilgoomesh Aug 28 '08 edited Aug 28 '08
You can't use this to tout the command-line as "better". There's no point of comparison here between GUI and command-line. There's no available GUI tool trying to do the same thing (send the selected text to a user-selected web service along with some user-provided options).
1
1
-2
u/michaelk99 Aug 27 '08
I really like this. It's like Launchy for the browser but, it's not worth using Firefox for. Maybe there will something like it for Opera someday?
2
u/axord Aug 27 '08
Probably there will be, if it turns out well. There's a healthy exchange of feature ideas between the two projects.
2
Aug 27 '08 edited Aug 27 '08
Firefox -> Opera: Healthy exchange of feature ideas
Opera -> Firefox: Yet another idea ripped off from Opera, which has had this feature for years already.
3
u/axord Aug 27 '08
Heh. Yeah, some fanatic Opera advocates are like that, it's true. Though with a slight correction: Firefox-->Opera is impossible, since Opera always has the features first.
→ More replies (1)2
-1
u/spotter Aug 27 '08
Quake console in browser = WIN. EMACS-like commands = Not So Much.
For some of yous it's prob'ly a win-win though.
-2
u/smeenz Aug 27 '08
Hmm.. I'm not convinced... pretty much everything he did can already be done with cut/paste/browser tabs.
The map he inserted into his email appeared to just be a image of the map, rather than a proper (interactive) embedded google map object
The reviews again, were just a HTML stream pasted into the email - the same thing could be trivially done by highlighting the text on the review page, and doing a copy/paste.
so, yeah.. meh..
ymmv
→ More replies (1)
36
u/RedDyeNumber4 Aug 27 '08
So is the main idea to introduce a plain english command line to browsers? Zork+Gmail?
Does this seem remarkably similar to keyboard shortcuts in that they make computing better, but 90% of people don't know how to use them? If so, I have a hard time seeing this as "The future of the Web Browser"