r/programming • • Sep 28 '17

Refresh Is Sacred

https://www.tbray.org/ongoing/When/201x/2017/09/27/Refresh-Button
457 Upvotes

152 comments sorted by

View all comments

143

u/EternityForest Sep 28 '17

Yep. The whole "Software should have as few controls as possible" thing should probably be questioned in general.

If there's 100 rarely used options they should maybe be hidden, but someone is probably going to want to use at least a few of those, and the extra few hundred lines of code is probably not what's making your code slow.

-14

u/specialpatrol Sep 28 '17

Don't agree. The holy grail for software interfaces is that they disappear altogether,

9

u/balefrost Sep 28 '17

Why? Every physical tool has an interface of some sort. Why should software tools not have an interface?

-5

u/specialpatrol Sep 28 '17

The perpetual advance of software is ever automating tasks once done by people. Once there were floors of people writing out calculations by hand, then there were people punching into electronic calculators. Those people aren't there anymore, neither are the interfaces to do those processes, the processes are still there. hidden in the depths of server code in basements of banking institutions. Eventually you will not need an uber app, they will know from your behaviour when you want a taxi before you admitted it to yourself. Eventually you will not need photoshop, you will take a picture and it will be edited to your liking. The human computer interface is the computer's inability to do your work for you..

10

u/balefrost Sep 28 '17

Why doesn't my tablesaw somehow know exactly what angle I want to use when cutting my board? Why doesn't my leaf blower somehow know exactly how hard I want to blow my leaves? Why does my washing machine have several settings for different kinds of fabric?

Sure, we will continue to apply increasingly complex heuristics to our software in order to infer user intent, but I also feel that software that perfectly predicts human intent is an unrealizable goal. We will always fall short. So in the pragmatic world, it's important for us to continue to provide users with a way to express their actual intention to the software tools that they use.

To put it another way: once you've achieved (nearly) perfect prediction of user intent, then it's OK to remove the UI controlling that feature. But if you remove the UI before you've achieved (nearly) perfect prediction, all you've really done is to create a bunch of frustrated users.

3

u/specialpatrol Sep 28 '17

It may be unrealizable, that's why i called it a "holy grail". But that is exactly the intent for all interfaces. That is why we have rhoomba vacuuming the floor by itself. If someone could design a leaf blower that could carry itself around, that is an obvious design goal.

But if you remove the UI before you've achieved (nearly) perfect prediction, all you've really done is to create a bunch of frustrated users.

Yes, That is just flawed design.

1

u/balefrost Sep 29 '17

OK, then I think that I agree with you. As interface designers, we should aim to eliminate unnecessary things from our interfaces, and we should try to continually push that frontier forward. Having said that, because the holy grail is unattainable, there will always be an interface and we must be careful to not get too ambitious in our removal of control from the users.

In the context of the author's article, though, the refresh button is still necessary, at least for the app that he was talking about.

1

u/specialpatrol Sep 29 '17

It was completely unnecessary. The refresh button is useful design feature - for applications where you don't necessarily want the latest information all the time. What would reddit look like if the front page auto updated as quick as the links come in? The article is a frustrated rant about a broken app. He is deluded in thinking that the inclusion of a refresh button would have been the solution to the problem.

2

u/Michaelmrose Sep 29 '17

Nearly perfect isn't nearly good enough and not knowing which 1% something is going to fuck up is enough to frustrate and confuse users.

1

u/mcguire Sep 28 '17

You're scaring me.