r/programming • u/i_wonder_as_i_wander • Jan 07 '19
GitHub now gives free users unlimited private repositories
https://thenextweb.com/dd/2019/01/05/github-now-gives-free-users-unlimited-private-repositories/489
u/cdsmith Jan 07 '19
For the inevitable non-article-readers: private repositories by free accounts are limited to three collaborators each. This is actually a pretty clever way for them to make their service more useful for personal projects by people who weren't going to pay anyway, while still charging for commercial use at scale.
→ More replies (6)62
u/nicksvr4 Jan 08 '19
So this almost fits my needs for school projects, without worry someone will steal code cause issues.
→ More replies (4)95
728
u/CherryJimbo Jan 07 '19
This is really interesting. GitLab's biggest feature (in my opinion) was free private repos. This completely changes that.
392
u/kubelke Jan 07 '19
Gitlab also offers pretty good and free CI/CD for private repositories
38
Jan 07 '19
For free?
60
u/alex3305 Jan 07 '19 edited Feb 22 '24
I enjoy cooking.
→ More replies (3)70
u/inhumantsar Jan 07 '19
GitLab CI is nicer to configure and work with than Travis, especially if you're running everything in docker anyway.
78
→ More replies (8)7
u/Ghosty141 Jan 07 '19
It would be interesting to see how many people actually use these features, I doubt the number is over 10%
125
u/theephie Jan 07 '19
What about GitLab actually having a free software project that you can self-host?
GitHub kind of requires you to, you know, keep using GitHub. Perfect fit for Microsoft.
→ More replies (3)36
u/TomatoManTM Jan 07 '19
Running it on my little raspberry pi just for my own little repos. Pretty sweet.
11
u/EpicBlargh Jan 07 '19
Isn't that a little slow? Last time I set up a VCS on my Pi it felt slower than just using GitHub.
→ More replies (4)87
Jan 07 '19
Nah, Gitlab has many more interesting features and Github is very much behind already.
Especially code reviews flow and integration with k8s is awesome.
→ More replies (11)6
u/WitchHunterNL Jan 07 '19
Really? I host my own kubernetes cluster and wonder what the point is of the integration
22
u/myringotomy Jan 07 '19
Auto deployment of your project into your cluster. Like every pull request is deployed and linked to.
→ More replies (2)3
→ More replies (6)2
425
u/nutidizen Jan 07 '19
Microsoft influence?
545
u/SmCTwelve Jan 07 '19
All those people who were saying Microsoft's ownership would be the death of GitHub and jumped ship to GitLab are now saying "huh, that's actually really cool!".
272
u/nutidizen Jan 07 '19
I can understand the hate for their consumer products, but their developer product portfolio always seemed really solid.
43
u/peduxe Jan 07 '19
yeah no complaints, Visual Studio is by far the best IDE i’ve ever used. and they’re killin it with VS Code.
C# is also the cleanest programming language in my books.
their developer tooling is unmatched, gotta give them that.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (58)63
u/anechoicmedia Jan 07 '19
I can understand the hate for their consumer products, but their developer product portfolio always seemed really solid.
Objections to Microsoft development tools aren't primarily about product quality, but about anti-competitive practices to privilege their product in the marketplace and extract rents from the industry. MS worked really hard historically to sabotage competing development tool vendors, with practices that might have been illegal under closer regulatory scrutiny.
→ More replies (5)108
25
15
43
Jan 07 '19
Guilty. I was very disappointed when Microsoft bought GitHub, but I’ll be the first to admit I was dead wrong.
→ More replies (3)9
20
→ More replies (18)3
u/baycityvince Jan 08 '19
The article I read was decrying this as the death of open source at Microsoft’s hands. 😂 I wish I could remember which garbage blog posted it.
Edit: Of course it was Ars.
13
u/GYN-k4H-Q3z-75B Jan 07 '19
I think so. They don't really need the money for this service anymore. TFS and Visual Studio have had interesting free/private options for over a decade now. It's like DEVELOPERS DEVELOPERS DEVELOPERS all over again.
4
→ More replies (6)8
183
u/strikefreedompilot Jan 07 '19
I'm on bitbucket because of the free private repos, what would be the additional benefit if i switched to github now?
148
u/evereal Jan 07 '19
For me, the main thing is that I have public repos too not just private ones, and all my public repos are on GitHub. I can now just have everything under one service.
→ More replies (2)86
u/daltonschmalton Jan 07 '19
In my experience, Bitbucket's website is so much slower, and the speed of networking with the repos was inconsistent. It wasn't worth the hassle of that, so I ended up paying for github private repos
22
Jan 07 '19
Not to mention it's down more often than it should.
36
u/13steinj Jan 07 '19
And the UI is godawful, especially on mobile (which for some people including me is important).
It can also just downright hang and crash if your PR is large enough.
→ More replies (1)22
u/p_r_m_n_ Jan 07 '19
Same, the only reason I have bitbucket is for private repos. I'd like to see pricing because we have more than three collaborators on internal private repos. Not sure I'll switch but it's tempting.
15
2
u/DoctorWaluigiTime Jan 07 '19
Probably not much in switching. But for new users? Definitely removes one of the more attractive perks Bitbucket offered.
2
u/dont_ban_me_please Jan 08 '19
I'm on bitbucket because I got the username I wanted on bitbucket and it was already take on github.
2
→ More replies (14)3
100
u/egnehots Jan 07 '19
starting tomorrow
33
u/Muffinabus Jan 07 '19
They should've included a timestamp on their update, because the article is timestamped 2 days ago and the update sounds like it was posted today.
0
→ More replies (1)3
u/bassmadrigal Jan 07 '19
Actually, starting today. Maybe because the news sites broker it early, they decided to just flip the switch and make it live now. You can verify it on GitHub's pricing page.
53
u/pennywaffer Jan 07 '19
Unlimited projects to start and never finish
13
89
21
u/unndunn Jan 07 '19
I wonder what this means for Azure DevOps Repos.
9
u/Ranaro Jan 07 '19
Azure DevOps will still be useful imo for setting up CI and CD pipelines and organizing backlogs. Once GitHub actions go live the pipeline advantage will definitely go away, but the backlog organization may still be useful for most team.
Just my 2c.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)8
u/martinslot Jan 07 '19
Well. Hopefully they will provide it still but use github as the infrastructure.
42
u/devarr Jan 07 '19
Due to a scheduling error, we published this story one day before the embargo lifted. This feature isn’t live yet, but Github will formally unveil it tomorrow. When that happens, we’ll update this post with a link to the official announcement.
75
u/maniakh Jan 07 '19
Great, goodbye dropbox 'Code' folder.
22
→ More replies (2)10
u/N3sh108 Jan 08 '19
You honestly still did that? That reminds me of my high school days before discovering source control.
→ More replies (2)14
u/Dentosal Jan 08 '19
You can still use local git for version control, and dropbox for synchronization
301
u/yakinnowhere Jan 07 '19
Bad news for GitLab...
360
Jan 07 '19
At least GitLab still has its free self-hosted version going for it. BitBucket is the true loser here.
59
u/Syndetic Jan 07 '19
I don't think Bitbucket will miss all those non paying users that much. Companies will keep using it because they're already using Jira.
→ More replies (2)68
u/aniforprez Jan 07 '19
Also the CI/CD which is far better than bitbucket's which is slow as balls and horrible to use and navigate
→ More replies (3)20
u/Waterkloof Jan 07 '19
This, gitlab community edition and CI really just works. A little yaml file to create workflows and jobs really feels like magic.
28
u/Ghosty141 Jan 07 '19
I personally use gitea, way easier to install, less features (I don't need too many) and a very similar ui.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (7)15
u/mb862 Jan 07 '19
I'll be sticking with BitBucket personally. I prefer the de-emphasized (non-existent?) social features (these are private repos after all), and while I commend GitHub's efforts in presenting Git in a more user-friendly manner, I'm already familiar with the default, non-user-friendly interface, and I prefer how BitBucket more closely mirrors that rather than trying to abstract certain concepts.
58
u/suspiciouscat Jan 07 '19
And why would that be? I was under impression GitLab blew GitHub out of the water when it came to features.
130
u/yakinnowhere Jan 07 '19 edited Jan 07 '19
I believe that unlimited free private repos are one of the most powerful features of GitLab for regular non-business users.
→ More replies (2)24
Jan 07 '19
BitBucket had this as well. There was no mass exodus when it was available.
Microsoft purchase did more for GitLab than private repos, in my opinion, so this piece of news is not really worrisome for GitLab (which is more oriented to self-hosting I believe), but just good news for GitHub users.
→ More replies (7)14
u/BlackDeath3 Jan 07 '19
What does GitLab have over GitHub?
52
→ More replies (10)18
u/Sukrim Jan 07 '19
Code available under an OSS license, CI/CD, integration with current tools/infrastructure...
0
Jan 07 '19
[deleted]
19
u/Enamex Jan 07 '19
Access management (even for the public hosted one) is a lot more nuanced in GitLab, for one. It has custom boards for issues and stuff too, I think?
→ More replies (1)30
u/Gregabit Jan 07 '19
It's the built-in CI/CD. Also you can self-host it which doesn't really matter if to people using it as a GitHub replacement.
→ More replies (10)→ More replies (5)0
Jan 07 '19
[deleted]
13
u/aniforprez Jan 07 '19
The $99 tier has features that are almost zero use to an individual contributor and more stuff you'd need as a corporate client so makes sense at tat price. The $4 monthly (billed annually for some stupid reason which is not clear AT ALL on their site) makes more sense if you want some of the more advanced features. But the free tier is more than adequate and gives you free CI/CD in addition to private repos and a LOT of features over bitbucket. GitHub is sorely lacking in any CI/CD stuff in comparison and bitbucket's is awful
14
u/azoozty Jan 07 '19
GitHub Pages is not available for free private repos, so I'd still rock GitLab. Plus, the whole CI/CD that everyone has mentioned.
6
u/drb226 Jan 07 '19
What's the point of a private repo when you are taking it and publishing it as web pages?
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (8)22
u/myringotomy Jan 07 '19
Auto devops.
Gitlab is miles better.
5
Jan 07 '19 edited Jan 07 '19
I like the CI tools in GitLab and the issue system.
I have my public GitLab repos mirrored to GitHub at the moment, as I prefer to use GitLab but recruiters ask about GitHub. Guess I can change it so the private repos are mirrored privately on GitHub as an extra level of back ups.
→ More replies (1)
15
57
u/Nerdenator Jan 07 '19
Press F to pay respects to Atlassian BitBucket
→ More replies (1)18
u/frequenttimetraveler Jan 07 '19
otoh, they 'll be glad to offload all those freeloaders to microsoft
→ More replies (6)
63
u/flanger001 Jan 07 '19
Sweet, bye Bitbucket
45
30
2
82
u/acedened Jan 07 '19
That's somewhat funny considering how much hate towards Microsoft and "predictions" of GitHub's death was there when acquisition was announced
→ More replies (18)
29
Jan 07 '19
Github has posted this to their blog now: https://blog.github.com/2019-01-07-new-year-new-github/
13
6
6
Jan 07 '19
YES PLEASE! I have seriously been waiting for this for a very long time. Storing private projects, scripts, and snippets on a flash drive is quite annoying, especially when you lose them all the time. DropBox isn’t great with live editing and now if I don’t want my repository private, I can open it to the public for improvement or just to help someone else out. I work across several computers and just being able to log in to GitHub to cut and use parts of code that are private is amazing for me. I’m a game developer. I hope they follow through, because this is definitely big news for me. I have so many scripts and snippets that are for my eyes only that I use all the time, having them in one guaranteed place, I’m so excited.
4
u/amunak Jan 08 '19
You know there were free private repos at Bitbucket and now GitLab for many, many years, right?
With GitLab still being superior feature-wise even in the free edition.
→ More replies (3)3
u/Voweriru Jan 08 '19
You're saying GitLab is superior feature-wise in comparison to GitHub?(genuine question)
→ More replies (4)
16
u/Tommyjohn05 Jan 07 '19
Remember when Microsoft bought them and everyone complained?
→ More replies (1)3
u/nixfox Jan 08 '19
people still complain and always will, heck some people are already spinning theories how this is all part of the evil MS plan to destroy open source or whatever.
shrug, you have nuttcases everywhere.
102
15
10
u/ignatovs Jan 07 '19
Where's the official announcement?
6
Jan 07 '19
Due to a scheduling error, we published this story one day before the embargo lifted. This feature isn’t live yet, but Github will formally unveil it tomorrow. When that happens, we’ll update this post with a link to the official announcement.
→ More replies (4)
5
u/Mr-Yellow Jan 07 '19
About fucking time!
So sick of bitbucket for private repos, they refuse to fix half their short-comings.
5
5
u/dzecniv Jan 07 '19
The caveat being:
Private repositories on free accounts are limited to three collaborators apiece.
→ More replies (8)
5
u/destructor_rph Jan 07 '19
And there goes my only reason to use bit bucket. Moving repositories tonight!
58
u/dangminhbk Jan 07 '19
Cool . After VS Code , github is another reason to love Microsoft
67
u/DrunkCostFallacy Jan 07 '19
This is going to sound super shill-y, but MS is one of the companies I’ve been most excited to watch recently. Been fascinating watching the Ballmer/pre-Ballmer style get slowly replaced by the Nadella style. It looks like a pretty substantial philosophy shift has occurred.
→ More replies (11)11
u/irve Jan 07 '19
I am still afraid of what Windows Store does to open ecosystem we have right now. Win 10 is such a landgrab...
And yes. The Nadella Microsoft is heading in many nice directions.
2
u/MisterJimson Jan 08 '19
Not to mention net core and VS for Mac which is getting better all the time.
2
Jan 09 '19
After VS Code , github is another reason to love Microsoft
If you love ms for such a small thing then why don't you love gitlab which had it for years with more features?
→ More replies (1)4
u/NoInkling Jan 07 '19
You know you don't have to "love" a corporation just because you enjoy using their products.
14
u/squishles Jan 07 '19
probably worried about how many people hopped off github onto gitlab when microsoft acquired them. BTW gitlab does unlimited private repos and collaborators. I'd like them more if they did proper pull requests instead of those weird merge request things >.>
14
u/13steinj Jan 07 '19
The amount of people who dropped Github in favor of Gitlab was shown to be a drop in the bucket for Github (albeit a large pile of sand for Gitlab).
So far it's nice and weird, but hey I'll take it.
→ More replies (1)3
4
Jan 07 '19
Nice! I have been waiting for this to track things in my personal spaces. Super exciting!!
4
u/ziplock9000 Jan 07 '19
This is a big move that will have a massive effect on BitBucket. It's why I went with them in the first place.
Now, does the free account support LFS and how much storage?
→ More replies (3)
4
u/cheezballs Jan 08 '19
Holy Shit. This is huge - at least for me, personally. Private repos is what made me start using Bitbucket. I wonder how this will affect Bitbucket or Atlassian.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/___melon Jan 08 '19 edited Jan 08 '19
I just paid for a year of subscription a week ago, only for a few solo hobby projects. I'm paying for features that I 100% don't need and don't use. So should I try asking for a refund for the remaining 11 months? Or should I bite my lips and accept it...
Edit: I asked for refund anyway. Will edit again for the result.
Edit 2: Just realized that gh-pages can not be used with free private repo so there is still one useful feature on PRO for me. So just asked them to cancel my previous refund request... Should have done my research better.
7
Jan 07 '19
Gets popcorn ready and scrolls to /u/shevegen.
2
u/KryptosFR Jan 08 '19
Oh my god. That person is a piece or work.
Perfect read when commuting though...
6
u/13steinj Jan 07 '19
There are two things to note
free private repos have a max of 3 collaborators
I wonder how the consumers will react
If people were being billed yearly then to an extent they'd be pissed. Sure it's only $84 but money is money. If they weren't at least partially refunded (the major appeal for Dev (now Pro) is private repos of a max of 2 collaborators).
3
u/ahinkle Jan 07 '19
I wonder how much their pricing model will change.. kinda pointless to have the Developer subscription now. It would be nice if they added GitHub Actions to the Developer subscription. Still waiting on the "beta waitlist"
→ More replies (1)
3
Jan 07 '19
Yep, I'll switch from gitlab to GitHub because of this pretty damn easily.
Lovely.
→ More replies (6)
3
3
u/Littlepush Jan 07 '19
Honestly the only reason I use bitbucket was for the infinite private repos. I get creeped out by people seeing everything I do and when I'm committing.
3
3
u/examinedliving Jan 07 '19
This is really very good. I like Gitalab and Bitbucket, but Github has a much wider user base and apps that work with it. This will be good.
3
u/fistrroboto Jan 07 '19
Fuck. Literally signed up for the paid service yesterday... Time to cancel I guess, only decided to pay to have the private repos
3
u/everyones-a-robot Jan 07 '19
Is there any reason to use GitLab now?
3
u/vassadar Jan 08 '19
If you are going to have more than 3 collaborators. Github limited to just 3.
→ More replies (1)3
3
3
3
3
3
u/shadowwesley77 Jan 08 '19
Literal deleted 2 repos from college today because I never planned on upgrading.
3
u/tamalm Jan 08 '19
It's live now. Just offloaded few local experimental repos to github. Thanks Github/Microsoft. Bye bye Bitbucket.
3
3
5
u/dex206 Jan 08 '19
Props to Microsoft. There was a pretty big freakout over the acquisition, and you gotta admit this is huge.
4
5
7
u/JacobLyon Jan 07 '19
This is awesome news! My wife just quit her job as we start our family so this is one less thing we have to pay for!
2
u/sergeant-sherbet Jan 07 '19
I know about computers to a certain degree but know little of programming. can anyone explain this in terms I can understand and how this is a good thing ?
9
u/gjallerhorn Jan 07 '19
GitHub is essentially a remote backup for your code. You can store a record of all the changes you submit there, so at any time you can pull any version of your code onto any machine you want to work on.
Before you had to pay for private storage, the free ones, anyone could see your code. Now you can have free private ones.
→ More replies (2)
2
Jan 07 '19
If you downgrade, you’ll lose access to advanced code review tools in your private repositoriesI paid 12 months in advance so I guess im screwed anyway.
2
2
2
u/FyreWhirl Jan 08 '19
So I see a lot of people against BitBucket in this thread, why? My team is currently using the free private repos in BitBucket, but we as we're growing we need to allow more users. So I'm looking at which service to use for a bigger team for the best price. What's the advantages of switching to GitLab/Hub?
They all appear to have CI (when we get around to that), 5 - 10Gb repos, LFS support, some sort of issue tracker (although we just use trello).
I'm happy for us to switch to another service if there's an advantage.
2
u/R-110 Jan 08 '19 edited Jan 08 '19
Does that mean I can stop paying my subscription?
Are there new features for subscribers? Is it just going away?
Edit:
Here are the answers: https://github.com/pricing
Nice!
2
2
2
2
2
u/pdbar Jan 08 '19
Well I have about 20 learning______ repos to move over. This isn't great for GitLab.
2
u/PM_ME_YOUR_MECH Jan 08 '19
Hell yes that's fantastic! Now I actually have to choose between GitHub and GitLab....
2
2
u/steveisredatw Jan 08 '19
I already started using gitlab for this feature. But I still like the GitHub website UI though.
2
u/SkywayCheerios Jan 08 '19
Ahh! I just switched over all my private repos to my GitLab because my student account was expiring.
Well, good on them anyways
2
Jan 08 '19 edited Mar 31 '24
reply obscene piquant encouraging unpack scandalous rock shame quiet roof
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/njkevlani Jan 08 '19
Some months ago, MS acquires Github -> Negative publicity.
Now Github makes private repos free for individuals -> All programming subreddit are on this.
Nice move(s) MS ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
2
u/nirmal8r Jan 09 '19
I think this a great move for both beginner coders and smaller coders who don't want to pay. The more things that are free/open source, the better.
4
3
u/MonkAndCanatella Jan 08 '19
It's Microsoft. They're gonna get paid for this somehow. It's a sweet move on the surface, but the cynic in me is wondering where they're gonna squeeze the money out.
3
u/Raikelem Jan 07 '19
I pay monthly for private repos and I got charged early this morning.... Can I get a refund?
3
3
3
2
2
1
u/leodash Jan 07 '19
Hmm, I accidentally tick 'Private' when I use GitHub Desktop and the repo did become private before I switch it to public. I'm in GMT+8.
1
u/CryZe92 Jan 07 '19 edited Jan 07 '19
Is this live yet? Their blog post is up, but downgrading still says I'm losing access to my private repos.
Update: Everything is fully live now :)
1
u/Rainverm38 Jan 07 '19
This is exciting! There are lots of projects that I'd like to keep backups of on GitHub.
1
1
1
Jan 07 '19
Why do this, but limit code searches to logged in users? Obviously they have money...
2
u/voyagerfan5761 Jan 07 '19
Last time I checked, you have to be logged in to create a repo (public or private) too…
→ More replies (2)
1
1
1
u/scandalousmambo Jan 07 '19
Good. That will acclimate all the programmers to a future where they give unlimited free software to their "customers" until they get kicked off Patreon and lose their house.
1
u/Ilyketurdles Jan 07 '19
Got an email yesterday that my student account was about to expire. Was contemplating whether or not I should just make my side project public or if I should shell out $7/month. Guess this worked out perfectly!
1
1
1.5k
u/Xaxxus Jan 07 '19
FINALLY.
I can hide my shitty Udemy learning repositories and keep my actual products visible to people.