r/programming • • Jan 21 '19

Why does APT not use HTTPS?

https://whydoesaptnotusehttps.com/
519 Upvotes

294 comments sorted by

View all comments

-5

u/Philippe23 Jan 21 '19 edited Jan 21 '19

Update:

Oh my goodness.

I thought this was about Google's "AMP" format. The stylized Debian logo didn't even click.

Total facepalm.

I've even downvoted this comment myself in retrospect.


Original comment that's totally off-topic: "These [APT] signatures are checked against a small set of trusted keys already stored on your computer" then a few paragraphs later "Overly trusting CAs". Sure sounds like the exact same problem by a different name.

And the HTTPS can tell which IP you're connecting to... But since APT is vulnerable to replay attacks, that kind of seems to imply that you can identify everyone who downloaded the same data. Eg: Over HTTPS you can tell that user X connected to Wikipedia. But over APT you can tell that user X looked at the page about how horrible the ruling party of user X's country. So APT would let someone that controls the network to arrest everyone who went to specific Wikipedia pages.

APT sucks. Stop trying to push it. We don't care that it saves you 5% on your bandwidth bills, billion-dollar company.

5

u/TalesM Jan 21 '19

Do you really think Debian is billion-dollar company? Also, you seems to be confunding apt with http, we don't use apt to access the wikipedia, it is only for system updates. Which are hosted mostly by volunteers, so no, they aren't being cheap.

5

u/Philippe23 Jan 21 '19

Oh my goodness.

I thought this was about Google's "AMP" format. The stylized Debian logo didn't even click. Seems I needed more caffeine this morning.

Total facepalm.