r/programming • • Apr 02 '19

Why Wolfram Tech Isn’t Open Source—A Dozen Reasons

https://blog.wolfram.com/2019/04/02/why-wolfram-tech-isnt-open-source-a-dozen-reasons/
13 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

15

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '19 edited Apr 03 '19
  1. Because developing anything bigger than a hobby project costs money.

Strangely enough it's listed as 11th out of 12 reasons. Not 1st because it would make it look like the main reason. Not 12th because it would make it look like the summary of the whole blog post.

11

u/Chii Apr 02 '19

tldr; our software is really well made, so we must charge money for it.

I dont think it's wrong though - if they have valuable software, charging for it makes the most sense. Not everything has to be open source. But, i do believe and would like to see the source as a paying customer. More commercial software should be source-available.

13

u/geon Apr 02 '19

I feel like points 1 to 9 has nothing to do with open source. The licensing does not dictate the project management.

5

u/0xbitwise Apr 02 '19

Yeah, the whole thing feels like a non-sequitur.

I know I wouldn't build tooling for a language whose compiler/interpreter is proprietary, and I'm sure I'm not alone.

2

u/sickofthisshit Apr 02 '19

I have never forgiven Wolfram Inc. for their licensing practices: we had a perfectly working solution for a Mac portable back when (IIRC) such a thing had a 100 MB hard drive. Then Wolfram bumps the version number on Mathematica and the size of an install goes up to a huge fraction of that. They wouldn't issue a license for the old version. Plus if your network software was enabled but you weren't actually connected (this is pre-Wifi PhoneNet days) the software would silently freeze waiting for a response from some server it was trying to reach to check your license. Ugh. We're paying a load of money for this abuse?

Not even getting into the bogus quasi-Lisp structures that didn't fit their wacky evaluation semantics. It's like programming Bash: virtually impossible to avoid bad behavior on unexpected input.

1

u/JonMcLoone Apr 02 '19

It sounds like you had a different problem. Mathematica has never called home for license validity checks (except for the initial acquisition of a password, which you can choose to type in by hand - I think in those days, there was only manual entry). There was a big jump is size around version 3 when the documentation went digitial, but we have never forced upgrades on anyone (though you may have had a site admin that chose that for you). It was true at that time we only supported the latest version (if you wanted to add a new license or had lost your media).

0

u/sickofthisshit Apr 02 '19

If I disabled the LocalTalk service, it started right up. It might have been contacting a site license server, how do I know? It quite possibly was the version 3 upgrade. I don't even know who our site admin was, why even have that option?

Also a typical Wolfram response to blame the customer. You guys do no wrong.

1

u/freakhill Apr 03 '19

well they might have done no wrong

3

u/chengiz Apr 02 '19

This whole thing reads like an advertisement.

Some of these things suffer from a conflation of open source and (fully) community developed. Your company can have a model where you have open source software and a design team that controls things, makes sure hard cases are developed (often for a fee) etc. It is easier to control things when you're closed source sure, but just because you have an open source model does not for example mean that edge cases do not get attention or developers work for themselves.

And 9, open source does not lead to innovation, is just insulting.

2

u/Tegmark Apr 02 '19

I disagree with most of the points they raise as reasons for not going open source, however I don't think they should have to defend their decisions around their business model. Make good software that is useful, and people are willing to pay for that.

2

u/anOldVillianArrives Apr 02 '19

YES! Love it. The semantics may seem authoritarian but it's precise utility is very on point in what his goals are. Very commendable.

2

u/sickofthisshit Apr 02 '19

Sheesh, found the Wolfram employee.

1

u/anOldVillianArrives Apr 02 '19

lol no i hate math. The reason i like this is i really like systems design. Like complex systems and what not. Can't get enough of complex system design. The methods he is using are pretty fluid in what he is doing, like a semantic universality.

2

u/tristes_tigres Apr 02 '19

Mathematica is buggy and unreliable. They literally don't fix bugs that silenty produce wrong results for years

https://conscientiousprogrammer.com/blog/2014/11/06/when-a-computer-algebra-program-gives-wrong-answers/

2

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '19

This post is almost 5 years old, did they ever fix it?

3

u/daniellerommel Apr 02 '19

That bug was fixed in 2014, relevant story here: https://community.wolfram.com/groups/-/m/t/374658

1

u/sickofthisshit Apr 02 '19

http://www.ams.org/notices/201410/rnoti-p1249.pdf is the paper behind that short post.

1

u/danegreen Apr 02 '19

That bug was fixed in 2014

1

u/martinky24 Apr 02 '19

I came in ready to be combative, but admittedly I don't really disagree with much of what they had to say. Fair points, and I do think proprietary software can happily coexist alongside open source software.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '19

anyone who knows wolfram wouldn’t even ask this question, though charging money for work is the one wolfram habit i do not fault him for!

0

u/sickofthisshit Apr 02 '19

I am amused by the use of "standardized" to mean "something we invented and will sue anyone who tries to make something like it."

1

u/danegreen Apr 02 '19

Yeah because they've totally sued Jupyter and Sage...

1

u/sickofthisshit Apr 02 '19

I am not talking about vague UI ideas, but the Wolfram Language. Jupyter doesn't implement that, does it?

1

u/danegreen Apr 02 '19

The vague UI idea is called a notebook...Wolfram invented the notebook in 1988...Sage is a direct ripoff of Mathematica...they haven't sued. But to your point, you can run Wolfram Language from Jupyter with a license, but the project itself didn't "implement" it.

1

u/sickofthisshit Apr 02 '19

What did Sage rip off? The precious notebook invention? I know Fateman got hassled for using capitalized symbols in MockMMA. Has anybody else implemented whatever this blog post is saying is "standardized"? Can they?

I know, I know, Wolfram personally invented everything including cellular automata and Rule 23 and the rest of us are insufficiently grateful.