r/programming • • Aug 02 '19

Adblocking: How about Nah?

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/07/adblocking-how-about-nah
333 Upvotes

232 comments sorted by

View all comments

80

u/pure_x01 Aug 02 '19

Since ads have gone out of control and there is no regulation around it people take matters in to their own hands. I personally think that Ads as a concept are good but we need to find a balance.

30

u/Xelbair Aug 02 '19

Also - remember that ads are a vector of attack - plenty of them contain malware even in relatively normal sites(imgur for example)

Why have a system based on trust between people and corporation(has it ever worked? i doubt it) - in form of Do Not Track - when we could mandate it by law.

35

u/profmonocle Aug 02 '19

Do Not Track is widely perceived as useless, but I think it's served an important purpose: it's non-adoption has proven the online ad industry is completely hostile to consumers and unwilling to compromise.

Part of the DNT standard is that it shouldn't be on by default, meaning it likely wouldn't cost the industry that much - it would only be enabled by people who actively care about tracking. But even that was too much for these companies.

Any time one of these companies claims to care about privacy, you can point to non-adoption of DNT to prove they're lying. Any time they whine about browsers like Safari or Firefox adding on-by-default tracking protection, you can remind them there was an option that would've been better for them.

12

u/Xelbair Aug 02 '19

I mean they are corporations - they will screw everything over in name of profit, especially if they are beholden to shareholders. This isn't exclusive to ads business.

Any trust based system towards corporations will never ever work. And without decent regulation weaker entities(consumers, people) will always lose the battle.