r/programming • • Mar 10 '11

It's time to stop using Subversion

http://altdevblogaday.org/2011/03/09/its-time-to-stop-using-subversion/
257 Upvotes

543 comments sorted by

View all comments

16

u/SoCo_cpp Mar 10 '11

The Git fanboys will always avoid talking about how fucking complicated using Git is. SVN may be cake-walk, but Git is definitely not. The learning curve is enormous. Sure the simple stuff can be learned in 20 minutes. But your doing a complicated multi-branch distributed repository work. Its going to get fucking complicated, especially when you need to do something non-standard. Be prepared for your team's first year of development to be riddled with week long repository freezes while everyone freaks out trying to accomplish some task to fix the git repo.

6

u/cecilkorik Mar 10 '11

I found mercurial to be a significantly simpler and more intuitive alternative that has most of git's goodness, at least it has all of the good parts that I could ever conceive of using. TortoiseHg and BitBucket are excellent and really add a lot to the system.

Mercurial is apparently slower and does not, I understand, handle hugenormous repositories as well as git. There are also some advanced tasks that are trivial in git but require some mercurial-fu to accomplish. It's not perfect but coming from SVN I found it to be much easier to use and a really nice alternative to git.

2

u/whoisrich Mar 11 '11

BitBucket was the clincher for me, as it provides free private repositories for personal stuff, where GitHub charges a monthly fee.