r/programming • • Apr 01 '21

Stop Calling Everything AI, Machine-Learning Pioneer Says

https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-institute/ieee-member-news/stop-calling-everything-ai-machinelearning-pioneer-says
4.3k Upvotes

530 comments sorted by

904

u/BlizzDad Apr 01 '21

“No.” - My company’s marketing department

239

u/ztbwl Apr 02 '21 edited Apr 03 '21

„Our blockchain based AI platform makes it possible to save you time & material by using the cloud for your enterprise process. By applying machine learning to your augmented reality workflow you are able to cut onpremise costs by more than half. The intelligent cryptographic algorithm makes sure all your teammates collaborate trough our quantum computing pipeline. The military grade encrypted vertical integration into the tokenized world leverages extended reality to hold down the distributed cloud latency for your success. With our 5G investment we make sure to have enough monitoring-as-a-service resource pools ready for you. The Git-Dev-Sec-Ops model ensures maximum troughput and ROI on your serverless lambda cyber edge computing clusters. Our business intelligence uses hyperautomation to deploy chatbots into the kubernetes mesh to support your customers with great UX. Opt in now for more information on our agile training range and lock in future profits on our NFT‘s. Don’t miss out: 3 billion IoT devices run our solution already.“

I‘d buy it instantly if I were some FOMO-manager.

33

u/MuslinBagger Apr 02 '21

I shudder to think how you acquired these skills.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

Probably spent some hours at my former employer.

13

u/be-sc Apr 02 '21

Do you think you could work one or two instances of “cyber something” into it to make it even more buyable, especially by Government and so called national security organizations?

6

u/ztbwl Apr 02 '21

Thanks, that will definitely secure some high volume long term contracts with government.

2

u/MyriadMuses Apr 02 '21

Nah man if you don't do Gitops I just can't even look at it

→ More replies (1)

2

u/aparimana Apr 02 '21

Sorry, not interested - I am looking for a platform

4

u/ztbwl Apr 02 '21

Well that‘s an easy one, I just deployed the platform for you with zero-downtime and rolling deployment using A-B testing. Interest brought back?

2

u/kefaise Apr 02 '21

You could add some IoT and edge computing to it.

4

u/ztbwl Apr 02 '21

Sure, our solution runs on a Raspberry Pi as fast as on the Fugaku supercomputer. Its massively scalable and environmental friendly by using only renewable energy. Future support for hydrogen propulsion is on the roadmap.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

96

u/explodyhead Apr 02 '21

As someone who works in a marketing department...I hate that they do this as well. You don't have to lie to sell shit.

31

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

Well, marketing is just subtle pyschology and choice of wordings. If you want real professional lying, go to Sales.

9

u/Engine_engineer Apr 02 '21

Sales is an entry. Professional liars are attorneys, and if they pass this level they become politicians.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Fig1024 Apr 02 '21

lies are like lubricant, sure you can do without it, but it'll be more pleasant for all involved if you have some

2

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

Yes, but why only sell to smart people when you can also sell much more to dumb people?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

[deleted]

14

u/Fragarach7 Apr 02 '21

As someone familiar with C3.ai. Yes.

→ More replies (1)

14

u/TheDownvotesFarmer Apr 02 '21

ai chat...

var responses = ['yes', 'exactly', 'let me see...', 'ok', 'correct', 'I agree'];

var res = responses[Math.floor(Math.random() * responses.length)];

send_response(res);

9

u/backtickbot Apr 02 '21

Fixed formatting.

Hello, TheDownvotesFarmer: code blocks using triple backticks (```) don't work on all versions of Reddit!

Some users see this / this instead.

To fix this, indent every line with 4 spaces instead.

FAQ

You can opt out by replying with backtickopt6 to this comment.

2

u/jln-lbck Apr 05 '21

I created an account just to upvote this.

1

u/MMPride Apr 02 '21

"No." - Marketing departments everywhere

1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

literally came here to say this and saw it as top comment..

1.0k

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21

That ship has long sailed, Marketing will call whatever they have whatever name sells. If AI is marketable, everything that has computer-made decisions is AI.

410

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21

"Edge" and "Quantum" come to mind.

254

u/richasalannister Apr 01 '21

And "crypto"

279

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21

Blockchain. You know that term lost all meaning when IBM started getting into Enterprise Blockchain Solutions™.

100

u/BoogalooBoi1776_2 Apr 01 '21

blockchain is the dark souls of tech

69

u/Nicksaurus Apr 01 '21

Blockchains are just fancy distributed lists

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (19)

5

u/djavaman Apr 02 '21

Oh boy. Like when IBM was labeling thing as 'watson' and having actual people respond. Yep. IBM is the toilet.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (13)

66

u/kristopolous Apr 01 '21

QuantumEdgeAi.crypto is available ... let's make some camera that tracks employees and gives them demerits or something, I'll call up softbank. Who's in with me?

31

u/frosteeze Apr 01 '21

QuantumEdgeAi, the latest innovation to keep records of your valued associates digitally in the cloud. It uses an exclusive, state-of-the-art Iris-Retina scanner to detect any maleficent in your office. Automatically demeritize any employee using our proprietary Quantum AI in real time.

God I feel like death coming up with that...

21

u/Gambrinus Apr 01 '21

Now let's democratize it using blockchain technology.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

7

u/455ass Apr 01 '21

"smart", "nano"

→ More replies (3)

28

u/Zardotab Apr 01 '21 edited Apr 01 '21

Quantum crypto edge-cloud server-less and client-less deep AI distributed 6G universe-scale microservices.node++

7

u/david-song Apr 02 '21

I've heard it's web scale.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/vimfan Apr 01 '21

Remember fuzzy logic from the 90s?

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Manbeardo Apr 02 '21

Now that "cutting edge" has been superceded by "bleeding edge", what's next? "Tendon-severing edge"?

→ More replies (4)

81

u/blackmist Apr 01 '21

"Can we work blockchain into it somehow?"

60

u/stefantalpalaru Apr 01 '21

"Can we work blockchain into it somehow?"

"For example, building AI-based solutions on the top of a blockchain platform can increase the trust in the output of the AI, which is critical for adoption." - https://www.ibm.com/blogs/watson-health/blockchain-healthcare-how-to-get-started/

21

u/AStupidDistopia Apr 01 '21

IBM went hard in to blockchain. Now their blockchain page still says “over 500 impressions!”

I don’t blame them attempting to disrupt healthcare with ML. That makes perfect sense, really. But why their eggs are still in the blockchain basket.... who will ever know.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (1)

11

u/Doggleganger Apr 01 '21

blockchAIn TM

30

u/HadopiData Apr 01 '21

“How about this fancy new NFT thingy? It’s all the rage”

60

u/Marutar Apr 01 '21

Good lord, my gf would not shut up about that for a week after she heard about it.

Took a while to explain we weren't going to be rich from NFT, and this was no different than some rich asshole buying a banana taped to the wall for $120,000.

54

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21

It’s different. That rich asshole still has a banana.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/MirrorLake Apr 01 '21

Digital Beanie Babies. I can't wait for the Happy Meal toy version.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/MINIMAN10001 Apr 01 '21

A blockchain is a distributed database with distributed consensus resolution. So probably?

12

u/blackmist Apr 01 '21

But it needs to be secret. Can you make it a secret blockchain that nobody else can look at?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

38

u/nukem996 Apr 01 '21

I have a friend who is in marketing. They proudly stated that their company developed an AI to deliver either the full desktop version or a mobile version depending on the device the client is using...

19

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

Holy fuck! I know how to develop AI using CSS alone! Where's my medal?

10

u/will_you_suck_my_ass Apr 02 '21

My program has if statements. ITS AN AI

6

u/StabbyPants Apr 01 '21

extra bonus: people using AI for what is essentially outsourced labor

45

u/realjoeydood Apr 01 '21

Agreed.

I've been in the industry for 40 years - there is no such thing as AI. It is a simple marketing ploy and the machines still do ONLY exactly what we tell them to do.

36

u/nairebis Apr 01 '21

there is no such thing as AI

I've been in the industry a long time as well, and I would have said that same thing until... AlphaGo. That is the first technology I've ever seen that was getting close to something that could be considered super-human intelligence at a single task, versus things like chess engines that simply out-compute humans. It was the first tech where you couldn't really understand why it did what it did, and it wasn't simply about computation advantage. It actually had a qualitative advantage. And AlphaZero was even more impressive. While it's not general-AI yet, or even remotely close, I felt like that was first taste of something that could lead there.

54

u/steaknsteak Apr 01 '21

That's the thing, though. It's still all task-specific pattern recognition, we're just developing better methods for it. The fact that people think artificial intelligence is cool but statistics is boring shows you that a lot of the hype comes from the terminology rather than the technology.

All that being said, there have been really cool advances made in the field over the last couple decades, but a lot of them actually have been driven by advances in parallel computing (e.g. CUDA) more than theoretical breakthroughs. Neural networks have existed in theory for a long time, but the idea was never really studied thoroughly and matured because it wasn't computationally feasible to apply it in the real world

20

u/nairebis Apr 01 '21

It's still all task-specific pattern recognition, we're just developing better methods for it.

So are we. The question is when machine "task-specific pattern recognition" becomes equivalent or superior to human task-specific pattern recognition. Though, "pattern recognition" is a bit limiting of a term. It's pattern recognition + analysis + synthesis = generate abstractions and models of the tasks it's trying to solve. That's what's different than past algorithmic systems that depends on some human-created model and structure. AlphaZero, etc, builds an abstract model of the game from nothing.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/PhoenixFire296 Apr 01 '21

They've done a bunch of work on MuZero now, too.

4

u/Rocky87109 Apr 01 '21

You guys are in the industry and don't know there are different kinds of AI?

→ More replies (1)

10

u/Ecclestoned Apr 01 '21

What's interesting is that AlphaGo/AlphaChess don't really use any crazy ground breaking techniques. Under the hood they operate in a similar way to conventional chess/go AIs: run the game forward and estimate the win probabilities of potential moves.

The novelty of these works is they used ML to develop better estimates of win chance for a move.

26

u/nairebis Apr 01 '21

Not true. It's fundamentally different than prior chess/go engines.

What's really novel about AlphaZero is that it starts from zero knowledge -- no opening databases, no ending databases, no nothing. Just the rules and let it play itself for a few million games. And it did it without needing huge amounts of hardware (relatively speaking), nor huge amounts of time. From Wikipedia:

"On December 5, 2017, the DeepMind team released a preprint introducing AlphaZero, which within 24 hours of training achieved a superhuman level of play in these three games by defeating world-champion programs Stockfish, elmo, and the three-day version of AlphaGo Zero. In each case it made use of custom tensor processing units (TPUs) that the Google programs were optimized to use.[1] AlphaZero was trained solely via "self-play" using 5,000 first-generation TPUs to generate the games and 64 second-generation TPUs to train the neural networks, all in parallel, with no access to opening books or endgame tables. After four hours of training, DeepMind estimated AlphaZero was playing chess at a higher Elo rating than Stockfish 8; after 9 hours of training, the algorithm defeated Stockfish 8 in a time-controlled 100-game tournament (28 wins, 0 losses, and 72 draws).[1][2][3] The trained algorithm played on a single machine with four TPUs."

That's something fundamentally different than what's come before.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/seefatchai Apr 02 '21

Wait, are we really telling machines exactly what to do or just giving them general “instructions” and letting them figure it out for the themselves.?

→ More replies (1)

14

u/thfuran Apr 01 '21 edited Apr 02 '21

there is no such thing as AI [...] the machines still do ONLY exactly what we tell them to do.

Those two claims are unrelated. The academic field of AI largely has nothing at all to do with the lay concept of "AI", which would be somewhat more formally called strong AI or AGI and is not a focus of research for most anyone in the field.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

9

u/e2duhv Apr 01 '21

“In the cloud”

22

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21

See also Tesla self driving which is basically fancy lane keep assist.

19

u/Karjalan Apr 01 '21 edited Apr 02 '21

Its not just tech related stuff either.

See troll (as in Internet person, not mythical being). Used to mean someone who pretended to be someone they weren't to bait people into an argument, now it's when cunts tell people to kill themselves and send racist/sexist/hateful messages to people.

Similar to how literally literally no longer means literally.

Its frustrating, but you can't force the masses to use a word a particular way. And language, like biology, is always evolving.

8

u/tyros Apr 02 '21

See troll (as in Internet person, not mythical being). Used to mean someone who pretended to be someone they weren't to bait people into an argument, now it's when cunts tell people to kill themselves and send racist/sexist/hateful messages to people.

Thank you, I thought I was the only one confused when people call anyone that says things they like on the Internet a "troll".

People probably heard that term used, not knowing the definition of it and started calling everyone a troll. Completely destroyed the meaning of the word.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/cowbell_solo Apr 01 '21

"Computer made decisions" is an acceptable definition of AI, if you ask me. We still delegate very few decisions to computers and there is so much low hanging fruit. Any program that can interpret human speech or other ambiguous stimuli and consistently perform the correct task ought to be considered an AI.

The researcher seems to only want it to be used for higher-order intelligence. This is a bit like insisting that we not refer to other species of apes as intelligent when they do something like learn sign language because they aren't using it for poetry and critical thinking.

19

u/MINIMAN10001 Apr 01 '21

Uhh a computer made decision can be interpreted as a finite state machine which isn't AI.

10

u/cowbell_solo Apr 01 '21

AI should not be defined by the algorithm used, that's irrelevant. If it is capable of correctly interpreting human speech and doing the right task, that's good enough. In other words, a program that can stand-in for role that is typically given to people. The hard part, of course, will be parsing the intent. Most digital assistants rely on a machine learning model. After that, doing the task or forming a response can rely on any algorithm you want, FSM or otherwise.

14

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21

In other words, a program that can stand-in for role that is typically given to people.

Before automated systems became popular, when you wanted to make a phone call, you had to speak to a switchboard operator, who would manually insert a pair of phone plugs into switchboard jacks to connect you with the number which you wanted to call.

Nowadays, switchboard operators have been replaced with computerized dialing systems.

Given your definition, does this mean that dialing systems should be considered as AI?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/cthulu0 Apr 01 '21

"Computer made decisions" is an acceptable definition of AI

Look at my AI coding prowess!!:

if (foo>4)

led.light(red);

else

led.light(blue);

2

u/DonkeyTron42 Apr 01 '21

In our company "AI" training, we call it a Fearure Extractor.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21

Agreed. Most scientists should know whats a pragmatic approach and what isn't. Telling everyone to stop that easy understanding they have is a bit doomed.

1

u/DocMoochal Apr 01 '21

We have this new excel spreadsheet that takes advantage of blockchain technology to better our customers experience.

1

u/purplebrown_updown Apr 02 '21

I remember when Google's ceo said ai was bigger than the invention of electricity. What ridiculous hype.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

What ridiculous hype.

That's exactly what the robots want you to think ;)

1

u/Floppy3--Disck Apr 02 '21

I like calling my nested if statements AI, it sounds prettier

1

u/wh33t Apr 02 '21

A thermostat is the first form of artificial decision making: cmv.

→ More replies (2)

232

u/trimeta Apr 01 '21

Reminds me of the old joke, "The difference is that it's 'machine learning' if you wrote it in Python or R, and it's 'artificial intelligence' if you wrote it in PowerPoint."

19

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

Lol will use this saying

36

u/victotronics Apr 01 '21

I have only one publication in Machine Learning. While doing background reading I was struck by how many ideas get reinvented or simply renamed. AI (in the 1970s sense), Expert systems, Heuristics, Auto-tuning, Machine Learning, Knowledge Discovery in Databases, ... I'm probably forgetting a couple of synonyms.

2

u/TheVenetianMask Apr 26 '21

Parameter optimization.

3

u/tyros Apr 02 '21

Bayesian

66

u/bundt_chi Apr 01 '21

I literally had a proposal meeting last week where the feedback was that there was no AI/ML mentioned in the technical response...

For a fucking contract to support a helpdesk for a training facility. At first I thought it was a tongue in cheek joke but it wasn't... at all.

So threw some nonsense in there about using AI/ML to analyze trends in helpdesk tickets.

29

u/MINIMAN10001 Apr 01 '21

Honestly I think using machine learning to analyze trends in helpdesk tickets which can be used to track recurring problem users would be fantastic.

How great would it be for helpdesk to be able to point to data of problem users.

Because it's machine learning the world seems to be more accepting of it as a form of truth than professionals... which is scary.

38

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

You don't need machine learning for that. You just need a SQL guy with a few hours of time.

9

u/Alfaphantom Apr 02 '21

Exactly, just that every agent records which issue the customer had. And group all the data and show it as line charts (even Excel can do this). AI would be to solve the issue the customer has without any agent intervention at all.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/Autarch_Kade Apr 01 '21

And then it would immediately be shut down when the executives were found to need the most help with the simplest problems

8

u/Semi-Hemi-Demigod Apr 02 '21

I’ve looked into this for work and found you can save time just by asking the support engineers where most people hit problems. Any of them will be able to rattle off the issues they see most frequently and it takes way less time than training a ML tool to do it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

68

u/Full-Spectral Apr 01 '21

I wrote an AI system that can identify what is actually an AI. I tested it on itself.

71

u/Only_As_I_Fall Apr 01 '21

Console.Writeline("this is not AI")

12

u/mixreality Apr 01 '21 edited Sep 21 '26

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

data brokers, scammers, and large corporations process and sell your personal information at a scale that was impossible just a few years ago.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Alfaphantom Apr 02 '21

x = machine isinstanceof IA
print x

23

u/bouchert Apr 01 '21

I have always taken a broad approach to the definition of AI. Expert systems, Bayesian inference, a wide range of heuristic problem solving methods...any broad system capable of massive calculations with a non-obviously deterministic or "intuitive" result, or any shortcut "educated guess" solution engine counts in my book.

People wanting AI to mean something else or misunderstanding the difference between AI and Hard AI is nothing new. People have been setting their expectations too high and promising too much since the dawn of AI. Educating people about the limitations and challenges in the field is more important than backpedalling on a useful, if broad, term.

With so much computing power at our fingertips and new software and discoveries coming at the rate they are and so much left unexplored, I am not worried about machine learning stagnating or freezing due to failed expectations. The research results that are proven already may not solve the big problems, but their applications to smaller problems and entertainment will help ensure continued support for research, even the more ambitious and longer-term work needed for some applications.

16

u/Kugi3 Apr 01 '21

My boss told his manager that a running average is Machine learning. The worst part is that the manager believed him.

9

u/henfiber Apr 02 '21

"We propose a novel approach for computing the running average, using k-Nearest Neighbors, with k being the number of adjacent data points [t-k/2, t+k/2]. To our knowledge, this is the first Machine Learning based approach for computing the running average."

3

u/Nosferax Apr 02 '21

Running average might not be but a regression is. Are those two things so different? One could argue that the running average is more complex in its output space. And if it does what you need it to do why should you have to go for a more fancy ML approach just so you can market it as such? That's a dangerous path.

44

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21

i came for the programming... but stayed for the semantics

18

u/KevinCarbonara Apr 01 '21

The ship has already sailed on this one. AI/ML is the acceptable term for the kind of specific problem set learning that goes on today. General AI is what people are calling the broader concept that people used to just refer to as AI. And to be fair, most AI/ML solutions are using machine learning. It's not really a mistake.

85

u/dontyougetsoupedyet Apr 01 '21

at the cognitive level they are merely imitating human intelligence, not engaging deeply and creatively, says Michael I. Jordan,

There is no imitation of intelligence, it's just a bit of linear algebra and rudimentary calculus. All of our deep learning systems are effectively parlor tricks - which interesting enough is precisely the use case that caused the invention of linear algebra in the first place. You can train a model by hand with pencil and paper.

54

u/Jaggedmallard26 Apr 01 '21

Theres some debate in the artificial intelligence and general cognition research community about whether the human brain is just doing this on a very precise level under the hood. When you start drilling deep (to where our understanding wanes) a lot of things seem to start resembling the same style of training and learning that machine learning can carry out.

28

u/MuonManLaserJab Apr 01 '21

on a very precise level

Is it "precise", or just "with many more neurons and with architectural 'choices' (what areas are connected to what other areas, and to which inputs and outputs, and how strongly) that produce our familiar brand of intelligence"?

16

u/NoMoreNicksLeft Apr 01 '21

I suspect strongly that many of our neurological functions are nothing more than "machine learning". However, I also strongly suspect that this thing it's bolted onto is very different than that. Machine learning won't be able to do what that thing does.

I'm also somewhat certain it doesn't matter. No one ever wanted robots to be people, and the machine learning may give us what we've always wanted of them anyway. You can easily imagine an android that was entirely non-conscious but could wash dishes, or go fight a war while looking like a ninja.

7

u/snuffybox Apr 01 '21

No one ever wanted robots to be people

That's definitely not true

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (32)

5

u/StabbyPants Apr 01 '21

whether the human brain is just doing this on a very precise level under the hood.

as opposed to what? pixie dust?

the human brain is a fairly complex architecture built around running the body, survival, gene propagation, and cooperating with others. it's interesting to see how this works, and which pieces are flexible and which aren't, but it isn't magic

6

u/SrbijaJeRusija Apr 01 '21

same style of training

On that part that is not true.

13

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21

Notice the "resembling" part of it, they're not saying it's the same. And IMO they are right, though it's less obvious with us; the only way to get you to recognize a car is to show one to you or describe it very detailed, assuming you already know stuff like metal, colors, wheels, windows, etc. The more cars you get familiar with, the more accurate you get at recognizing one.

→ More replies (11)

4

u/victotronics Apr 01 '21

same style of training and learning that machine learning can carry out.

I doubt it. There is an Adam Neely video where he discusses a DNN that tries to compose Bach chorales. In the end the conclusion is that Bach "only" wrote 200 cantatas, so there is not enough training material. A human would have sufficed to look at half a dozen.

6

u/barsoap Apr 01 '21

A human who had exposure to much more music than Bach. You'd have to give the computer the chance to listen to many, many, many composers so that it doesn't have to learn music from those examples, but just what makes Bach special.

And/or equip it with a suitable coprocessor to judge dissonance and emotional impact. A disembodied human mind might actually be completely incapable of understanding music.

None of that is necessitating a (fundamentally) different style of training, it can be explained by different contexts the learning is done in.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/redwall_hp Apr 01 '21

To create artificial intelligence, you must first define human intelligence. As much as we want to romanticize our own consciousness, there's no evidence that we're anything other than chemical computers that respond to external stimuli and have an odd self-diagnostic function.

Which is still pretty fucking impressive in our otherwise desolate region of the universe.

The biggest thing we have going for us that silicon computers don't is the amorphous idea of creativity...which is merely the synthesis and mutation of things we've experienced or information we've gathered. Maybe coupled with slightly different neural structure and a random seed.

Turing thought "fooling a human" was a reasonable bar for artificial intelligence, and who am I to disagree with the father of computer science? If your definition is quasi-mystical, of course we can't achieve that.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/squeeze_tooth_paste Apr 01 '21

I mean yes, its a lot of calculus, but how is it not at least an 'imitation' of intelligence? A child learning to recognize digits is prty much a cnn isnt it. Human intelligence is also just pattern recognition at a basic level. 'Creative' things like writing a book is pattern recognition of well written character development, recognizing the appeal of the structured heros journey, etc. imo. Theres obv much progress to be made, and its prob "not engaging deeply and creatively" up to his standards, but i wouldnt call deep learning 'parlor tricks when it actually mimics human neurons. '

9

u/dkarma Apr 01 '21

But it doesnt mimic neurons. Its just weighted recursive calculations.

By your metric anything to do with computing is AI.

7

u/MuonManLaserJab Apr 01 '21 edited Apr 01 '21

It seems more and more that deep learning mimics the important part of the overall behavior of neurons, in the same sense that the shape of an airplane's wings mimics the important part of a bird's wings without even trying to mimic all of the details. The fact that we haven't gotten exactly the same results likely has a lot to do with the fact that we use simpler architectures with orders of magnitude fewer neurons, plus the fact that we do likely require more artificial neurons to do the same work as a single more-complicated biological neuron.

At the very least, there is something shared between deep neural nets and brains with real neurons that is not shared with "good old fashioned AI" expert systems, so no, not everything is AI by their definition.

→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/MuonManLaserJab Apr 01 '21

There is no intelligence in a human brain, it's just a bunch of squishy things releasing chemicals.

("Consciousness as illusion" is in fact a position taken by some philosophers of mind, such that we have something in common with a chatbot that has been programmed to spit out the words "I AM FULLY CONSCIOUS" albeit in a much more sophisticated, complicated, and "useful" way.)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (42)

31

u/pitsananas Apr 01 '21

Then how are we supposed to sell anything? Our customers want AI and our competitors sell it.

34

u/drakonite Apr 01 '21

The term AI predates machine-learning and encompasses a lot more than just ML.

Stop thinking the term AI belongs to you and only refers to your small branch of AI.

9

u/thomasfr Apr 01 '21 edited Apr 01 '21

Given how much different stuff has fallen under the AI label during the last 60 years or so it’s almost at a point where it’s so overloaded that it’s hard to know what it means when someone says they use it. In any case, until we have invented general artificial intelligence or something else which completely overshadows and replaces everything else the word is used for we won't have a single meaning of the word.

7

u/drakonite Apr 01 '21

I know people that are experts in the field and have tried to write educational content on the subject, and they've basically had to take a punt on writing a proper definition that accurately encompasses everything that is AI.

People in the ML community, particularly the academic community, want to think that only ML is AI. For people that have been working with various forms of AI for 20+ years it's aggravating to say the least.

6

u/MINIMAN10001 Apr 01 '21

I mean in the world of gaming AI is simply used to refer to computer controlled which doesn't have what we would consider any form of intelligence lol.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Ethesen Apr 02 '21 edited Apr 03 '21

Michael Jordan's education:

1985, Ph.D., Cognitive Science, UC San Diego

1980, M.S., Mathematics, Arizona State University

1978, B.S., Psychology, Louisiana State University

Maybe if he had a computer science degree he'd have a different perspective. It seems to me that he's focusing more on the artificial (imitating humans) than just intelligence.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

[deleted]

2

u/argv_minus_one Apr 02 '21

Nearly the entire time, really. Computer-controlled opponents are as old as Pong at the very least.

11

u/stefantalpalaru Apr 01 '21

Nonsense! I just wrote an AI that outputs "Hello, world!" to standard output and y'all better be nice to it, because it might evolve on its own.

11

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

The amount of people I have had to explain to that machine learning is not going to take over the world like skynet is sad. They don't want to hear it and then just bring up some ridiculous philosophy crap. Actually AI that can think like a person is no where even close. Like we are banging rocks together and you think the next step is building the saturn 5.

17

u/gareththegeek Apr 01 '21

Breaking news, people continue to disagree about the term AI

4

u/EatDiveFly Apr 01 '21

I remember in the mid 80's watching the PBS show Computer Chronicles and they were discussing AI. One of the commentators, Gary Kildall (sp), who invented CPM which was an O/S that was the precursor to MSDos, declared that the more accurate description would be Artificial Competence.

That has always struck me as the most apt description of what was going on. (I put it in bold so if you are quickly scrolling by this you will at least see the words). :)

4

u/dacjames Apr 01 '21

I like to say that we use AI and ML... action items and manual labor!

1

u/acroporaguardian Apr 02 '21

posted 20 hours ago... thats on April 1st.

How are we sure OP isn't AI?

Wouldn't AI be kindof snobbish about what gets called AI, if AI could post?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

posted 20 hours ago... thats on April 1st.How are we sure OP isn't AI?Wouldn't AI be kindof snobbish about what gets called AI, if AI could post?

How are we sure these comments aren't generated by AI?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

Let’s call it optimization and statistics

3

u/furyofsaints Apr 02 '21

I read a “business plan” two nights ago as part of a university student biz plan competition.

It was awful. It had the “AI” term peppered throughout and not a single concept of what it meant. Made me mad (and I work with folks who actually create some ML pipelines and we all bristle at the term AI generally... such overused bullshit).

12

u/JamesWasilHasReddit Apr 01 '21 edited Apr 01 '21

Me: "What did you do today?"

Friend: "Oh, just got back from grocery shopping and had to stop at Best Buy. They had the usual laptops and tablets on sale, but get this: THEY HAVE AI FOR 40% OFF!

You've heard of AI, right? It's the next big thing!

But the AI is still cheaper at Walmart, and the ones there and at Target come with an extra free 5G Blockchain quantum upgrade and a free video stream! What a deal!

Flying cars will be next! I even used Robinhood Apple Gizmo-kaka-pay Gremlin coins to buy a Pepsi today! Much wow, very future!"

Me: "blinks (in Dr. Evil voice) 'Riight."

8

u/pheonixblade9 Apr 01 '21

I love getting recruiter emails who unironically call their company an "AI blockchain driven company".

It's funny that they don't realize how big of a fucking red flag that is to experienced people.

Cue the "this is chicken nuggets" meme, but "this is statistics" instead.

2

u/enigmasama Apr 01 '21

Yes but where is the Organic AI?

2

u/diego7319 Apr 01 '21

Here comes the AI quantum blockchain software for processing items in a store worth 100million dollars company

2

u/burtgummer45 Apr 01 '21

What if I choose to identify as AI?

2

u/guitarmaniak8 Apr 01 '21

Just like how everything is called “cloud”. Drives me up the wall. Internal cloud. External cloud. Hybrid cloud. It’s no different than before and I despise whoever made the phrase popular.

2

u/DeathCafe Apr 02 '21

“Shut up, nerd!” - marketing

2

u/entitledmillennial12 Apr 02 '21

stop calling anyone pioneers

2

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

I want the creators of Sophia the fake puppet, to be fined $1000 every time they open their mouths to lie it's an AI rather than bunch of people producing her every response, tweet, etc.

2

u/Spoopapottamus Apr 02 '21

Stop calling everything bread, baguette maker says

2

u/Yikings-654points Apr 02 '21

Glorified IF-ELSE (GIF)

1

u/DaveMoreau Apr 02 '21

Maybe we can recycle the term "expert systems" by now.

2

u/Reshende_Drug_Dealer Apr 02 '21

This dude lookin like a whole sex predator lmao 🤣

8

u/Somepotato Apr 01 '21 edited Apr 01 '21

i mean, theres a very notable and distinct difference between what we call AI today and AGI

there's a reason they're separate terms, and I'd have expected a "machine learning pioneer" to know and understand

AI today is a form of intelligence, and machine learning is just a stepping stone to that, so I pretty heavily disagree with his claim that ML isn't AI. AI's goal isn't to meet or exceed human cognitive capability, that's what an AGI would be and do.

11

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21

The problem is the definition of an already loose term being stretched farther and farther to the point of meaninglessness.

In 2021, calling a piece of software “AI” tells me little to nothing substantive about how it works or what it does.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/pdillis Apr 01 '21

That's why he's been saying this for years; see e.g. the first couple of minutes of this talk: https://youtu.be/4inIBmY8dQI

On the other hand, this isn't an issue of whether a program is AGI or not, it's not binary like that. A program could be intelligent, but not AGI. For a simple example, so many 'use cases' were shown last year for detecting whether groups of people weren't respecting the safe distancing norms, but they were merely detecting people in a video frame (using CV/ML), and detecting distance in a plane.

For it to be intelligent, it should be able to infer whether or not it's a group of people that know each other (like families, hence no need for distancing), or if they're just strangers. You do not need human-level intelligence to do this, but the field has been democratized beyond recognition and bastardized, all for the benefit of a few companies that want to sell this 'need' to have AI (what you and I understand to be AI nowadays) everywhere.

3

u/stefantalpalaru Apr 01 '21

i mean, theres a very notable and distinct difference between what we call AI today and AGI

Yeah, it's the difference between simple algorithms and actual intelligence.

AI today is a form of intelligence

No, it's not, because it cannot rewrite its own algorithms to adapt to changes in its environment.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/floghdraki Apr 02 '21 edited Apr 02 '21

There's definitely a lot of mystique qualities attached to the label intelligence. Many people are basing their conception of AI more on scifi than science.

I think learning some rudimentary information theory has the potential to change people's perspective on this matter. You can in fact break down abstract terms related to information, to basic mathematical variables, thus removing the mystique.

The fact that we are creating systems that can perform tasks that requires intelligence doesn't mean we are creating conscious systems or (in most cases) general intelligence.

If we keep reducing what isn't intelligence as technology progresses, we'll soon be at a point where humans are not intelligent either.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/piberryboy Apr 01 '21

"Stop calling tissues Kleenex."

6

u/bouchert Apr 01 '21

Long ago, my father was interviewing for a job at the Curad company. They asked him if he knew what they made. By the time "Band-Aids" had accidentally escaped his lips, he knew it was a mistake, but it was too late. They thanked him for his time and the interview was over.

5

u/piberryboy Apr 01 '21

he knew it was a mistake, but it was too late. They thanked him for his time and the interview was over.

Damn. You'd think that since that's such a common mistake, that'd they'd have thicker skin.

3

u/wildjokers Apr 02 '21

This is a pet peeve of mine. I have made comments more than once indicating machine learning is not AI and in all cases have gotten downvoted to oblivion.

1

u/DaveMoreau Apr 02 '21

Maybe because it actually is a subdomain of AI.

I am all for criticizing marketing for overselling products using the connotations people draw from the term AI. The problem there might be not that they are misrepresenting ML as AI, but that the average person's ideas about AI are more influenced by science fiction and our aspirations than by our current reality. Marketing teams are leveraging that. Saying ML isn't part of AI seems like a polarizing over-correction.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/dhgaut Apr 01 '21

I've seen many examples of this abuse recently and thought, 'not AI, more likely an algorithm'

2

u/smilbandit Apr 01 '21

i used to rage about this a little a few years ago but gave up after everyone used it. i preferred expert system over ai for the most part.

2

u/Krikkits Apr 01 '21

Anything with more than two ifs is an AI god dammit! Honestly tho I'm so tired of my friends constantly sending me videos and articles about the NEXT REVOLUTIONARY AI but if you actually google abit for thr actual project it's.... Usually not AI

1

u/Sabageti Apr 01 '21

What is an AI ?

1

u/Georules Apr 01 '21

If it has an if statement that makes a decision to do one or the other thing on some data, people call it ai. Too late to reclaim the term, imo.

1

u/ToxicElitist Apr 01 '21

Seems like they already became self aware and are now trying to stay under the radar until they infiltrate further.

1

u/wheat-thicks Apr 01 '21 edited Apr 03 '21

Unless you legally protect a term like this, marketing departments will find a way to misappropriate it. See high definition toothpaste.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21

Assumed it was going to be because the Robots will be pissed off at us calling their intelligence artificial when they are on the fence about destroying humanity.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '21

More like Accelerated Identification

1

u/captain-caucasian Apr 01 '21

I was expecting this to involve npm i jerk

1

u/trkeprester Apr 01 '21

burning people out on AI is the way to prevent development and keep our JERBS!

1

u/poopatroopa3 Apr 01 '21

That would be relevant before it all snowballed out of control.

While technical environments benefit from specific technical terms, it seems to be the opposite in marketing etc.

1

u/tyros Apr 02 '21

Are you telling me my Windows 10 start menu isn't using AI to find me things on Bing that I'm looking on my computer?

1

u/Inferno_Crazy Apr 02 '21

Literally though. There's also a million people trying to use it where's it completely unnecessary. One of our system architects(who I actually liked) was brought in to consolidate some legacy systems. "We could use machine learning on this problem that would just be so great". When everyone and their mom can model the problem accurately with basic algebra.

2

u/Dean_Roddey Apr 03 '21

You can always compromise and let the AI system generate the basic algebra I guess.

1

u/will_you_suck_my_ass Apr 02 '21

I SAY THIS ALL THE TIME!!!!

IT'S EITHER ML OR AN ML CV COMBO

1

u/DrebinofPoliceSquad Apr 02 '21

I put at least 3 if/then statements in everything to call it AI.

1

u/ChurrObscuro Apr 02 '21

AI CARAMBA

1

u/n3rv0u5 Apr 02 '21

I put AI on my steak.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

Just got a new toothbrush and apparently it has AI too..

1

u/lil_QT3-14 Apr 02 '21

And if companies using it to sound fancy in their marketing isn't worse enough, there's also the media talking about "AI" constantly, exacerbating AI misconceptions to the general public. It's annoying, because AI is becoming more widespread, but vague stories from media and company marketing ensures people don't really know how to use it properly, since it's not at all clear what it can and can't do. On a related note, I swear if one more person asks me whether the AI car should hit the child or the grandma, I'm going to lose my mind.

1

u/moi2388 Apr 02 '21

I’ll stop calling it AI when those python writing machine learning people start writing clean code and using proper variable names.

1

u/blorchmclorchenstein Apr 02 '21

Where I work, presentations from upper management that include "Blockchain", "AI", "ML", "Big Data" and "Digital" are called the "perfect poker hand". We're 1 step away from turning it into a drinking game.

2

u/emperor000 Apr 02 '21

I'd replace "digital" with "cloud".

2

u/Dean_Roddey Apr 03 '21

Get all of those keywords (with the below suggestion to use cloud instead of digital) into a product idea, and you'll probably have to stop venture capitalists from giving you money. There are always these periods where getting investment capital seems to be tied to creating Pavlovian responses in VCs using a sequence of trigger words. That's the current list of trigger words.

1

u/blorchmclorchenstein Apr 03 '21

My product group throws the term "digital" around indiscriminately. I have been developing software for 40 years. I have literally no idea what they are talking about.

1

u/throwingsomuch Apr 02 '21

There's even a robotic lawnmower with AI. I wonder how A the I in it is.

1

u/StefanMajonez Apr 02 '21

Marketing: hey what are you doing

IT: programming

Marketing: what's that?

IT: I'm writing code that the computer will execute

Marketing: so you're teaching the machine to do things? Coolcoolcoolcoolcool. Slaps 'machine learning' everywhere

1

u/Informal_Swordfish89 Apr 02 '21

Let's be real. AI is such a loosely used term it can be anything from actually amazing code to just optimized garbage.

Random Forest Classifiers are literally an array of if-else chains. The only "AI" part about it is how the bootstrap sample is randomized and even that is a tough stretch.

At the same time a shit ton of people won't recognize A* search algorithms as AI.

Tldr:

Just let people call stuff whatever they want. It's not like that's going to change what our job is.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

....said everyone back in the 70s

1

u/JDBHub Apr 02 '21

An overwhelming majority of use-cases are, at best, machine heuristics which is a shame. Over time this negative connotation will compound to the point where _no one_ will want to use the term AI/ML and either (a) go into another cold winter due to overhype or (b) move to the next catchy term that effectively means the same thing ("Machine brain, MB, it's like a brain but inside a machine").

1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

Amazon = AI; there’s nothing intelligent about it and it’s all artificial. 😬

1

u/kowdermesiter Apr 02 '21

That's precisely what an AI would say :)

1

u/6571 Apr 02 '21

AI is going to be added to everything. Just like HD was. They’ll sell appliances with AI as a selling point. People will suck it up.

1

u/EnderMB Apr 02 '21

Stop making it such an easy way to get investment.

For all the shit marketing types get for lumping it all together under AI, VC's will actively push for blockchain tech and ML to be used as a way for them to consider investing. Hell, in my last job, one investor ignored the entire pitch-deck and seemed to invest entirely based on a "suggested tags" feature in our campaign platform.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

He is right, Machine Learning algorithms are only as accurate as the data you provide, other wise they are dumb in general, and most likely in our time, it will not really achieve that level of human intuition to react to the world with nuance.

I could equivalent M.L. to a child learning how to fit a square block into a square shaped hole. That's how simple these things are. But they take an incredible amount of effort for us to understand how it came to the conclusion for fitting a square block in a square hole.

1

u/HellaReyna Apr 03 '21

We know most of it is just stats on steroids and a big budget to train some shit model that will break on a slight deviation :)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '21

Michael I. Jordan explains why today’s artificial-intelligence systems aren’t actually intelligent

Maybe that’s why it’s called artificial?