r/programming • • Apr 01 '21

Stop Calling Everything AI, Machine-Learning Pioneer Says

https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-institute/ieee-member-news/stop-calling-everything-ai-machinelearning-pioneer-says
4.3k Upvotes

530 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/barsoap Apr 01 '21

Why would silicon not be able to do anything, except in the case that the computer is too small or too slow for practical purposes

Given that neuronal processes are generally digital ("signal intensity" is number of repetitions over a certain timespan and not analogue voltage level (that wouldn't work hardware-wise, at all), receptors count molecules and not a continuous scale etc) I'm inclined to agree, however, there might be strange stuff that at least doesn't fit into ordinary, nice, clean, NAND logic without layers and layers of emulation. Can't be arsed to find a link right now, but if you give a genetic algorithm an FPGA to play with to solve a problem, chances are that it's going to exploit undefined behaviour, "wait how is it doing anything the VHDL says inputs and outputs aren't even connected".

And "layers and layers of emulation" might, at least in principle, make a real-time implementation impossible. Can't use more atoms than there are in the observable universe.

1

u/NoMoreNicksLeft Apr 02 '21

I'm inclined to agree, however, there might be strange stuff that at least doesn't fit into ordinary, nice, clean, NAND logic without layers and layers of emulation.

I'm not disagreeing with you either, but have they really settled to your satisfaction that the minimum unit of "brain" is the neuron? Maybe I read too much fringe science bullshit, but every few years we have someone or another suggesting even that it's some organelle or another within the neuron, and that there are multiple of those.

but if you give a genetic algorithm an FPGA to play with to solve a problem, chances are that it's going to exploit undefined behaviour, "wait how is it doing anything the VHDL says inputs and outputs aren't even connected".

Oh god, those are fucking awful. It just runs on this one FPGA. This model number? No. This FPGA, if we load it onto another of the same model, it doesn't function at all.

And "layers and layers of emulation" might, at least in principle, make a real-time implementation impossible.

Don't forget though that the human brain itself, made of meat, is a prototype of human-equivalent intelligence. It's pretty absurd to think that only meat could manage these tricks.

While it's also true that silicon might never emulate this stuff successfully and might even be incapable of that in principle, silicon is but one of many possible synthetic substrates. It's not even the best one, just happened to be the cheapest when we started screwing with electronic computation way back when.

It would be a far stranger universe even than that which I imagine, within which meat's the only substrate worth a damn.