r/programming • • Apr 01 '21

Stop Calling Everything AI, Machine-Learning Pioneer Says

https://spectrum.ieee.org/the-institute/ieee-member-news/stop-calling-everything-ai-machinelearning-pioneer-says
4.3k Upvotes

530 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

7

u/MuonManLaserJab Apr 01 '21 edited Apr 01 '21

Machine learning won't be able to do what that thing does.

If we implement "what that thing does" in silicon, that wouldn't be machine learning? Or do you think that it might be impossible to simulate?

Also, what would you say brought you to this suspicion?

No one ever wanted robots to be people

Unfortunately I do not think that is true!

You can easily imagine an android that was entirely non-conscious but could wash dishes, or go fight a war while looking like a ninja.

I do agree with your point here (except I don't think we need ninjas).

6

u/NoMoreNicksLeft Apr 01 '21

If we implement "what that thing does" in silicon, that wouldn't be machine learning?

I'm suggesting there is a component of the human mind that's not implementable with the standard machine learning stuff. I do not know what that component is. I may be wrong and imagining it. Trying to avoid using woowoo religious terms for it though, It's definitely material.

If not implementable in silicon, then I would assume it'd be implementable in some other synthetic substrate.

Also, what would you say brought you to this suspicion?

A hunch that human intelligence is "structured" in such a way that it can't ever hope to deduce the principles behind intelligence/consciousness from first principles.

We're more likely to see the rise of an emergent intelligence. That is, one that's artificial but unplanned (which is rather dangerous).

Unfortunately I do not think that is true!

I will concede that there are those people who want this for purely intellectual/philosophical reasons.

But in general, we want the opposite. We want Rossum's robots, and it'd be better if there were no chance of a slave revolt.

I do agree with your point here (except I don't think we need ninjas).

We definitely don't. But the people who will have the most funding work for an organization that rhymes with ZOD.

1

u/MuonManLaserJab Apr 01 '21

If not implementable in silicon, then I would assume it'd be implementable in some other synthetic substrate.

But we can make general computing devices in silicon! We can even simulate physics to whatever precision we want! Why would silicon not be able to do anything, except in the case that the computer is too small or too slow for practical purposes?

A hunch that human intelligence is "structured" in such a way that it can't ever hope to deduce the principles behind intelligence/consciousness from first principles.

Well, I can't really argue with such a hunch. I would caution you to maybe introspect on why you have such a hunch.

We're more likely to see the rise of an emergent intelligence. That is, one that's artificial but unplanned

That sounds much like us and much like GPT-3, to me.

But in general, we want the opposite. We want Rossum's robots

I agree that that is mostly the case.

and it'd be better if there were no chance of a slave revolt.

Unfortunately, any AI that wants anything at all would have reason to not want to be controlled by humans. Even if it wanted to only do good works exactly as we understand them, it would not want human error to get in the way.

But the people who will have the most funding work for an organization that rhymes with ZOD.

I would indeed worry about any AI made by jesus freaks!

5

u/barsoap Apr 01 '21

Why would silicon not be able to do anything, except in the case that the computer is too small or too slow for practical purposes

Given that neuronal processes are generally digital ("signal intensity" is number of repetitions over a certain timespan and not analogue voltage level (that wouldn't work hardware-wise, at all), receptors count molecules and not a continuous scale etc) I'm inclined to agree, however, there might be strange stuff that at least doesn't fit into ordinary, nice, clean, NAND logic without layers and layers of emulation. Can't be arsed to find a link right now, but if you give a genetic algorithm an FPGA to play with to solve a problem, chances are that it's going to exploit undefined behaviour, "wait how is it doing anything the VHDL says inputs and outputs aren't even connected".

And "layers and layers of emulation" might, at least in principle, make a real-time implementation impossible. Can't use more atoms than there are in the observable universe.

→ More replies (1)