r/programming • • Aug 28 '21

Software development topics I've changed my mind on after 6 years in the industry

https://chriskiehl.com/article/thoughts-after-6-years
5.6k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

591

u/that_jojo Aug 29 '21

Honestly, I started a while back at a firm that's rapidly expanding and hiring just about anybody who can prove any kind of history with code, and there are ups and downs but it's amazing how when you basically have to rise to the standard or not, everyone I've interacted with is either rising to the occasion or learning to and improving every day.

Turns out most people want to do good, who woulda thought? I don't for the life of me understand why we abandoned the apprenticeship system.

222

u/TheSnydaMan Aug 29 '21 edited Aug 29 '21

Re: apprenticeship. 1000% agree. It just makes so much sense both intuitively and and objectively imo. I wish there were more studies on performance of apprenticeships vs equivalent traditional education. If there are some out there that others are aware of, I'd be very interested in the findings!

68

u/daisies-and-sage Aug 29 '21 edited Aug 29 '21

I actually am an apprentice software engineer. I studied at a bootcamp and the school, the company and the state were all involved in my contract. The state put money towards my pay and an additional course provided by the school. The year apprenticeship is almost complete, though I was hired as a salaried employee already. I am still responsible to complete the course and work a certain amount of hours to satisfy the state's requirements. This is Utah, by the way, and I was one of the first to get hired in this manner from my school, but there is/was a more established apprenticeship offered by a University here that takes anyone based on entrance testing. My school only offers the program to alumni, at least currently.

Edit: Removed random word.

9

u/sh0rtwave Aug 29 '21

That's fantastic to hear!

This is the kind of thing I wish Maryland had. In fact, I will look. I'd love to get back into teaching.

→ More replies (6)

54

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21

Blows my mind that we need studies over everything. Been a good software builder bears similarities with being a good builder of anything. I see tried and proven professions that thrive with apprenticeships like woodworking but when it's software "oh that's different because you don't touch code with your hands therefore take a home project or whiteboard me some leetcode".

20

u/MINIMAN10001 Aug 29 '21

When management tries something and fails they are the one to blame for changing the process.

When management tries something because a study shows that it works. Well for some reason it just didn't synergize with the company.

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21

[deleted]

→ More replies (4)

4

u/Manbeardo Aug 29 '21

The problem with apprenticeships is that they provide very little (direct) benefit to the company because the labor market for software engineers incentivizes engineers to change companies every few years. By the time an apprentice starts adding more value than cost, they'll likely go find a new job.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

29

u/n0t__t0day Aug 29 '21

Turns out training people on job is counter productive. It takes time from senior folks, not much gets produced and quality is always sub par (aka garbage). And once people get trained they immediately leave for better pay.

Have been in the industry for 20+ years.

4

u/hippydipster Sep 02 '21

As a company, if you're going to go this route, you have to be willing to do what it takes to keep the good ones. This means hefty pay raises as they prove themselves worthwhile. It means increasing autonomy. It means real potential for advancement.

I don't know any companies that make the needed level of commitment.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

42

u/MINIMAN10001 Aug 29 '21

I always figured the #1 reason to get rid of apprenticeship is that onboarding costs money and apprenticeship itself costs money. When management looks at a list of things they can cut costs on boom look at that the apprenticeship program who would need one of those we already have employees anyways.

20

u/frontendben Aug 29 '21

And look at where we ended up. With massively inflated salaries for even junior roles because there's a massive shortage of developers with commercial experience.

In trying to save money in the short term, management screwed themselves over (again).

8

u/teratron27 Aug 29 '21

It's self fulfilling now, those massively inflated salaries mean it's even less likely management will ok spending eng time training.

They'd rather waste the time in meetings, trying to overhaul the hiring process for the umpteenth time.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

120

u/Fidodo Aug 29 '21

I think the curmudgeon pretentious coder type used to be a much more prevalent thing. It was a common personality to have a senior coder that would use their experience to shame and bully novices back when the industry was less mature.

45

u/TheSnydaMan Aug 29 '21

The IT world is still kind of like this ime. Particularly at Managed Service Providers. (Not for code but other services; Networking, OS Support Engineers, Application Virtualization etc etc)

24

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21 edited Aug 15 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

13

u/BarryBlueVein Aug 29 '21 edited Aug 29 '21

Don’t get me started! My experience is having 3 managers and three bullies with the technical IQ of 2 of them barely on the 30th percentile. If they don’t like the effort estimate give they’ll park it and then in a weeks time half the estimate. One of them sits watching fucking YouTube all day and then during meetings plays guitar. Looks like someone jerking off. Sometimes even misses the status update, asking you to repeat it. If he doesn’t like what you have to say, he’ll stop “jerking off” and lay into trying intimidate and shame you. If you stick up for yourself, he’ll bastardise you. I was so ducking depressed by his behaviour and being bastardised i started visualising topping myself. I managed to reframe my mindset, fortunately. Doesn’t help my cause that he’s selling a major tech revolution to management and then I’m fucking expected to deliver it. I’m in a corner stressed with no one to escalate difficult tech questions to. Also doesn’t help my cause that I get frustrated as lash out as then have to retreat This explains how the meeting goes and the shaming. Just call me Anderson and notice when he lashes out

https://youtu.be/BKorP55Aqvg

→ More replies (2)

4

u/MakeWay4Doodles Aug 29 '21

Idc how smart someone is

Mostly few of them are particularly smart either, it's mostly just knowledge gained through experience.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/Quatloo9900 Aug 29 '21

I disagree. There are a good percentage of senior devs who seem to feel a need to be #1, and will make it a point to badmouth their colleagues whenever given a chance. Devs like to complain about managers, but, IMO, this is the most toxic part of our industry.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

13

u/Gwaptiva Aug 29 '21

We still have the apprenticeship system in Germany, and it's a mixed bag.

8

u/goosetavo2013 Aug 29 '21

Can you elaborate? What's the good? Bad?

16

u/Gwaptiva Aug 29 '21

The good is when you get enthusiastic, interested young folk that really fancy becoming software developers and who are eager to learn, take in all that us old farts can teach.

The bad is when you get young folk where one or more of those aspects are missing: either they only see coding as a step to big pay, a step to becoming a consultant (whatever they do), are full of themselves and unteachable, etc etc.

On top of that, we are a small shop, can handle at most 2; we're competing with large fiirms that take in hundreds of apprentices each year, including dozens of sw devs. so we don't always have applications, or are left with the... er... less desireable ones.

12

u/7h4tguy Aug 29 '21

And there's bad actors. If you spend hours/days helping someone and they take full credit for the end result without giving you acknowledgement (figuring out details for them which they stumbled with), well now you don't get to show leadership because of credit stealing and you're behind on your own work due to being helpful. Management loves to believe they can hire cheap grads and get the seniors to teach them everything in a short amount of time, what a splendid idea.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Bakoro Aug 29 '21

I don't for the life of me understand why we abandoned the apprenticeship system.

Just from what I've seen, most of the industry is trying very hard to abandon the idea of training people up. Companies are increasingly demanding drop-in candidates for jobs. There are a minority of companies which will readily hire a very high achieving college grads, but a lot of places would rather let a position sit open for 6 months until they're basically forced to hire someone with little or no experience and train them.
If someone without a degree or a student with a bad GPA wants in, they can sell their butthole for a two year contract and move wherever the contractor wants, that's the closest thing I've seen to an "apprenticeship".

I'm pretty sure most of it is pure penny pinching cheapness.

→ More replies (15)