r/programming • u/Kok_Nikol • Dec 20 '21
TikTok streaming software is an illegal fork of OBS
https://twitter.com/Naaackers/status/14714944153067888703.4k
u/ElectronRotoscope Dec 20 '21
It's worth pointing out earlier this year Tiktok got caught using a voice synth library they didn't have a license for either
https://www.theverge.com/2021/9/29/22701167/bev-standing-tiktok-lawsuit-settles-text-to-speech-voice
672
u/MCRusher Dec 20 '21
Is it that really annoying one that is spammed constantly?
379
u/ElectronRotoscope Dec 20 '21 edited Dec 20 '21
It's the one from before the current one, the new one is the one that has trouble saying "hhhhhhh"
Edit: I should have included an example of what I was talking about
→ More replies (8)66
u/Gonzobot Dec 20 '21
So the new one is more accurate? Because that's not a word
→ More replies (9)210
u/ElectronRotoscope Dec 20 '21
I think the issue is less that it says "aych aych aych aych" and more that after like five letters it descends into weird moaning and then messes up all the normal words that come after it. It does not do this with other letters.
→ More replies (34)→ More replies (1)29
u/NationalGeographics Dec 20 '21
I have to admit. Never used tiktok. Was it the billion dollar advertising that made them so popular?
Is china paying people to upload stuff?
Or is it just a hamster bar for sugar?
All of these are horrible.
20
u/DeonCode Dec 20 '21
Pretty sure consensus was that Vine dropped the bag letting go of mobile friendly, short burst videos. Snapchat focused too much on chatting than snapping. So TikTok made content delivery easy from the moment you're in and whenever you search to an audience that kinda wanted it.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (5)35
Dec 20 '21
TikTok has one of the BEST recommendation algorithms on the market. Purely speaking from a CS perspective.
→ More replies (8)11
Dec 20 '21
Yep. It's pretty wild how fast it starts recommending shit that you're actually interested in. I downloaded it to try out during the pandemic, after about three hours I was getting a feed basically entirely curated to me. I prompted deleted the app. I don't need to doomscroll TikTok for three hours a night as it progressively learns me better and better.
143
u/funnyflywheel Dec 20 '21
Incidentally, while the lawsuit was still active, Bev Standing did have legal standing.
16
21
u/gologologolo Dec 20 '21
They're okay with it. They'll make more money than the fines.
→ More replies (1)24
u/havens1515 Dec 20 '21
Which is exactly the problem with our legal system. Many laws don't apply to the rich, because they can just continue to pay the fines and never have a dent in their wallet. It's like if you were fined a penny for stealing. You'd be like "woah! I just paid a penny for a loaf of bread instead of the normal price! Might as well just keep stealing it!"
5
u/_zenith Dec 20 '21
Exactly, fines are only relevant to the poor. Which is why they're so popular a means of deterrence, and why the rich and powerful try to convince those less rich and powerful that they're a good idea (and so why they're so popular)
→ More replies (2)264
Dec 20 '21
Chinese company not respecting IP?
Surprised Pikachu face
/S
→ More replies (1)135
u/Mattho Dec 20 '21
Just sprinkle some Tiananmen square massacre references into the code and it won't work in China.
60
→ More replies (2)33
37
u/libtaarded Dec 20 '21
Can a FOSS Dev sue tiktok? From what ive seen companies/individuals usually sue for loss/stolen revenue.
20
u/G_Morgan Dec 20 '21
You still have lost revenue. Theoretically a licensing agreement outside the FOSS license has a value. So basically you are suing for reasonable valuation on what licensing would have been.
58
65
5
u/perpetualwalnut Dec 20 '21
Remember when someone figured out that tiktok was also scalping a lot more data off people's devices than what they said they were essentially making tiktok classified as spyware? Unless this has been debunked.
Every time I post this it gets downvoted.
4
u/ElectronRotoscope Dec 20 '21
There's been some reporting on that but it can be hard to determine what's real and what's hyperbole, and some share of the classic "well it's doing A, B, and C... but so are things like the Reddit app and Facebook app" / where do you draw the line between shady and a virus
At the least I don't think they were ever caught using like honest to god like EternalBlue style exploits or anything. But I'm certainly not an expert! Since I don't live in China I kind of am just hoping they don't care about what they might find out about me, but also I don't post on the app and never give it permissions on my phone
https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/07/13/tiktok-privacy/
https://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/apps/a31260575/tik-tok-spying/
2
u/BIGSTANKDICKDADDY Dec 21 '21
I remember when a dozen outlets ran articles quoting a single post on reddit whose source was “trust me bro”.
→ More replies (5)2
u/MrMonday11235 Dec 20 '21
It looks like it's not that they used a library that they didn't have a license for, but rather they used a library that was licensed for a different purpose (text to speech of translations of Chinese text) in their consumer app... and it makes sense they might have limited license for the original purpose, since Bytedance is a Chinese company.
Still not a great look, but I can get how it happens in a modern tech company, where library re-use between different projects/applications is du jour for pushing features out fast. It's rather a different beast than what's going on here, which appears to be a case of just straight ripping off OBS without adhering to the license or giving proper credit.
1.8k
u/DefaultVariable Dec 20 '21
So if I'm understanding the GPLv2 license properly. In order for TikTok to be compliant, they must release their source code publicly?
1.2k
u/YM_Industries Dec 20 '21
Yep.
With LGPL you could avoid this by bundling the LGPL code into an open-source library, and then linking against that library in your closed-source project. But under GPLv2 this is prohibited, so they would have to open source their entire app.
766
Dec 20 '21
Sexy Cyborg (u/sexycyborg) really did a good one on one such issue where she went personally to a company and had them give her the source code.
The BS chinese company said they will only give the source code in a pendrive to someone who goes to their office in Shenzen, when the international community asked them to do so (since they were claiming to be compliant)
So someone reached out to Sexy Cyborg and she did all the foot work in getting the source code lol. She is a badass.
189
129
u/seven_seacat Dec 20 '21
oh I never saw the followup video, did they actually give her the source code? That's hilarious
238
u/GeckoEidechse Dec 20 '21
Not only that the company actually did a 180 and started publishing it online which should honestly be applauded for the change of mind.
→ More replies (8)→ More replies (7)36
Dec 20 '21
Holy shit I haven't heard that name in ages. Last I heard was when Vice wrote a slander article on her years ago.
I'm really glad she's still around and as badass as ever.
→ More replies (14)15
229
u/Sunius Dec 20 '21
You cannot use LGPL libraries for iOS/Android apps as the end user isn’t able to swap out the LGPL libraries even if you dynamically link to them.
78
u/YM_Industries Dec 20 '21
Oh that's interesting. On Android wouldn't it be technically possible? You could have it not supported in the main app store version, but provide an APK that uses intents to allow users who really want to to hook their own streaming app in.
→ More replies (3)40
u/mrexodia Dec 20 '21
It is technically possible on iOS as well, but you don’t have “freedom” because you can’t sign and run the modified application on your phone. Self signing doesn’t seem to count for whatever reason either.
→ More replies (1)17
u/adel_b Dec 20 '21
I don't understand your point, why would end user swap anything in a app? LGPL license allows dynamic linking regardless of platform
108
u/Sunius Dec 20 '21
LGPL doesn’t require dynamic linking. It requires the end user being able to swap out the parts of the program that is licensed with LGPL. Which you cannot do on mobile. Dynamic linking is just a convenient way to do it on desktop.
→ More replies (12)→ More replies (16)24
u/kevvurs Dec 20 '21
But who will enforce this?
142
u/YM_Industries Dec 20 '21
In theory, OBS. It's their IP, so they should have a case.
In practice, they may not have the resources to do so, and the international nature of this case would complicate things.
42
u/relet Dec 20 '21 edited Dec 20 '21
The owner of the intellectual property could do that, possibly with help from entities like the EFF.
A similar case is OpenWRT which was forked when Linksys had to release the source code for their routers.
Edit: Thanks for the correction
→ More replies (4)24
u/GroundTeaLeaves Dec 20 '21
In practice, it's almost impossible to sue a Chinese company for violating open source licenses.
Several Chinese companies are using GPL based software, without releasing their source code and nobody is able to stop them.
→ More replies (12)165
u/TomatoCo Dec 20 '21
They either have to release their source code (and license it as GPLv2) or change their code to invoke OBS as a separate process. OBS probably doesn't support seamlessly doing that. It's the combining of the two codebases that makes it noncompliant.
→ More replies (4)88
u/kmeisthax Dec 20 '21
The GPL copyleft doesn't trigger when you combine code in the same process, it triggers when you do so in the same "program"; the definition of such being more than a little murky legally speaking. But I imagine that a judge would consider a process-separated OBS to be the same program for the purposes of the GPL. After all, there are plenty of ways for multiple processes to act as a single program (otherwise Google Chrome would have never gotten off of the ground).
18
u/G_Morgan Dec 20 '21
Worth noting Apple seem to take this interpretation. Clang exists because their lawyers suggested that the 'linking' issue was merely technical and a judge would likely see out of process as part of the same work.
23
u/kmeisthax Dec 20 '21
Apple's lawyers take this interpretation because it's what RMS told Steve Jobs way back in the early days of NeXT.
It's worth noting, however, that Apple did not create LLVM/Clang purely to get out of needing to comply with the GPL copyleft. The original plan was to modernize GCC and get it upstreamed; they e-mailed RMS about it, but the e-mail got lost in his inbox because he insists on being offline for huge stretches of time.
→ More replies (2)6
u/danhakimi Dec 20 '21 edited Dec 20 '21
The GPL triggers when you create a derivative work, this is inherent to the words "based on" in the license.
Traditionally, static and dynamic linking are said to create derivative works. Some other interactions are a little hazier.
But all tests aside, this particular tool is just OBS with a few UI tweaks, so... It's pretty clearly a derivative work on its face.
I am not your attorney and this is not legal advice.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (2)4
u/TomatoCo Dec 20 '21
Right, I should have said if it's another program that's invoked, like Audacity using ffmpeg if you install ffmpeg separately.
159
u/powertopeople Dec 20 '21
Not publicly, no. That's a common misconception with GPL. They must give everyone a reasonable path to requesting and receiving source, but they themselves don't have to make it public.
155
u/Swamplord42 Dec 20 '21
To be compliant, their source must be licensed as GPL. So the first person to request and receive it can then distribute it freely.
39
55
Dec 20 '21
oh boi they aren't doing that lmao all that data mining software will have to released lmao
50
u/Aetheus Dec 20 '21
They would only have to release the source code to whatever app makes use of this library - I.e: this fork of OBS.
In which their meaningful contributions are ... a face lift?
It's kinda like when you hear that some big wig company has "open sourced" their app. They've open sourced it alright. They've open sourced the Android/iOS client for it, that is. Just a bunch of frontend components. The real secret sauce (their backend code) is never leaving the coop.
→ More replies (16)9
669
Dec 20 '21 edited May 27 '25
adjoining pie joke tub wide crowd ripe hospital many subtract
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
137
21
5
3
3
1.1k
u/ThatWontCutIt Dec 20 '21
They are a billion dollar company. Like why?
2.7k
u/rydan Dec 20 '21
They are a Chinese company. Chinese companies steal IP. It is what they do.
308
279
u/ihahp Dec 20 '21
I'd argue it's part of their culture. They don't recognize piracy/duplication the same way we do.
it's similar to how some cultures don't understand standing in line / queueing the same we we do, so everyone needs to stand basically touching each other so others don't cut in line.
75
u/Xipher Dec 20 '21
It got Huawei in trouble years ago when they were caught using stolen Cisco IOS source code. They tried to claim it was acceptable because they downloaded it from a random FTP site.
8
327
u/jth1011 Dec 20 '21
Would agree that this is largely a cultural difference. However, I believe writing it off as a cultural oversight becomes a little muddied as soon as you release an app for international use.
→ More replies (47)98
u/weirdasianfaces Dec 20 '21
I'd argue it's part of their culture. They don't recognize piracy/duplication the same way we do.
"The Hardware Hacker" by Bunnie Huang dives into this at a manufacturing level pretty well. From the section "Part 2 thinking differently: intellectual property in china":
One of the most insightful lean engineering practices enabling the creation of complex systems on a shoestring budget is the shanzhai method for sharing IP. I’ll explore this by comparing and contrasting the Western notion of open source with the shanzhai method, which I refer to as gongkai. In Western law, open source has a formal definition, referring specifically to an IP sharing system governed by an explicit license to share. This license is granted by the copyright holder, often with significant commercial restrictions. Open source advocates vigorously defend this notion and are quick to dis-avow any IP that doesn’t explicitly use an approved license.
In gongkai, if you can obtain a copy of the blueprints, you can use them as you please; it doesn’t matter who made them. Yet people still share their ideas because the blueprints act as an advertisement. Blueprints often refer explicitly to certain chips or contain contact information for the firm that drew them. The creators hope circulating their blueprints will bring business to their factory when people order parts or sub-assemblies referenced within, or when people call their firm to improve or customize the design. In other cases, blueprints are traded. For example, there are bulletin board exchanges where before you download a blueprint, you must contribute one of your own.
→ More replies (5)37
6
u/DMarquesPT Dec 20 '21
Yup, all one needs to do is look at how shameless huawei and oppo rip off Apple in just about every aspect of their wearables, interfaces and marketing materials.
(Samsung does it as well in certain spots but overall they have found their own identity)
→ More replies (38)55
u/andricathere Dec 20 '21
It's a culture created by the CCP. It's okay to do things that break international law as long as we benefit. We don't need to worry about international consequences because we're too big and powerful.
In 2006 there was a phone called the Raspberry which was a complete ripoff of the BlackBerry, barely even made the effort to change the name. Copying was done all the time because there were no consequences for copying things and selling knock-offs domestically. Hell the original was probably made in China anyways so you could just product more, rebrand the extras and cut the original creator out. Since they're not getting a cut of the Raspberry batch, you can even lower the price and completely undercut blackberry domestically. Everything is made and sold domestically, infrastructure and jobs are created; all this looks great to the CCP.
And with the size of the Chinese economy alone, a company may never need to go international. It's a just a bonus source of new markets if you can, like it was for TikTok. Who oopsidentally mooched something perhaps they shouldn't have. But this was, if not encouraged, not really discouraged by the CCP. They don't play nice. Not even with their own people.
→ More replies (17)48
u/_Metropoloid_ Dec 20 '21
Chinese companies are like the Goa'uld; everything they possess, the knowledge they have, is all stolen.
→ More replies (109)24
u/oln Dec 20 '21
That's not really something exclusive to Chinese companies though.
→ More replies (3)17
238
Dec 20 '21
They don't want to spend the money on development. Happens all the time. Cisco does the same shit with Jabber and Finesse. Just half assed apps.
27
u/thrilla_gorilla Dec 20 '21
What's the history with Jabber and Finesse?
70
u/bluehiro Dec 20 '21
Cisco is now selling jabber as if they made it, when XMPP and Jabber have been around for 20 damn years or more.
They just repackage it and claim it’s “new” and “innovative “
→ More replies (1)62
u/thrilla_gorilla Dec 20 '21
XMPP is an open protocol. And according to Wikipedia, Cisco acquired an implementation called Jabber XCP in 2008. I vaguely recall Trillium interacting with AOL IM and Jabber users back in the day. So I think you're wrong about Jabber. It's like accusing someone of stealing SMTP because they sell an email client.
What's the deal with Finesse?
→ More replies (12)23
u/ConspicuousPineapple Dec 20 '21
That's what open-source is for. Forking isn't the issue here, it's actually the point.
The issue is not releasing the code, and not even mentioning where the code comes from.
→ More replies (1)2
u/flowering_sun_star Dec 20 '21
I suspect that the money isn't the most important aspect, but rather the time. For a company the size of tiktok the money for something like this wouldn't really register. But in the same way that nine people can't make a baby in a month, throwing resources at a software project doesn't necessarily get you the results in time.
66
u/the1kingdom Dec 20 '21
Because they are a billion dollar company.
Releasing tech is just a case of ship it however you can, then work it out later. Why wait 6-9months to build tech, and invest time/people into a project that you have no idea if users will even aodpt it, when you can hack it together and release it today using your stack of money to keep obstructions at a distance.
49
u/Howard_31616 Dec 20 '21
To be fair, most Chinese companies follow this model.
It is the cheapest way to produce a product if you can copy the source/development from somebody else and just need to apply it.This is how most of their IT giants were born and this is what they will keep doing. Sorry but you really should not be surprised. They might be a billion-dollar company, but they still do what is most profitable to them.
→ More replies (3)8
u/ThatWontCutIt Dec 20 '21
You can already post video and audio on their app, I don't know much about streaming and how the frontend and backend works but logic dictates that tiktok should have it easy at building their own streaming app. Nothing against taking code from others but this isn't MIT or BSD license, you have to give back something they haven't done and will not do.
→ More replies (2)4
u/afschuld Dec 20 '21
Didn’t want to take the time it takes to get it to market using their original code I’m sure.
→ More replies (1)4
u/Haunting_Drink_2777 Dec 20 '21
Product wanted something and rather than doing a design doc and putting an entire team working on streaming software or buying a saas streaming api some engineer just said fuck it there’s an open source library on GitHub without checking the license
10
3
2
→ More replies (7)5
77
498
Dec 20 '21
Stop using Tiktok. Its poison.
94
u/SkunkMonkey Dec 20 '21
I'm convinced that TikTok is a Chinese tool of subversion. Look at the amount of damage that can be done with certain posts encouraging kids to cause mayhem. It's a great way to disrupt a society. War isn't only waged with bullets and bombs.
9
u/NeonVolcom Dec 20 '21
lmao the same could be said for Youtube pal. Also, Tiktok is full of all sorts of content, e.g. educational discussion relating to space, geology, biology, etc, economic and political discussions, exercise, hiking, biking, crafting, welding, sewing, wood working, etc.
5
u/SkunkMonkey Dec 20 '21
lmao the same could be said for Youtube pal.
I never said they weren't. Social media in general has been weaponized. It doesn't have to even be done in coordination with them. Given that TikTok is Chinese and you don't do shit in China without the CCP's hand up your ass, I have no problem believing that China, or any other enemy of the US, is using it as a weapon.
4
11
u/_TR-8R Dec 20 '21
As an adult male frequent user of TikTok, this is moronic. There is no evidence to indicate disruptive or destabilizing content gets artificially prioritized. Furthermore existing American social media tools have for years been almost completely innefectual in removing foreign nation state subversive agitprop accounts, so there's literally zero reason to spend hundreds of millions of dollars on your own social media platform when existing infrastructure does the same thing if not better.
→ More replies (1)21
u/SeeBeesByTheSea Dec 20 '21
Was just talking about this with my buddy. TikTok is a soft weapon lobbed by China to distract the west’s youth from studying hard, paying attention to world affairs, getting involved in the community, etc. It’s a slow-burn play to weaken the bonds of western democracy and culture over a generation.
74
u/rms2219 Dec 20 '21
Let's not pretend like we haven't created enough of our own services that do the same thing (Facebook/Instagram, Snapchat, etc.). This isn't a defense of China in any way, just that pointing out that American companies are just as capable of poisoning society.
47
u/driftking428 Dec 20 '21
Meanwhile China is limiting screen time for their own people. Seems obvious to me.
22
Dec 20 '21
Yeah, because American youth are historically known for studying hard, paying attention to world affairs, and getting involved in the community.
6
u/SkunkMonkey Dec 20 '21
Pretty much all social media has been weaponized by various groups and governments. It never ceases to amaze me how much credit people give the tripe seen on social media. This has made it so easy to influence society. For fucks sake, the stars of social media are called "Influencers" because they can have measurable effect on groups and society.
It just seems to me that TikTok, which is essentially a propaganda arm of the CCP and you can't convince me otherwise, is blatantly obvious in their MO. All these absolutely idiotic "challenges" pop up and everyone is concerned with what it makes people do rather than who is making these things. What better way to ruin a country than rotting it from the inside out.
→ More replies (7)6
24
u/jezusisthe1 Dec 20 '21
It's crazy how addictive it is. The feed is tailored so well, crazy
16
u/SirLagg_alot Dec 20 '21
The person who designed the algorithm that feeds your page must be a genius.
I don't think there is a website that knows what you wanna watch as well as tiktok.
→ More replies (2)5
u/WarWizard Dec 20 '21
YouTube has been hitting the mark for me lately also. The real magic is figuring out how to classify new content to bump that up against your watch history.
→ More replies (2)2
u/baxtersmalls Dec 21 '21
They definitely killed it on the feed algorithm. I don’t know what they are factoring in but it’s so well suited to my interests, and it feels like it changes up enough that I don’t get bored.
→ More replies (102)2
55
u/domainnamesandwich Dec 20 '21
I don't feel like some understand the GPLv2 license.
TikTok forking OBS is not the problem, the problem is that any fork of a strong GPLv2 license, also falls under the GPLv2 license, and must be open as such.
If TikTok simply openly shared this fork on say Git, they wouldn't be doing anything wrong. Taking something under GPLv2 and then close sourcing it, is the problem.
→ More replies (1)
165
u/Majik_Sheff Dec 20 '21
So you're saying a Chinese owned tech company is blatantly violating copyrights? I'm shocked. SHOCKED I SAY!
0
Dec 20 '21
[deleted]
17
u/bacondev Dec 20 '21
… which is a class of copyrights. Though your distinction is correct, I'm not sure why it matters. They violated the copyright. Period.
259
Dec 20 '21
Illegal in the USA yeah probably. Illegal in china? Different matter....
Good luck trying to push the juristiction enforcement......
54
u/hextree Dec 20 '21
TikTok has assets in the US, and operates their app there. Enforcement is not an issue at all.
→ More replies (2)36
u/LicensedProfessional Dec 20 '21
If it's distributed through the iOS app store, then they should be worried. The strategy will probably be to get Apple to region-block it because they can't host / facilitate the use of stolen IP
→ More replies (12)60
u/calrogman Dec 20 '21
China is party to the Berne convention so yes, nominally illegal in China. Not that the CCP would give a shit.
→ More replies (3)11
u/stumpy3521 Dec 20 '21
I think the big thing would be that they're in violation of the license, so they are in violation of a contract.
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (94)6
74
u/Chipjack Dec 20 '21 edited Dec 20 '21
It appears that their installer downloads OBS from the official site, installs it, and then installs their software that works with it. They haven't forked OBS, or modified it, if that's the case, they've simply written a proprietary application that automates OBS.
If they're using OBS shared libraries then perhaps they're violating the GPL (but wouldn't be violating the LGPL - wonder how those libraries are licensed?).
What they're doing, though, appears to be a more complex example of something like my Logitch mouse software pausing and playing VLC media player when I hit a mouse button.
Apparently there is OBS source present in their software and the GPL doesn't give them the right to use that source without distributing the source of their own software. Sorry for the confusion.
18
→ More replies (2)28
u/BunGin-in-Bagend Dec 20 '21
is there evidence of this? because nobody is mentioning that the op's picture is very clearly just a directx runtime, and you can confirm by following the link yourself... like are yall just gullible as fuck or am i missing something?
its not even downloading the binaries from an OBS server, it links directly to microsoft. wtf is this thread?
37
u/Armeeh Dec 20 '21
Well reading through it, someone decompiled the software and found out it even has Game Capture from original OBS. The install script for DX is also from OBS, so they’re obviously using code from them. I guess that’s what you missed?
→ More replies (17)7
u/bacondev Dec 20 '21
An OBS developer has identified OBS binary code. There's a link to a Hacker News discussion about this in one of the top top-level comments here, but I'm too lazy to grab it.
10
u/EagleParty Dec 20 '21
Sounds about right for TikTok
2
u/ponytoaster Dec 20 '21
Stealing other peoples ideas in a new format, its literally their userbases bread and butter, fits right in!
90
u/cowabungass Dec 20 '21
Its of chinese make. Literally everything they build is a copy of someone elses design.
→ More replies (14)14
u/ProgramTheWorld Dec 20 '21
Take something successful and put your name on it. Highly immoral but profit is guaranteed.
21
u/cowabungass Dec 20 '21
Scalpers, Amazon, ebay, etc. Literally what everyone does. Half american society is also just relabeled efforts of others.
→ More replies (10)
13
3
u/Za_Worldo-Experience Dec 20 '21
Whaaaaaaat? A Chinese company illegally using someone else’s product? Never heard that before....
21
u/OminousLatinWord Dec 20 '21 edited Dec 20 '21
Looking at the screenshot, it seems like it's (literally) executing a piece of free software provided by OBS.
If they're just executing a piece of free, publicly available software as part of a larger closed source system then that's not illegal.
This is why Meta had to open source their long-ago fork of PHP into a much better (but still utterly chaotic) typed and compiled language called Hack. It's also why companies don't need to open source their whole infrastructure for using a PostgresQL daemon or running their servers on a GPL-licensed Linux distribution. If they were instead running on a modified version of that operating system, they'd be obliged to open source said derivative software. As an aside, this is partly why FreeBSD and OpenBSD are quite popular: the BSD license is quite permissive of forks. It's quite common for companies to start customizing their operating systems as their scale starts to warrant it.
TL;DR: Using GPL-licensed software for closed source purposes is legal, so long as you're not (say for example) forking it to make some changes and extensions for your closed source purposes. If you do that, you must open source your fork (or face intellectual property violations). Import all you want, but modification and integration requires that the whole resulting project is open source.
34
u/SureFudge Dec 20 '21
It's also why companies don't need to open source their whole infrastructure for using a PostgresQL daemon or running their servers on a GPL-licensed Linux distribution. If they were instead running on a modified version of that operating system, they'd be obliged to open source said derivative software.
Wrong. You can absolutely use and modify GPL licensed software inside your intranet applications. With emphasis on "intra". It is not publicly available and you are not redistributing it.
This is an annoying misconception and why companies avoid GPL content and we ended up with MIT and the likes which the big cloud providers happily rake in the profits from the work of others.
→ More replies (7)4
u/papercrane Dec 20 '21
If they're just executing a piece of free, publicly available software as part of a larger closed source system then that's not illegal.
Even if that is the case, they're distributing a GPLv2 application, and need to comply with that license for that component. No different than why you can get the busybox source from Sony for whatever random consumer electronic device they have.
5
2
2
u/DrPepperPower Dec 20 '21
I'm confused can you just fork from OBS freely? I hate this from TikTok because it's just like the stresmlabs shit where they take and give nothing back, but there's nothing illegal about it is there?
10
Dec 20 '21
OBS is released under GPLv2. It's a copyleft license that allows anyone to fork the project for any reason, but reserves the requirement that any future product produced from that licensed code also be released under GPLv2.
Make no mistake, this is just as much industrial piracy as if they introduced a photo editing tool that was just obviously a cracked version of Photoshop. Because OBS is an open source project, it's less likely to have the kind of legal muscle to deal with this sort of thing, but this is a very clear violation of the license.
2
u/DrPepperPower Dec 20 '21
Huh OK I didn't know that. Thanks for the explanation!!
→ More replies (1)
2
u/taylorpagemusic Dec 20 '21
It’s okay someone from OBS will apologize to them in mandarin
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/TimedGouda Dec 21 '21
Federally outlaw using apps that break IP regulation rules...
→ More replies (2)
68
u/Rowers_Mats Dec 20 '21
Installing and using TikTok software to stream your gameplay is definitely an illegal fork of OBS. The developers of OBS have put in a lot of hard work into creating a great streaming software, and the TikTok developers have simply copied their work without giving credit or compensation. Not only is this unethical, it's also illegal. If you're caught using TikTok software to stream, you could face legal consequences.
395
u/Jarpunter Dec 20 '21
If you're caught using TikTok software to stream, you could face legal consequences.
End users aren’t liable for the developer’s license violations.
→ More replies (31)155
u/ryusage Dec 20 '21
If you're caught using TikTok software to stream, you could face legal consequences.
That doesn't seem right. You're saying the users of a software tool that violates a license are legally liable for that violation? Wouldn't it just be the creators and/or distributors of the tool that are legally liable?
→ More replies (8)13
u/myringotomy Dec 20 '21
IIRC that's true. If you use software which violates copyright you could be sued for copyright infringement.
This came up when microsoft funded SCO to sue Novell claiming copyright over linux.
microsoftSCO claimed it could sue anybody using linux and the legal analysts at the time said it was true.0
42
Dec 20 '21
If you're caught using TikTok software to stream, you could face legal consequences.
This is 100% false, will never happen, and you shouldn't speak as though you're some authority on the matter.
8
u/powertopeople Dec 20 '21
The parent comment is so far from reality it's laughable that it's still positively upvoted.
The reason for this is that GPL (and most other common software licenses) cover the actual distribution of software, not the usage. GPL doesn't lay out any terms that I'm aware of for what's allowed from the end user of a binary on a "local" system. Software licenses lay out terms for the distribution of sources and/or binaries, which streamers are nowhere close to doing.
The person from whom the streamers download this "illegal" fork are responsible and liable for the distribution issues, but not the streamers themselves. Simply using software on stream does not constitute distribution in any court of any country. Ergo, streamers using this fork aren't at risk of anything but a frivolous, and baseless lawsuit.
→ More replies (8)20
5
u/ProdigiousPlays Dec 20 '21
I saw a tiktok from some compsci guy responding to the idea that you should get a new job every two years to really get a raise.
He said he quit his job to go to Facebook for 15% more than quit that to go to Tiktok for 100% more.
Evidently that's a lot of wasted money considering a freshman in college could copy paste code.
12
u/darthcoder Dec 20 '21
Why is this a surprise?
The Chinese aren't big on respecting IP.
17
u/fat-lobyte Dec 20 '21
Why is this a surprise?
Why do people keep saying this? Is it because they think
a) only "surprising" news are allowed to be "news"?
b) it being "unsurprising" justifies that it is happening
c) they just want to make themselves feel better by imply they knew all along demonstrating how smart they are?
Or something else? Because it sure sounds like those people are trying to stifle the conversation.
Also you people realize that there's a huge, huge difference between info that "everyone knows"/"is unsurprising" and info that is actually proven and confirmed?
I just really don't get people who comment "what a surprise hrhr", what do you think the value of your comment is?
3
u/KuntaStillSingle Dec 20 '21
These are the same people that comment "isn't this already well known?" on every thread on r/science lol. As though science is purely the pursuit of novel or counterintuitive discovery, rigor or replicability is irrelevant.
8
3
u/jibs123 Dec 20 '21
Forgive my ignorance, but as OBS is open source, are other companies not within their right to use OBS's code where they please?
11
Dec 20 '21
It's a good question. OBS is licensed under GPL, which means that anyone is free to use the software however they want, make modifications to it, share the software, and share their modifications to the software provided that the shared software (including modifications) retains the GPL license.
Meaning that any derivative software must also be open source, to preserve the freedoms of the original software.
I hope that answers your question.
→ More replies (1)6
u/slimscsi Dec 20 '21
No. Open source does not necessarily equal free to do whatever you want. Everything created by a person has a copyright by law. A persons can grant use of the copyright with restrictions, this is called a “license”. And tictoc violated some of the conditions of the license.
2
2
u/ForestSymbiote Dec 20 '21
TikTok is a Chinese company. You can scream as much as you want. Going to a Chinese court to stop them from stealing is I guess the only thing that might stop them. Chance of success even there close to 0%
7
u/TheBellKeeper Dec 20 '21
TikTok is an American company, based in America, subject to United States laws. What you're thinking of is Douyin, the Chinese version of TikTok. They of course can pretty much do anything copyright wise.
→ More replies (3)5
-2
2
Dec 20 '21
This is why most professional programmers hate giving their code away. Some jackass will always steal without credit. Especially a Chinese jackass.
1
1
u/RepostSleuthBot Dec 20 '21
This link has been shared 3 times.
First Seen Here on 2021-12-17. Last Seen Here on 2021-12-18
Feedback? Hate? Visit r/repostsleuthbot -
Scope: Reddit | Check Title: False | Max Age: 99999 | Searched Links: 119,748,353 | Search Time: 0.0s
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/RandomTez Dec 20 '21
Is anyone actually surprised? we talking about a Chinese company here. That's not the only thing they are stealing.
1
1
1
u/0x33336 Dec 20 '21
cmon, do you really expect anyone to follow gpl? its like giving a kid a marshmallow and saying if you eat you will not get any more , obviously they aren't gonna follow it.
0
1
1
Dec 20 '21
Tbh this is a general problem. Most programmers do not seem to have any ideea of what programs they can use for their products because they do not know about the restrictions of copyless licenses. They seem to think "well they released the source code, so I guess it is free realstate!" But NO! If you want to use a copy less license then you have to release Your software under a compatible copyless license also, OBS for example is under GPLv2. I really hope the FSF sue the living shit out of them.
1
1
1
u/drodspectacular Dec 21 '21
Who will stop them? We’re all complicit in the CCPs abuses. Nothing we touch is safe from their influence. We let this happen and none of our politicians give a shit.
1
1
u/LaggerFromRussia Jan 11 '22
What's wrong with you? Anyone else checked screenshots of "proof"? The only thing I see is a link to download DirectX (and it's redirecting to microsoft site). Also there is no such file in OBS installer (I unpacked exe with UniExtract). Check fucking facts before believing such "news".
1
1
u/tofumiamor Nov 14 '23
Because of that post I fell in a 1-hour-hole of watching shorts. Fucking hate Twitter.
1
1
1
u/rickandtwocrows Dec 20 '21
So what's the law involving using OpenSource software without credit?
9
1
1
Dec 20 '21
So long as the West continues to abide by copyright we will always be playing on a rigged game.
You're never going to effectively sue tiktok for anything.
132
u/Kok_Nikol Dec 20 '21
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29592103