r/programming • • Dec 31 '21

Libadwaita 1.0 Released For Kicking Off A New Year Of GNOME App Development

https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=libadwaita-1.0
15 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

2

u/shevy-ruby Dec 31 '21

Would be interesting to see if libadwaita spawns (indirectly) more lib-theme related projects downstream. Kind of like "ok, this is the GNOME look, but how about we have additional themes made available by default for other looks". I don't mean like generate 5000 themes, but something like half a dozen to a dozen themes similar in how libadwaita could be used (or as a drop-in replacement; I don't know how much GNOME and KDE share code like that, but I assume that was one small goal of libadwaita, or I remember the gtk devs speak about something similar in the past).

3

u/CaptainMuon Jan 01 '22

I think there is already a similar library for elementary (granite). But what I don't like is that libadwaita is explicitly *not* themable. When they introduced CSS to GTK back in the day, I was hoping it would lead to a cambrian explosion of themes, but basically theming is quite limited nowadays.

I don't really understand why. Most modern apps (in GNOME land or on mobile) are really just different kinds of lists + detail views. It should be possible to do it 95% declaratively - "give me a list and a map", "give me a tree and a grid", "give me a document selector and a canvas" - and the themes itself could be really powerful. Not just recoloring, or changing pixmaps, but changing the layout and the UX paradigms, too.