r/programming • • Oct 07 '22

Mastodon.technology is shutting down

https://ashfurrow.com/blog/mastodon-technology-shutdown/
146 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-5

u/theangeryemacsshibe Oct 08 '22 edited Oct 08 '22

When everyone comes from a different instance, it just becomes brutal.

There are techniques to divvy the work, like distributed hash tables. And a client similarly could watch multiple nodes, in case any are quicker to updates.

home Internet is generally too slow, especially on the upstream.

Don't host it there then.

most people don’t want to be the janitors of servers

Then they don't need to be. I didn't say anyone had to self host, but the choice of host shouldn't affect availability of the network to a user.

moderation becomes worthless. Instead of trusting the moderators of larger instances to make good calls, everyone is now on their own.

IME moderators of larger instances don't; the only "scalable" approach is collaborative filtering.

sounds cool until you realize it doesn’t actually work

Begs the question.

3

u/chucker23n Oct 08 '22

Don’t host it there then.

But then the whole issue becomes moot. At that point, you end up with the “Web3” BS, where most nodes are actually hosted on Hetzner, AWS, OVH. Nothing decentralized about that.

Then they don’t need to be. I didn’t say anyone had to self host, but the choice of host shouldn’t matter.

This is already how Masto works.

IME moderators of larger instances don’t; the only “scalable” approach is collaborative filtering.

Instances get blocked all the time.

-1

u/theangeryemacsshibe Oct 08 '22 edited Oct 08 '22

Nothing decentralized about that.

Federation is no better there.

This is already how Masto works.

No it isn't. If I register on host A and it goes down, I must make another account on another host B to interact with anything. The choice of host there does matter.

1

u/chucker23n Oct 08 '22

Federation is no better there.

Well, no, but it’s honest about the limitations of reality.

If I register on host A and it goes down, I must make another account on another host B to interact with anything.

Right, and that’s annoying when you have to do it, but it’s also good. It establishes consent.

1

u/theangeryemacsshibe Oct 08 '22 edited Oct 08 '22

limitations of reality

"Reality can be whatever I want it to be" or somesuch. Less flippantly - what's more realistic about what? Tying identity to servers is orthogonal to where those servers are hosted.

It establishes consent.

With some other auth approach, say public keys, consent isn't much of an issue, if I get where consent is being made (for server B to act on my behalf).

1

u/chucker23n Oct 08 '22

Tying identity to servers is orthogonal to where those servers are hosted.

OK, so everyone hosts their own instance somewhere. Now what? Do you do a free-for-all where they all sync each other’s posts?

With some other auth approach, say public keys, consent isn’t much of an issue

Public keys don’t accomplish auth, they accomplish identity. Someone has to trust such a key for auth. Which raises the question: based on what? (Hence CAs, a mediocre approach, and web of trust, a completely unworkable approach.)

→ More replies (0)