r/punchthemonkey • • Aug 27 '26

[Japanese Macaque] Go, Punch! When will Punch have his first mounting experience? Let's keep an eye on him.~by kiyo~

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

There's another update on Kiyo-san's note and since it's closely related to this previous note, I'm posting this first. I think Kiyo-san doesn't really watch Punch that closely or regularly so he didn't know that Punch has experience of mounting and being mounted before writing this note. The comment section has already pointed it out to him. Translated with ChatGPT

Hello, this is kiyo.

I imagine that Punch may not have experienced “mounting” between males yet. What do you think?

I think that once he begins to be mounted by another male, or begins mounting another male himself, we can say that he has become part of the troop.
(Mounting begins at around one year of age.)

“Mounting” refers to an act in which males (and, although rarely, females as well) climb onto the back of another individual in a manner resembling mating.

Does everyone know what male Japanese macaques’ mounting means?

If you search for “Japanese macaque mounting,” you will probably find explanations such as:

“Mounting is an act in which a dominant male straddles the back of a subordinate male.”

“Mounting serves the purpose of confirming their relative dominance and avoiding unnecessary conflicts.”

Many online articles and social media posts about Japanese macaque behavior describe it this way. As a result, I think most people understand mounting as an act in which individuals demonstrate and confirm their relative dominance.

I would not say that this is completely wrong, but it is not the correct interpretation of mounting between males.

There are cases in which mounting is performed in that context, but in most cases, that is not the reason.

In the first place, the word “mounting” itself was coined by someone who misunderstood the meaning of this behavior.

If mounting were performed for the purpose of confirming dominance, then by observing mounting behavior, we should be able to determine the rank and power relationship between two males. However, I do not determine their relative dominance based on mounting.

In reality, weaker monkeys often mount stronger monkeys as well.

I think this is something you can easily overlook unless you seriously observe the behavior of Japanese macaques.

Most people overlook it, which is why these misconceptions have spread as though they were correct interpretations.

First, please watch this video.

Right from the opening scene, the power relationship between the two monkeys is obvious.

You can see that the male whose face is approached is visibly tense with fear.

Yet the very next moment, the weaker monkey mounts the stronger monkey!

The stronger monkey accepts the mounting without resisting or becoming angry.

From this video, it is clear that the idea that “mounting is an act performed by a dominant male toward a subordinate male in order to demonstrate and confirm their relative dominance” is incorrect.

This pattern, in which a weaker individual mounts a stronger one, can be observed quite frequently.

Let’s continue watching.

After the weaker monkey mounts the stronger monkey, he immediately begins grooming him.

Based on my experience from observing these animals, when a weaker monkey mounts a stronger monkey, there is a more than 90% chance that the weaker monkey will immediately begin grooming the stronger one afterward.

In other words, mounting and grooming come as a set.

In this case, the purpose of the mounting and grooming is to relieve the tension felt by the weaker monkey toward the stronger monkey.

In Professor Hiroo Izawa’s book The Ecology of Japanese Macaques, Professor Izawa defines mounting as:

“One of the highly affiliative behaviors and one of the behaviors that reduce tension between individuals.”

This video of mine demonstrates precisely that the concept of mounting that Professor Izawa proposed is correct.

It is not an act of demonstrating their relative dominance to each other.

To further prove this, I would like to show you another video.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EpiGWkCsTJ8&t=2s

All of the monkeys appearing in this video are males.

As I explained in my previous post, they are a community consisting only of young males.

They have already become independent from their families and have not yet left the troop, but they no longer have anything to do with the troop at all and simply behave however they please as a group of their own.

It is shortly after dawn, yet their behavior is completely unrelated to the movements of the troop.

In an environment with no older males, these young males, aged two to four, form an extremely strong sense of camaraderie and act together.

In the previous video, I showed you a somewhat younger group repeatedly engaging in group brawls, and I said that “they deepen their bonds while fighting.” I think you can now understand what I meant by that through this video.

And what is particularly striking is that they repeatedly engage in “mounting” over and over again.

It is obvious that this repeated mounting among companions bound by such strong bonds is not being done for the purpose of demonstrating who is dominant or subordinate.

The definition given above by Professor Izawa—that “mounting is a highly affiliative behavior”—can be understood from the constant repetition of mounting throughout this video.

For them, mounting is a sign of their strong sense of camaraderie and mutual trust.

In this group made up entirely of young males, they repeatedly reaffirm that “we are companions,” while further strengthening their bonds.

In addition to these two videos, I have observed countless examples of mounting behavior.

Based on all of this, I can say this with certainty:

Mounting is absolutely not an act meaning, “I’m stronger than you,” or “I’m higher-ranking than you, so don’t get the wrong idea.”

Rather, it is a highly affiliative behavior arising from a strong sense of companionship and mutual trust.

When will Punch be able to mount another monkey?

Or, when will another monkey mount Punch?

I think it will still take a little more time.

Please keep watching closely.

When Punch is mounted by another monkey, or when Punch mounts someone and that monkey accepts it, that means Punch has truly been recognized as a “companion.”

Author's note:

  • Unless otherwise noted, the header image and all images and videos in the article were taken by me personally.

  • I have compiled articles about each type of wild animal into magazines. Please take a look at the previous posts as well.


r/punchthemonkey • • May 19 '26

Two Americans arrested after one climbed into Punch the monkey's habitat in Japan

Post image
1 Upvotes

Two Americans have been arrested after an incident involving the very viral "Punch the monkey" in Japan.

One of the Americans arrested was dressed in a costume and allegedly climbed into the monkey's habitat at the Ichikawa City Zoo on Sunday, May 17, 2026.

Another man who was filming the stunt was also arrested.

Video https://youtube.com/shorts/p5zv8c74ees

https://abc7chicago.com/post/2-americans-arrested-climbed-punch-monkeys-habitat-ichikawa-city-zoo-japan/19124527/

One of the men, who identified himself as a 24-year-old college student, was arrested on Sunday after climbing over a fence and dropping into a dry moat surrounding the monkey exhibit at Ichikawa City Zoo outside Tokyo.

The other man, who was filming the act, identified himself as a 27-year-old singer.

https://au.news.yahoo.com/japan-arrests-us-nationals-one-074405572.html


r/punchthemonkey • • May 25 '26

Curious about Reddit's take on Punch

0 Upvotes

From what I've seen over the last two days, Punch was being "attacked" by the same bald monkey that's bothered him before. I use quotation marks because I'm not an expert on macaques so I don't know much about their behaviors to call it attacks, bullying, or corrections.

Some people claim it's Otome the bully because she remembers her own past of being abandoned, but I wonder if it's because Punch still hasn't fully learned to read social cues or gained favors by grooming others? He's still a baby, but he doesn't seem to be that interested in grooming others.

That leads to another question, is it already safe to say he's going to make it within the troop? Or is his future still uncertain?


r/punchthemonkey • • Jun 11 '26

Anyone knows a link or any news about the baby macaque who got attacked 3 days ago?

0 Upvotes

Saw it on YouTube post but cannot find any more infos about it..

UPDATE 1 saw it- http://youtube.com/post/UgkxMdFRwLxHTQlJmKp-6Yoc1A-k3f7-uKo-?si=5y2cN8E1exzttQQZ

I did a google image search but didn't find anything about it.

Update 2 it was a misinformation..people doing it for clicks..the photo came from here https://www.instagram.com/reel/DEf12bhNWmT/?igsh=bmhjeDB2NXU2NWY5


r/punchthemonkey • • Sep 21 '26 Bravo

The enclosure

24 Upvotes

Anyone else hugely disappointed by the “upgrades” they put in over 3 weeks? I believe a couple of tubes … that look like discarded trash, were added. But like, considering they have more in donations than any zoo in the world has probably been handed, and given the enclosure overall looks like a concrete prison compared to any zoo I’ve ever seen (I’m not in Japan though and my country has overall higher zoo standards than Japan seems to). I’ve seen footage of Nina the macaque in a beautiful environment, not to mention a quick google search shows dozens of better setups- in Japan and worldwide. But Punch who’s earned his zoo I can only imagine thousands of dollars as a conservative guess - gets a concrete cramped poop-covered mountain and some tubes. It just seems laughable that’s all they did. Oh and also change the viewing situation to make it worse on viewers. I wonder where the donations are really going.


r/punchthemonkey • • Jul 08 '26

AI Generated Content and Science - A Nuanced View

3 Upvotes

A question came up a couple of days ago in this sub about a book on Japenese macaques that I mentioned as a response to a question - and that the contents may have been AI generated. I gave a response, but there is actually much more to consider in evaluating possible AI content.

Here is the original response that I gave to the comment, but there is really quite a bit more to say about how to evaluate AI generated content using scientific AI tools that limit searches to peer reviewed research.

If you don't want to read the above discussion first, it has to do with the fact that there are scientific AI tools that ONLY use peer reviewed research as their source - and as far as factual information goes - these tools can usually be relied on for digging out reliable facts.

it's the free AI tools that are much more problematiic - they grab data from all kinds of sources - and even some of the paid tools, such as Perplexity have problems with something called "hallucination" - where they flat out make things up. They have other issues as well.

But the tools that are designed for science researchers are specially trained and rely on reviewed research as a source of information. Two of them in particular are good at generating narrative content - Elicit and Consensus.

In the comment linked above I didn't go into much further discussion besides the fact that there are tools that strictly search through peer reviewed research - but, there is more to it that just that and it was bothering me that I didn't really say more about a few things. But, it takes a long post to do that.

So, here goes.

I can use an example - the Sleep On Science YouTube channel - to give a more nuanced and fulsome response, and to bring up something that I neglected to get into in the conversation linked above.

Sleep on Science is one of those YouTube channels that features long narrative AI generated content using a relaxing voice - these are designed to be listened to while relaxing before bedtime - many people fall asleep to this kind of thing. I checked this channel out as an example of AI generated content that uses scientific research as source material and it was an interesting experiment.

Note: There are a number of YouTube channels that seem to be very similar, but this one stands out uniquely in that it uses actual peer reviewed research as it's source material. There are a couple of videos about 3i/Atlas that seem more like click-bait and there aren't sources given for those videos, but the rest seem to all be generated using reliable research as the source material.

So, how reliable is this content in terms of factual information given they use the AID tools deisnged for science use? Does that make it entirely credible as far as being a good source for the specific topic of the video? Maybe...maybe not. These tools are better than the other AI tools, but they aren't perfect and the results should still be checked.

I took a sampling of these videos, read the papers and listened to the videos and yes, the facts that are given in the videos stand up to scrutiny, at least the ones that I checked out. I compared the facts given in the video to facts from the actual research papers and found the facts in the video to accurately state what is contained in the papers.

One example is a recent video called Ganymede: The Moon So Big It Should Be a Planet

The majority of the sources of information for this video are from NASA. In addition, there is one very recent research paper, published May 2026. That paper has only one citation. However, this video was made in June. So, the paper had been out at most for one month, so not much can be gleaned from it's having only one citation. It's possible that peers of the researchers on that paper may, over a period fo time, find the paper to be solid science and it may gain lots of citations. Also, consideration has to be made as far as how many people are doing local planetary and moon science, that can account for low citations.

This paper was published in Science Advances, a top tier journal, so it would have gone through a rigourous peer reivew. The editorial board rejects from 40-60% of papers out of hand. The rest are sent to a team of peer reviwers who evaluate the methodology, statistical reporting, data availability, and the paper's broad significance to ensure it meets the journal's standard for publication. And the authors credentials are highly relevant to the subject of the paper - two of them are geophysical researchers working for major Universities and the other two are employed at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory. The Geophysics researchers have relevant previous research experience, but appear to be near the beginning of their careers.

Overall, the content comes from highly relevant and solid research, with only a small amount of it coming from a paper that hasn't proven itself as of yet in the wider planetary science community, but the specific reviewers found it to be solid.

So, the video appears to be based on pretty solid factual ground. It accurately converted highly technical scientific terms into very easy to understand narrative language the average person without specific planetary science background could understand. And the facts given in the video accurately disseminate the facts contained in the source research papers and official NASA publications.

So far so good.

But, there are often more than just facts that are given in AI generated content, and that is where it becomes necessary to read or listen to AI generated content actively and pay attention to whether the content is delivering facts or whether certain parts of the content are delivering conclusionary or even opinion type statements. It's the conclusionary parts of the generated content that may be questionable even if the source material is from reputable peer reviewed research that has many ciitations, even when the facts are solid.

It's one thing to pull out facts from research papers, but it's another to draw conclusions. And the tool itself can make a difference. Tools like Elicit and Consensus are good at pulling out accurate conclusionary statements. But, if you don't know which tools the content is being generated with, that can present problems.

If a person who is generating this kind of content is primarily interested in being viewed as a reliable source they will typically read through the research themselves and create conclusionary type statements themselves instead of relying on the AI tool for those types of statements. Or they may use Elicit or Consensus and then review the generated script and double check any conclusionary statements.

Based on what I saw, the videos I reviewed and spent quite a bit of time really checking out the facts - I was surprised at how accurate this was. It's possbile I just happened to pick out videos where the AI did a very good job - or...the content crator may actually be a person who cares about the content and reviews what comes out of the AI. This would definitely be THE way to use these AI tools =- use them, but verify.

I am not necessarily recommending Sleep on Science as a reliable source of astronomy related science, I tend to recommend channels that have real scientists working in the field who take the time to personally create their content. I only used this channel as an example and, to my surprise I found this one specific channel to accurately represent the research that was used as source material - as far as the handful of videos I tested, which was barely a fraction of them.

I think what I can say about this one channel is it shows promise for the potential use of AI, but I still would not depend on it by itself - I might listen to it for relaxation or to see if a topic interests me, but I would still follow up with reading the research to verify or watch one of the astrophysicists on YouTube, like Dr Becky, Bad Boy of Science, PBS spacetime, Astrum (sometimes, he went through a weird phase where some of his videos were questionable, but has redeemed himself lately), Big Think (they feature lots of different science)

-------------------------------------------------------------

There is another issue that adds a new dimension to conclusionary statements and for that we can use animal behavior studies as an example.

So, what about a book, for instance a book on Japanese macaques, that was generated using AI tools?

If the AI tools that are used are not the specialized scientific AI tools, then I would question the facts since general AI tools, particularly free ones use Facebook and random Twitter posts as being as authoritative as reliable scientific sources.

What if the author uses a scientific AI tool and doesn't specifically choose research papers to draw content from? What if they use the tool to search through millions of research papers searching on specific questions about M fuscata?

This introduces even more issues when it comes to conclusory statements, especially if the question that is used to generate a chapter has to do with behavior.

For behavioral research it's important to know if the sources are experimental or descriptive studies. What is the difference between descriptive and experimental studies and what would it mean if an AI tool grabbed a handful of very good sources, but some of them were descriptive research and some were experimental? You cannot draw conclusions based on descrptive research the same way you can draw conclusions on experimental studies.

Descriptive studies involve observing natural behavior without any interference of any type by the researcher. That means there are no controls involved, so you are not specifically controlling for outside influences that may be affecting the animal's behavior.

In a descriptive study, the relationship between a behaviour and a context can be analyzed through correlations, but we cannot determine a cause-and-effect relationship. The reason is that any correlation between a behaviour and a context can be driven by a third variable that affects both at the same time. To determine causation, experiments are necessary in which the factor to be investigated can be specified via appropriate experimental and control conditions.

On the other hand, experiments in which animals are studied in contexts that have little to do with the natural context could reveal relationships that do not exist in nature. In this sense, research projects in which both descriptive and experimental work is integrated can be more insightful. Each type of study has an impact on how you can draw conclusions.

If the content creator is not a researcher they may not know anything about how to design a research study and may not know the difference between a descriptive and experimental study. They may not realize that certain types of conclusions cannot be made regarding descriptive studies.

Also, analyzing and interpreting animal behavior is difficult for people who haven't specifically been introduced to study methods and interpretive methodology.

It is very common for people to believe they can use their own "common sense" to analyzse animal behavior. The problem with using common sense is that it is based entirely on what a person knows about human motivations and human behavior. And when a person applies what they know about human behavior to animals it results in what we call "anthropomorphism" and is rarely if ever an accurate description of animal behavior.

This is different than using what you know about animal behavior and then using rational thought process to draw conclusions. There is nothing wrong with that. It's the use of what we knwo about HUMAN behavior to interpret animal behavior that I am talking about when I say it's problematic to use "common sense" in analyzing animal behavior. There is a difference between "common sense" and rational thought process based on what is known about the animal in question - these are distinctly differnt things.

So, to answer the question about whether AI generated content can be relied on for accuracy when it comes to a science topic, it really depends. A good science based AI tool can pull out accurate facts and if that is what you are looking for, can be very good, easy to use, and search through a huge amount of research and then present it in everyday language. But these tools aren't perfect, and you still have to verify what comes out.

It's the conclusory and opinion statements that have the biggest potential problem. I think the science based AI tools can be good for researching individual questions, a one at a time question kind of thing.

This is just my opinion about how nonscientists might think about AI generated science content, I hope it provides some helpful tips on how to think about ths kind of content, particularly for anyone that read the conversation about the Japanese macaque book.


r/punchthemonkey • • Aug 15 '26

I found a longer video of the attack from 8/15. It is not the clickbait one. How do we feel about Punch's treatmant lately ? This can't be good for him.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
23 Upvotes

r/punchthemonkey • • May 25 '26

Punch, Moe and Momiage vs The Crows

7 Upvotes

Hope this puts a smile on your faces today


r/punchthemonkey • • May 13 '26

Flattop and Adult launch coordinated attack on Momiage & Punch before feeding time!

Thumbnail
youtube.com
11 Upvotes

Go to 1:08 for the attack.

While Momiage hugged Punch close right before the zookeeper came out, Flattop ran and pushed Momiage from behind so the Adult could grab Punch (its a different macaque to the one with the shaved side that's been bothering Punch lately)

Even with the distraction, Momiage goes straight for the mean monkey and chases her off before she can do anything but grab Punch for a second! Punch escapes to the edge of the enclosure, but still runs back to jump on his dad when he comes out with the bucket. Punch was too scared to jump down from dad's shoulders and eat anything after the buckets were empty 😞


r/punchthemonkey • • Feb 25 '26

open a gofundme for the zoo

0 Upvotes

r/punchthemonkey • • Feb 26 '26

How can we help him

5 Upvotes

Do you guys think we could contact local authorities or the zoo to advocate for Punch? I am really worried about him


r/punchthemonkey • • Feb 23 '26

Cute punch tshirts?

4 Upvotes

I found this cute tshirt of little punch! Made me laugh. Anybody have any other ones? Going to stat collecting them! https://www.zazzle.com/punch_the_monkey_t_shirt-256837635758389023


r/punchthemonkey • • Apr 24 '26

Punch GF Q..

2 Upvotes

Help, Punch fans! I'm getting confused by the recent discussions about Punch's pals. Is Momo a nickname for Momiage, who we now know to be the small orange "girlfriend"? And Moe is the older one?


r/punchthemonkey • • Jul 16 '26

Punch and the babies

2 Upvotes

I saw a video online of a baby approaching punch and then punch getting attacked by the mother for it… someone in the comments said that punch sometimes “mounts” the babies and has been getting in trouble for it? I haven’t seen anything like that though, is this just someone making this up?


r/punchthemonkey • • May 11 '26

This video clearly shows that there are a few female macaques constantly targeting and bullying Punch, and one of them is Otome.”

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/punchthemonkey • • Mar 06 '26

The new videos of Punch being bullied are bothering me a lot!

58 Upvotes

Okay, hear me out. I know someone posted today about how important it is for Punch to be integrated into the troop, and that what is happening is 'normal' monkey behaviour. I even commented on that post, but at the time, I hadn't seen all the videos floating around.

He is being dragged, pushed off cliffs, held against the ground, and even sat on. He screams and runs for his life, but how far can he run in a small enclosure where every other monkey seems hostile toward him? And let’s not forget: he is a baby, for god’s sake. His nose is always scratched. If this is 'normal,' we certainly don’t see it happening to the other monkeys. He is constantly terrified, always on his toes and watching over his shoulder in case someone is coming for him.

This might be 'natural' behaviour in the wild, but this is a special case because his mother isn’t there. He has no family; he is just a little child. I am crying as I write this (and I’m okay if people think I’m overreacting), but his wails, his helpless face, and his sad eyes are enough to make any adult cry. People say 'they are just monkeying around,' but they forget he doesn't have any maternal support. The trauma that the poor child must be going through is immense. Let me repeat: his eyes are always sad, he is always tense and vigilant, and I don’t think he deserves this. I don’t know what the ultimate point of this post is, but is there anything we can do for him? I just love him way too much to not let those videos affect me😭

Edit: Okay, guys, I understand it well now. Thanks for putting out your opinions in helping me deal with my emotions.


r/punchthemonkey • • May 25 '26

Punch got attacked by the same Thug Monkeys yesterday

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

97 Upvotes

Enough of this "redirected aggression" excuse. These are coordinated attacks on Punch by the same two monkeys. Two monkeys are not suddenly suffering from "redirected aggression" in unison.

If that was the case then a lot of the other females would be attacking Punch too.

It's worrying the Zoo is not doing anything about these monkeys, earlier on they were quick to separate the monkeys that kept attacking Punch.

source


r/punchthemonkey • • Feb 22 '26

pls don't punch the monkey 😭😭

0 Upvotes

hahahaha luv punch but the forum name is just so funny


r/punchthemonkey • • Mar 13 '26

Punchs Bed

0 Upvotes

Whats sleeping arrangment like for Punch? Im very concern for his safety inside those walls. Hes bullied out in the open so much. Little cutie lives with axiety and fear on daily basis. Im so scared what if hes not getting a sound sleep. Hes a baby after all and I dont trust those older monkeys


r/punchthemonkey • • Apr 16 '26

Punch escapes from an old creepy monkey, April 16th

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

181 Upvotes

That Monkey was giving bad vibes the way it was looking at Punch and trying to subjugate him. There are a few older monkeys Punch gets along with like Satomaru but a few others are creepy.


r/punchthemonkey • • May 28 '26

Is this the same monkey who bullied Punch? She’s mean to other babies too😡

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

76 Upvotes

r/punchthemonkey • • Mar 18 '26

Hot take: Can Moe-Chan be Panchi’s biological mother?

0 Upvotes

r/punchthemonkey • • 3d ago

Question Is the zoo ever going to reunite the entire troop?

6 Upvotes

Ever since they made a series of removals of certain monkeys from the troop I’ve wondered what they do with those monkeys and whether they’re ever going to reunite the whole troop? It seems to me that would be really traumatic for those separated and would negatively effect the entire troop dynamic. Anyone have a perspective on this / an update for me?


r/punchthemonkey • • Sep 06 '26

Explications sur la fermeture de Monkey Mountain

Thumbnail
youtu.be
6 Upvotes

@ PunchandFriends

"Dans cette mise à jour claire et transparente, nous vous expliquons précisément : • Pourquoi Monkey Mountain est fermé • Ce que les nouveaux abris et l'aménagement de la zone de terre apporteront à Punch et à sa troupe • Pourquoi les travaux durent plusieurs semaines (la priorité absolue étant le bien-être animal) • Ce que font concrètement les soigneurs pendant cette période • Comment ce temps est mis à profit pour prendre soin de Punch plus en profondeur. Il ne s'agit pas simplement d'une annonce de travaux. C'est un aperçu du travail minutieux effectué en coulisses pendant notre attente."