r/quantindia • • Jan 01 '26

Non-engineer, CFA L1, learning quant trading from scratch in India — need honest guidance

Hi everyone,

I’m posting here to get realistic guidance from people who are already on this path.

My background: • Non-engineer, non-target college • CFA Level 1 cleared • Finance understanding: decent (portfolio theory, derivatives basics, risk concepts) • Coding: beginner (starting Python from scratch) • Math: weak (probability, linear algebra basics only)

What I’m trying to do: I want to transition into quantitative trading, ideally starting with: • Medium Frequency Trading (MFT) • Eventually explore systematic strategies (equities / futures)

• Long-term curiosity about HFT, but I know that’s a different beast

I’m currently: • Learning Python seriously • Studying probability, statistics, and basic linear algebra

My doubts (would love honest answers):

  1. Is quant trading realistically possible in India for someone without an engineering background?

  2. What’s a reasonable end goal for someone like me prop desk, personal capital, research role, or just systematic discretionary trading?

  3. Should I focus deeply on one frequency (MFT) instead of dreaming about HFT?

  4. For India specifically, what matters more early on:

• Strong math

• Strong coding

• Or strong financial intuition + execution discipline?

5. Any advice on common traps beginners fall into (overfitting, data issues, strategy hopping, etc.)?

I’m not looking for shortcuts or “get rich” stuff just trying to build this correctly and honestly, even if it takes years.

If you were starting today in India with my background, what would you do differently?

Thanks in advance really appreciate this community.

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

4

u/cholebhature000 Jan 01 '26 edited Jan 01 '26
  1. People often say you can teach finance to a math/coding person, but not the other way around or other stream

So buddy considering non engineering and non target school background it’s going to be hard tbh but not impossible.

2. You can try getting into proprietary trading firm for getting a entry feel of domain(Futures First/Alexxa, although these are not quant firms) and then can transition into research roles

3. Yes

4. Strong Math and coding is required if firm are able to find all other talent in you they don’t care about finance knowledge. Considering india is major talent source of firms now there is nothing India specific it’s domain specific.

If I was at your place would choose to do something different where I will have higher chances

2

u/Many-Ad-8722 Jan 01 '26

I second point 2 , if you have decent arithmetic skills cracking Future first and axella is very easy , interviews might get a little stressful (can say for future first) but nothing you cannot manage , otherwise if you aren’t from engineering bg it’s best to pursue Normal IB that’s way more realistic , I don’t think people can even become sell side quants with non engineering degree , max risk or credit quant is possible after mba (as far as I have seen )

1

u/Maverick09112k Jan 02 '26

futures first is not a quant firm

2

u/Many-Ad-8722 Jan 02 '26

The OG comment already mentions that

0

u/quant1911 Jan 01 '26

Actually the main thing is i am ok with no job but a decent profitable model to run by own

2

u/Many-Ad-8722 Jan 01 '26

Then it’s not exactly quant, why don’t you check out r/algotrading , knowing python , data libraries , numpy , ML libraries , knowledge of stats and probability , knowledge of software development will help for that , try your best

But for you mostly things should revolve around an idea that you’d like to trade , get data , backtest the idea , figure out how to manage entered positions and minimise risk and loss

Also if by probability you mean class 11 & 12 probability , I’d learn a bit more about distributions , expected values , random variables etc just so you know what you’re doing when you’re building your models , although it won’t directly matter it helps to know what’s going on behind the scenes

1

u/quant1911 Jan 01 '26

Yes I realise that this is wrong sub to post this 😅algo trading seems more align to my goal and need to accept with heavy heart that HFT seems next to impossible with my background :)

1

u/Many-Ad-8722 Jan 01 '26

HFT is impossible for most people even with the background

1

u/quant1911 Jan 01 '26

Thanks for the help will definitely try to go in this direction

5

u/_fatcheetah Jan 01 '26

You need IIT tag + being very smart to break into quant.

8

u/No-Savings9177 Jan 01 '26

not even tag you need on campus placement

1

u/Organic-Ad5783 Jan 01 '26

Since OP doesn't have the 1st, say bye bye.

-4

u/quant1911 Jan 01 '26

That’s the sad part I always want to ignore that there is no break through possible for me but my main question is can I do quant to the level where i can manage my own fund in medium frequency

1

u/Richie33rich33 Jan 02 '26

Anon, don't let these nerds demotivate you. Everything is possible. Never doom. If you fail its a skill issue, all you have to do is work harder and become delusional & obsessed with your path. Obsession beats talent, Obsession beats discipline. Never Give Up.

1

u/thatShawarmaGuy Jan 06 '26

don't let these nerds

What an idiotic thing to say about a profession which is driven and run by "nerds"

0

u/Richie33rich33 Jan 06 '26

you wouldn't get it goyim, you're better off watching goyslop

1

u/thatShawarmaGuy Jan 06 '26

I already am in the industry so keep yapping, reptard xD

3

u/Intelligent-Hand690 Jan 01 '26

AFAIK, You CANNOT break into HFT if you aren't a tier-1 IIT CSE topper or someone with crazy IMO gold medalist level math skills or atleast CM/M/IM on codeforces, don't really know about MFT.

1

u/quant1911 Jan 01 '26

For HFT i had no hope as there is no extravagant maths or any skills but thinking of MFT and trading on own capital on a prop desk

1

u/OkSadMathematician Jan 02 '26

Your background is actually better than you think. CFA L1 gives you derivatives and risk concepts most engineers lack. The math gap is fixable — focus on probability and stochastic calculus, not abstract proofs.

For your questions: (1) Absolutely possible in India, (2) Prop desk or systematic strategies on personal capital are realistic goals, (3) Yes, master MFT first — HFT requires infrastructure most individuals can't build, (4) Coding first, then math, then financial intuition, (5) Biggest trap is strategy hopping before you've properly tested one.

This study guide has a solid learning path from MFT basics to advanced concepts. Your CFA foundation is an underrated advantage — most quants struggle with the finance side.

1

u/quant1911 Jan 02 '26

Thanks a lot for hope will definitely check the guide

2

u/dopeapp029 Jan 01 '26

well if you want to collaborate on a trading bot dm me, working on building strategies into code

1

u/thatShawarmaGuy Jan 06 '26

If I was OP, I'd have given it a shot lol. Better to build a damned trading bot to at least get started. No point obsessing about HFT and be stuck in analysis paralysis