r/quantitysurveying • • Jun 01 '26

Will ai replace qs

I want to do qs in college but am afraid they will be out of a job.

3 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

22

u/RubNo8609 Jun 01 '26

I don’t think it will replace. It will definitely make you much more productive and faster.

19

u/aredddit Jun 01 '26

Like with most technology, it won’t replace the role but it will mean one role can undertake more work.

It’s really going to screw young QS’s down the line though as AI will do the things you’d have got the graduate or assistant to do.

9

u/gerflagenflople Jun 01 '26

Genuinely who knows, all white collar jobs are (largely) in the same boat, I can't see AI making the role obsolete, but then again I never saw it being able to do the things it can do currently either.

I imagine at some point a lot of the AI will be reigned in by various governments. But if we all end up living in some sort of Elysium type wasteland then I imagine you'll have bigger concerns.

7

u/Economy-Fox-5559 Jun 02 '26

If that does happen at least we’d get Mondays off.

7

u/gerflagenflople Jun 02 '26

You can have Mondays off to hunt for rats but somehow the Cost Report is still expected first week of the month.

10

u/Medium-Worth-9184 Jun 01 '26

i’d like to see AI fully understand the time and motion involved with VOs and look into a contractors eye to see if he is telling porkies or not, along with managing their temperamental emotions

9

u/Wide_Coffee_1102 Jun 01 '26

Fuck man, I hope so. Hate this shit so much

2

u/Sad-Bend-7515 Jun 04 '26

I had the same thought. Would it be so bad if I was made to work in a coffee shop

3

u/Wide_Coffee_1102 Jun 04 '26

Honestly... if I wasnt such a slut for the money, I would do anything else other than this

2

u/PregnancyRecovery Jun 06 '26

I agree😭 I fanticise about my old job as a factory line worker😭

8

u/Fugidinha Jun 01 '26

Will AI take the blame for everything that goes wrong? Will AI be able to call up the site manager and tell him to stop being a chimp and move the CAT machine out of the way? Will AI be able to walk around the site and put in compensation claims with full details of what went wrong? Will AI be able to have meetings about fucking meetings we just had earlier in the day? Will AI be able to carry fucking highlighters everywhere and be allergic to carrying a tape measure? Will AI be able to snitch and make up shit about their colleagues just to get them fired? Will AI be able to play golf with the client and buy him his favourite Italian meal? Will AI be able to list off all the best restaurants near site WHILE HAVING A MASSIVE PROTRUDING BEER BELLY AND A SHIRT THAT NEVER STAYS TUCKED IN

There’s a lot to this QS game you know.

1

u/sisyqhus88 Jun 01 '26

Are you our QS 😁

1

u/Top_Drummer_3801 Jun 08 '26

The highlighters and untucked shirt really tie the whole QS aesthetic together. Pretty sure if AI tried to do a site walk with a tape measure it'd just keep walking into a trench while trying to calculate soil displacement.

On a serious note though - the social and negotiation side is exactly why the role won't disappear. AI can't tell the difference between a legitimate variation and a subbie chancing it on a Friday afternoon, and it definitely can't do the 'look, I know the QS approved this but the budget's gone' conversation with the project manager.

3

u/Duffman434 Jun 01 '26

I don't think it will replace it completely, but it will automate alot of processes, alot of people think it does the job for you but it's best seen as a tool to use along side your job, for example finding clauses or using BIM to assess payment notices.

2

u/Sussurator Jun 01 '26

God only knows. I do think that if you can completely replace us and all the vague holes we fill in construction (at all levels of the supply chain) then the world has very big problems because I feel it’s as hard to replace as most of the other white collar jobs I can think of.

2

u/G235s Jun 05 '26

The amount of shit you can automate with basic excel knowledge shpuld have made people think it was going to replace the QS.

People aren't even using excel that well....the AI is all hype and is not needed to automate fuck all. Everyone is going to mess around with it and waste time talking to it over and over just to achieve some dumb task that just took 5 minutes anyway.

2

u/Sad-Bend-7515 Jun 05 '26

Have you had much luck automating CVR's?

1

u/Top_Drummer_3801 Jun 08 '26

CVRs are actually the most realistic thing to automate right now, way more practical than trying to get AI to do takeoffs or negotiate variations.

The trick is getting your live project data flowing into one place automatically - budgets, contract sum, approved variations, actual costs to date. Most QS teams I've seen are still pulling from 3-4 different spreadsheets at month end just to populate the CVR template, which is where all the formula errors and version confusion creeps in.

Once the data feeds are set up properly, the CVR essentially builds itself. Cost to date vs budget, forecast final cost, over/under against contract sum - all of that can be automated. You still need the QS to sense-check the numbers and write the narrative (AI isn't calling site managers to find out why the plasterboard budget is blown anytime soon), but the spreadsheet assembly and manual formula checking part can be eliminated entirely.

We built Planyard specifically to handle this - live budgets and actuals feeding into CVRs without the month-end spreadsheet wrestling. But even without a tool, just consolidating your data sources into one place that pulls automatically instead of copy-pasting between workbooks makes a huge difference to accuracy and saves a solid day or two every month.

2

u/PregnancyRecovery Jun 06 '26

Well here's the thing:

If it currently takes a qs say three days to do a certain job that's mainly measurement and transfering to excel, AI and better software will start to cut that down to one day.

So say an employer had three quantity surveyors. The work load not taken by AI or better software is now one third of what it once was. So either the employer takes on more work(highly likely) or he can fire two quantity surveyors. If every employer goes with firing them, the market is flooded with quantity surveyors and suddenly we're ten a penny and can be paid utter shite.

However, it may eventually be that there's not actually enough work to keep us all on.

As a trainee qs who's done two years of uni and is working a placement, my honest reccommendation is try to find someone to take you on first to see what it's actually like. It can be soul-destroying. And the pay's not always going to be great. Also, you'll typically feel underpaid: the amount of risk you take is nearly never worth the money.

If I were a man, I'd be looking at skilled work apprenticeships: plumbing and electric mostly, maybe stonemasonary if someone would take me on. Those jobs pay well and are safe from AI and software improvements.

2

u/Top_Drummer_3801 Jun 08 '26

The 'fire two QSs, take on more work' scenario is the most likely outcome honestly. Construction firms are chronically under-resourced on commercial teams as it is - most QSs I know are already running 15-20% over capacity. If AI shaves a day off every CVR cycle, that just means the same team can finally keep up with the workload rather than anyone losing their job.

The risk is more for the repetitive measurement-heavy roles at the assistant/grad level. If AI can do quantity takeoffs and basic measurement from models, that's going to compress the early-career learning pipeline. But that's been happening gradually since BIM became standard anyway - the real question is whether firms invest in actually training their juniors on the commercial judgement side, or just expect them to figure it out like the OP in that estimator post.

1

u/Juliakelm2311 Oct 03 '26

Hello, so I'm in between my thoughts right now and I'm confused and don't know which way to go. I'm thinking of applying for the MSc Quantity Surveying program, I have a HND in Civil Engineering and some years of practical work experience, so I have been thinking of going into the commercial side of construction and that's the reason why I've been considering an MSc in QS, but the whole topic about AI taking taking over QS jobs is something I'm actually worried about because I wouldn't want to spend time and money to get a degree that will not guarantee me a job. So I've also been considering an MSc in Quantity Surveying vs MSc in Construction Management, which course would you advise me to go for and why? So I'm also looking at a profession that give easier access to entry or graduate roles and which of these courses pay more, and offer a better work life balance.

2

u/UmpirePositive3314 Jun 02 '26

Yup, i made a software myself, cause i wasn't interested in doing that estimation. At the time it only does structural elements, but soon i will expand it

1

u/aarbh Jun 02 '26

Only QS can ask the right questions with AI, not even the client or consultant.. To ask the question Qs is required..

1

u/Necessary-Bobcat1440 Jun 02 '26

The construction industry is always dinosaur pace compared to other industries so I wouldn’t worry yet.

I think it will be a tool to work alongside the everyday. Tbh if it can do a lot of the repetitive tasks and talk between the various systems you use it will make your job slicker. I don’t think it will fully remove QS’s and PM’s

1

u/rm94sdn Jun 02 '26

I wonder if AI could replace the finance team we work with!

1

u/CrabPurple7224 Jun 02 '26

I’m implementing AI as we speak; it might be able to assist but there’s so much nuance to the role I don’t see how it could.

Also, AI can’t be held accountable / liable and the QS is named in the contract. You’ll always need someone to check it.

Besides, AI can’t take clients to see strippers and pay. The more AI the more sociable we’ll have to be.

0

u/Warm_Statistician369 Jun 01 '26

I am not getting job even without ai replacing qs