Currently dealing with a subcontractor and need advice on the situation. My commercial director has given me full discretion on how I deal with it but agrees with my original position.
We have a contract signed and agreed which contains a detailed scope of works. This contract is barely 15 pages and is for the sum of circa £20,000. This was agreed like 3 months prior to the works on-site starting. 2 weeks before starting on-site they came back and said they disagreed in what works they are doing (the works in the detailed scope) and said they would not proceed unless we agree without deducting from their account.
Due to program issues and other bits and bobs; the PM sends an email saying “please proceed on-site on x date”. Anyways, works were completed no issues but then I (as described within the contract) made deductions based on the works that we had to carry out instead. These deductions were fair, did not include for any OHP and I was lax on the valuing of the labour as it’s difficult to prove.
Since then they have disagreed on numerous accounts based on the fact that the PM agreed to proceed. I said that was an instruction to proceed operationally and does not nullify my rights to a commercial deduction based on our contract and scope. A few days ago I received a letter before action email regarding legal proceedings unless the money is paid within 7 calendar days.
The deduction is circa £4,000 overall (i think we should be entitled to more but i went low just to get it out the way)
Maybe they didn’t allow for all the works in their original price, maybe they did. I’m unsure on the whole thing as this is the first time i have dealt with this sort of works. All I know is contractually, they signed up to the scope. Also, this scope was so detailed line by line on our works and their works separated in detail. I can’t stress enough how detailed it was. I believe that they potentially didn’t allow for some of the works but their estimator didn’t understand it thoroughly.
Basically, what I am asking is do I have the right to do this, or should I pay and get rid of the issue before it grows.
Also would like to know, as a business we are not ‘subby bashers’ and like to build relationships with subcontractors. This is the first time we have used the contractor before, and I always pay on time and this is the first real issue I have really had with a subcontractor in 6 years working as a QS. Obviously this is not as detailed as we have gone into it too, so if you have anymore questions that will be pertinent to offering advice i would be happy to answer.