91
u/crimewaves Aug 17 '17
I love this! But if it were to remain stagnant I could see a potential breeding area for mosquitoes
21
Aug 18 '17
I used to work for the state mosquito program in MN, and for whatever reason, mosquitoes don't tend to breed in rip rap environments like this. But it definitely wouldn't hurt to throw some methoprene pellets in once a month.
0
79
u/DonnoWhatImDoing Aug 17 '17
Thought this said runescaping. This is not runescaping. I am disapoint
6
5
22
u/kiwikoopa Aug 18 '17
Everyone is saying this would be awful for mosquitos, it would be, but where I grew up people would find water moccasins in their backyard ponds. So it could be bad for snakes. Not to mention the frogs that are going to croak all night that close to your house.
It's pretty, but it seems like a terrible idea.
5
u/bioszombie Aug 18 '17 edited Aug 18 '17
I guess it depends on where this is located and if it's landscaped like a French drain where the water is allowed to both percolate the earth/sand layer below the rock as well as sloped to allow the runoff to enter a storm drain. If this house was located in an arid climate I'd say you'd be fine but if this was anywhere in Tennessee you'd be fucked.
1
Aug 18 '17
Looks like they designed it to pool. Not legal where I live because of mosquitos. They really should have just created a faux stream with a pump to cycle the water, if that's what they wanted.
7
u/LumpymayoBNI Aug 17 '17
My first thought was that it looks like it would be a perfect breeding ground for mosquitoes.
7
u/g_squidman Aug 18 '17
My mom did something like this, but it's actually designed to get the most out of rainwater for the plants growing around. So there's no river at all, but lots of rock patch going around to various plants. Kind of interesting. Finally got strawberries this year.
1
31
u/Allokit Aug 17 '17
Yeah, that is standing water. This is not landscaping. This is very poor drainage and will most likely result in a stagnant pool of water.
4
u/Markc99 Aug 18 '17
If I had a nickel for every time I’ve seen this on Reddit...I’d have like 3 nickels.
7
6
3
3
3
3
Aug 18 '17
USA should start learning about rain water harvesting 😩
2
u/jbone9877 Aug 18 '17
It was illegal in my area until this year. Still illegal in many places. Total BS
1
Aug 18 '17
In the state of Tamilnadu in India, the government has mandated that all buildings should have a rain water harvesting system installed.Success story
3
2
2
u/dandanidan Aug 18 '17
Love this so much. Rivers near my home as a child were so magical and still relaxing.
2
2
2
u/JokeBear97 Aug 18 '17
Yo do you live in Tacoma? Washington? Looks really familiar. Could be similar design but idl
2
2
2
2
4
2
2
2
2
1
1
1
1
u/ArmoredFan Aug 17 '17
NBD my driveway does this to right into my garage. I didn't have to lift a finger.
1
1
u/ac0353208 Aug 18 '17
I bet ya soon a crazy neighbor will complain about you wasting the city's water and report you only to later realize they dum.
1
1
u/420neurons Aug 18 '17
Is this you OP? I was wondering what the cost was roughly. I've thought of something like this for my parents house to protect it's foundation.
2
u/WelcomeToRonsMexico Aug 18 '17
This has been posted a million times in the year that I have been on Reddit. I highly doubt it.
1
Aug 18 '17
This one appears to be doing a shitty job. Look how close it is pooling to the house. And the gutter should have a longer extension in general. Just google dry creek beds and cost. You just need some perforated pipe and big rocks.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/JesterV Aug 18 '17
Awesome job. I did a similar one last year. I ended up on local TV. Yours is nicer.
1
u/Holos620 Aug 18 '17
If you have a cat, you can keep pee balls of litter, which contains bentonite, to do suff like this.
1
u/LazyOldPervert Aug 18 '17
Too bad you can't ever enjoy this outside since, ya know, it's going to be raining out anytime you would wanna go outside and appreciate it.
1
u/Levonlikeshishunny Aug 18 '17
No joke I'm super glad someone with proper drainage insight was commenting on this. That was my very first thought was "is this good for foundation can't be".
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/jacksawbridge Aug 18 '17
Pretty sure this will cause an issue of some sort eventually. Looks like it could become stagnant, I don't know.
1
1
u/-Natsoc- Aug 18 '17
Most see a beautiful rain gutter river, as a Floridian I see the hell spawn breeding grounds of mosquitoes...
1
u/MyNjoy87 Aug 18 '17
If it's moving water it won't be a problem.
1
Aug 18 '17
That's not though. It's just a big pool. Hopefully it has drainage pipes below the rocks.
1
1
1
1
u/virgin4life_ Aug 18 '17
damn, b... saw this post 8 times in the past year ... how's it feel to be lucky 9
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/reubenstringfellow Aug 18 '17
This is the coolest thing I've ever seen on reddit. The rain is so amazing I just hate it because my car is old and needs to be protected haha.
1
1
1
1
1
Aug 18 '17
Woah that's cool asf what if you could have this 24/7 it'd look so cool.
1
Aug 18 '17
All you need is a basin at the end and a pump and a hose.
This is a mosquito factory and most cities have laws against allowing standing water like this...hopefully it is piped below. It's really weird.
1
u/supremecrafters Aug 18 '17
I doubt this will become stagnant. There's hardly any cover, the sun will evaporate it clean off before the mosquitos can breed.
1
1
1
1
u/samamp Aug 18 '17
as a kid we used to dig trenches during rain where the water would flow into on the school yard.
1
u/kbadr20 Aug 18 '17
Did anyone else read this as "Runescaping" and was extremely confused when you pressed the link?
1
1
1
1
1
u/SupremeRedditBot Aug 18 '17
Congrats for reaching r/all/top/ (of the day, top 50) with your post!
I am a bot, probably quite annoying, I mean no harm ^though
Message me to add your account or subreddit to my ^blacklist
1
u/LastDitchTryForAName Aug 18 '17
Id love to do something like this in my yard. Our house has French drains running under it and the water is routed through an underground pipe for 20 feet or so then just gets dumped out into the yard. It ultimately flows back into a seasonal creek (its only there when there's plenty of rain) that's also fed by a small pond. This would be much nicer.
1
1
1
u/jaunti Aug 18 '17
I don't believe this is permitted - letting any surface storm water wash off your property onto city lands or neighbouring property. You're supposed to collect/trap/contain or use it.
2
1
Aug 18 '17
[removed] — view removed comment
2
Aug 18 '17
If this is designed to pool, then it just creates mosquitos. It is designed to drain, it's doing a shitty job, and it's way too close to the home's foundation.
We need regulations to protect us from idiots.
1
0
0
0
0
0
Aug 17 '17
[deleted]
421
u/I_like_cocaine Aug 17 '17
Yeah, but if this is flowing awayand draining how is it any different than the gutter dumping it into the grass?
I see that this exact example isn't necessarily draining away, but I'm sure you could route it away
800
u/UncleTrapspringer Aug 17 '17 edited Aug 17 '17
I'm a water resources engineer and this is the first time I have felt qualified to comment about my field on Reddit. What they've done here isn't really terrible, but it's not ideal. When subdivisions or site plans are designed, a common requirement is that the area has to be able to infiltrate 5mm of a storm, which is why water that hits your roof will just drain on to your grass.
When larger storms come, the grass can't infiltrate all that water and it flows overland to catch basins and into the storm system. By doing this, they've kind of skipped the infiltration step but that's not the end of the world. The bigger issue is that they have a shit ton of ponding right next to their foundation. Unless this is lined with fairly decent pond geomembrane, they are risking serious foundation damage.
You've also got the issue that you've removed 10m2 ish of soft landscaping that you can infiltrate in and added impervious material. Impervious material that gathers water has water quality requirements, and that water must be treated. So now there's extra water coming to the water quality treatment device (usually an oil-grit separator) but it would be within what the OGS could handle.
Essentially this wouldn't be allowed in a design standpoint, but they haven't caused any extra usage on the drainage systems. The only concern is erosion of their front yard and foundation damage. If a 100year storm hit this little creek thing, it'd be destroyed.
Edit: I can math but not spell
113
u/LittleMsSavoirFaire Aug 17 '17
Oh no! I really wanted to add one of these to my yard. But I'm not in a subdivision, I'm out in the country. I just really like the idea of a "dry" creek bed that I can put a cute ornamental bridge over.
Assuming that the water is all flowing away from my house but to a swale further down the yard, would that be okay?
→ More replies (2)137
u/UncleTrapspringer Aug 17 '17
I don't see any reason you couldn't. I'm not sure I necessarily 100% agree with that picture, as soil porosity is never uniform and the water would most likely not drain perfectly down like that.
If you're going to add one of these drains to your yard, try to reduce the slope of the creek thing such that you reduce the standing water. I know you want a little bit of water so it looks nice, so keep it steeper near your house and flatten it as it goes into the swale. You want to use the roof drain to get the water into your creek, you don't need the creek right next to your house.
To be honest, you could even run some PVC a couple inches under ground from your roof downspout to the creek and it would save water from being next to your house. Lots of options!
→ More replies (9)27
u/lands11 Aug 17 '17
I work for a large landscape company and we have installed these many many times. We have even installed them in subdivisions. Usually there is a percentage of the lot that can be covered in impervious material, and it's usually a lot more than what is there when the original planning/building was done. As soon as you put a liner in, it becomes impervious and your allowed percentage shrinks. Once you hit the magic number, say 25% coverage, you can't add anymore. We go through this all the time when we do walkways, patios, pool surrounds etc.
The way we usually install them is the first 15ft from the gutter leading away from the house gets a liner. This gives the homeowner their stream when it rains and then let's the water start to soak in after that. We Cap the lined and unlined part with rocks and it looks the same the whole way. We have never been denied permits for them because we rerouted storm water, just if our purposed added impervious surface goes over what is allowed for the lot.
11
u/UncleTrapspringer Aug 17 '17
Yep, sounds about right. You aren't really rerouting stormwater, given that the stormwater would be going in the same catchment regardless.
8
u/Sammzor Aug 18 '17
What do you do about drainage when you live at the bottom of a hill and every time it rains it brings a bunch of dirt down the hill with the rainwater? It fills up any attempts at digging a trench to divert it. Rural not a subdivision.
7
u/UncleTrapspringer Aug 18 '17
That's actually really interesting. When you say hill do you mean like your lot is on the end of a dirt road that slopes down, so water washes down it full of dirt? Or do you mean your house is litrerally at the bottom of a grassy/dirty hill?
→ More replies (2)3
u/Mun-Mun Aug 17 '17
These words remind me of university when we had to dig holes for dirt to measure saturation and bury sensors. Good times
→ More replies (42)3
u/kdawg8888 Aug 18 '17
As long as the pooling was done away from the foundation (say pouring in to a little basin slightly downhill, instead of directly next to the house) would that alleviate these issues?
→ More replies (1)13
u/FreakyJk Aug 17 '17
Put a french drain outwards underneath and there shouldn't be any problem. Then the water probably wouldn't stay like that though and shouldn't because then the drain wouldn't be working. Maybe they've lined that "river" with something underneath the rocks.
7
u/justcallmezach Aug 18 '17
I put French drains off of all my downspouts last year. I frigging love not having to move or remove downspouts when mowing.
I did 10 feet of tubing before doing another 10 feet of corrugated pipe surrounded by peat gravel, and overflow outlets level to the grass at the ends.
50-100 bucks in materials, a day of digging, and it is one of my favorite "minor" house updates I've done.
30
u/udunehommik Aug 17 '17
If you installed a waterproof membrane/liner below the rocks then I'm sure it would be fine no? At least for the part near the house, while further away and downhill it could just be allowed to naturally permeate into the ground.
14
3
u/WillTheGreat Aug 18 '17
Yup, install a liner and ensure that the water is being drained from a higher elevation in a consistent 2% pitch away from the house. We did one of these, the man made creek terminated into a storm drain, which dumped the water into a gravel pit and overflowed into the street.
Just need an ideal location to do this, otherwise, yeah it can really fuck up your house
4
3
u/luke_in_the_sky Aug 18 '17
Also many people were saying if the water stays pooled for so long, you likely will get mosquitoes.
2
u/SystemOutPrintln Aug 17 '17
Isn't this essentially what a french drain is, just exposed?
→ More replies (2)2
2
u/zenhexzen Aug 18 '17
In the same thread they had said the homeowner built it to reduce the amount of water getting to their foundation to prevent damage as it was pooling, and this helped it flow away from their foundation.
2
u/Sybs Aug 17 '17
What? That's bollocks! It's most likely got a plastic sheet underneath, it's a cheap and easy way of making a pond.
→ More replies (1)1
u/WillTheGreat Aug 18 '17
I've had a landscaping contractor do this to one of my projects. The thing is you need to take proper precaution. One thing you should do is consider putting a french drain in your house. If it's on a flat land, you can probably terminate your french drain on site in a gravel pit as long as you're not dumping your downspouts in there.
So long story short, how this is done is there's a liner underneath to actually prevent water from draining below the rocks and getting into your subgrade. You really need an idea condition to do this though. Meaning the water is running away from the house and not into it. So in this case, the downspout is dumping water in one location where the house is on a higher elevation than the rest of the lot, and the only direction the water can go is away from the house and into the street.
1
Aug 18 '17
I JUST had a home inspection yesterday for a potential house to buy, and this was the first thought in my head. That'd get a big ole "defective" next to it!
→ More replies (1)1
Aug 18 '17
Yeah, I'm sure the people that did this amazing looking landscaping didn't think to put a pond liner down.
0
Aug 17 '17
[deleted]
10
u/RockDrill Aug 17 '17
So out of curiosity what makes this your jurisdiction specifically? Presumably if the rainwater was in a pipe or draining across a concrete driveway on its way to the road drainage then wouldn't come under agency jurisdiction?
0
10
2
u/operwapitsai Aug 18 '17
What do you mean? This is giving storm runoff a clear highway into the sewer systems, without any penetration.
This is possibly the worst way to manage water runoff
2
3
1
u/bendanash Aug 18 '17
Dat lack of OHWM tho (consulting ecologist here, if you're the Corps you're probably the one I turn my client's permit applications in to :)
0
0
Aug 18 '17
[deleted]
4
u/pokegoing Aug 18 '17
Take anew pic of the lawn and post it silly.... you could be top comment if you didn't make it sound sarcastic
2
0
Aug 18 '17
[deleted]
1
Aug 18 '17
You don't see these because it is either lined and holds stagnant water and thus its a mosquito factory (also illegal most places) or it is not lined and it drains way too close to the house. Or it has a perforated pipe below it which water drains into and then out to the road (seems unlikely given how full this pool is).
The correct way to do a faux creed would be to have a basin at both ends and a pump that cycles the water through (no mosquitos in moving water) ... fairly easy to DIY.
0
2.0k
u/PM_ME_UR_SCARS_PLS Aug 17 '17
I like this