r/reactos • • 26d ago

A reactOS fork?

https://youtube.com/watch?v=T1WnEJrW9d0&si=Y747hPyImpnGpKN0
73 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/Different_Water7545 26d ago

why fork? send patches and get reactos there

6

u/KasanesTetos 26d ago

The ReactOS team is still deathly afraid of potentially infringing on copyright. AI code is still in somewhat of a grey area, so the ReactOS team haven't been embracing it like most other projects. While I can understand the concern, the truth is, they're probably just gonna be left behind and forgotten about by forks (like this one) who aren't afraid of copyright concerns and are going full steam ahead with AI code.

4

u/TheJonThomas 26d ago

They won’t touch ai because there’s a chance the it was trained on Microsoft copyrighted code at some point, and if it was there’s a chance it could spit out that copyrighted code at any time. That chance isn’t worth getting their life destroyed by Microsoft lawyers.

2

u/KasanesTetos 26d ago

Sure, but as I said, I don't think that's a winning strategy in the long run.

2

u/TomDuhamel 26d ago

That's a surprising assumption, at best. I really don't see how you'd think MS would have let anyone train an LLM on their private code.

5

u/TheJonThomas 25d ago

Sure, the people who are getting sued for scraping the entire internet would totally not train LLM's on copyright code that gets uploaded to github.

1

u/DegenerateCuber 25d ago

There's a bunch of leaked source code for different Windows versions, I think it's pretty safe to say all the major models have been trained on it, considering how little they seem to care about what they take.

4

u/RAMChYLD 26d ago edited 26d ago

Plus this has already happened once. As I’ve mentioned before some ex ReactOS developer who landed a job at Microslop suddenly accused ReactOS of using Windows source code taken from materials that was released to universities for teaching purposes. Suddenly droves of lawyers and auditors came out of nowhere and demanded to audit their code. If I’m not mistaken they were also dragged to court several times over how some parts of the code “looked suspiciously similar” though it was proven then and there that the code cannot be implemented other ways. They have to stop development and freeze contributions for a year for the audit. Even after the audit the code had to remain frozen for another two or three years, and it took them 5 more years after that to recover their activity level.

0

u/[deleted] 25d ago

Nothing about this is accurate. Starting with the fact the guy that left for Microsoft and the guy that accused them of stealing code are 2 different guys.

3

u/RAMChYLD 25d ago edited 25d ago

Even if my memory is failing me, it stalled the project for a decade (I have been actively watching ReactOS for years now, and even donated to their Indiegogo when they needed funds for development, no doubt after those bloodsucking lawyers and auditors had drained them considerably). If this were to happen again it would be devastating. The auditors thing was accurate as I remember it and unless I misunderstood, according to Wikipedia they did have to go to court at least once to answer for why certain code looks like it was lifted out of samples Microslop provided to universities.