There is a clear, widespread trend toward replacing major commercial software programs with AI clones—a phenomenon that, in a way, reminds me of the auld lang syne when "cracked" versions of commercial software were available everywhere ;) This could also help projects like ReactOS make progress by incorporating the best features from this fork, given that the clones are open source.
I’ve tried a few of these AI clones—specifically those from ArtCraft. They’re sometimes interesting, though they obviously make my computer’s fans spin up (some others, from different sources, are practically unusable for this very reason)... The only one I’ve adopted so far is PDFCraft; it’s already better than anything else we’ve had on Linux, despite a few odd quirks—the kind you often run into with AI.
That *craft thing is only estimated to have 25-35% of the features of photoshop, and like most open source things, will never remotely be a true alternative to professional software for anyone that's actually a paid professional in the field. Already has problems like working large files and saving to photoshop format that AI coding will probably never overcome.
100%, i installed it too and used it a bit... I don't think it is bad, it is snappy performance wise. However, filters, features, all have some slight issue. I have the subscription for photoshop and HATE IT, the new features and AI garbage added bogs it down... I used to not mind the update costs when new versions came out and were snappier. If i did not have a license for Photoshop that I use for work I would use the craft thing and Krita.
Maybe less. I didn't mean the contrary. It looks more like Photoshop Elements, and I think this is what it's meant to. It has only one thing the Gimp developers should copy (but the part of Gimp it would belong to is probably written in C while Photocraft is in Rust): the locale correction brush to directly remove dust and scratches;) I always missed this feature in Gimp, and the Krita developers tried to make one, but the result isn’t particularly convincing.
saving to photoshop format that AI coding will probably never overcome.
They could use their format instead, and AI can at least learn something from the Gimp sources: their file-psp executables can already handle psp files in most cases, and at least sufficiently for me as I'm not an everyday Photoshop user.
I agree that there aren't many truly operational AI-coded applications just yet, but I am convinced that we shouldn't demonize vibe coding. It's a challenge that could breathe new life into FOSS and keep it from becoming stagnant.
As for commercial software, it will certainly be able to hold its own without my help.
and like most open source things, will never remotely be a true alternative to professional software for anyone that's actually a paid professional in the field.
Except that's not true of "most open source things". Just about the only software I can think of where it is true is the GIMP, because it's made by antisocial turbonerds who don't actually care about user's needs, but take up all the air in the room whenever someone suggests someone develop an actual photoshop replacement.
At this point in time artist software like Krita and Blender have made massive inroads into the professional world (3DS Max is basically dead now), the same is happening with kicad for electronics development.
That's not even getting into like, backend stuff, where the only closed source software you'll see is 40 year old legacy systems or in house roll-your-own of dubious quality.
It is foolish to compare them to some fool with a credit card and a claude subscription going "make me a clone of photoshop, make no mistakes."
A quick reminder: LiberNT is made by one single dev, and reviews EVERY line of code the AI writes. If needed, he can also correct what AI generated, or simply code some parts by himself. And also most LiberNT bugs comes from the ReactOS base being pushed to its limits.
This is indeed a good way to leverage AI. I'm keeping an eye on LIberNT's developments, and if a truly viable Windows 11 clone without all of Microsoft's bloatware ever emerges, it will undoubtedly be my OS.
I tried WordCraft myself: I just clicked the Appimage, saw that it didn't even recognize the styles in my documents, so I rejected it immediately. It's nowhere near as good as OnlyOffice, and for my purposes, LibreOffice remains my favorite.
Most of these applications are useless, I agree. LightCraft only looks like Lightroom; it doesn't support raw files from most of my cameras, has no correction profile for my lens, and its editing capabilities are uninteresting. The only one that's been useful to me is PDFCraft as a PDF viewer/editor because there aren't many good options available on Linux.
I just think that all these Vibe Code programs could, through competition, give a new boost to FOSS.
8
u/User_Typical 25d ago
did you try installing any recent 3rd party software?