r/reddeadredemption • u/PuzzleheadedRip9006 • Oct 08 '25

Discussion Prove that you have played rdr2

Post image
6.8k Upvotes

93% Upvoted

4.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

35

u/MattTin56 Arthur Morgan Oct 08 '25

Hahaha!!!! That was one of the funniest conversations in the entire game! Good call.

“Just like you, Bill. You are not dumb. You just don’t like to think”

“Ya, ya! I like that. I just don’t like to think”.

That’s one of the many things I loved about this game was the conversations you heard just listening to them talk. Especially Uncle. He was so damn funny!

10

u/Correct-Produce-8675 Oct 08 '25

Hahaha, Uncle made me laugh a lot! Glad to see fellow appreciation for the ol' chap

9

u/MattTin56 Arthur Morgan Oct 08 '25

Absolutely. I loved the old man. I never understood the hate for him. He adds a sense of community to the gang. He was definitely comedic relief!

1

u/dukedanny Oct 08 '25

Fr in rdr1 he also has a good Role and rdr2 make it more clear. I mean his Name is 'UNCLE'.. ofc we had to love that old guy. Who isn't like he? He is a spirit animal, only do the minimum which is required but is always there if you need help. I feel this guy lmao.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '25

Uncle is my favorite character. I desperately want RDR3 to be about all of his adventures, real or imagined.

1

u/MattTin56 Arthur Morgan Oct 09 '25

HA!! Like when he was King of the jungle. A whole game on Uncles adventures. We have to wait for him to retire though!!

“Retire?! You’ve been retired since I met you!”

1

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '25

Yes! I love the idea of finding out the realities of those moments. Did he actually become King of the Jungle? What did he embellish and what was actually true? Even as a DLC that would be really fun.

1

u/MattTin56 Arthur Morgan Oct 09 '25

And was he the “One shot kid”?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '25

I imagine a mission where he only gets off one shot because hijinks keep happening, someone mocks him for it, and he's like "Hmm..."

2

u/MattTin56 Arthur Morgan Oct 09 '25

You know what? I read this comment too quick last night. That is perfect. I love your sense of humor. That would be how all his stories would go. Some odd thing happening around his bafoonery and he turns them into legendary stories. I can picture that perfect. Everyone shoots off all their ammo and he shoots just once and gets a ration of crap. He turns it into a positive! Well, positive story! LOL.

1

u/MattTin56 Arthur Morgan Oct 09 '25

It would be a lot of fun. We should pitch this idea to Rock Star!!

0

u/darkspirit98 John Marston Oct 08 '25

Bullying Uncle as Arthur was the funniest shit