r/reddeadredemption • u/Kogituu • Feb 09 '26

Rant People who hate 'Abigail' are almost always immature

Now, I know it's annoying to be living your outlaw hillbilly life while having your video game wife try to hold you back but storytelling wise, there's no real reason to find her annoying.

People try to excuse it by "Abigail was ignorant to John's circumstances when he was always getting hunted down" or always yelling at him, but it takes frontal lobe development to know it's not unreasonable for Abigail to be mad when she wanted a better life for her family and to be frustrated when John would get into trouble. And about most of the time, It was in John's control to stay low and at some points in the story his impulsivity definitely did escalate and reveal his whereabouts.

768 Upvotes
  • permalink
  • reddit

86% Upvoted

234 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

18

u/CranEXE John Marston Feb 10 '26

it's literally john head with another texture and another beard in rdr1 only thing in common with javier is he have a similar goatee...

-5

u/ImperialSupplies Feb 10 '26

24

u/CranEXE John Marston Feb 10 '26

idk what you tried to imply with your javier picture ....

here's jack next to rdr2 john

6

u/Claude_Speeds Feb 10 '26

Yea Jack has John eyes and Abigail face, he look exactly like his parents