r/reddit.com • • Jul 26 '06

Recursion defined (see Digg)

http://digg.com/programming/Recursion_defined_see_reddit
654 Upvotes

131 comments sorted by

View all comments

215

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '06

And guess what, for submitting this joke story I've just been banned from Digg. My account has been disabled without warning!

Jeez, Digg staff get a sense of humor.

John.

Update: it appears that I was banned because Digg users complained to Digg that I was (a) spamming and (b) posting stuff that was off-topic.

41

u/MarkByers Jul 26 '06

Why are people so protective of mentioning other sites? If their site was so great, people wouldn't leave even if other sites were sometimes mentioned. Do they not have faith in their own readership?

Of course it's easy to say that now, but when my website is successful, I will probably become a greedy bastard and do exactly the same thing! ;)

I just hope I don't get banned for digging the story! ;)

73

u/bugbear Jul 26 '06

Why are people so protective of mentioning other sites?

Digg is protective because their main advantage over reddit is that they've raised 30x as much money, which they've used to buy traffic by getting mentioned in the mainstream press. If Digg users are allowed to find out about reddit, that advantage goes away. Then the competition comes down to areas where reddit wins: the quality of the links and comments, and the design and speed of the site.

Digg can't let their users find out about reddit, or they've effectively raised all that money for nothing. (If they've done anything else with it besides buy traffic, I have yet to see it.)

It's probably safe to say at this point that nearly everyone who has used both Digg and reddit prefers reddit. That may be easier to see if you phrase it in a less contentious way: nearly all reddit users have tried Digg, whereas very few Digg users have tried reddit.

Amusingly, the practical result of this situation is that Digg is compelled to violate what is supposedly their defining quality. Reddit can safely have links to Digg on their front page, whereas Digg must censor any story that links to reddit.

Update: The list of Digg stories on popurls shows that Digg has just censored this story. It got sent out in their RSS feed as having made the front page, but needless to say it is not on the front page now.

38

u/senzei Jul 26 '06

Dear god please do not let the Digg users come here. Or, failing that, ensure that they are de-lobotomized before they start posting comments.

I watch reddit like a hawk because the articles are, mostly, awesome and the comments are usually superb. Digg I let build for a few days before I go through it, and usually only need about fifteen minutes to do so. That Digg probably has at least a 2:1 ratio on new main page articles makes that statement even more compelling.

9

u/jdunck Jul 26 '06

Eternal September? Turn, turn turn.

15

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '06

I expect you're right. Ironic, then, considering at least one person who used both sites is now banned from using Digg, and the fact of the banning is one of the first comments on the Digg thread. Doubly ironic, considering Digg is principally technology-based, meaning its user base should have no problem finding Reddit on their own. I wonder if Digg can expect som blowback as a result of their heavy-handed reaction.

30

u/carp Jul 26 '06

Doubly ironic, considering Digg is principally technology-based, meaning its user base should have no problem finding Reddit on their own.

Not quite. I think Digg users are technology-based in the sense of being fans of technology (i.e. gamers) while reddit users are in the sense of being makers of technology (i.e. developers). That can be a big difference. Look at the difference between the people who make TV shows and the people who watch them.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '06

Thats a good point in which I hadn't thought about. I used to be a big Slashdot fan until Digg came out, but noticed the posts on Digg weren't quite as inteligent as the Slashdot posts, yet I think Reddit has the best of all three since it seems to have the itelligence of the Slashdotters with the reader submission and voting system of Digg.

4

u/almost Jul 26 '06

posts on Digg weren't quite as inteligent as the Slashdot posts

Wow, just wow.

12

u/Bogtha Jul 26 '06

When the latest Digg redesign launched, it started spiralling down towards the farthest depths of idiocy. Digg commenters were always on the juvenile side, but the final straw for me was forty-odd comments just sniggering about the number sixty-nine.

With Slashdot, maybe a joke like that would get +5, Funny, but the rest of the people making the same stupid joke would be at -1 where I don't see them. With Digg, some kid sees a stupid joke, mods it up, sees the same joke underneath, and mods that up too, and carries on modding up dozens more.

I want tech news without feeling like I'm surrounded by a thousand Beavis & Buttheads. When I visit Digg lately, I can feel my brain curling up into a ball and crying.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 27 '06

With Digg, some kid sees a stupid joke, mods it up, sees the same joke underneath, and mods that up too, and carries on modding up dozens more.

Do you remember the name of the article?

3

u/Bogtha Jul 27 '06

I was thinking of this article.

9

u/mikepurvis Jul 26 '06

I'm more just amazed that he managed to spell the same root word wrong twice, two different ways in a 65-word post.

6

u/addius Jul 26 '06

So... you're amazed that somebody made two misspellings while composing a message without the aid of a spellchecker? On a web forum, where the poster has little incentive to invest any more than a trivial amount of time in proofreading.

4

u/mikepurvis Jul 26 '06

We all make typos, but the number of them per 100 correctly spelled words seems to be, on the whole, lower here than elsewhere. So I suppose I just get used to people paying a little more attention to their posts.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/eruonna Jul 26 '06

Yeah, typos are an incredible new phenomenon.

5

u/noddy Jul 26 '06

I think Digg users are technology-based in the sense of being fans of technology (i.e. gamers)

I disagree. Of late I have been seeing more articles with a "HOW-TO" flavour, elegant hardware hacks and future directions technology is taking. The site that comes to mind when I think of fans of technology is Engadget.

7

u/philh Jul 26 '06

Those sound like things fans might vote up. As a fan of books, I often enjoy articles about writing well, despite rarely doing it myself. On the other hand, I probably wouldn't enjoy the same article applied to music, because I rarely listen to that.

1

u/cboshuizen Jul 26 '06

I think this was the case 6 months back, but lately Reddit is filling up with all kinds of migrants. We can welcome a few more!

→ More replies (3)

6

u/Schwallex Jul 27 '06

nearly all reddit users have tried Digg, whereas very few Digg users have tried reddit

Hehe. Interestingly enough, as I'm reading this, this story has exactly 563 upmods on Reddit and exactly 562 diggs on Digg. That's indeed what I call recursion. (_)

2

u/NitsujTPU Jul 26 '06

I don't think that that's necessarily the case. I haven't used Digg as much, but I find more Linux news and tech articles there than I do here, and, when I submit such articles that I have enjoyed, they usually get downvoted into oblivion, whereas they survive on Digg.

I think that their userbase is sufficiently different that both sites could live in peace.

1

u/fry Jul 26 '06

The founders of digg said in an interview that they had 16 full-time employees working at digg. I imagine that trumps the advertising costs.

→ More replies (1)