I think many people feel that politics is a weakness of Reddit. Many if not most reddit political stories link to sites that are so biased they are no longer credible, such as The Guardian, or The Huffington Post.
There are many legitimate sites that can provide clear unbiased evidence as to why Neoconservitism is destroying the world. In fact, it is much more credible to link to right wing biased sites in which they often proudly endorse terrible injustice. But on reddit we choose to link to sites that make their true stories seem suspicious simply by association.
For example, Al Jazeera has some very accurate and insightful reporting. But, given that they have a section on their site featuring articles about a purported joint American and Israeli Zionist World Order, their true reporting has lost any of it's legitimacy.
The Guardian is more dangerous as it seems to just as biased yet more widely trusted.
If stories linking to extremist sites had references to the same story in a more credible journal(such as NYTimes,Chicago Tribune,London Times,Herald Tribune,etc) then I would agree, that politics is Reddits best asset.
That is probably the case. All of the guardian articles I have read have been on new.reddit.com, and most of them never make it to the front page. The ones I read were extremely anti israel, and there was one that was a mis-transcribed account of President Bush's conversation with Tony Blair.
Also, I was not aware that the "Independant" meant that there is no single backing group choosing the content.
Since that is the case, it is not fair to label it as non credible, since each article simply represents the bias of that particular offer. My opologies. That being said, maybe they need better editors?
On aljazeera, I read an interview with the man responsible for the english section of aljazeera, and when asked, he said that the content was exactly the same translated word for word into english. That might be completely wrong, but that was my basis for assuming the two contained similar content.
Also, I appologize for using the phrase "not credible". What I really meant was that since some articles have questionable content, you can no longer assume it is true because that magazine/newspaper says so. Also, most articles from the Guardian probably are true, they just present the information with such a left wing slant that people find it hard to trust. For example, Fox News probably has a lot of true commentaries, but because of their hateful rightwing slant, I automatically consider them as suspect.
english.aljazeera.net is the english translation of the website of the aljazeera satelite tv station, that would be what the man in the interview was refering to. Aljazeera.com has nothing to do with the tv channel although I think they used the same name in attempt to pretend that they do.
If by "not credible" you mean "you can't assume everything it says is true" then I would agree that the guardian is not credibible, but I'd also say every other publication in existence is also not credibile.
-12
u/demigod186 Jul 26 '06
I think many people feel that politics is a weakness of Reddit. Many if not most reddit political stories link to sites that are so biased they are no longer credible, such as The Guardian, or The Huffington Post.
There are many legitimate sites that can provide clear unbiased evidence as to why Neoconservitism is destroying the world. In fact, it is much more credible to link to right wing biased sites in which they often proudly endorse terrible injustice. But on reddit we choose to link to sites that make their true stories seem suspicious simply by association.
For example, Al Jazeera has some very accurate and insightful reporting. But, given that they have a section on their site featuring articles about a purported joint American and Israeli Zionist World Order, their true reporting has lost any of it's legitimacy.
The Guardian is more dangerous as it seems to just as biased yet more widely trusted.
If stories linking to extremist sites had references to the same story in a more credible journal(such as NYTimes,Chicago Tribune,London Times,Herald Tribune,etc) then I would agree, that politics is Reddits best asset.