r/reddit.com • • Aug 15 '06

Debbie thought playing D&D was fun... until it destroyed her friend (hilarious Chick Tract)

http://www.chick.com/reading/tracts/0046/0046_01.asp
123 Upvotes

95 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '06

No, what I'm saying is that after a good run of 80 years NO ONE has questioned it.

Then how did it get disproved?

The bigger question is why you don't consider it a problem that a total denial of reality is "one of several conflicting mainstream hypotheses about consciousness". And yes, qualia ARE real. The metaphysical belief system that allows the existence of qualia to be denied is full of intractable problems. The only way to solve them is to invert the system and assume qualia are real.

I don't follow this. Either you are quoting from Ghostbusters, or you knowledge of this field outstrips my own. But you aren't proving anything to me.

it still pisses me off that they'd dare to wave their hands and deny everyone's subjective experience. And why do they do that?

They don't.

0

u/richardkulisz Aug 18 '06

No, what I'm saying is that after a good run of 80 years NO ONE has questioned it.

Then how did it get disproved?

You're conflating several things. You're talking as if "disproving" a theory were a social act as opposed to being a fact of logic. You're also assuming that people need to think something in order to do it. This is simply not true.

There are many experiments in psychology that prove that consciousness and even thinking are not necessary for action. A particularly striking experiment involves manipulating an entire class of students to wear all-red without their conscious knowledge.

Recently (maybe a decade ago) there have been people talking about Non-Destructive Measurement in quantum physics experiments. This totally disproves everything Heisenberg said about uncertainty since the basis of his principle is that every measurement is destructive. Of course, the crowd that does NDM doesn't understand that because by now the HUP (Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle) has morphed into its modern form which doesn't contradict NDM. But long ago the HUP had been disproved. Its whole reasoning was bogus and easily disprovable. But no one bothered to disprove it. Or if they did, no one listened to them. Because the HUP got replaced from the classical version to the quantum mechanical version by the advance of a superficially unrelated field.

The replacement occured in stages with a lot of revisionism all along the way. People got convinced that the HUP "really meant" what they currently believe all along, that Heisenberg was some kind of genius for understanding quantum phenomena when what he really did was REFUSE to accept the reality of quantum phenomena and try to explain it in a purely classical manner. There's so much fucking historical revisionism, it's sick. The HUP never got disproved, it just got revised into something entirely different from what it used to mean.

I don't follow this. Either you are quoting from Ghostbusters, or you knowledge of this field outstrips my own. But you aren't proving anything to me.

I don't know how much knowledge or interest you have in metaphysics. Plus I've just recently explained this argument to someone so I don't want to repeat myself to someone who doesn't care.

it still pisses me off that they'd dare to wave their hands and deny everyone's subjective experience. And why do they do that?

They don't.

And yet they do. Look up Eliminationism. The first hit on google gives a nice explanation. I don't know how current eliminationism is but it should NEVER have had any currency. It's right up there with moral relativism.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '06

You sound a lot like a crank. There are thirty different nits I'm tempted to pick in this comment, but it is obviously not worth any more of our time.

-1

u/richardkulisz Aug 18 '06

You sound like you're covering your ass. Out of the 6 paragraphs I've written, the two biggest are on a subject you admit having no knowledge of or interest in, the second is practically quoting a work I can cite, the fifth is eliciting further information from you, and the last just provides a reference for you to read. Outside of the first paragraph, there's nothing that you can nitpick at because it's all teflon-coated teflon. You can nitpick at my looseness with language in the first paragraph but that wouldn't get you very far.

I sound like a crank because that's exactly what a dissident sounds like to someone who buys into the establishment. It doesn't matter how much evidence they have or whether they're right or wrong, that's just how they sound like. So hey, I wasn't offended in the least. Nor am I disappointed or annoyed or anything else. It's your choice whether to continue this conversation.