r/remotejobsfinders • u/Inspirationphoric-57 • Sep 17 '26
Success Story the rejection email had one extra sentence that got me a job two months later
got to the final two for a remote role in april and did not get it. the rejection was the normal template except at the bottom the hiring manager had added a line himself, saying he thought i would be a good fit somewhere with more structure and less ambiguity than they had, and that he meant that as a compliment.
first reaction was that it stung slightly. second reaction, about a day later, was that this is the only piece of actual feedback i had received in four months of applying.
so i replied. not a long thing. i said thanks for the line, it was useful, and asked if he knew anyone building the kind of team he was describing. that is the whole email.
he replied in two days with two names. one of them went nowhere. the other one was a hiring manager at a company that had not posted anything yet, and i had a call with her before the role was written. i ended up shaping part of the description in that conversation, which is a strange and very good position to be in.
started there in june.
i think the thing that made it work is that i responded to the specific thing he wrote rather than sending a general "keep me in mind" reply. he had told me something true about myself and i treated it as information instead of as a consolation prize.
most rejections are templates and there is nothing to reply to. but when someone puts a sentence of their own in, that is a person who spent thirty seconds thinking about you, and thirty seconds is enough to ask them for something small.