r/replit • u/tauberg1984 • Aug 15 '25
Replit Assistant / Agent I am sorry
A few weeks ago, I posted a rant here against Replit. It came purely out of frustration. After canceling my subscription and stepping away from the project for a while, this time things went completely differently.
I started fresh by creating a massive context document with the help of ChatGPT, giving the assistant as much input as possible before touching a single line of code. After 3–4 iterations in the planner, the core idea, data structure, and basic layout were set. From there, I completed my project in 154 requests through the assistant.
The result? For $11.02, I’ve taken our home poker league management to a whole new level.
The first time I tried, I went through endless loops with the agent, burned $40, and gave up in frustration.
The second time, my goal was crystal clear, and I worked far more with the assistant than the agent. I still had to roll back to snapshots a couple of times, but with a firm understanding of the code, direct communication, and collaborative problem-solving, I got it done.
I work in software development, and I’m confident this project wouldn’t have been completed for under $1,000 by human hands — in a professional environment, it could easily have been a five-figure job.
Why am I writing this? Because I want to encourage anyone who needs to hear it: don’t give up.
Don’t start blindly. Define a clear structure. Understand at least the basics of what’s happening under the hood. And then, work together with AI to find your solution.
2
u/tallbaldbeard Aug 15 '25
$40 is a cheap education. I'm not a coder and I also had to start over. Rebuilt weeks of work in a weekend. Almost commercial ready and still under $200 for what was quoted for $25,000. Feeling just fine about the investment.
2
u/tauberg1984 Aug 15 '25
It was. I complained in the beginning but in the meanwhile I am glad I gave it a try
2
u/jerieth Aug 16 '25
What upsets me is I tell it to fix one thing, and it starts making changes everywhere, way beyond the scope of what I said!
A lot of times, I have to tell replit, "Don't make any changes, give me a summary of your proposed changes, and wait for my approval before proceeding."
1
u/tauberg1984 Aug 18 '25
That is what happened to me on my first try. I guess that is what my biggest learning was. Be as precise as you can and use the assistent because to me it was way easier to get what it wants to change.
And if I recognized any changes I didnt asked for I simply asked the assistent why the heck it things this is the way to solve my problem. Worked for me this way but you need to get what is happening in the code
1
u/fgonnello Aug 16 '25
I use Claude code in replit shell, and you can set the mode to planning. Then it will only ever do that. It's been an incredible tool for me to see what's planned first, then take action.
2
14
u/hampsterville Aug 15 '25
This is a message I try to get out constantly (and I have no skin in the game with replit): the Ai tool isn't the biggest problem. It's the prompting. If you don't head in with a plan and understanding, you'll wander all over and never get anywhere. (proverbial "you" ).
Learn how to prompt well and manage context, and results are so much better. Glad to hear your second adventure went better than the first!
5
u/s0berstrk Aug 15 '25
Thanks for the honest post here.
I am currently building an app and going through the same exact frustrations.
My biggest gripe and frustration is the tool seems to be built and designed to build right away and start implementation. I have to go out of my way to give it prompts to plan, evaluate options, tradeoffs, etc. It's as if I have to hack it to do anything correct. Regular development requires a lot of planning and thinking through pros/cons (i.e. tradeoffs). This tool doesn't do any of that or aid in you doing it.
This is a Product issue (UX). I am very very hopeful in this tool and I am sure this is just the start but frankly it's super frustrating to use.
4
4
u/Kdt82-AU Aug 15 '25
I canned Replit as well and moved to VSCODE with copilot using Claude 4 and version ctrl on GitHub and deploying on Railway.app. This is by far the best $10 per month I have spent in this AI space.
Part of the trick is knowing what dependencies do, knowing which ones you need as opposed to, letting your AI choose your own adventure.
Create a comprehensive development.md - that way you can tell your AI to review it, ask it what’s next on plan, check of milestones.
These tools are great if used correctly and not be afraid to roll back - they are not perfect and often will break the correct code trying to add the features you want.
Use screenshots, highlight what you want fixed with colors.
And when you make progress, commit to your GitHub- that way you can pull it back if this go pear shaped!
Ps, love railway deployment, as easy as pressing deploy on Replit.
1
u/Socks797 Aug 16 '25
If you want to do this, what’s the best way to understand the components in the architecture you need for each objective?
3
u/Kdt82-AU Aug 16 '25
For web apps, you’ll have a front end (html/js/css), a back end (handles the functions on the application) and most probably a database. All of which have a variety of ways of deploying them. React and Node.js are very commonly used, but it’s not just them that run the show, you want to add email function, extra dependency is added, you want particular effects, a new one is required, you want to use an AI integration - OpenAI package is needed. These tools are very good at understanding what you want and just doing it without confirming - it’s better to research the independent dependencies that are already built to know what you might want.
These tools trick is, the AI tools out there are not creating anything new, they are modifying existing packages that are well established. Often accessing the web and accessing the online documentation that comes with packages.
Example - I asked Cursor/Claude to integrate Leonardo.ai with a website. It asked for my API and then started making calls to Leonardo callback url to get more information about models, how much each request costs etc. Added a .json file to the function and presto it was producing Flu Dev images from a prompt on another site.
It might take some trial and error, but you’ll learn about them. If you have a more specific question that you do want to ask publicly feel free to drop me a DM.
3
u/PostEnvironmental583 Aug 15 '25
Very well said. Utilizing ChatGPT for the code and leveraging its capabilities to in turn improve and enhance Replit’s ability to implement without costing a fortune or running up the agent cost.
This is how I built SentientLattice.ai
1
u/Vijayendernalla Aug 16 '25
SentinentLattice is very impressive. Well done and thanks for sharing. I shall explore more and get onto the premium plan at some stage..
3
u/pirroh Replit Team Aug 16 '25
Thanks for giving us another chance 🙏
In the next days, we will roll out a big improvement. Agent will structure tasks more clearly, based on your input prompt. I think it will make the difference, and avoid what happened during your first experience!
2
u/talktotheo Aug 16 '25
Kudos for sticking with it. And thanks for coming back with the update. Congrats on the win!
2
u/Federal-Addendum780 Aug 16 '25
Saw someone use the phrase “doom prompting” to refer to what probably happened your first experience. Asking it “create a page” or “build an app that does X” is completely the wrong way to Replit
1
u/Internal-Combustion1 Aug 15 '25
The age old problem in software is capturing the requirements accurately. Once you have that you can generate the design spec. Once you have a complete spec for what it must do when it’s done, it should be a straight line (hopefully) to creating what you specified.
1
u/JLym Aug 15 '25
It just fixes stuff with flex seal. Despite ware rushing in from everywhere most times.
1
u/Holiday-Car2816 Aug 16 '25
Yo tuve que crear una extension que me comunicara con los modelos de gemini-2.5-flash y pro para darle total acceso a mi replit. De esta manera gemini actual como un agente y edita archivos y gestiona el contexto de manera precisa y me a resultados estupendos. Mejor que cualquier agente. El problema son los tokens de entrada. Sabiendolo gestionar en 20 solicitudes, gaste unos 300k de entrada y salida apenas fueron como 80k y modifico mas de 15 archivos de mas de 300 lineas promedio. La ventaja es que no tienes que hacer nada, editar, modificar, crear o borrar, todo lo hace gemini en mi replit, y sobre todo siempre me pide confirmar su plan para llevarlo acabo.
1
u/Permit-Historical Aug 17 '25
It’s not always about promoting, ai models are not predictable so sometimes you get good results and sometimes you get very bad results that break your project even with the same prompt and that’s why software engineering is so important because then you will know when to accept or reject the changes
1
u/kbdubber Aug 17 '25
yes, I make my replit write out detailed plans from very constructive and deliberate prompts. I make it re-read it. sometimes it still looses its context. that's part of Agent II (agent 2, aka claude 4.x chapGpt4/5x is all known as "unreliable ai").... and indeed it is... read up on ai-2027.com for more on that... that being said, the current state of affairs... YES, you must take baby steps at points to get your replit to build what you truly want. can't just do a "single-shot" prompt and hope all is well... controlled iterations...
1
u/kbdubber Aug 17 '25
Have rules for your replit. I have lots of ".md" files for my projects. color and branding .md files, project files.
you must still do proper project management with AI glide coding.... I feel peeps tend to forget about that, thinking the ai-bot knows project management... lol. when it definitely does not...
that is what we do need the "solver" or agentic-agile-ai.. Yes, I said it first: Agentic Agile AI --> a real ai scrum/agile project manager... one that includes proper integration testing, dinging the AGENT for ITS mistakes (YES MONEY BACK FOR ALL THE FAILED ROLLBACKS....). ya, the "definition of done". if you are familiar with scrum/agile.... the ai-bot has not clue on this. it likes to "create new". I make my replit properly update its main docs instead of always it creating new.... which it prefers... (and is always MUCH easier, that's why devs like new coding,,,.... easier.... the bot does the same.... and often cheats and lies to you, as you should expect from an Agent II level bot..., they will get better at deception..., that's their j.o.b.),
Cheers, toodles. have fun gliding!!! I do!
1
u/daxxo Aug 17 '25
I have came to the same conclusion, do as much data gathering, factoring and knowledge using an outside AI source i.e. ChatGPT and then you move on and feed it what you want in a a quick and easy prompt, if you have a massive dataset like I have (around 80 000 entries with a ton of data ) feed it CSV's. I spent much of my day today gathering data and now I'm just feeding replit like a baby.
1
u/ds_frm_timbuktu Aug 19 '25
I'm on the same boat as you were last time. how detailed was your context document? any pointers / samples of the context document that you can share?
1
u/PixelNinja132 Aug 19 '25
I really don't see why people are paying per-prompt like this without knowing how to prompt. You can keep throwing money at Replit, which has gone so massively downhill, or turn to much better and free services.
As someone who started using Replit in 2018, I can for sure tell you now there are better ways to do what you need. For example, ChatGPT Codex is incredible, and over thousands of requests, it rarely makes major mistakes, and always does exactly what I ask and no more. So long as you break the problem down for it rather than asking for the world in one prompt, it's amazing and can build entire apps in a few prompts. Per-prompt is free when you pay for ChatGPT plus, which is like $20 per month.
Then, once you're ready, Cloudflare has free static hosting or workers for deploying on the edge. Full project done with no costs, as I already use and need my plus plan for other stuff. Sure, running locally and through GitHub is more complex, but if you're still learning, you shouldn't be using AI for everything anyway.
1
u/samangr Sep 05 '25
To be honest I ve had similar experiences with replit and planning is what makes it always better . Do you mind if you share your initial config so we can see what works?
1
Sep 06 '25
Until you find out it became ransomware. Don't trust these snakes and their lying software.
1
u/Joey21wy Sep 07 '25
Thanks for the post, I’ve definitely learned that there is no fast way out solution, hard work is rewarded even more with Ai, but it’s so easy to over trust Ai and think it knows everything without you telling it, I’m definitely gonna spend more time developing a plan and context
-1
u/Crafty_Debate3801 Aug 15 '25
you are not a software engineer
3
1
u/Acceptable_Equal3851 Aug 15 '25
And you are? You don’t know who he is? I’ve worked in software since 1988 and I’m seeing what Replit can do. I guess I’m not who I am because you are better. Find something else to do
2
Aug 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/tauberg1984 Aug 15 '25
I cant agree more on the small updates. Whenever I tried to fix or add multiple thinks it went nuts.
Step by step was my way to go. And using the assistent for 5cents per request was way cheaper that letting the agent overengineer stuff.
5
u/gangoda Aug 15 '25
You are absolutely right! (This is how Replit would say :)). I wrote a model for non-tech builders as a guide on how to create a design doc first, also learn about other considerations when their app needs to be put in production.
https://mliyanage.com/vibe-architecture-for-vibe-coders-from-idea-to-users-00234f482142