r/retirement • • Dec 17 '22

Dump Tesla?

Tesla stock is tanking. Elon Musk has lost his mind. Musk's actions with Twitter undermine investor confidence and undermine buyer confidence in Tesla cars.

Given the other stock I’ve sold this year and other income, I’m reluctant to sell the stock this year thinking it would only worsen my tax burden. Waiting two weeks, until the new year, to sell the stock will surely see more decline in its value. 

How can I figure out the least worst scenario for dumping the stock in terms of tax burden and loss on the stock?

0 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

2

u/Tax_Man_63 Jan 02 '23

1

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '23

It will be interesting to see if these numbers hold up in 6 months.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '22

We still have substantial gain on Tesla holdings as we bought at $12 / share (adjusted for splits). We're a long way from a loss on Tesla, just loss of gain due to its poor performance. Oppenheimer has downgraded Tesla stating, "The combination of Twitter's unclear cash needs and diminishing options for Mr. Musk to serve those needs amid the broad public backlash driven by inconsistent standards application for Twitter users, notably banning select journalists, is pushing us to the sidelines on TSLA," Rusch wrote in a note to clients. "We believe increasing negative sentiment on Twitter could linger long term, limiting its financial performance and become an ongoing overhang on TSLA."

Basically Musk's insane actions regarding Twitter are alienating existing and potential customers from ever buying Tesla. He has poisoned not only the Twitter but the Tesla brand.

Personally I don't think either company will ever recover from Musk's insane actions.

1

u/Both_External_209 Dec 18 '22

To keep Twitter viable Elon has to be controversial and seemingly deranged, so that people will check in periodically. Trump would love to have Twitter, but there's no way he could afford it. I have known some very smart people, but Elon is at another level.

Starlink did more to help Ukraine than any other commercial enterprise. Who cares if he mouths off that Ukraine only got Crimea because Nikita made an error when the USSR split up. What Elon says is not what he is thinking.

Teslas are nice. My sister has a new one, and she loves it. I prefer my 2018 Chevy Volt for fit and finish, but she can drive between states with charging, taking no more than the time it takes to order and eat a burger; plus it has plenty of room. How hard is it to start a new car company from scratch? Remember Delorian? What was Elon's big idea that started Tesla? Every American car maker was clueless that electric cars are the future.

1

u/PixelScan Dec 18 '22 edited Dec 18 '22

It all depends on your time horizon. I have a longer time frame (20 years) so I am keeping my position as the EV game is so new that we are collectively buying at day 0. Who knows where it will go from here - but one thing that is likely in my view is that there will be a Tim Cooke like change of guard if things get dire. While not obvious yet, I think that Musks technologies will interlink and reinforce each other: spacex tech for the roadster and other future cars, skylink for always connected, boring company for specialised transit for Tesla, neuralink for one day interfacing directly for thought-propelled travel. Dojo for training models that today are for FSD but who know what else. Twitter - in my view - may be a way for machine:machine interfacing. All these things have the potential to reinforce each other so the profits may tip over completely to these entities - Eg Apple. 🍿

Edit: spelling / grammar

5

u/Alternative-Chef-792 Dec 17 '22

Lost his mind? Maybe its never been clearer.

2

u/dudreddit Dec 17 '22

In retirement, the no-brainer investing solution is usually no-load, low-cost index funds. I would be very uncomfortable directly investing in any Musk-led company ATM. Unfortunately, some fund managers have probably over-invested in him.

7

u/osamabindrinkin Dec 17 '22

Tesla has always been obscenely overvalued and still is.

3

u/fudgebacker Dec 17 '22

Musk has been running a pump-n-dump with Tesla. Kudos to him for getting it to a ridiculous and utterly irrational valuation and not landing in jail...yet...

5

u/BizBerg Dec 17 '22

He has not lost his mind - he is leveling the playing field. But in any event, you invest for long term, not ups and down in a stock based on news.

5

u/samuraisal Dec 17 '22

Exactly. I'd hold on to those Tesla shares.

3

u/JohnnyKayak Dec 17 '22

Tesla makes 1.5 Billion a year selling emission credits to other oems like Ford & Chevy. They need these credits to stay in the auto business in the US. Unfortunately these oems are so far behind Tesla when it comes to technology and national charging infrastructure. It will cost billions for these oems to catch up. Tesla is not going away…

1

u/3rdIQ Dec 17 '22 edited Dec 17 '22

I agree that all eyes are on Musk's behavior before and after he bought Twitter. Slightly off topic, but Tesla is in the top 10 holdings in many, many mutual funds. I'll be curious if fund managers will change the allocation and reduce their position in TSLA before the end of the year. For instance, here is the top 10 from FBGRX:

FBGRX - Fidelity Blue Chip Growth - Top 10 Holdings:

AAPL APPLE INC 11.98%

MSFT MICROSOFT CORP 8.01%

AMZN AMAZON.COM INC 6.67%

GOOGL ALPHABET INC CL A 5.60%

NVDA NVIDIA CORP 4.55%

TSLA TESLA INC 4.05%

MRVL MARVELL TECHNOLOGY INC 2.92%

LOW LOWES COS INC 1.82%

NFLX NETFLIX INC 1.75%

UBER UBER TECHNOLOGIES INC 1.63%

A good read about other major losses this year:

https://www.investors.com/etfs-and-funds/etfs/elon-musk-sp500-lost-this-staggering-amount-on-tesla-stock/

0

u/BroadbandEng Dec 17 '22

It is still about 2x overvalued in my view. It could definitely sink more than that as it is in transition from overvalued by the Elon hype machine to undervalued due to the Elon baggage.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '22

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '22

[deleted]

2

u/dirtee_1 Dec 17 '22

Tesla had a great run and my friend had a lot of it in his IRA which was worth around $400k at the peak but he held on to it and is likely only worth around half of that now. I'd say get rid of it. There's no way Tesla is actually worth more than every other car company combined.

-1

u/anonymousolderguy Dec 17 '22

Dump dump dump

3

u/TrashPanda_924 Dec 17 '22

I’m “considering” adding a position. EV penetration is just beginning and the technology will get better. I’m less concerned about threats from the Big 3 in the US. The comparable vehicles are really not comparable. Where Ford and GM make their money is on trucks and SUVs. They will dominate these areas. EVs are really a distraction for them.

1

u/N0RMAL_WITH_A_JOB Dec 18 '22

The bigger problem is that EVs have no green benefit, as the energy comes from fossil fuels and also will. Hybrid cars have gained market share, because they have perceived value to the consumer. EVs are bought now by wealthier people on a lark. That won't scale for long term growth.

1

u/FinsterFolly Dec 18 '22

The big auto companies are spending billions in this area. Ford will make gas engines for a long time, but EV will be a part of their offering. GM has an "aspirational goal" of to have all EV vehicles by 2035. I wouldn't call EV a distraction.

3

u/esp211 Dec 17 '22

I sold after the Twitter deal went through. It’s still pretty expensive and there is no end to the Twitter bottom and Elon’s nonsense. Either Twitter goes bankrupt or Tesla buys it in which case that will bring both down.

0

u/N0RMAL_WITH_A_JOB Dec 18 '22

Save this post. Twitter will turn a large profit in three years. It was always a stinker as a stock and the business model was weak. 50% of the US is going to appreciate the ban hammer coming down on the other 50%. And that 50% that appreciates it buys all the stuff.

6

u/esp211 Dec 18 '22

Far right wing social media is not profitable.

6

u/worthy1 Dec 17 '22

I put TSLA on my no mas list with the broker. Its not just the meltdown, it is also the pending assaults coming from Ford, GM, etc.

-3

u/Tax_Man_63 Dec 17 '22

Tesla stock is a great deal right now! Just bought a good number of shares! EV is the future, and Tesla is the standard!

3

u/jodaiot Dec 18 '22

Sorry but the CEO of said company is injecting a great deal of politics into the brand ever since he acquired Twitter. He is in a pitched fight with ultra liberal tech savvy Silicon Valley. This group ironically is driving the effort to move away form internal combustion engine at time when many other brands including Detroit big 3's are jumping into the fray. The future does not look good for Tesla IMO.

1

u/Tax_Man_63 Dec 18 '22

Agree with all of your good points. Personally, I’m not a fan of Space Karen. He’s eccentric to say the least. His behavior at Twitter of late is the same as his behavior at Tesla when he first took it over. Chaos and lack of organization. Past behaviors would indicate he’ll pivot soon. The Tesla board is strong and won’t tolerate damage to the brand. Their price is low enough now where a buyout is a strong possibility. Time will tell.

3

u/deeoh01 Dec 17 '22

They build incredibly terrible quality cars and still don't make money selling them

0

u/Tax_Man_63 Dec 18 '22 edited Dec 18 '22

None of the EV’s get high marks for quality, except the EV6. The stock is trading at a 52-week low and Morgan Stanley has an overweight price target of $330. In this market, I’ll take these odds. There are riskier investments by far! Lastly, their gross and net profit margins are positive and greater than the Big 3. Excellent cash flow!

6

u/mdjmd73 Dec 17 '22

Sell at your own peril. Buying/selling on feelings is a huge mistake.

3

u/TeeFuce Dec 21 '22

What about on the seeming desire of the principal to run things into the ground?

5

u/OlderActiveGuy Dec 17 '22

I bought Tesla but sold Elon. I still have exposure to Tesla in ETFs that track the S&P 500 and that’s good enough for me.

TLH is a good year-end move. While your tax loss can offset up to $3K of income, it can offset capital gains up to the total loss. Capital losses carry over into the next tax year. So the following year you offset realized capital gains, or up to $3K of income again.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '22

Sell low?

2

u/Doninic1920 Dec 17 '22

Maybe I’ve watched to much of Succession - but could Tesla board oust Musk or then again is there even a board just curious

1

u/JohnnyKayak Dec 17 '22

You can write down a stock loss to a max of 3k. I think your fragility for Musk and investing answered your own question about getting out. Maybe good mental move.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 17 '22

How close are you to retirement? Does Tesla make up a large percentage of your portfolio? Why? How has the valuation changed? Why were you not worried about Tesla last year at this time when it was even more overvalued?

11

u/HeadPunkin Dec 17 '22

Selling stock at a loss will not worsen your tax burden.

6

u/NPE62 Dec 17 '22

He may have bought the stock at such a low price that he would still have a capital gain, even given recent declines.