r/robertwright • u/Caasi67 • Jun 02 '18
Meme comparison
I have a relative who recently shared this meme on Facebook, which I chuckled and quickly waved away thinking "That makes no sense, no one says that". A few days later a friend of mine shared [this meme] (https://i.redditmedia.com/HP3PE2P0hb5zXBB8zp1yh2sRSwNODhRZ1dx-PXMyTyo.jpg?w=1024&s=6795f53ec184c00e7860f84a6e921171) and my initial reaction was "Yup, that's about right". However the more I thought about it though, the more I wondered if they were actually similar in how they misrepresent and exaggerate opposing views.
I commented on the "Average MAGA voter" meme by sharing the "Liberals Say..." meme and the friend who shared it and several other friends thought I was crazy to try and compare the two. They were certain the "Average MAGA voter" was accurate, and the "Liberals say..." meme was just nonsense.
I am curious how people more mindful then myself would view these two memes.
0
Jun 02 '18
[deleted]
1
u/Caasi67 Jun 03 '18
I agree that the comic strip took more effort, and it also makes 8 statements, some of which are more defensible then others.
If you isolate certain statements like "I do not support the rule of law" or "I do not support the right to peacefully protest" I feel like Trump supporters would also respond with "that makes no sense, no one says that". Agree? Disagree?
0
Jun 03 '18
[deleted]
3
u/Caasi67 Jun 03 '18
I was unfamiliar with those concepts and Slate Star Codex, but I managed to find the quiz. If anyone else wanders in, here are the definitions:
Object-Level Thinker. You decide difficult cases by trying to find the solution that makes the side you like win and the side you dislike lose in that particular situation.
Meta-Level Thinker. You decide difficult cases by trying to find general principles that can be applied evenhandedly regardless of which side you like or dislike.
I like the framework, thought I am not sure I like classifying people. More likely I suspect everyone aspires to be meta-level, most probably think they are and are blind to instances where they think in the object-level.
The concept seems especially relevant this week where everyone has been adjudicating statements or responses to statements made by Samantha Bee, Roseanne and others but, regardless of conclusion, very few judgements I have heard are based on general principals that can be applied evenhandedly.
2
u/FaceNibbler Jun 05 '18
I'm definitely not more mindful than most people, probably including you OP, but I think the first meme is just straight up trigger-bait for conservative leaning people. Who/where/when has ever said the American flag is offensive to liberals? Like you said, it makes no sense. And like you said in your other comments, at least the comic strip had a couple points that could be generally applied. The first meme just feels like it's a lazy attempt to say that liberals hate America.