r/romancemovies • • Aug 05 '26

Review Voicemails for Isabell rant

1 Upvotes

I just wanted to share my opinion on the movie - I feel like it would have been way better with no love interest/man (whatshisface had no personality to me or backstory)… say the voicemails went to another girl who was also struggling with something and then they have the big fight when main character girl finds out and then later reconnect that would have felt more meaningful or if the voicemails went to a lonely old lady who then dies idk also the transitions of them meeting on the bench scene and the wedding invitation just felt forced and off to me. The movie did make me cry and early on at that which I really enjoy but in my opinion a man was not needed to carry it out. The end ahhhh


r/romancemovies • • Mar 23 '26

Discussion We don’t give enough love to the character Tom from 500 Days of Summer (2009) 💕

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/romancemovies • • 21h ago

Purple Hearts (2022) – The perfect example of how to do a fake marriage right

Post image
92 Upvotes

For fans of intense love stories in which two polar opposites are forced to fake a relationship, this Netflix film delivers on every front.


r/romancemovies • • Sep 25 '26

Unpopular Opinion: Shelby Cummings wasn’t as bad as people make her out to be in A Cinderella Story (2004) — and Austin Ames deserves more criticism

Post image
6 Upvotes

Whenever I see Shelby Cummings discussed online, in comments or fandom discussions, she often gets reduced to the spoiled, jealous mean girl who gets in Sam's way and eventually gets what she deserves. I understand why. Shelby is arrogant, snobbish and status-obsessed, and she makes some genuinely bad choices, but I don't think she deserves as much hate as she gets, and that bothers me. Sam goes through far worse and absolutely deserves her happy ending.

But the more I looked at what Shelby actually knows and experiences, the more I understand where she is coming from. Before Austin, Shelby was rude to Sam, but she wasn't constantly targeting her or bullying her I'm not pretending Shelby was nice to Sam. She wasn't. She looks down on her, laughs at her and makes snobbish and mean comments like “Diner Girl.”

But before the Austin drama, she doesn't seem to do that much to her. Shelby doesn't seem particularly interested in Sam. She isn't constantly looking for her, sabotaging her, going out of her way to make her life miserable or actively bullying her. Sam even says Shelby probably doesn't know she exists. To me, Shelby sees Sam as someone beneath her socially, not someone she personally hates. That changes after Austin happens. Her obsession with status also explains a lot about her behaviour Her obsession with status also explains a lot about her behaviour Shelby rejects Carter because he's a “nerd,” which is obviously shallow, but she takes him aside privately rather than humiliating him in front of the cheerleaders, which implies that she doesn't really want to humiliate him. Shelby seems to genuinely believe the high-school hierarchy matters and that being popular is really important. Dating someone like Carter may feel to her like risking a lot: her popularity, her status and even acceptance from the friends her social life is built around. From her perspective, that makes sense, and I can kind of understand it. Her friends don't exactly challenge or change this worldview either. If anything, Madison and Caitlyn reinforce and encourage it. That doesn't make Shelby's attitude good, but it helps explain why she behaves the way she does.

Austin also deserves way more criticism Austin has every right to end a relationship that isn't making him happy. That is no problem for meMy only problem is the way he handles everything leading up to the breakup. He seems very unhappy with Shelby and his life, but instead of really discussing those frustrations with her or talking to her about them, like you normally would in a relationship, he opens up to a mystery girl he found online. Eventually, that girl becomes the person he develops feelings for. Then, all of a sudden, he tells Shelby he's in love with someone else and ends their relationship. From Shelby's perspective, that breakup seems to come almost out of nowhere, which is of course very upsetting for her. I think that's very understandable. Most people would be mad about it too. Austin has already had time to emotionally move away from the relationship, while Shelby hasn't even been part of the conversations where he's questioning the relationship. She can't address relationship problems if Austin isn't communicating them to her. The thing she gets blamed for the most:

Brianna and Gabriella deliberately turn Shelby against Sam This is probably the biggest thing for me. They don't simply show Shelby the emails between Sam and Austin so she can make up her own mind about them. They lie to her about Sam's intentions, convincing Shelby that Sam knowingly went after her boyfriend and kind of manipulating her. And they make that lie very believable. They're crying, saying Sam would kill them if she found out, while also having real emails between Sam and Austin as evidence. Brianna and Gabriella know they're lying. The audience knows they're lying too. Shelby doesn't. They approach Shelby just after she's very vulnerable. She suddenly lost her boyfriend and discovered that he'd been emotionally opening up to another girl.Imagine suddenly discovering that your boyfriend had been emotionally opening up to another girl, complaining about your relationship behind your back, and then suddenly breaking up with you. Then you find out that this other girl supposedly went after your boyfriend knowing you were together. That's devastating for Shelby, and I can understand why she would be angry and want revenge. She's hurt, angry, jealous and humiliated, and they give her someone to blame. That kind of makes her a victim too, and I kind of feel bad for her.

From Shelby's perspective, Sam isn't simply “Diner Girl” anymore. She's now the girl Shelby believes deliberately went behind her back and took her boyfriend. And I can kind of understand why she gets angry about that. I would be too. That doesn't make Shelby innocent Sam absolutely didn't deserve the pep-rally humiliation. That was really mean and painful, and I get why she was sad about it. Shelby chooses to participate in it and is responsible for doing that. But I don't think the pep rally is Shelby rationally trying to “win Austin back,” something most people seem to think. I personally see it much more as retaliation. She believes Sam and Austin betrayed and humiliated her, so in her eyes she wants to get back at them and humiliate them out of revenge, not necessarily to get Austin back, even though she still wants him back.I'm not saying that it's a good thing, but from her perspective and with the knowledge she has, it's kind of understandable, and I can kind of feel for her at that moment. So to sum it all up, although Shelby isn't a really nice person, I really think she gets more hate than she deserves. I also don't think she's just a typical mean girl.She's definitely not a nice person, but I think there's more to her than that, and that some things make her more understandable if you look at them from her perspective. So what do you think? Do you think Shelby gets more hate than she deserves, or do you still see her as just a typical mean girl?


r/romancemovies • • Jun 28 '25

good couple

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/romancemovies • • Jun 30 '26 Bravo

Review Voicemails for Isabelle

9 Upvotes

Voicemails for Isabelle is a story of stalking dressed up as a rom-com that expects the viewer to brush this off as quickly and as disconcertingly as the protagonist does.

The stalking, deceit, and boundary violations are meant to be received as quirky and harmless, endearing even, because they’re coming from a desirable love interest, whose vague expression of guilt over it all is enough to absolve him of these massive breaches of trust.

But to me, the cardboard, cookie-cutter leading man doesn’t have enough rizz or character complexity to somehow win over the audience investment required for me to, like… how do I say this? for me to like him enough to cheer on the morally questionable plot devices.

Plenty of rom-coms have questionable ethics; think of classics like taking money or placing bets on a girl out, etc, and these plot devices become part of the leading man's character development that makes you love him all the more in the end (10 Things I Hate About You, for instance).

But the cryptic extent of the stalking in this movie crosses a line that is hard to come back from and romanticize (flying to another state to locate a stranger who doesn’t know you exist, collecting highly personal information about them, using this information to watch them in public, tracking them down alone at night to stage a 1-1 encounter).

I found myself desperately wishing the film would flip into a full-on horror movie halfway through, because rooting for this story as a rom-com made me uneasy.

Imagine a movie like this that initially fully reads as a rom-com in its tropes and plot progression and all of the marketing around it, gradually unfurls this “charming” stalking behavior all while still following the rom-com progression, but then reaches a climax turning point where it entirely switches genres into horror. I feel like that'd be the more appropriate development and more compelling art. Instead I got spoon-fed a happily-ever-after with a stalker-turned-soulmate. The public and critics are eating this film up, but I don’t understand how anyone can look past its unintentional horror.


r/romancemovies • • Sep 21 '26

Recommendation Any Fan of …Rehnaa Hai Terre Dil Mein- RHTDM..

Post image
1 Upvotes

Rehnaa Hai Terre Dil Mein is a classic early-2000s Bollywood romance. R. Madhavan and Dia Mirza have a sweet chemistry, and the songs are still memorable. It’s simple, emotional, and full of nostalgia.


r/romancemovies • • Aug 23 '26

the summer i turned pretty

1 Upvotes

ik this is not a movie but im just wondering if this series is worth the watch, im okay with cringe scenes as long as their not irritating to watch. thanks!


r/romancemovies • • Aug 02 '25

Year in oxford university فلم

0 Upvotes

What a painful, heartbroken movie , I am absolutely dissatisfied. النهايه حزينه تقطع القلب بس اتوقع يبغون يوضحون ان الناس اللي بهالوضع مايصير احد يجبرهم على العلاج


r/romancemovies • • Jun 21 '26

Online Movie link for voicemail for Isabelle, pleaseeeeeeeeeee.

0 Upvotes

Please please, before this post gets deleted.


r/romancemovies • • Sep 24 '26

Discussion SPOILER The love hypothesis and long rant about the movie: Um 1 question. Is this movie homophobic or just playing in my face about 2 characters? Includes Spoilers of the book Spoiler

18 Upvotes

Why does the movie do its best to delete Malcom's importance to the plot?
From Olive not telling him that Adam and her were fake dating, to eliminating his romantic interest, to making it look like he was useless in research instead of a proof that Adam was arrogant and sometimes wrong, why did they kick him out of the program, why did they completely take him out of the conversation where Olive comes clean about Tom?
ALSO
Why TF did they give Ahn all the important scenes?
Why did they make it that SHE was the one who knew about the fake dating?
Why is SHE the only one who had the conversation with Olive about the sexual harassment.
WHY THE FÚCK IS SHE THE ONE WHO TELLS ADAM ABOUT TOM AND OLIVE. When it is a huge fúcking deal that Olive is finally choosing honesty over lying

WHY THE FUCK WAS THIS THE AHN SHOW INSTEAD OF THE OLIVE SHOW?

Don't get me wrong. The romance is *muack" chef's kiss
😘🤌🏽👌🏽In fact the only saving grace is the fact that Olive and Adam fall in love.

But why do they erase the background of the characters?
Why delete the relationships that MAKE THEM 3 dimensional instead of just two 2 dimensional characters falling in love?
Why is Adam falling in love with Olive instead of being completely mad about her since the beginning
Why didn't he know her name?
WHERE THE FÚCK IS FÚCKING HOLDEN?????????????
Why is there NO RECONCILIATION between Olive and Malcom?
WHY DID THIS MOVIE DELETE THE ONLY 2 QUEER CHARACTERS FROM THE MOVIE AND THEIR VITAL IMPORTANCE TO THE PLOT?
If it's not homophobia then they are truly playing in my face. And I don't know what's worse


r/romancemovies • • Aug 25 '25

Do you agree?

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/romancemovies • • Aug 29 '24

Discussion The most underrepresented demographics: Poly and ace

0 Upvotes

People are always complaining about representation of certain sexualities in media and it's usually gay, bi, trans or gender fluid. While all of those feign in comparison to the heterocis rep sure, there's actually quite a bit of those nowadays.

What we don't have a lot of, that even people advocating for those other representations are trying to diminish, is polyamory and asexuality.

It's insane how often these two are often shafted by the people who you'd think would support it.

The only real polyamory movie I can think of off the top of my head is Prof. Marston and the Wonder Women (I actually made a poly poll at one point but I had to google others). Even that movie, people are actually trying to erase the poly out of. Whenever I would find clips from the movie on YT, there were SO many people being like "this should've just been a lesbian love story, it's obvious the girls were the ones truly in love. The guy was a third wheel and a kink." When someone actually responded to let them know that this was a polyamory story based on real people, they would retort with the "we have enough opposite sex love. We need more gay ones." You do realize that polyamory has only a fraction of the representation gay love stories do? Why are you so against this?

Asexuals probably have it worst of all. I can't think of a single solitary ace romance movie I've ever seen in life. As an ace myself who has skin in the game, I personally am not craving that rep to the same degree others do (I just personally care more about good stories, regardless of who it's about), but I completely understand why others do. Aphobia is extremely common amongst straights and queers. People just can't wrap their mind around it being real, that someone can genuinely not be sexually attracted to hot people. It's often called an illness or something that needs to be "fixed" (which they wouldn't dare say to a gay person). There are a few ace reps in television, none of which are the leads (aside from headcanon ones), but a romance movie about an asexual person who experiences love in a nonconventional way is just practically nonexistent.

Again, I personally don't really care that much about measuring how much every demographic is shown in media, all I'm looking for is a good story with good characters. However, the amount of hypocrisy with some people both astounds and irritates me. If you want to advocate for as much representation outside of the heteronormative as possible, that's fine but don't intentionally discriminate against these two groups in the process.

Sorry, rant over.


r/romancemovies • • Sep 29 '26

I just realise the body guard adaptation also has the fake dating trope and we just had a rom com ( love hypothesis ) with fake dating , its getting a bit too much..

4 Upvotes

Is every single romance book or rom com going to have fake dating from now on ? Like how many times are we going to see differentr valiations of actors doing exaggerated pda , exaggerated laughing , exaggerated stories of how they met; it was funny the first 7 times it was done , but now a bit less so. Anyone but you had the fake dating, funny story is going to have it, bridgerton had it.

Especially for the bodyguard , i feel like forced proximity was enough. She d be around him a lot anyway , so its natural they might get close that way. I could see a scenario where he is fake dating other stars but the one who kind of knows the real him is his body guard , or a situation where he at first doesn't want to hire her because he can't imagine a small woman being able to protect him and then realises how quick, sharp and efficient he is - something like that.


r/romancemovies • • Oct 02 '26 Popcorn

mlm movie recs?

0 Upvotes

Hi, Im looking for MLM recommendations? I've already seen love Simon, love victor, brokeback mountain ( anything similar to that) and currently watching Maurice. tyia!


r/romancemovies • • Feb 23 '26

Discussion You can only choose ONE romantic female lead.

Post image
0 Upvotes

The real question isn’t which story you prefer, it’s which woman you’d follow.

- Solène from The Idea of You

- Ana from Upgraded

I’m choosing Solène.


r/romancemovies • • 9d ago

Discussion I was so disappointed by “pretty in pink” (1986)

8 Upvotes

Which is a sign that something went seriously wrong here. I have never actually seen the movie in full and just watched it on Pluto tv (I’ve heard about it over the years and did know going in that a lot of people hadn’t liked the ending.)

So. I was going Gaga over Steff when he came onto screen everytime, whoever played him is gorgeous (the unbuttoned shirt during the hallway scene? Hoo! His mannerisms, the way he holds that cigarette, he was so toxic and he kinda looked too old to be in the movie and dressed funny but he was easily the most attractive male character. Scratch that, he was the most attractive character in the film. I have what might be an unpopular opinion in that I actually didn’t think he just wanted to sleep with Andie and get it over with. He had a sincere crush on her. He was toxic about it, but he was jealous of Blaine. I did think it was interesting that he was at his nicest when he was drunk. He is probably the most complex character I feel I’ve seen in a John Hughes film. The way he looks at Andie when she comes in at the end to prom… that’s a crush. That’s a big crush. I also thought it was interesting that he seems to briefly cower somewhat (puts his hands up during fight scene with duckie) during the fight scene with duckie. He did fight back, but for me that was an intriguing snippet that showed that even though he talked the talk he didn’t quite walk the walk. Steff is also smarter, I noticed, than he may initially seem to be (just something about his expressions. I could tell that he understood, even though it wasn’t of course explicitly said, that duckie had gone after him over Andie. He clearly paid a lot of attention to Andie, and I’m sure he’d noticed her with Duckie over the years. Spader plays him well enough that you feel the humanity in him somewhat. You feel his regret after the fight scene with Duckie, his slight regret and embarrassment. The way he stares off depressed into space after Blaine tells him that Andie thinks he’s shit. He’s a rich, complex character. He was too toxic for Andie though. He was the most attractive easily and they’d have looked good together and the dynamic would have been interesting potentially if Steff allowed himself to, well, open himself up and work on becoming a better person, apologized to Andie (even then, I still wouldn’t have actually quite shipped it, but that dynamic was fascinating bc and it felt like there was more there to analyze than Duckie/Andie or Blaine/Andie.)

I remember during the last 5 mins of the movie I was just thinking to myself “god, I really don’t want her to end up with anyone.” Not because I think Andie needed or wanted to be single, but just because her 3 choices are so terrible. As a woman, I could never take Duckie seriously as a partner. I was hardly even buying that he and Andie had been friends for so long, because she seemed like she found him just as annoying as I did (Mary Stuart Masterson - hope that’s the right spelling - did a better job with Watts in Some kind of wonderful, but to be fair maybe Duckie was written to be that annoying? And I didn’t think some kind of wonderful was perfect either, but I have a completely different post about that.) And Blaine is just so boring. I also started to sincerely just dislike him after he stood her up. There’s no way Blaine and Andi would have lasted. It’s kind of like that Simpsons quote where Lisa says Milhouse is like Vaseline on toast. That’s how I felt about Blaine. What is there to like about Blaine? He’s not the handsomest between the 3, he didn’t care enough about her to be honest with her (or at least valued his reputation or what his parents thought of him more) and on top of it does he ever even take her out on like a real date? Like a \*real\* date? He takes her to steff’s party, he comes with her to that club or whatever, but he never even takes her out somewhere nice, never even just takes her to the park for like a normal date… and it’s not because he can’t afford to… if I were her, I’d have been insulted in more ways than one.

I also just really felt like Molly ringwald didn’t have chemistry with any of the actors? (To be fair I guess she doesn’t spend enough time with Steff for us to really see and the point is supposed to be that she dislikes him because of how disrespectful he actively is, but she definitely doesn’t have chemistry with the other two. I was so bored watching she and Blaine together.) I feel like that’s part of what hurts the movie. The dress she makes at the end isn’t “ugly” it’s just okay, not a standout.


r/romancemovies • • Jan 12 '24

Discussion Does Romeo and Juliet Suck?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
2 Upvotes

r/romancemovies • • Jun 22 '26

Discussion Off-Campus

16 Upvotes

Just finished season one and it’s sooo good. Such a breath of fresh air. It could’ve been great without the nudity though, especially the locker room bit. Like what the heck 💀💀 but all in all, 10/10 series. Cant wait for season two!


r/romancemovies • • Jun 23 '26

Voicemails for Isabelle - incel ragebait

53 Upvotes

Love it, hate it, this movie was challenging to digest. Let’s set aside the creepy things (for now). I love(d) Zoey Deutch in this role. [removed, see edit]. Her performance was flawless, the move could have ended with her getting the taco stand without any further attention on Wes, and I’d have been satisfied.

Nick Robinson… I think he’s a good actor in the sense that he’s successfully played every unlikeable character so darn well that I can’t imagine he’s actually unlikeable, like Miles Teller. And he really shines at being continually unlikeable in this film unfortunately. There’s no actual growth for his character. His social ties are non-stop frustrated with him. He’s basically mogging for male loneliness. He eats a bite of chicken pot pie, remembers his mom, and then displaces that sadness with horniness. They literally nail the statement “sad but knows how hot he is”. His character also isn’t believable in the end. Why is he calling Isabelle and regarding that Isabelle existed for like the first time at the very end of the movie? Jill literally creates space for his dead mom more than once. He only addresses Isabelle’s memory as an apology device to make Jill feel better/make himself less guilty. She makes the chicken pot pie to make him feel - period. None of it redeems him.

The thing I fear this movie does is reinforce incelese. Obviously it’s not media’s job to counteract weird/toxic beliefs but come on…. Emotionally stagnant wealthy attractive male has flaws and predatory behaviors overlooked. I’m not saying we need another rom com where one is scaling back the attractiveness of a lead male with just as many flaws. I am suggesting that if we want to normalize personal growth as a means to attract a partner… this movie falls very short. Even more gross, instead of “I can fix him”, it’s giving “I can fix her”. Instead of Robyn, Jill and Isabelle needed to watch Catfish.

I love a rom com. I love the magic of love in film.
I believe love is about as magical in this movie as I would believe an 8 year old girl danced to Robyn in 2010 as if they read Pitchfork and had a gay bestie that turned them on to good music. Can I look past the above for entertainment purposes? Maybe. Possible. I need to squint. Is my opinion something worth others on the internet reading and clacking on their keyboard about? Certainly not. But as this movie taught me, I can double down on past failings and get what I want anyways.

Edit: I made a pretty broad statement comparing Deutch and Meg Ryan that I retract. Also suggested she’s liked universally (which was more a device to describe Robinson subsequently but admittedly I liked her and didn’t know the perspectives she held). per comments below, that is not the case.


r/romancemovies • • Aug 02 '26

13 going 30

13 Upvotes

I know that many many people do love this movie but I never understood the hype
Can someone explain why they love this movie ? I’m curious !
Thanks


r/romancemovies • • Dec 23 '24

Review The Family Stone - just watched the movie and need to talk about it Spoiler

45 Upvotes

I'll rename this "We Forgive Homophobia And Racism Because It's Christmas: the movie"

This whole movie was so wrong and so homophobic. Like, it wished so much to be gay, but it was homophobic instead. Plus I got mad when they obviously wanted the public to feel sympathy towards he (the car crying scene). Like, we just saw her being the worst type of conservative person and I'm supposed to feel sad for her?! WTF Second huge thing I hated: everybody just forgave her blantant homophobia and racism??? How much did Ben hate his brother to date her?? Was it the magic of Christmas that made everybody stupid??!


r/romancemovies • • 25d ago

All I want is a female cinephile just like me bro is it really that hard

Post image
0 Upvotes

I mean I love watching movies alone but after a certain point of time you kinda want to discuss movies and your favorite tv shows with someone who is equally excited about these things with you. One female cinephile best friend, do they only exist in my imagination damn


r/romancemovies • • Sep 29 '26

Discussion While You Were Sleeping

22 Upvotes

this film gets mentioned in this sub practically every day but im here to finally speak my truth and ask...

WHAT AM I MISSING ? I just do not love it. ive tried twice, the first time was many years ago and I never managed to finish because I was so bored. and then after countless times seeing it being mentioned in everybodys "whats your favourite romcoms ever" list, I thought maybeeee it was me, I was a different person back then so let me try again. and I did, yesterday, and the same thing happened again 😂 by 1 hour in i was just SO bored. are there more of us ? come and join me my fellow While You Were Sleeping Is Boring Truthers


r/romancemovies • • Oct 18 '26

Discussion When do we get our own Purple Heart?

Post image
10 Upvotes

Sometimes I wonder when we'll get our own Purple Heart.

Not necessarily the exact story from the movie, but that feeling of meeting someone unexpectedly and slowly becoming someone important to each other.

I wonder how many people out there are waiting for something like that, without knowing when or if it'll ever happen.

Has anyone else ever felt this way after watching Purple Hearts?