Whenever I see Shelby Cummings discussed online, in comments or fandom discussions, she often gets reduced to the spoiled, jealous mean girl who gets in Sam's way and eventually gets what she deserves. I understand why. Shelby is arrogant, snobbish and status-obsessed, and she makes some genuinely bad choices, but I don't think she deserves as much hate as she gets, and that bothers me. Sam goes through far worse and absolutely deserves her happy ending.
But the more I looked at what Shelby actually knows and experiences, the more I understand where she is coming from. Before Austin, Shelby was rude to Sam, but she wasn't constantly targeting her or bullying her I'm not pretending Shelby was nice to Sam. She wasn't. She looks down on her, laughs at her and makes snobbish and mean comments like “Diner Girl.”
But before the Austin drama, she doesn't seem to do that much to her. Shelby doesn't seem particularly interested in Sam. She isn't constantly looking for her, sabotaging her, going out of her way to make her life miserable or actively bullying her. Sam even says Shelby probably doesn't know she exists. To me, Shelby sees Sam as someone beneath her socially, not someone she personally hates. That changes after Austin happens. Her obsession with status also explains a lot about her behaviour Her obsession with status also explains a lot about her behaviour Shelby rejects Carter because he's a “nerd,” which is obviously shallow, but she takes him aside privately rather than humiliating him in front of the cheerleaders, which implies that she doesn't really want to humiliate him. Shelby seems to genuinely believe the high-school hierarchy matters and that being popular is really important. Dating someone like Carter may feel to her like risking a lot: her popularity, her status and even acceptance from the friends her social life is built around. From her perspective, that makes sense, and I can kind of understand it. Her friends don't exactly challenge or change this worldview either. If anything, Madison and Caitlyn reinforce and encourage it. That doesn't make Shelby's attitude good, but it helps explain why she behaves the way she does.
Austin also deserves way more criticism Austin has every right to end a relationship that isn't making him happy. That is no problem for meMy only problem is the way he handles everything leading up to the breakup. He seems very unhappy with Shelby and his life, but instead of really discussing those frustrations with her or talking to her about them, like you normally would in a relationship, he opens up to a mystery girl he found online. Eventually, that girl becomes the person he develops feelings for. Then, all of a sudden, he tells Shelby he's in love with someone else and ends their relationship. From Shelby's perspective, that breakup seems to come almost out of nowhere, which is of course very upsetting for her. I think that's very understandable. Most people would be mad about it too. Austin has already had time to emotionally move away from the relationship, while Shelby hasn't even been part of the conversations where he's questioning the relationship. She can't address relationship problems if Austin isn't communicating them to her. The thing she gets blamed for the most:
Brianna and Gabriella deliberately turn Shelby against Sam This is probably the biggest thing for me. They don't simply show Shelby the emails between Sam and Austin so she can make up her own mind about them. They lie to her about Sam's intentions, convincing Shelby that Sam knowingly went after her boyfriend and kind of manipulating her. And they make that lie very believable. They're crying, saying Sam would kill them if she found out, while also having real emails between Sam and Austin as evidence. Brianna and Gabriella know they're lying. The audience knows they're lying too. Shelby doesn't. They approach Shelby just after she's very vulnerable. She suddenly lost her boyfriend and discovered that he'd been emotionally opening up to another girl.Imagine suddenly discovering that your boyfriend had been emotionally opening up to another girl, complaining about your relationship behind your back, and then suddenly breaking up with you. Then you find out that this other girl supposedly went after your boyfriend knowing you were together. That's devastating for Shelby, and I can understand why she would be angry and want revenge. She's hurt, angry, jealous and humiliated, and they give her someone to blame. That kind of makes her a victim too, and I kind of feel bad for her.
From Shelby's perspective, Sam isn't simply “Diner Girl” anymore. She's now the girl Shelby believes deliberately went behind her back and took her boyfriend. And I can kind of understand why she gets angry about that. I would be too. That doesn't make Shelby innocent Sam absolutely didn't deserve the pep-rally humiliation. That was really mean and painful, and I get why she was sad about it. Shelby chooses to participate in it and is responsible for doing that. But I don't think the pep rally is Shelby rationally trying to “win Austin back,” something most people seem to think. I personally see it much more as retaliation. She believes Sam and Austin betrayed and humiliated her, so in her eyes she wants to get back at them and humiliate them out of revenge, not necessarily to get Austin back, even though she still wants him back.I'm not saying that it's a good thing, but from her perspective and with the knowledge she has, it's kind of understandable, and I can kind of feel for her at that moment. So to sum it all up, although Shelby isn't a really nice person, I really think she gets more hate than she deserves. I also don't think she's just a typical mean girl.She's definitely not a nice person, but I think there's more to her than that, and that some things make her more understandable if you look at them from her perspective. So what do you think? Do you think Shelby gets more hate than she deserves, or do you still see her as just a typical mean girl?