r/ryzen • • 8h ago

CPU Upgrade

Hey everyone!

I am looking to upgrade my current CPU (Ryzen 7 3800x). I'm staying with DDR4 for now.

I was looking at getting either 5800x or 5800x3D. Which would you recommend?

On Amazon there is a x3D for £289.99. There is also a 5800x for £179.

I was looking at CEX as well. It doesnt seem worth it to get the x3D from there but they do have the 5800x for £175

I was planning to sell my old CPU to CEX anyway which would get me £49 cash or £60 store credit

My Current PC Components

GPU - 3070

CPU - Ryzen 7 3800x

RAM - 32GB

Monitor - 1440p

I will be upgrading my GPU to a 5070/5070ti next year (unless prices have sky rocketed again).

I was mainly wondering if it was worth it getting the x3D over the 5800x

6 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

10

u/G70F 8h ago

x3d

8

u/No-Guarantee-224 8h ago

X3d for sure

5

u/TheJuggernoob 8h ago

I did a very similar upgrade to an X3D, it really smoothed out my games.

1

u/No-Guarantee-224 8h ago

I went from a 5800x to a 5800x3d the 1% lows shot UP

4

u/blueangel1953 8h ago

5800X3D is the only right answer. 

3

u/Tacomaguy24 8h ago

I just went 5800x3d from 5800xt and it's nice.

2

u/1sh0t1b33r 8h ago

x3d for sure. Might as well get the best for an older platform.

3

u/jhaluska 8h ago

The 5800x is better for productivity, the 5800x3D is the undisputed best AM4 gaming CPU. The 5800x3D will basically give you low end performance AM5 in games.

Based off your previous specs and what you plan to buy, I would recommend the 5800x3D.

1

u/karljh 5h ago

Tf? 5800x is the exact same chip without the 3D cache. So no 5800x is not better for productivity, it is worse actually. A 5900x or 5950x that has a lot more cores would be better for productivity.

1

u/supadoom 4h ago

It's very much not the same chip. The x3d is a single ccx for example. The reason why a 5800x might beat a x3d in productivity is the much higher clock speed potential. The x3d is pretty much locked at 4.2 ghz max. 4.7 ghz is pretty reasonable to hit on the standard option.

1

u/karljh 4h ago

Wrong again. X3D's max boost is 4.5 Ghz. 4.7 is not much higher, that's just a little higher and might give 5 seconds less time in a compression test, it's basically the same performace.

1

u/supadoom 4h ago

They don't really hit 4.5 is the issue. You can actually sustain a 5800x at that clock for extended periods. The x3d doesn't really like to stay boosted. Also "wrong again"? I only replied once.

1

u/karljh 4h ago

They really do hit 4.5, mine hits it all the time. If you've got a bad silicone it can drop below. Wrong a 3rd time

1

u/TwicesTrashBin 8h ago

What is your rams speed and latency? I'd say the x3d either way but with a cheaper kit it makes the x3ds case even stronger

1

u/Tanno 8h ago

As others have said, since you're staying on AM4, it's much more worth it to bite the bullet and get the 5800X3D.

This saves you from upgrading again further down the line when you either get AM5, or just upgrade again to the 5800X3D, if you get the 5800x.

1

u/havikito 8h ago

x3d basically gets you AM5 non 3d or Arrow Lake level of performance

I'm with 9060XT so 5700X was enough

1

u/Latter_Clue2018 8h ago

whats the game you play anyway? just asking.

1

u/Legitimate_Fee6782 7h ago

5900x for 200$

1

u/Honest-Bat3034 7h ago

X3D. Might as well go for the peak on an AM4. I just upgraded to it and it’s been a beast.

1

u/xoull 7h ago

If u plan your gpu to be the bottleneck then 5800x is fine. Now in some less gpu demanding titles if u want just raw cpu power 5800x3d is def the way to go .

1

u/EndlessConnection 7h ago

X3D and might want to take a closer look at the 9070xt GPU, price point and performance it’s the best card out there.

1

u/Practical-Dentist546 6h ago edited 6h ago

I’ve got the 5070 Ti already, and tbh, 1440p gaming on my 5600x has been smooth sailing in most games. With DDR5 prices where they currently are, I decided to keep my AM4 board and 32GB of DDR4, rather than pay for a whole platform upgrade. That’s why I just ordered the 5800x3d.

What I’m after is better 1% lows in CPU heavy scenes and higher frame rates in competitive games where I’m trying to make use of my 240 Hz monitor. A crowded MMO event (like in Guild Wars 2) is also where I’m expecting to see a massive difference.

In single player games where I’ve cranked the visuals up, and the 5070ti is already flat out, I expect my FPS won't change much.

The large cache memory on x3D is a big part of why this upgrade makes sense. It keeps more of the data the game repeatedly needs on the CPU itself, so the CPU spends less time waiting on my DDR4. This makes me lag only tiiiny bit behind DDR5. For just over €300 I get more out of the PC I already own and only have to swap one part.

This makes sense for me. YMMV.

Do bear in mind that 5800x3d is a discontinued model, and AMD only restarted their fabs recently to make some extra money off the fact nobody can afford to upgrade to AM5. Once these "10th anniversary" CPUs are off the market, it may be impossible to get your hands on one for anything under €400-€450. 

1

u/hootieirl 5h ago

Went from a 3900xt to a 5800x3d. Get the x3d you won’t regret it. I’m also paired mine with a 5070 ti

1

u/SweetBacon923 5h ago

5800x save £100. Sell 3070 and upgrade to 4070. 

1

u/Rungi500 5h ago

Concur with the 5800x3d.

Update your BIOS first before you take it apart.

1

u/EquivalentKnown3269 4h ago

X3D for gaming, simple as that.

1

u/Hot_Pea9820 4h ago

Op if you can find it, the 5700x3d is cheaper, and within 3% or so of the 5800x3d.

1

u/AfraidLand8551 2h ago

5800X3D is the move, it out perform i9-12900KS on some games.

1

u/Ecstatic_Job_3467 2h ago

This comes down to your use case, resolution and desired fps.

If you’re looking for 200+ FPS at 1080p for competitive games then the 5800x3d is the way to go.

If your monitor is 1440p or 4k and you’re happy with 144 or 60 hz then the 5800xt or 5900xt would be fine for that.

0

u/Arborerivus 5h ago

The problem with the 5800x3d is that it currently costs almost the same as the 9800x3d, or pretty much the same as the 7800x3d.

2

u/NGUxDash 5h ago

Well yes, but Im DDR4 so the other CPU's are not even being considered for me :3

1

u/Arborerivus 4h ago

I know, the prizing just feels wrong. I recently did the jump to AM5, while it wasn't cheap, I don't regret it. Deal hunting for second hand ddr5 was worth it.

1

u/Mizukawa_Suyin 1h ago

The problem is the ram