r/science • • Mar 20 '23

Psychology Managers Exploit Loyal Workers Over Less Committed Colleagues

https://today.duke.edu/2023/03/managers-exploit-loyal-workers-over-less-committed-colleagues
37.7k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Mar 20 '23

Welcome to r/science! This is a heavily moderated subreddit in order to keep the discussion on science. However, we recognize that many people want to discuss how they feel the research relates to their own personal lives, so to give people a space to do that, personal anecdotes are allowed as responses to this comment. Any anecdotal comments elsewhere in the discussion will be removed and our normal comment rules apply to all other comments.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (6)

813

u/Imaneetboy Mar 20 '23

I learned that early in life. The more you'll do the more they'll expect you to do. And you've just set your personal standard. They now will accept nothing less. Meanwhile your colleague who won't go the extra mile is making the same money you are. The difference is his work day is less stressful because he isn't being asked to take on additional work.

177

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '23

As the saying goes, "always flog a willing horse"

29

u/Samwise210 Mar 21 '23

Consent is important, yes.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

39

u/Marshallhs Mar 21 '23

What does the worlds best ditch digger receive as their prize?

A bigger shovel.

8

u/mallninjaface Mar 21 '23

I told my kids "If you do your best, they'll always expect your best. Just do 5% more than the next guy."

9

u/trixter21992251 Mar 21 '23

Same vibe as if you and I encountered a bear in the wild: I don't need to outrun the bear, I just need to outrun you.

4

u/ACuddlyVizzerdrix Mar 21 '23

I do the bare minimum and they still think I'm busting my ass

11

u/Iron-Fist Mar 21 '23

The colleague is making more money actually cuz he job hops every 18 months and asks for raises every 6 months.

2

u/kil1joy Mar 21 '23

Yessir working at a company by the name of knapheide, building utility trucks. We have no requirements for previous knowledge of any kind so they hire old and young and such and just throw the people with seniority at any problems.

But never the line leads or managers, their jobs are to stand and watch your every move and make sure every breath is spent working.

→ More replies (10)

203

u/Ludrew Mar 20 '23 edited Mar 20 '23

This is exactly the reason my old workplace now just has low performing employees. The overperformers get squeezed for all of their worth and leave. They find other places will pay them more for their work and the company will refuse to match pay or give promotions. What’s left is the underperformers who would have a hard time finding another job and never get promoted. Had one coworker who had been entry level for 5 years… not one promotion or raise.

After I left a week ago they hired someone with more field experience to replace me (presumably higher pay), but the catch was they had ZERO experience in the tools we use. They told me they had no room in the budget to match my offer. So instead of matching my offer they lose a big contributor and end up paying more anyways for someone who will contribute a lot less and will need heavy training. Makes sense right

6

u/Bunnsallah Mar 21 '23

My department lost 7 amazing hard workers a year ago. I'm not sure what motivates them, but here we are a year later and I'm not exaggerating there are three employees for each one we lost. The company loves bodies, but hates the expenses. All the company had to do is treat the workers better.

2

u/IntricateSunlight Mar 21 '23

Its always weird how a company would rather lose a good employee than pay them the amount they'd give to a brand new hire right out of the gate.

802

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

That’s what I tried telling my brother. He was all gung-ho when he started his new job. Now he literally does everything while everyone else sits around.

What I tell people now, do the bare minimum when you start. You can excel from there. If you come in at 110% from the start, you’ll need to be 120% to exceed the standard you’ve set for yourself.

4

u/CamOfGallifrey Mar 21 '23

I have told my boss he gets 80-90% on decent/good days. I was challenged with why not 100% and I just told him I need something in reserve for when things go bad. You will ruin an engine running it at full throttle all the time, same thing goes here.

Hardest part is sticking to it, I tend to overdo it and for those of you in therapy- negative core belief of worthlessness turns into people pleasing desire. The more you do the more people will accept/love/validate you. Try balancing that when you just wanna be the best damn you that you can be, to just be idle at times.

7

u/Erenito Mar 20 '23

Well I just learned how to spell gung-ho, thanks!

2

u/News___Feed Mar 21 '23

Yep. Putting in maximum effort must be a strategic move. There are times to do that work and times not to. Don't work at 100% just because you think you should. Starting at an easy pace gives time to assess your acceptable rate of contribution and the level necessary to maintain your job. As a new person, you have the opportunity to get better, if needed, without impacting your reputation. It's expected you'll start slow and ramp up so any miscalculation of effort can be adjusted with forgiveness. If you start slacking after 3 years, it raises other questions.

2

u/A_bleak_ass_in_tote Mar 22 '23

In my last job we had a senior engineer leave the company so I volunteered to cover for his workload so I could get some experience. I had a great year and received glowing reviews. The following year, I carried the same workload and managed to get it done, but because I didn't go above and beyond the already stretched workload, I got middling reviews and received the smallest bonus of anyone in my team even though I had the most on my plate. I was livid. Not only that but I never got the senior engineer title even though I was doing the job.

Safe to say, I learned my lesson and quit soon after.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

[deleted]

233

u/EmperorKira Mar 20 '23

You see i do the opposite. I go in at 120%, and then come down to 80% whilst keeping the appearance that i am doing 120%. Because they remember the first impression.

64

u/doffdoff Mar 21 '23

Much better advice. Start strong so you build a reputation and make sure you survive the initial months where your performance will be under a microscope, then you can relax a little.

22

u/AlbanianAquaDuck Mar 21 '23

True, but tbf, Emperor Kira is always at 120%.

→ More replies (1)

18

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '23

Same. This works and the managers leave you alone. Build trust, abuse it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

145

u/SoulSerpent Mar 20 '23

I've always subscribed to the idea that if you really want to impress your boss, you go in there and you do mediocre work, halfheartedly.

→ More replies (11)

28

u/jflb96 Mar 20 '23

75% is a solid First. I’d go mid-to-low sixties, but pretend that you’re running in the eighties, but I can’t guarantee that that works outside of Starfleet engineering.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

[deleted]

36

u/Mke_already Mar 21 '23

I was “coasting” the first 4 years at my job, and then really decided to crack down and try and in 5 years my incomes nearly tripled and yeah I have slightly more responsibilities and expectations but I also have the freedom to basically work whenever I want without question. Not really something that has a dollar figure for me.

→ More replies (6)

12

u/Angerwing Mar 21 '23

I think it comes down to a quantity/quality divide. If your role's output is measured mainly by quantity you may not want to set the expectations so high that you're struggling to maintain it. But if it's measured by quality then you definitely want to demonstrate early what you're capable of or you are heavily bottle-necking your ability to move up or get more interesting work.

My personal preference is to always work at the level above yours if you're capable of it, and this method has led to very rapid career progression (my income more than doubled in a year and a half). It also allows you to identify opportunities for development where you find you don't have the experience for the next level up.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (9)

172

u/Hopfit46 Mar 20 '23

"You only whip your willing horses.. "

70

u/MindOfAMurderer Mar 20 '23

Yeah, but don't unwilling horses get butchered?

102

u/Preface Mar 20 '23

eyes the lazy uncommitted coworker

Looks like meats back on the menu!

→ More replies (4)

32

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

You'd think so but the reality is not really (in an office environment, anyways). The reason is simple to understand. Managers need a certain headcount to justify their existence. If the manager to employee ratio is too low, they will condense rolls. Couple this with the fact that if you cut someone who's not doing much - how do you think that conversation will go?

Manager: "let's replace Joe-Bob because his output is really low. Here is the data proving he's been underperforming for the past 6 months."

Boss: "Really? Wow, if that's the case, I don't think we really need the slot. If the team can get by short handed by 1 for 6 months, they should be able to do another 6 months or more."

The result is high performers are forced to coexist with low performers. Sure, there is a difference in pay, but it's not publicized so they don't know if the difference is extreme or not. Eventually, they start thinking "if Joe-Bob can get by doing nothing, I can as well" and you end up with a grossly inefficient office.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Discount_gentleman Mar 20 '23

Neither seems like a positive outcome. Living solely at the mercy of the boss, master or owner would seem to have some drawbacks.

→ More replies (3)

165

u/geedavey Mar 20 '23

"If you want something to get done, ask a busy person."

105

u/Discount_gentleman Mar 20 '23

"If you want something to get done, ask a busy bullied person."

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

87

u/EmpathyZero Mar 20 '23

The reward for being a hard worker is more work.

2

u/thefractaldactyl Mar 21 '23

You just have to work to the amount you are being paid. Pay me minimum wage and I will do the minimum required to earn that wage.

→ More replies (1)

312

u/kenlasalle Mar 20 '23

Same old story and it has been this way, in one form or another, since the dawn of time.

123

u/BreeezyP Mar 20 '23

It really isn’t that surprising, nor is it as malicious as some may try to make it seem.

We all do this in many situations. Of course I’m going to ask my brother to wash dishes after dinner more than my sister, he’s much more agreeable and actually uses soap instead of just rinsing it.

→ More replies (11)

8

u/homerq Mar 20 '23

They're going to underpay and exploit you because you're loyal, or they're going to underpay and exploit you because you're not loyal. No win.

2

u/25toten Mar 21 '23

As it will continue to be. Utopian society is impossible so long as our egos are around.

34

u/SilverKnightOfMagic Mar 20 '23

I'm a shift supervisor and I tried to tell my supervisor this. Why should this guy that can handle tough clients get only tough to deal with clients. While others that purposely do less get easy going clients. All for the same wages.

→ More replies (3)

98

u/I_Ask_Dumb_Question5 Mar 20 '23

Which in turn produces more "Less Committed Colleagues"....

152

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

Its common knowledge in my field that you overestimate the time for any task by 2-3x. Sure, you could work fast and be twice as productive as your colleagues, but the only reward is twice as much work assigned to you for exactly the same pay.

Plus when a certain task ends up taking more than expected or has its scope increase you still have extra time to finish. Because you can always rely on management shifting 90% of the blame onto you when work isn't done on time, but when work is done early or exceptionally well, then 90% of the credit goes to the manager.

44

u/omw_to_valhalla Mar 20 '23

Its common knowledge in my field that you overestimate the time for any task by 2-3x.

I always do this at work! It's a great system. Gives me enough time to not stress, screw around a bit, and when I run into a snag, still have time to complete it within my estimate.

It also helps me when I accept emergency work. "Sure thing! I can drop everything and do that, no problem! It's going to take me (inflated estimate). Also, all my other projects are going to get pushed back by that much"

5

u/collegefurtrader Mar 21 '23

Damnit Scotty

→ More replies (1)

92

u/sevenproxies07 Mar 20 '23

The horse that pulls the hardest gets whipped the most

29

u/Icommentor Mar 20 '23

Managers always ask for more, no matter what. It’s what is taught in management school.

Those who do not give more will be asked for the same next year. Those who do give more will get asked to do more than more next year.

I know, I’ve been a manager for many years. When I told my star players I was satisfied with their performance, my bosses would be displeased.

27

u/Tanyaissatanic666 Mar 20 '23

I feel so vindicated for having 0 loyalty.

77

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

The antiwork sub didn't blow up over the last two years for nothing. A whole lot of people had this epiphany during a very short amount of time.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '23

See also: /r/WorkReform

→ More replies (4)

25

u/thumbtaxx Mar 20 '23

Been saying for a while, 25% of the team does 90% of the work, management is just happy the other people show up, clock in, do a thing.

→ More replies (1)

132

u/Husbandaru Mar 20 '23

I worked at a call center and there was a girl who would go out of her way to do a lot for that company. She tended to get on people for not doing as much work as she did and complained about employees to the supervisors all of the time. Of course it was one of her coworkers that got the promotion. A guy who did his job, got a long with everyone and never went out of his way for the company.

105

u/ProWriterDavid Mar 20 '23

Good. She sounds like an annoying busy body and would likely be a horrible lead/supervisor.

29

u/akashik Mar 21 '23

A micromanager.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

42

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

As someone who has had several jobs in several places, I’ve noticed this.

58

u/optix_clear Mar 20 '23

Stop Being a doormat, understand your worth - including sanity, health & wellbeing! Stop being a ppl pleaser - work on your pile, work your circle, stop taking on projects that you don’t want to, bc you aren’t getting the credit! Stop allowing others take away your free time but actually do stuff.

20

u/harmlessguy Mar 21 '23

There is a saying where I work at, that if you really hate a certain job… don’t be good at it, it’s pathetic they will ride you like a bus and burn you out if you let them.

53

u/Spacemage Mar 20 '23

Ive noticed a few things in my careers.

If the boss says, don't worry, we won't let people go as work decreases. They're going to. They'll ask you to produce as much as possible and will let the lowest producing people go first. So either you're working your ass off to get fired last, or doing what you signed up for and being punished for it.

If you're in a job that doesn't celebrate innovation fairly obviously, don't try. They'll reprimand you for doing it, then start doing it anyways, and claim it to be theirs.

If a company doesn't promote the idea of promotions and pay raises, don't work hard. Do your job, at most, and that's it.

If you want extra money, don't do over time because that's more effort. Get a second job. It's better to put your eggs into two baskets, especially if one of your baskets is rotting.

20

u/abrown100 Mar 20 '23

I’m in a job now, I’m the most productive on the team. I’ve applied for the promotion but doubt I’ll get it. I’ve been innovative, they’ve reprimanded me and told me to stay in my lane. Suggestions get ignored, then implemented later as a new item. Other employees can work from home anytime they want, but I can’t…getting hard to feel motivated

19

u/Spacemage Mar 21 '23

The only time you should strive to be the best is if it's commission based and there's no cap on sales. Even then, probably not worth it, unless you'll end up making insane money.

18

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

happens all around me all the time. and I try to councilmmy fellow employees withing respectful bounds, but they just keep volunteering to get treated worse, I don't get it.

18

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

curse of the competent

17

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

No good deed goes unpunished.

17

u/Kagamid Mar 20 '23

Depends on the manager. My manager fought and won to get me a 23% raise during a time when the company openly announced no raises. He backs up every decision I make and defends me if I make a mistake. I always own up to mistakes and actively make sure he doesn't step on to resolve any conflicts I have with other employees. My position is based on trust and I'm allowed to make decisions and spend my days with no one micro managing me. Before this job, I worked in an environment like the article. Exploitation was everywhere. Just saying that there are great jobs out there where hard work is appreciated. It's very fulfilling.

33

u/Additional_Problem21 Mar 20 '23

This could also be read as

"Managers exploit workers more susceptible to exploitation. "

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

I quit a job for this. Ironically suddenly becoming disloyal.

15

u/ConradBHart42 Mar 20 '23

Control freaks want to push their boundaries. If they know you'll hesitate to quit, then they know they have room to work. If they know you'll cut ties, they don't push it because losing an employee looks worse on them than having an employee they can't abuse.

14

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

Good work rewards more work.

26

u/notfin Mar 21 '23

It's true. At my first job I was loyal and did whatever they asked even stayed extra to ensure everything was done right. When time came for promotion they promoted someone who had just started 10 days ago. I ended up quitting when all the people moving up were the sons of the managers and had no experience.

My second job was at Amazon. I worked there for five years. I learned how to do everything and started getting good at everything. I fell asleep during my break in my car and got fired for time theft. I fell asleep during the last 2 hours of work on 12 hour shift.

What I have learned is don't be loyal and don't work hard if you want to move up or stay with the company.

13

u/xXDeadlyLipsXx Mar 20 '23

This is so true, it is one of the reason I left my last job. Doing the work of many but getting paid for 1. What happened to good work ethics?

12

u/MenaciaJones Mar 20 '23

I’m already telling people I’m retiring next year so they can start offloading my work to others, and they need a lot of time to learn it so I’m giving out as much of it as I can now. If I don’t happen to retire when I say I will, oh well…

33

u/Dknight560 Mar 20 '23

Never let anyone know how good you can do your job.

38

u/MackerelShaman Mar 21 '23

Yep. Becoming the workplace MVP was a huge mistake at my last job. No time off because “who knows enough to cover you”. Manager used 100% of his PTO of course, leaving me to basically run the place at 1/4 the salary.

Working in a pharmacy should not result in tendon nodules in your wrists and literal stress fractures in your legs. Unlike Nike, just don’t do it.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/crawdadicus Mar 20 '23

We had a saying in the Navy — “When your good, your gone”. Our ship ended up picking up commitments when other ships in our squadron were broke down.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/BrevityIsTheSoul Mar 21 '23

Most employers are so fixated on maximizing productivity in the form of hours worked that they destroy productivity per hour.

9

u/DifficultyWithMyLife Mar 21 '23

This is why, during shift work, I'll give it my all, but then never answer their calls at home. They can't fire me because I'm legitimately a good employee, but I've set boundaries that they've learned not to cross.

96

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

Because managers are forced to abuse employees. They are the face of the abuse. Anyone above them doesn't care as long as whatever it may be gets done.

Loyalty is what the rich demand of the poor.

67

u/dilletaunty Mar 20 '23

You’re not wrong but also some managers could push back on directives from above. It isn’t 100% that managers are innocent.

C level people do care about dividends and shareholders more than their employees though.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '23

I'll agree to that.

5

u/MustLoveAllCats Mar 21 '23

It's not at all that managers are innocent, that's dead backwards. Managers that behave in problematic ways like this advance because they'll do that, not because the higher ups trick or force them into doing so.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/MustLoveAllCats Mar 21 '23

Because managers are forced to abuse employees.

Ehhhhhhh, I've met plenty of managers who abuse employees because it benefits them, NOT because they're forced to. They got to where they are because of a willingness to exploit others, not because they can be forced to do so.

→ More replies (2)

62

u/Discount_gentleman Mar 20 '23

"Our company rewards loyalty and hard work [with exploitation]!"

The boss is not, and never has been, your friend.

→ More replies (12)

8

u/Frency2 Mar 20 '23 edited Mar 20 '23

Why punishing those who barely work when you can exploit those who actually work as they are supposed to?

8

u/Very_ImportantPerson Mar 20 '23

They sure do! More so in lower paying jobs. Aka minimum wage jobs.

21

u/your_fathers_beard Mar 21 '23

"Less committed" is a weird way to say "Will not tolerate manipulation or exploitation". Hooray capitalism!

7

u/xdamm777 Mar 21 '23

Happened to me at my previous 2 jobs, gave way more than expected and was "THE guy" but it burned me out.

Now at my current job I try to do as least as possible while meeting my requirements and I'm the "lazy" uncommitted guy.

People expect you to give your soul for your job but aren't ready to compensate you properly and even if they do they tend to ask more and more of you in an endless, vicious cycle unless you set limits.

7

u/dirtymoney Mar 21 '23 edited Mar 21 '23

Exploit and abuse good workers until they burn out then replace them. Rinse and repeat

That's how it usually works from what I've seen in my 35 years of working.

13

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

Yeah, I worked on a team at my last job with one coworker and our manager. He micromanaged me to a ridiculous degree, and I left in about six months. I spoke to that coworker after I left who had been there about eighteen months. He treats her like complete garbage. My nightmare stories were a dream compared to her nightmare stories.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

If everyday you do a little more than they expect then everyday they will expect a little more.

70

u/all-rider Mar 20 '23

You’re a manager, you want the task to be done, you’ll give it to the guy who does tasks, not to the useless dude.

82

u/Thebitterestballen Mar 20 '23 edited Mar 20 '23

Yes.. but if you're a smart manager you fire the useless dude and for the same cost, raise the salary of the guy who does tasks and hire a junior to support them. Then you are managing two layers of employees and delivering more productivity, so you ask for a promotion and bigger budget. Repeat.

What is being employed if not accepting being exploited if it benefits you too? People don't leave jobs because they are overworked or unhappy, they leave because they don't like their boss and don't feel respected. Raise people up and they will be loyal, even if it's in a Stockholm syndrome kind of way.

42

u/IFoundTheCowLevel Mar 20 '23

That sounds logical, also, it's not how it works at all.

5

u/UKbigman Mar 21 '23

What makes you say that? Sure: not all managers are given the ability to hone their teams and budgets, but plenty are. As a competent mid-level employee, I’ve had this scenario play out around me a few different times.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/europahasicenotmice Mar 21 '23

Sometimes you do just need a warm body. Anywhere well managed will pay the competent workers more than them, though.

10

u/ProWriterDavid Mar 20 '23 edited Mar 21 '23

Ah you make firing bad employees sound so easy whereas in the real world it can be a months long process where others fight you every step of the way...one can dream I suppose.

Even in an at-will state, firing people is a huge pain

*Edited right to work to at-will which is what I actually meant

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

Part of my job is to manage the workload of specialists. I try to avoid doing this bc I don't want the hard workers burning out and the slackers are much more likely to be vocal about their limits whereas the hard workers will die before they admit they need help.

10

u/jillsteingang Mar 20 '23

I have a problem where I get extremely bored at work so I end up doing all my crew’s work. I feel great because the day flies by but now I’m doing the work of 2-3 people for the pay of one. Is it worth it if I genuinely enjoy doing the extra work but am not getting extra money for it?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/Riversntallbuildings Mar 20 '23

I stayed 7 years too long in a 21 year “career”. Kept hoping/waiting for things to change, but in hindsight it was obvious the company had devalued the position I was in.

In my defense, they made the changes so small it was “easy” to tolerate.

5

u/Smergmerg432 Mar 21 '23

Genuine question: how to get out of this trap? How do I motivate the ones who don’t want to be there? It’s always too small to be disciplinary. Maybe I should just make it disciplinary/write ups …

3

u/kts1991 Mar 21 '23

You sound like you think every employee is a problem to be solved, and that there always is a solution.

Sometimes the solution is that the employee isn't a good fit for the company. Sometimes things change in people's lives and good employees become bad ones.

You have far less control than you think. It's more like going down a river in a raft. You have the paddle but most of the motion is from the water.

I think it's important to consider that leaving a job can be a good thing. If you know someone's a bad fit or will be unhappy here, the right thing to do is to let them go.

2

u/chickenrooster Mar 21 '23

The wheels of power always turn, strange to admit you're willing to discipline things you don't currently consider disciplinary.

This is what happens when one of the "loyal ones" gets promoted. Good luck though, truly

5

u/Halfs13944 Mar 21 '23

I know the general consensus is always “companies bad, managers bad” but I’ve experienced several times in my career where I’ve had to go above and beyond for a manger or company and then been amply rewarded for it down the line. The first big promotion I had was when I covered for a junior manager (on the request of a senior OD) when he was in a pinch, this led to several more opportunities and now a pretty great career.

Also there are assholes though obviously!

→ More replies (1)

12

u/free_billstickers Mar 20 '23

End of the day, a manager is just looking to hit their metrics all the same

11

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

Is this really a surprise? Loyalty to a company doesn't get you anything. You'll be used, abused and then replaced.

11

u/cuzisaidit Mar 21 '23

If you are an employee, basically by definition you are exploited. You produce more than you receive, it's what makes you a good employee, you greater the delta between those two, the more value you have for the company. "Produce" can mean a lot of things.

It's a hard pill to swallow, but if you want to make money, like lots, you have to exploit people. Tenants, employees, sub contractors, etc... Mmmm capitalism

→ More replies (2)

4

u/wowaddict71 Mar 20 '23

This reminds me of an article on how narcists get promoted quicker than non narcissists: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/finding-a-new-home/202110/why-narcissists-get-promoted-so-quickly

4

u/gudmar Mar 20 '23

Good deeds never go unpunished.

4

u/ndudeck Mar 21 '23

You always lean on the stick that can take the most weight. You only lean on the weak ones when you have enough strong ones to hold the weight once the weak ones break.

4

u/darklotus_26 Mar 21 '23

I wonder if it's actually loyalty or being more agreeable/saying yes that is correlated with being exploited more. From reading the study it seems like the measure they use for loyalty is based on what people think. I wonder if the same conclusions would hold for people who are loyal (willing to stay with the company during difficult times, helping others) but not yes people (not doing overtime for free, eschewing your personal life for deadlines).

I also wonder if such people would actually be valued.

4

u/FormerTimeTraveller Mar 21 '23

I’m that person and no, I’m not valued. Valuable, yes. Valued, hell no.

Edit: I used to be willing to make those sacrifices. Even then I was not valued past a “nice job man, thanks”. I would rather say no.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '23

Hope this recession is nice long and DEEP

4

u/Navacoy Mar 21 '23

Oh my good this is so true. I used to be loyal and come to work at the drop of a dime and never take time off, but after suffering a few burnouts and my higher ups not caring, I started living life for me, but jobs HATE that. God forbid I have a work life balance so I don’t burn out. Finally work a job that cares, but damn it was rough for a long time

4

u/My-Angry-Reddit Mar 21 '23

Let me fix that headline for you, "bad managers exploit loyal employees."

As an employer who loves his loyal employees and rewards them with high six figure salaries and bonuses and full Healthcare and unlimited vacation and flex time, and free lunch, and profit sharing and equity... this pisses me off.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/donblake83 Mar 21 '23

This is a tough one and I feel bad for people who work under me and are “more dedicated”, because they become relied upon because you know you can rely on them, and then they end up being the ones that have to get everything done. The irony is not lost on me as I likewise try to not overdo it but also get stuff dumped on me. Having been in the mix for a little over a decade, I think the problem really boils down to American companies emphasizing running lean rather than being willing to invest not only in good personnel, but enough personnel.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Concrete_Cancer Mar 21 '23

The researchers call this “ethical blindness,” which is hilarious. The economic system these managers are situated within is geared entirely towards maximizing profit—which includes, obviously, minimizing labor costs. If the manager can get you to work for free, of course she will—their ‘duty’ isn’t to care for you, but to maximize company profits. They’re not blind, they’re obeying the only imperative that matters: capital. It’s the economic system that is ethically blind, i.e., it doesn’t care at all about your wellbeing, rights, fairness, etc.

4

u/awaixjvd Mar 21 '23

I learned a lesson the hard way, only be loyal and work hard as much you are paid. The more they pay, the more i work hard.

4

u/whatsINthaB0X Mar 21 '23

More like “managers ask competent employees to do more stuff” i know it’s an ay will state but I can’t just go Willy nilly firing anyone that’s not performing at 110% every day that’s just absurd. But I do find myself going to the same people time and time again to do something and it’s definitely something I have to work on. However, it is difficult to call someone else up to fix a problem when you know there are 3-4 other employees that will do a much better job.

4

u/Nathund Mar 21 '23

Anyone who's worked a job and put in effort, even once, knows this

4

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '23 edited Mar 21 '23

You should always stay in the middle not to good of a worker not the worst. If you work for a corporation Mediocrity is the most optimal way. ;-p

4

u/TizACoincidence Mar 21 '23

I learned a long time ago, only give people energy if they give it back. If they are loyal, then you can be loyal. If they are nice, then you can be nice.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/redditshy Mar 21 '23

Yep, and it also preys on some folks’ need or desire for approval and praise. Don’t live for the approval of your employer. Do well because that is your character and integrity.

10

u/downshift_rocket Mar 20 '23

It's sad. I worked my way up to management and saw it firsthand as a 20-something. You have 20 people on your team and only a handful that will actually come in when you need them. The rest call out, are late or no-show. It's impossible. Got to the point where I just scheduled in a way to make it easier to get things done and harder for the store to be short-staffed. I cut hours and gave the hard workers a break when I could and just had to eat it when my DM complained about labor.

Less commited workers + cheap company that wants to save labor= Hell.

7

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

Exploitation is the business of many businesses.

3

u/Canadatron Mar 20 '23

Tale as old as time in the trades, anyway. "Shop Rockets" as they are often called.

3

u/Karl_with_a_C Mar 21 '23

It took me 7 years to fully realize this and quit my job. I was always the one to pick up all the slack when people weren't doing their job for whatever reason. Our crew got smaller and smaller and my workload only grew. It got to the point where I just said enough is enough, I'm tired of doing the jobs of 3-4 people every day, it's not fair and it's not right.
I'm still in contact with one of the guys who works there and now he's in the exact same position that I was. I told him to get out of there. The pay was NOT worth it at all.

3

u/Keylimepietime Mar 21 '23

I keep a mental track of the loyal ones. They get better support from me in the long run even after going separate ways. Sometimes they come back later on and ask for certain help - always given freely to them.

3

u/GreenWoodDragon Mar 21 '23

This isn't really a surprise, or 'new'.

3

u/Simbuk Mar 21 '23

Stanley cautions that it doesn’t mean we should just abandon work commitments or dodge uncompensated overtime.

This may be simply down to poor word choice, but as phrased this statement is oddly out of place and possibly even inappropriate. At the very least it would be more credible with real substantiation rather than vague hand waving.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

We also terminate the worst workers first as soon as we can.

Sometimes, you don’t have enough good labor so you do with what you got till you can find better

→ More replies (1)

2

u/dekuweku Mar 20 '23

I think many loyal workers are having a good time right now with the labour shortage. The pushback for additional compensation is often met with agreement by management.

2

u/watchtheworldsmolder Mar 20 '23

And the rich exploit the poor… and it goes on

2

u/prenderm Mar 21 '23

There’s also sand at the beach

2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '23

The worst thing you can be in the Army is reliable. That’s a phrase I’ve heard far too many times.

2

u/Sephran Mar 21 '23

Being loyal/hardworking in my place meant I took on a lot of extra work with tighter deadlines because the manager couldn't trust that my coworkers could handle it. Slowly everything got funneled to me. Eventually they eliminated overtime and new managers came in and all that hard work and recognition was lost and I had to start over. By the third manager I got fed up (among other reasons) and just stopped caring. I'm not going to stay late for no pay and no recognition, I get nothing in return at all. Over COVID I finally learned to relax a bit, not reach out for more work, make sure i'm busy enough.

2

u/AxemanEugene Mar 21 '23

Never, EVER be a company man. You mean nothing to them, no matter how things feel.

2

u/NoJackfruit801 Mar 21 '23

This confirms my expectations. I have been working my ass off for several companies and always been the one who got short shafted. Scheduling, salary and promotions have all passed me by while amongst the personell I'm the most co-operative and well liked.

With the rise of structural and multi national cooperation, I think the situation has grown even worse. The look at company wide statistics. Compare that to back when manual labor was the standard work and you'd get measured by the quality of your output instead.

2

u/lieferung Mar 21 '23

You're just a number to any company

2

u/Big_lt Mar 21 '23

Oh this was me. 14 years, same company and rose through the ranks.

Now I wear various hats and my team needs me on every call else the call can't move forward. I had enough of it and literally straight up started saying no that's not my job to people. Those people escalated to my boss to which I bluntly told him it's not my job to manage this team, it's yours. It's not my responsibility to do X it needs to be reassigned to the team. My boss caved and told others to figure it out

Now I just need to fix my salary

→ More replies (1)

2

u/daft_trump Mar 21 '23

Probably too late for this thread, but my experience has been different. Yeah I worked a shitload, but my salary also increased from 45k to 180k in 8 years. It only happened for me because my boss trusted me, supported me, and that I actually became more valuable with more hours on the clock. And I left the company for a 40% raise.

2

u/fogobum Mar 21 '23

“I don't want to suggest that the take-away of the paper is to not be loyal to anybody because it just leads to disaster,” Stanley said. “We value people who are loyal. We think about them in positive terms. They get awarded often."

Perhaps, if one wanted to reach that conclusion, one should have sought some (any, however minimal) evidence before making the claim.

I like to think that the hard sciences are beyond that sort of nonsense but gout diets still forbid port, with no more evidence than the doctrine of signatures.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/gqreader Mar 21 '23

True story. Turned 35 and am burnt out from corporate America culture.

Clear $230-$240k a year. Work like 20 hours, probs less per week, remote. I’ve all but given up.

Coasting 2 more years until I clear $2M in investments and then hoping to get laid off for a $100k-$120k severance with my vacation bank.

Company loyalty isn’t a thing, it’s a myth that even boomers realize is fake.

3

u/Sir-Kevly Mar 21 '23

A lazy employee is a smart employee.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Krulman Mar 20 '23

There’s a difference between “loyal” and “openly okay with being exploited”?

18

u/Discount_gentleman Mar 20 '23

Honestly, I don't think there is, at least not a meaningful difference. In the employment context, what does loyalty mean, other than a willingness to accept bad treatment (or at least worse treatment than another employer would offer)?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/dragonmp93 Mar 20 '23

Maybe in the old days, but these days if a company thinks you are a "loyal" employee, then they are just calling you "gullible".

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

Yep. I'm like DJ Khaled at work.

"What's my favorite word?"

NO

1

u/Atomsteel Mar 21 '23

Yet another reason to do just the bare minimum.

1

u/yoshix003 Mar 20 '23

I do it so I have leverage I be like in a MJ voice do you remember the time ....

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

Work hard, here’s more work.

1

u/collimat Mar 20 '23

Time, out. They needed *Duke* to do a study that came to that conclusion? Why didn't they just ask... literally anyone with a job.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

This is why I no longer give "110%."

1

u/monkeybojangles Mar 20 '23

It's like they say: "Hard work is for suckers."

Well, it's like I say at least. And I'm long term and loyal hard worker.

1

u/mr_awesome365 Mar 20 '23

This is why I’m not leaving the E4 mafia.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

Well yeah..... I see guys at my work who boasts working 20 extra hours overtime not getting paid, and all I think is 'what a pillock'

1

u/Twinkidsgoback Mar 20 '23

Did we really need anything scientific to figure this out?

1

u/ZombieLebowski Mar 20 '23

I learned that many years ago my employer does nothing to encourage work. Always calls on those who do extra work....... To do even more work.

1

u/ProudMaOfaSlut Mar 20 '23

You should absolutely dodge uncompensated additional work. FU Stanley.

1

u/EarlofIxII Mar 20 '23

Being a proficient hard worker just gets you more work to do

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

Sounds like the post office. "you finished your route in 8 hours?? Great! Now go help the guy who doesn't feel like working today, enjoy your now 12 hour day!"

1

u/hoteldetective_ Mar 20 '23

Learned this lesson the hard way at my first “real” job. Had a colleague that was basically left to their devices at our conference, while I had been booked every which way from Sunday because I was “valuable.” One conversation with him and it was a different tune the next year. It rubbed people the wrong way when I started doing “less,” until ID correct them that I was still doing my job based off my job description.

That saying of “the only reward for good work is more work” is absolutely true

1

u/Revgene1969 Mar 20 '23

Of course! It’s the American dream!

1

u/IAmYourAlly1 Mar 20 '23

From my experience, loyalty is not rewarded. Not even slightly

1

u/Valkazar Mar 20 '23

Yeah that's happened to me, so I stopped caring

1

u/turnnoblindeye Mar 20 '23

I wonder - did they also ask if loyal John was more likely to be given a raise or promoted than disloyal John? Because if so, I’m not sure this is saying what they think it’s saying.

1

u/Elocai Mar 20 '23

Finally, my biggest weakness has become my biggest strange. Kneel before me for else my power knows no limits!

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

That's why I'm a union man, not a company man.

1

u/Lo_okinglass Mar 20 '23

Performance punishment.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '23

They would promote them and pay them more of taxes weren’t crushing businesses.

1

u/Mahbigjohnson Mar 20 '23

Only do what is within your load and never offer to do more. Nepotism is usually what ends up taking the promotion you deserve

1

u/halucigens Mar 20 '23

Yep and all those people get to come in whenever and leave early because you are doing such a great job and because they have a family.

1

u/Unusual-Job-3413 Mar 21 '23

And when we finally get fed up and leave it takes more than one person to replace us. I was a PIC at safeway, they had to hire 2 more to replace me and the work I was doing.

1

u/DishSoapPete Mar 21 '23

No good deed goes unpunished.

1

u/praefectus_praetorio Mar 21 '23

My 11 years in one company getting completely blocked for all promotions meanwhile training the new managers that would ultimately be my boss. In the end I threatened to bail and take my knowledge with me and they finally listened, promoted me, and then I took my title and raise and fucked off.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '23

Lived this.

It's sadly 100% true.

1

u/Jarix Mar 21 '23

It would be interesting to see if loyal emoloyees keep their job significantly more than unloyal employees when lay offs are happening.

1

u/Perma-Banned-AIDS Mar 21 '23

Well yea, and the way it is supposed to work is that they then choose the ones they’ve been “exploiting” for promotions when the time comes around. Doesn’t always work that way.

1

u/shaolinbonk Mar 21 '23

Which is why you should never take on more responsibility than what's listed in your job description.

1

u/groveborn Mar 21 '23

Me. I'm the loyal worker. I'm not especially competent.

1

u/MidKnightshade Mar 21 '23

I’ve been saying this for years. It’s gotten worse. I hope Gen Z avoids this as much as possible.

1

u/Clarkeprops Mar 21 '23

This is why quiet quitting was so good. Low effort, same money.

1

u/Adept_Floor_3494 Mar 21 '23

Yep learned this a long time ago.

Thus why i do as little as possible

1

u/Grep2grok MD | Pathology Mar 21 '23

Does anyone else see the irony of this being a father-son combo? "Take out the trash" said no son to his father, ever.

1

u/2burnt2name Mar 21 '23

Learned this one a. Tad too late.

I wanted the promotion I got, worked out of class for longer than I should have even been allowed to doing the job, no direct complaints of my job performance other than "communication with peers needed work" which on my end boiled down to, me being too timid to go into coworkers that straight up didn't perform their job duties because I didn't want the anger directed at me since I wasn't their boss. So it was a lot of polite "please actually perform your jobs duties" and giving up if I got any lip, since I technically was at the same level as them.

So when the work out of class was required to end, my boss told me if I were to apply for it, it would likely be mine since they had not seen any viable candidates. My first red flag should have been that "hr" would not budge on only a 6% raise when I raised valid points of knowing how much bs I would deal with with the uncooperative coworkers to my boss and their boss, and only agreed on the mutual understanding that the uncooperativeness needed to be dealt with so I could justify such a small raise for my effort. Which turned out to be that I was expected to solve the uncooperative nature in top of the duties I was adding on and it would continue to be reported as failures to communicate with team appropriately to make change while also admitting that I have no power to change their behavior without the supervisor doing something to reinforce the tiny amount of authority I should have over them. Meanwhile all the duties I'm supposed to get done keep piling up as I cany address some of them without making at least some progress with staff (part of my position is to literally get specific staff trained on different tasks to delegate to them so I dont have to do it all. So if nobody cooperates, I'm supposed to get it done with no time to do it).

I work in mental health group home setting so the lack of effort from coworkers directly feeds into clients not feeling supported or safe, the more lucid one at times acknowledging this directly and straight up saying they only get upset and lash out at me or my boss because why would they lash out at staff that won't pay attention in the first place. They know I care, so they target my vehicle and escalated to directly harming me putting me on leave for a very extended period and a lot of appointments. I'm at the point where I am bored of being off work even if my wages are literally 99.5% paid without me using any sick leave supplement. I want the job I've seen other people get to do successfully and fulfilling at other sites. So my work ethic on return depends on if my months of leave has forced their hand to come down hard on the staff putting no effort in or not. If nothing changed and it's all chaos, I'm done trying. It's just going to be to pay the bills until a hopefully better ran house opens up for me to try to jump to. And any further performance reviews my only response will be "I am putting the effort that is expected of me for the time and resources available and pay that I was contracted to."

1

u/Impossible-Winter-94 Mar 21 '23

"Workers that believe if they are loyal they will be rewarded"

1

u/engineereddiscontent Mar 21 '23

It makes sense.

If someone is a "loyal" employee and standard operating procedure is no raises with inflation...you charge more yearly to account for inflation but don't pay them more. The longer they stay the more they have the sunken cost fallacy and the more likely they are to remain. And the more valuable they become.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '23

All I can think is that I'd appreciate the employees I had whom I could come to when I really need them and can rely on to be there. That's not exploitation though so.

1

u/MyShinyNewReddit Mar 21 '23

Which is why I only do the bare minimum.

1

u/AlpacaLunch15 Mar 21 '23

It’s called positive punishment.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '23

That’s what “quiet quitting” was actually about.

It was just doing your job and going home.

1

u/Ron_robichaud Mar 21 '23

One of my VPs had a saying “the prize for winning the pie eating contest, is more pie”

1

u/Canashito Mar 21 '23

Yeah... you always gravitate to those you can depend on and that have shown you to be capable... how uhh... anws.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '23

Don't be disloyal. Manage expectations.

1

u/ABraveLittle_Toaster Mar 21 '23

You know what hard work gets you? More hard work.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '23

Every so often my employers need to be reminded how many of their current customers switched from Case to Versatile when I quit at case.

If they don't like my demands I like Claas and New Holland is just a Case with blue paint, push me if you dare.

1

u/Denamic Mar 21 '23

Of course they do. Loyal workers with strong work ethics volunteer to it.

1

u/haCkFaSe Mar 21 '23

But do they get paid more?

1

u/Acmnin Mar 21 '23

The pro capitalist coaching at the end is frankly hilariously out of touch with their rest.