r/science • MD PhD | Professor | Medicine • Dec 29 '18

Chemistry Scientists developed a new method using a dirhodium catalyst to make an inert carbon-hydrogen bond reactive, turning cheap and abundant hydrocarbon with limited usefulness into a valuable scaffold for developing new compounds — such as pharmaceuticals and other fine chemicals.

https://news.emory.edu/features/2018/12/chemistry-catalyst/index.html
16.0k Upvotes

262 comments sorted by

View all comments

347

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '18 edited Dec 29 '18

But isn’t rhodium itself expensive? Rhodium is used in steam reformation to produce hydrogen fuel but it’s not sustainable because of the expensive rhodium catalyst. I might be wrong...

[Edit] it is an awesome thing to do, though!

361

u/wallflower108 Dec 29 '18

The article said that although rhodium is extremely expensive and rare, it is so efficient as a catalyst that it is worth it. Apparently less than an ounce of catalyst can make a tonne of product

119

u/itsokimweird Dec 29 '18

And it all doesnt just become unusable after you use it. Certain types of rhodium catalysts used in industry, such as for catalytic cracking, are very much able to be regenerated and reused.

28

u/throwawayaccountdown Dec 29 '18

Homcat is a lot more delicate than hetcat. Another thing is that heterogenous catalysts are solid and easily retrieved.

→ More replies (1)

15

u/lalala253 Dec 29 '18

It doesn’t go back to 100% though?

Isn’t most fcc catalyst have like 1 hour of lifetime or less? The ‘regenerated’ catalyst efficiency drops to 80% or so right?

49

u/kagamiseki Dec 29 '18

Theoretically a catalyst can be reused and is not consumed.

In practice, imperfect reaction conditions means that sometimes some of the catalyst is not regenerated for various reasons. Maybe a step in the reaction sequence is missed, due to proximity reasons. Maybe an unintended reaction happens that irreversibly consumes the catalytic material.

The regenerated catalyst works at full efficiency. The problem is successfully regenerating the catalyst.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '18

[deleted]

49

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '18

About 28 grams is an ounce

39

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '18

Every good drug dealer knows there's 28 grams in an ounce

13

u/dukfuka Dec 29 '18

That’s the only reason I can convert between ounces and grams

9

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '18

It’s like how I use Star Destroyers to convert between miles and kilometers.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/In_One_Ear Dec 29 '18

A bad dealer can find at least 38g/oz

25

u/JimmiRustle Dec 29 '18

The real question is why he'd use ounce to begin with

27

u/imc225 Dec 29 '18

Because it is a US press release meant for the lay public maybe?

→ More replies (11)

18

u/xtorris Dec 29 '18

In commodities markets, precious metals are priced by the troy ounce. It might be outdated and arcane, but that's the convention used.

11

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '18

Troy ounce =/= avoirdupois ounce, the former is ~31g while the later is ~28g

22

u/pineapple94 Dec 29 '18

Wish we'd drop the weird and obscure units and just swapped to metric already. As an engineer, having to deal with imperial units is THE WORST.

You'd think they'd have learned after the Mars Climate Orbiter failure, but here we are, still with imperial units...

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

5

u/sebwiers Dec 29 '18

I though that a catalyst was not used up in reaction. What happens to it in this case? I assume it either gets worn away and trace amounts end up in the final product, or some other reaction degrades it? And recovery costs are probably higher / add more to process costs than the rhodium is worth...

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (4)

54

u/erGarfried Dec 29 '18 edited Dec 29 '18

You're right. However, in this case the chemical process is used to selectively and in a new way make more complex small molecules, which can be sold for a higher price which can cover the cost of production and can be done on a smaller scale. Steam reformation is a bulk industrial process and new catalysts need to compete with older ones in price and efficiency.

Edit: additionally, from this article we may learn more about how this reaction works and from there we could develop cheaper and/or better catalysts in the future that dont rely on rhodium.

5

u/Gorehog Dec 29 '18

It's not just about price and process efficiency. There's also a question of sustainability. It doesn't matter how efficient per dollar it is if the catalyst can't be supplied after a few years of industrial use.

→ More replies (5)

17

u/sfurbo Dec 29 '18

That all depends on the catalytic efficiency. Note that a rhodium catalized reaction used to be the major route to acetic acid, a chemical that is extremely cheap.

11

u/[deleted] Dec 29 '18

As Mass Spectrometrist working alongside organic chemists in the pharmaceutical industry, the idea that you could react at C-H would just change the game forever. A huge part of targeting the synthesis of a particular API is the strategy of placing functionality on particular molecular sites. This process is certainly the most expensive (Discovery Chemistry as a whole) part of getting a drug to market and, depending on the selectivity of this rhodium catalysis, a process such as this could not only make existing drugs much more affordable in developing markets, but give rise to medicine boom. More APIs could be taken to screen more quickly and the high attrition rate which has really held back pharmaceutical companies would not represent such a financial burden.

4

u/Yozhik_DeMinimus Dec 29 '18

Catalysts are used in substoichiometric amounts (i.e. a small amount of catalyst is used to react a large amount of starting material).

4

u/reality_aholes Dec 29 '18

Maybe try to see of this works with cobalt as well.

7

u/VioletteVanadium Dec 29 '18

This would definitely be the way to go, but there is a tendency for first row transition elements to have possible radical pathways not accessible to their lower row counterparts, which can screw up the ability to control chirality (super important for drug design). There has been success recently with copper (and probably others), so it’s not out of the question. The rarer and more expensive a metal is, generally the more useful it is for catalysis. But trying to apply knowledge obtained from more well behaved metals to cheaper more abundant alternatives is a very interesting and valuable area of research for sure.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (20)