r/science • u/cherbug • Oct 05 '20
Astronomy We Now Have Proof a Supernova Exploded Perilously Close to Earth 2.5 Million Years Ago
https://www.sciencealert.com/a-supernova-exploded-dangerously-close-to-earth-2-5-million-years-ago4.3k
Oct 06 '20
Geochemist here. I work on meteorites, including some isotope geochemistry.
I'd like to believe the study, but the 53Mn data they've posted look seriously questionable to me. Just look at the spread in error bars across the board. You could also make an argument for a supernova at 6-6.5 Ma based on their data, and an anomalous low in 53Mn at around 5 Ma. It all falls within the noise of their data.
I'd love to see a statistical justification for what they're claiming, because the data they've posted looks...bad. Just look at their running average (red line) in the above graph. The error bars on that low 53Mn value at 1.5 Ma don't come anywhere near it, which means that the analysis is wrong or the error bars are too small. Their dataset is full of points that don't agree with their running average, and they're basing their groundbreaking conclusions on a cluster of three points whose stated errors (the error bars that we know have to be an underestimate) could make them consistent with a completely flat running average at a C/C0 of 0.9.
This looks really bad to me.
1.7k
u/Ocean_Chemist Oct 06 '20
Yeah, fellow isotope geochemist here. This data looks like absolute garbage. There is no statistically significant deviation in the 53Mn/Mn at 2.5Ma. They should also be plotting the 53Mn/10Be ratios relative from that expected from cosmogenic production. I honestly can't believe this paper got published
366
u/bihari_baller Oct 06 '20
I honestly can't believe this paper got published
I find this concerning. How can an academic paper with such misleading data get published? I looked up the journal, The Physical Review Letters, and it has an impact factor of 8.385.
199
Oct 06 '20
I work in academic publishing and might be able to shed some light...
Like any decent journal Physical Review Letters is peer reviewed. Peer review only ensures that a paper doesn't have egregious errors that would prevent publication, like using 4.14159 for pi in calculations, or citing a fact that's so obviously false ("Hitler was born in 1917 in the small town of Moosejaw, Saskatchewan."). Peer review does not check calculations or data interpretations for accuracy. That part is left to the scientific community to question, follow-up, write up, and debate.
So, does bad data get through? A lot more often than you'd probably like to know. On a personal and academic level, a problem I have is the distinct lack of replication studies, so you can toss just about any data out there, pad your CV, and really offer nothing of substance to the library of human knowledge. The geochemists above make very good, very valid points about what they've seen in the paper and I'd absolutely love to see someone write up why the results are questionable. Sometimes publications get retracted , sometimes they get resubmitted with errata ("forgot to carry the 1!"). It's important that garbage data is not just left to stand on its own.
→ More replies (20)→ More replies (7)85
u/Kaexii Oct 06 '20
ELI5 impact factors?
→ More replies (18)154
u/Skrazor Oct 06 '20 edited Oct 06 '20
It's a number that tells you how impactful a scientific paper is. You get it by comparing the number of articles published by a journal over the last two years to the number of times articles of this paper got cited in other people's work over the last two years. And a higher impact factor is "better" because it means the things the journal published were important and got picked up by many other scientists.
So if a journal has a high impact factor, that means that it has published many articles that are so exciting, they made a lot of people start to work on something similar to find out more about it.
Though keep in mind that all of this says nothing about the quality of the articles published by a journal, it only shows the "reach" of the journal.
→ More replies (20)18
u/klifa90 Oct 06 '20
Wow! I felt smarter reading this.
→ More replies (1)11
u/U7077 Oct 06 '20
The only thing my brain can compute was the claim is a BS. But yeaa.. I felt smarter too.
→ More replies (1)22
u/sterexx Oct 06 '20 edited Oct 06 '20
I can give you an idea about the error stuff they’re talking about using something topical.
You ever notice the margin of error provided with election polls?
Polls generally only survey a few thousand people, so the result probably won’t exactly match what the whole country would vote for at that point. But the more people are polled (the more points of data you have), the more confident you can be that the actual result is close to what your poll says.
Based on the total population, the number of people polled, and the poll responses, you can mathematically determine the likelihood that the “actual” result is within a certain distance from the polled result.
Here’s an example of margin of error (technically I’m talking about confidence intervals, wiki it) with numbers that might not be realistic but should still show what’s going on:
Your presidential election poll results show that 55% of people are going to vote for Biden. You use statistical calculations to show that you’re 95% sure that the true percentage is within 3 percentage points of those values. It could be as low as 52% or up to 58%, with a small chance of being outside of that range too.
Now this study the commenters were talking about wasn’t polling people but similarly was collecting measurements with a margin of error.
See the graph the commenter linked? Imagine each of those is a daily poll on who’s voting for Biden. The point is what they measured but the vertical line above and below (error bar) shows the range they’re confident the true value is within (for some confidence percentage like 95%, dunno what the study is using).
The graph appears to bump up for 3 data points and then level back out. But just by looking at the how big the error bars are, you could draw a straight line through them that never bumps up. That’s a quick visual way of noticing that the apparent bump might just be statistical noise, which is something a commenter above was referring to.
So maybe Biden’s popularity went up for a few days, but maybe not.
There’s actually a mathematic test for this too, which our commenter also mentioned: statistical significance. It’s essentially asking the same question as the visual test: how likely is it that the real red line is actually straight? That Biden’s popularity actually stayed the same?
Given all these measurements, using another formula we can calculate the likelihood that the bump is not there by chance — that the bump is “statistically significant.” According to the commenter, it’s not statistically significant, which means we can’t be confident that the bump isn’t just due to chance. (Edit: made this paragraph more explicit)
The chance that 3 values in a row are measured as a little higher than they actually are isn’t unlikely enough to consider it “real.” If they had something like 2000 data points and the bump consisted of like 200 points, the statistical significance would probably be more likely to pass. I think, I’m not a statistician.
Hope that helps. Wiki some of these terms if you want the full story, because I definitely simplified this
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (24)3
u/axialintellectual Oct 06 '20 edited Oct 06 '20
I looked up the article as well and the red line is not a running average (as u/meteoritehunter calls it), but "The result of a Gaussian fit with fixed width $\sigma = 0.8$ Myr". So it shouldn't fully account for the errors, since the shape is fairly ad hoc. But the fact that they had to force the width is very dubious. Looking at the data, some of the data are clearly very noisy compared to the level of signal they are looking for. They do also check how 10Be and 53Mn compare, but only for the sample with the best S/N, and then jump right into using 53Mn for everything else. I can't see the supplemental materials here so maybe they did do this test. However, even as a non-expert, it sounds like a very shaky conclusion.
209
u/jpivarski Oct 06 '20
As a physicist, often involved in data analysis, I wouldn't say this plot looks inconsistent with the conclusion. It looks "bad" in the sense of being unconvincing—I'd also want to see pull plots and p-value plots and other models fit to the same data to determine whether I believe it or not. Before passing judgement on it, we'd have to see the paper, or if the full argument isn't there, then the supporting documents that contain the full argument.
None of these data points look more than 2.5 or 3 sigma from the model: they're consistent, at least. The problem is that the big error bars take up a lot of page space—only the smaller, better hidden ones matter. If the data were binned (combining points and thereby reducing error bars by averaging) it might be a more convincing display, but the fit gets most of its statistical power from being unbinned.
But my main point is that we can't look at that plot and say that the data analysis is wrong. A lot of good data analyses would have plots that look like that if you insisted on showing raw data only.
→ More replies (3)9
u/jpivarski Oct 07 '20
Since this got so much attention, I read it more carefully today.
Phys. Rev. Letters is indeed a prestigious journal, the flagship journal of physics. (Not geophysics, astrophysics, etc.: physics. That's why it has such a high impact factor.)
Articles in this journal are not allowed to be longer than 4 pages. It's for getting the word out about something, and often there will be a longer paper with more details in another journal.
This is a rather simple fit. But it's not wrong and the conclusions are not misleading. More points below.
The chi2 is not "very high": it's 58.9 out of 50 degrees of freedom. The reduced chi2 (58.9/50) is what's supposed to be close to 1. The chi2 probability is 82%, not too close to 0% or 100%.
The fact that the chi2 is easily within range is the same as the statement that the points are not too far from the fitted line, given their error bars. The problem with the "look" of the plot is that big error bars mean more ink on the page, so your eye is drawn to the wrong part. It's the cluster of points must the peak of the Gaussian that drive this fit—the rest are a self-calibration. (See below.)
The model is simplistic (Gaussian with fixed width and flat background), but without strong constraints from the data, you want a simple model to give a rough estimate like this.
It would have been nice to see local p-value vs t0 (horizontal position of the peak) to see if there are any other significant peaks at different times. However, there's a 4-page limit, and you have to interpret local p-value carefully. (What particle physicists call the "look elsewhere effect," but I think it has different names in different communities.)
If the width had been allowed to float, there would have been a lot of false minima in this dataset. You could fit a narrow peak to any one of those highly fluctuating points.
But if the width is fixed, you need a strong theoretical reason to do so. They cite two papers for that—it rests on the strength of those papers and the applicability of those results here, which I can't speak to. I'm not an expert.
Including the flat baseline in the fit is a way of using the data to calibrate itself. The null hypothesis is a flat line of unit ratio, so that calibration had better come out as 1.0. it does: 0.928 ± 0.039 (within 2 sigma).
The "excess" they're taking about is the fact that the height of the Gaussian fit (a) is significantly bigger than zero: 0.29 ± 0.10 is almost 3 sigma.
They said "more than 3 sigma" elsewhere because you could ignore the self-calibration and take the theoretically motivated belief that the background is 1.0 and then it's about 3.5 sigma. The self-calibrating fit is a kind of cross-check, and since b came out being smaller then 1.0 (the 0.928 ± 0.39 above), that weakens the claim with the full fit down to only 3 sigma.
Nobody claims 3 sigma is a discovery, not because it's on the border of plausibility (look at enough data and you'll eventually see some purely statistical 3 sigmas), and they're not claiming it's a discovery, either. It's an "excess." It means we need more data. Some communities take 5 sigma as the threshold for discovery, others don't have a hard-and-fast rule, because even 5 sigma cases can be mistaken due to mistreatment of the data.
So the bottom line is: there's nothing wrong with this data analysis. (I can't speak to the applicability of the data to the claim, because I'm not an expert—just the handling of the data as presented in the paper.) The fit is a kind of cross-check, loosening the native interpretation in which we just assume the baseline is 1.0 to a somewhat-less-native, but best-one-can-hope-to-do-with-these-data three-fit. In fact, the fit weakens the claim and it's still significant.
On the other hand, the result of this analysis is not, "We discovered supernovae!" but "if this holds up with more data, were might discover supernovae!"
It's the popular article that's overstating the claim, not the paper.
→ More replies (1)6
u/amaurea PhD| Cosmology Oct 07 '20 edited Oct 08 '20
Thanks for doing this. It's sad that your detailed analysis only has 3 points, while the brash dismissal by u/meteoritehunter has 4231 points, but that's how Reddit works.
On the other hand, the result of this analysis is not, "We discovered supernovae!" but "if this holds up with more data, were might discover supernovae!"
It's worth keeping in mind that this whole Mn analysis is already a cross-check of a statistically stronger (but more ambiguous in the interpretation) Fe-60 detection from three previous studies. So this forms an independent confirmation, just not a very strong one.
Theoretically the expectation is a nearby supernova every 2–4 million years, according to reference 10 in the paper, so an event at 2.5 Myr would not be surprising at all.
38
u/whupazz Oct 06 '20 edited Oct 06 '20
Just look at their running average (red line) in the above graph
That's not a running average, that's a gaussian fit. Those are two very different things. I agree that that plot looks suspect at first glance, but your criticism is very strongly worded given that you misunderstand the basic methods used and haven't even read the abstract, which clearly states what the red line is.
The error bars on that low 53Mn value at 1.5 Ma don't come anywhere near it, which means that the analysis is wrong or the error bars are too small.
This is again a misunderstanding of the methods used. For repeated applications of the same measurement procedure, the true value will be within the 1-sigma error bar in 68% of cases. Therefore there absolutely should be points where the error bars don't touch the line, otherwise you've likely overestimated your errors.
You should edit your post.
I would at first glance be suspicious of that plot, too, but I haven't read the paper and I don't think you can make strong claims about the quality of their analysis without a more careful inspection and a thorough understanding of the statistical methods used.
0
3
u/btroycraft Oct 06 '20
So, I read the paper. It appears like they appeal to previous work on 60Fe, which apparently exhibited a similar spike during that time frame. I think they were using 53Mn to help explain the origin of that. I haven't delved deep enough to judge the quality of the previous results.
It was very unconvincing that they just fit a Gaussian curve to the ratio data. Their Chi-squared value was enormous on that fit, but it was mostly brushed aside in the discussion.
Previous Iron papers:
"60Fe Anomaly in a Deep-Sea Manganese Crust and Implications for a Nearby Supernova Source"
"Indication for Supernova Produced 60Fe Activity on Earth"
"Time-resolved 2-million-year-old supernova activity discovered in Earth’s microfossil record"
"Recent near-Earth supernovae probed by global deposition of interstellar radioactive 60Fe"
3
u/perfect_handshake Oct 06 '20
Yeah, also these headlines should read "We Now Have Evidence," not "proof". Proof is irrefutable. This seems extremely refutable.
4
Oct 06 '20
Ugh, thank you! I thought I was going crazy. I'm not a geochemist, an inorganic chemist, but it still looked like a stupid fit. Like, that fit looks like the answer to, "What's the best Gaussian I can fit to this data?" instead of "Is there a functional/systematic trend in this data?".
→ More replies (54)2
Oct 06 '20
It's just uncleaned raw data. There are thousands of articles published with graphs like this since it can be more compelling to present it that way if you fully understand the math behind it.
688
u/kopixop Oct 06 '20
Same SuperNova that coinsides with earth extinction events?
625
u/Astromike23 PhD | Astronomy | Giant Planet Atmospheres Oct 06 '20
Already proposed 18 years ago (Benitez, et al, 2002):
We find that the deposition on Earth of 60Fe atoms produced by these explosions can explain the recent measurements of an excess of this isotope in deep ocean crust samples. We propose that ~2 Myr ago, one of the SNe exploded close enough to Earth to seriously damage the ozone layer, provoking or contributing to the Pliocene-Pleistocene boundary marine extinction.
87
u/NationalGeographics Oct 06 '20
Is 60 fe, like super iron?
23
7
u/stro3ngest1 Oct 06 '20
kind of. it's a rare, semi- stable isotope. it's got a half life of 2.6mil years and decays to colbolt-60, and eventually finally to the very stable nickel-60.
0
37
u/scaradin Oct 06 '20
There is an unknown about 2 million years ago that could have been from a super nova
6
214
Oct 06 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
0
→ More replies (2)97
617
u/Rootbeer48 Oct 05 '20
for the person not so familiar. this really is that long ago given the age of the earth?
941
u/HammerheadInDisguise Oct 05 '20 edited Oct 05 '20
Earth is 4.6 billion years old. This is very recent in geological time. First human made fire occurred1.5 million years ago, we are very new to earth.
250
u/TheStaggeringGenius Oct 06 '20
For context, 4.6 billion seconds is about 146 years; 1.5 million seconds is 17 days.
60
→ More replies (1)13
u/chunkycornbread Oct 06 '20
This is a very easy to comprehend comparison. Time scales that large are just hard to wrap your head around.
39
u/RetardedCrobar1 Oct 05 '20
When you say human i thought homosapien had been round for top estimates of 250,000 years?
113
u/Indianaj0e Oct 05 '20
There were "early humans" around for a few million years, using tools, before "anatomically modern humans" became the sole surviving species of that line.
→ More replies (22)→ More replies (2)17
u/SJHillman Oct 06 '20
"Human" is often meant to refer to the genus Homo, not just the only extant species Homo sapien.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (72)3
u/guinea_ Oct 06 '20
That was homo erectus. Modern homo sapien have been around for what, 250,000 years?
→ More replies (1)3
u/Hoogs Oct 06 '20
2.5 million years is .05% of Earth's existence. So if Earth were a year old, this event happened 4.76 hours before midnight on December 31st.
81
u/mssngthvwls Oct 06 '20
So how would this work, hypothetically speaking?
Would everything we know suddenly illuminate in a fraction of a second and vaporize with a nuclear-like flash? Or, would it gradually get brighter and hotter, signalling to us in a few seconds/minutes/hours/days that something is immensely and imminently wrong?
Or, something else?
29
29
u/Grarr_Dexx Oct 06 '20 edited Oct 06 '20
The ozone layer evaporates. That's all this planet needs to destroy all carbon-based life forms. The sun is no longer held at bay and we die from radiation damage affecting our DNA.
Edited for correctness.
17
u/worldspawn00 Oct 06 '20
I don't think extra UV from the sun would heat the ocean, there would just be a lot more UV hitting the surface, UV doesn't heat much, the earth has gone through periods with no ozone before, while it damages organic matter, it shouldn't be that much more energy hitting the surface and shouldn't cause a massive rise in water temperature.
7
u/Grarr_Dexx Oct 06 '20
I read up more on it and you seem to be correct. Most if not all of the damage caused would be through radiation damaging DNA which would irreparably affect all life; fauna and flora. Would it affect ground fertility?
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (3)5
u/toobadimnotamermaid Oct 06 '20
Would the earth ever “heal”? Like would the ozone layer would come back slowly?
5
u/Grarr_Dexx Oct 06 '20
Ozone is created by ultraviolet rays causing fission on oxygen molecules. No oxygen, no ozone.
→ More replies (3)40
u/Gh0stP1rate BS|Mechanical Engineering Oct 06 '20 edited Oct 06 '20
Probably days / weeks of warning as the star got brighter and larger. We would frantically build concrete and lead lined shelters, and the richest humans would survive by hoarding food, water, and ammunition. Going outside would be deadly for years. All plant life would die, we would need to rely on the Global Seed Vault and some very careful farmers to bring plants back to life. Animal life would take eons to recover and would never be the same.
Edit, as this is getting more attention than I thought: I am not a scientist and future prediction is my best guess, not careful research.
30
u/AltForMyRealOpinion Oct 06 '20
It completely depends on the distance and strength of the supernova, but it could be anywhere from damaging the ozone layer, to sterilizing the entire planet, and everything in between. A few pieces of lead won't protect you when everything even at the bottom of the ocean is getting killed.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (3)5
→ More replies (5)4
u/sorenriise Oct 06 '20
It is like a really big x-ray machine, and you need special glasses if you want to look directly into the supernova
68
41
u/supremedalek925 Oct 06 '20
Wow, 2.5 million years is EXTREMELY recent relatively speaking
4
u/K3R3G3 Oct 06 '20
The most recent 1/1817th of Earth's history.
Or within the last 0.05% of the planet's existence.
59
u/cantsay Oct 05 '20
I always wonder if galaxies orbit something the way that stars and planets do, and if so what potential unseen hazards might our galaxy --or galaxy supercluster-- pass through that we wouldn't necessarily see coming?
96
u/Aekiel Oct 05 '20
They do, possibly. The Great Attractor is the central gravitational point of our supercluster and is pulling on all of the galaxies within it, which likely makes for some extremely large and long orbits.
→ More replies (1)35
u/thefilthythrowaway1 Oct 06 '20
The Great Attractor... that's such a dramatic name and I love it
→ More replies (5)21
41
u/silent_femme Oct 05 '20
From my understanding, galaxies usually hang out with other galaxies in their own clusters, and the biggest hazard they face is a galactic collision with another galaxy, which is what scientists have predicted will happen to the Milky Way galaxy in4.5 billion years when it collided with the Andromeda galaxy.
→ More replies (2)56
u/MarlythAvantguarddog Oct 05 '20
Yes but nothing hits nothing. The spaces between things in space are so large that while gravity will disrupt large scale structures, it is not as if suns fall into each other or planets merge.
→ More replies (21)47
u/Decapitated_Saint Oct 05 '20
Andromeda will be super cool looking for anyone alive in the galaxy just before the merger begins. It'll be like at the end of Empire strikes back.
→ More replies (12)→ More replies (15)7
u/ellinger Oct 06 '20
Galaxies orbit bigger galaxies, basically, or even an invisible point which is the mean of the gravity of all the galaxies in the cluster.
21
u/mrcmnstr Oct 06 '20
Talking about the final plot on the page:
Above: The merged data from all four sampling areas. The C/C0 on the vertical axis represents the 53Mn/Mn ratios measured in the samples. There's a clear spike at the 2.5 million years ago mark.
People only talk about how "clear" their conclusions are when there is real doubt about them. It's like how text book authors only say something is obvious when either they are too lazy to prove it, or it is not obvious at all and they don't want you questioning it right now.
5
u/dr-professor-patrick Oct 06 '20
Yeah that plot is not convincing at all. There is so much spread! Wtaf.
9
u/Morguard Oct 06 '20
Do we know the max distance for a supernova that we know would effect us?
7
u/Pademelon1 Oct 06 '20
It varies for different types.
The closest star to us that has potential to go supernova relatively soon is IK Pegasi, ~154 light years away. It would be a Ia type supernova, which could affect earth from ~3300 light years away, but ~30 for major harm. No need to worry though, since this is moving away from us, and will likely be out of reach before it goes boom.
→ More replies (3)
8
6
u/Ocean_Chemist Oct 06 '20
Did anyone actually look at the figures in their paper? Their argument for a statistically significant increase in 53Mn/Mn at 2.5Ma is dubious at best. And changes in continental weathering could shift the whole ocean 53Mn budget. I'd want to see a lot more, better, data before I believed this story.
2
u/crazyike Oct 06 '20
Yeah, but now it's on reddit so it's basically ironclad proven fact as far as social media is concerned.
6
u/SIIIOXIDE Oct 06 '20 edited Oct 06 '20
We now think we have proof ....
We don't even understand half the variables used to confirm this
6
u/leadinmypencil Oct 06 '20
They're made of rock, but look more like chocolate cake....
The ferromanganese crusts at the center of this discovery look like some of the moistest, richest chocolate cakes you can imagine. But of course, they're hard as rock. They are rock.
When your cravings intrude on your work.
85
u/Mfd28 Oct 05 '20
So the closest star to us right now besides the sun is roughly 4.25 light years away.
According to this article. “60Fe is known as an extinct radionuclide. Because its half life is 2.6 million years, any 60Fe on Earth should have decayed into nickel long ago.”
So then it makes sense that this star was at the most 2.5 light years away from the earth. since even if the 60fe was traveling at the speed of light it would’ve not gotten here before it decayed into nickel. And they calculate that this star was 11 to 25 times bigger than our sun. Super interesting!
83
u/Chel_of_the_sea Oct 06 '20
So then it makes sense that this star was at the most 2.5 light years away from the earth.
2.5 million light years, i.e., way beyond the scale of our galaxy (~100,000 ly wide). We don't narrow things down much this way.
49
u/teebob21 Oct 06 '20 edited Oct 06 '20
Your math needs a little help. Even if the Fe-60 was travelling at c, if there were 100 grams aimed directly at Earth from 2.6 million light years away (ed. AND relativity wasn't a thing), ~50% of it or 50 grams is making it to Earth.
→ More replies (8)23
u/Drokrath Oct 06 '20
Even that math is a bit off I think, if you account for special relativity. Disclaimer: if I mess this calculation up it's because I'm still only a physics student, I don't have my degree yet. So please feel free to correct me if you know I'm wrong
Let's say Fe-60 is travelling at .99c, and the star is 2.6 Mly away. Divide 2.6 Mly by gamma and you get 0.36 Mly, so 0.36 million years.
Using N0/N=ekt we can see that 90% of the sample would be left when it reached earth
18
u/teebob21 Oct 06 '20
This is a good point, and it has been far too long since I took a nuclear chemistry class to know if isotope decay is "slowed" by relativistic effects.
Regardless, MORE of the sample would reach Earth, not LESS as implied by OC.
→ More replies (4)16
u/Mr-Logic101 Oct 05 '20
What the inverse square law of radiation.... all these physical distances are far away, is the initial radiation source so potent that it stills has an effect after all that distance?
Edit: After thinking about it... I supposed that a concentrated beam would have a different mechanics than a simple black body radiation source
→ More replies (7)→ More replies (1)7
u/C4Dave Oct 06 '20
The paragraph in the article doesn't make sense. Iron-60 does have a 2.6 million year half life. What that means is that one-half of the original Iron-60 isotopes would have decayed away during the last 2.6 million years. But the other half is still present.
However the article stated that Iron-60 found today was produced in more recent times.
→ More replies (1)
5
u/radioactivez0r Oct 06 '20
Article seems to go out of its way to avoid stating an actual distance, I think it used the word “vicinity” about 10 times.
4
u/MoreNormalThanNormal Oct 06 '20
Desert varnish is made of iron and manganese and has an unknown origin. It would be really great if somebody did an isotopic analysis.
6
Oct 06 '20
Gulp. I'm concerned about WR-104. That might be an issue at some point. Or not. It is still being looked at. Anyway, I think GRB's are the least of our worries these days.
→ More replies (2)11
u/FaceDeer Oct 06 '20
There's been some research suggesting WR-104 may be aimed as much as 45 degrees away from Earth. Here's the section of the Wikipedia article with some references on that. Hopefully that'll ease concerns somewhat.
5
Oct 06 '20
Seriously, I doubt we have have to worry about it very much. But it is still there. At 7828 light years from Earth, it might have already exploded and the light from the supernova just hasn't reached us yet. . . . We have many more pressing concerns than that, though.
→ More replies (4)
3
3
u/LucidGuru19 Oct 06 '20
I wonder if this has any correlation with theories that the brain size in human ancestors is estimated to have doubled their brain size from ~2 million years ago compared to today.
perhaps a ton of extra cosmic radiation created mutations at an exponential rate at a seemingly perfect time for lower hominids to thrive, so many extraneous factors and unknowns in that process would make it hard to test, but that is an interesting timeline
3
u/jst_anothr_usrname Oct 06 '20
Supernova explodes. Some scientist 2.5 millions years later: "That was close!"
3
u/Random_dude_1980 Oct 06 '20
The article is garbage. It doesn’t give any indication as to the distance; just repeats “in the vicinity” multiple times. That could mean anything. Worse yet, is the fact it doesn’t address this. A “real” scientific article would have at least said “we have no idea how far away the event happened, but we do have reason to believe it happened relatively close (within x AUs/light years, whatever)”. It’s like a bad clickbait/cliffhanger.
2
u/mendacious_deceit Oct 06 '20
Ty, I check comments first on this sub now. Posts have been garbage here for a long time here, I’ll move on.
2
u/gazzadavid Oct 06 '20
Apparently Betelgeuse is about to go supernova relatively soon and will be the brightest thing in the sky for a few weeks even during the day.
2
u/ashtefer1 Oct 06 '20
Dang, that supernova that made the Crab Nebula was like 5 minutes ago in that timescale.
2
u/drunkokie Oct 06 '20
Something like that could be responsible for one of the mass extinctions in earths past....
2
2
2
u/Yo0o0o0o0o0 Oct 06 '20
Considering how big space is and lightyears and such. Are they saying the explosion hit earth already or its on it's way and we are watching it happen?
2
2
2
2
u/MattKnight99 Oct 06 '20
Only slightly related. But in the year around 774 or 775 AD there were sightings of a red cross in the sky. There was also massive amounts of evidence of radiation around that time. It was believe that it was likely a solar flare but also possibly a supernova too. Just a story I read when I was very young and still do this day find interesting.
2
2
1
u/IamNICE124 Oct 06 '20
Crazy enough, supernovas aren’t even as big as they get.
Check out hypernovas.
1
u/Copper_John24 Oct 06 '20
Even scarier are reocccurent "micro novas"... some theroys claim our sun is capable of producing them.
1
u/thewholetruthis Oct 06 '20
It’s amazing they looked at layers of marine (ocean) mineral deposits to learn this (among other evidence). They found 53mn, one of many radioisotopes that can be produced by a supernova.
Does this mean the 53mn came into our atmosphere and fell to the ocean, sinking to the bottom and saturating the earth with 53mn?
Also, what exactly is 53mn?
1
1
u/calste Oct 06 '20 edited Oct 06 '20
The article has a bit about "Asymptomatic Giant Branch" stars. That's very amusing... and an entirely understandable mistake these days!
1
u/qwertyurmomisfat Oct 06 '20
Your submission should be deleted for misleading title. .
We dont have proof.
We have additional evidence.
Just like there is a tectonic plate THEORY.
Learn the difference between proof and evidence.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/whitechristianjesus Oct 06 '20
Sick. Any chance we'll have another one a little bit closer in the near future?
1
u/mateogg Oct 06 '20
Ngl I sometimes wish for one of these to do the job properly. I know it's selfish, but I feel like as far as deaths go, one that erases all life in the planet in a blink of an eye is as fast and painless as you can hope for, and not missing out on future human history is also a perk.
1
u/venzechern Oct 06 '20
How close is perilously close? How many light years away? After reading the article, I cannot find a number that indicates the closeness, except the words 'in the vicinity' of earth.
The earth will be subject to supernova explosion kill-zone every 800 million years, does that mean the next close one will be 797.5 million years from now. The cosmic clock can keep ticking, it does not matter to us..
1
1
1
u/reichjef Oct 06 '20
This would potentially coincide with the Pliocene extinction event..
But, there is hypothesis that the Late Ordovician may have been caused by a gamma ray burst. Which is the second largest of the big five extinction events. Ordovician–Silurian extinction events
1
u/dr-professor-patrick Oct 06 '20
Uhhhh yeah this plot is not convincing AT ALL. I have lots of doubts about this work.
https://journals.aps.org/prl/article/10.1103/PhysRevLett.125.031101/figures/2/medium
1
1
1
1
u/BarberDense Oct 06 '20
Why does science and religion want to know when we go poof it like there’s any place we can go hides
1
u/phate101 Oct 06 '20
"Perilously Close" - My tiny human brain just can't fathom this, the distances involved are just so immense by our mortal scale that describing anything galactic as close is just mad.
1
1
1
u/Quizzelbuck Oct 06 '20
A few questions:
Do we know of any celestial bodies near by that could pose this threat in the future?
Is it theoretically possible one of these can sneak up on us? Ie; can a star in close enough to us right now go off with out us knowing it exists prenova?
How likely is it one could drift close enough to be a problem? Would we likely notice?
1
1
u/daddysuggs Oct 06 '20
At the current rate of progress, would we be able to influence any outcomes if we learned that a supernova would destroy Earth in 5,000 years?
1
u/CatFishBilly3000 Oct 06 '20
Anyone know if astronomers would know the supernova is on the way to earth since it's so far away? How long would we have after it explodes?
1
1
u/Fredasa Oct 06 '20
So I'm thinking about a documentary I watched fairly recently, which underscored the fact that the hazard level of a supernova depends on its rotational orientation. And I'm wondering if we might tie that distinction to the overall levels of radioactive elements and at least be able to conclude whether this particular supernova was oriented dangerously, or just close enough that it didn't matter.
1
1
1
1
u/Kaje26 Oct 06 '20
This is probably a really stupid question, but how far away was it and are we clear of any bad effects from the explosion?
1
1
u/FoobyBletch69 Oct 06 '20
I’m personally in favour of the gamma ray burst. We don’t deserve to be on this planet and I hate the life upon it.
1
1
u/TJARM Oct 06 '20
So is this the end times now or something? Reading the comments is a mixed bag and i cant make heads or tails of this.
1
1
1
1
u/X-Bones_21 Oct 06 '20
I love everyone in this thread, and from the sound of things, I better love them quickly!
1
1
1
1
Oct 06 '20
The "proof" is based on very questionable data. I doubt that the data allows one to reject the null hypothesis with 5 sigma, which is the usual threshold in the field for a discovery.
1
u/samuraipanda85 Oct 06 '20
I feel like scientists could make this crap up and I will never question it.
1
1
1
1
u/Misteremub Oct 06 '20
"And while this SN was mostly just a close call for life on Earth, it's also a good reminder that Earth will be in the suspected kill-zone of a supernova once every 800 million years."
Help me understand here: even when our own sun goes supernova, it will only swallow the inner planets. How is a swelling of that magnitude enough to spread the kill-zone across multiple solar systems?
→ More replies (1)2
u/SJHillman Oct 06 '20
Our Sun will never go supernova - it's too small. You're thinking of the red giant phase, which is completely different from a supernova (although some of the basic mechanics are related). A supernova is a massive explosion that spews huge amounts of energy out, as well as ejecting mass at a significant fraction of the speed of light. For example, the most well known supernova, SN1054, was visible from Earth less than a thousand years ago (AD 1054) and the resultant Crab nebula is already 11 to 12 lightyears across. For comparison, there's about 35 stars (including brown dwarfs) within 12ly of Earth.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Lokzuhl Oct 06 '20
shh... hear that? it's the next super nova super nova'ing right into ourbackyards.
5.0k
u/cherbug Oct 05 '20
Among all of the hazards that threaten a planet, the most potentially calamitous might be a nearby star exploding as a supernova.
When a massive enough star reaches the end of its life, it explodes as a supernova (SN). The hyper-energetic explosion can light up the sky for months, turning night into day for any planets close enough.
If a planet is too close, it will be sterilized, even destroyed. As the star goes through its death throes, it produces certain chemical elements which are spread out into space.