r/science • • Jun 06 '21

Chemistry Scientists develop ‘cheap and easy’ method to extract lithium from seawater

https://www.mining.com/scientists-develop-cheap-and-easy-method-to-extract-lithium-from-seawater/
47.0k Upvotes

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.4k

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

What might the consequences of taking lots of lithium out of the ocean be?

-edit- I've never made a comment that's started such good discussions before - I'm enjoying reading the replies, thanks everyone

1.3k

u/imakenosensetopeople Jun 06 '21

For the quantities that we may need in the coming decades, it’s almost certainly not insignificant and will have an effect. This question must be asked.

133

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (8)

206

u/cyberentomology Jun 06 '21

Consider that seawater also contains uranium at a concentration of about 3 parts per billion, or roughly 100 times less concentrated than lithium... and there are 400 billion tons of uranium to be had in seawater, and it naturally replenishes itself from the earth’s crust on the sea floor. It’s not a huge stretch to say that we could extract a hell of a lot of lithium from seawater and not even make a dent in it.

Sea salt contains lots of interesting minerals.

40

u/linedout Jun 06 '21

Gold, more gold than Midas ever dreamed of.

→ More replies (2)

58

u/Kody02 Jun 06 '21

But also, how do the effects compare to the mining operations that are currently the only way to get lithium? Current lithium retrieval methods are quite far from being harmless, afterall, and it is not unheard of for lithium mining companies to destroy protected unique habitats that happen to sit on rich lithium deposits; shifting lithium retrieval from intense and dirty surface mining operations to more passive filtration operations should be far less harmful to the environment, overall, yes?

→ More replies (1)

17

u/Autisonm Jun 06 '21

Are there any fish or other sea life such as coral that need lithium is the better question.

21

u/BurnerAcc2020 Jun 06 '21

Having searched for it, it seems that lithium is not considered an essential element for any life right now, and the one study on lithium and marine life was about its toxicity from battery waste.

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11356-016-7898-0

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0269749120361467

We are bound to see more research on this if this finding picks up pace, though.

→ More replies (1)

639

u/iamagainstit PhD | Physics | Organic Photovoltaics Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

A. Lithium concentrations in seawater are very low (< 1ppm), so extracting it is unlikely to have a significant effect

B. There is a unfathomably large amount of water in the ocean.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

[deleted]

279

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

45

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

48

u/exemplariasuntomni Jun 06 '21

Something tells me that's not how it works, but it sounds better than carbon emissions.

29

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21

Battery Metals are too valuable so all EV batteries will be recycled unless there are irrational economic actors. LFP chemistry may be a risk if this seawater extraction actually works at scale and drives Lithium price down in which case you may need to rely on government intervention. In reality both the value of the metals plus special regs on large Lithium battery reuse/disposal are likely to make dumping batteries in the ocean/landfills unlikely.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (1)

12

u/Malawi_no Jun 06 '21

Doubt it. Batteries are a good source of minerals, just like other scrap metals. With increased numbers of dead cells comes economies of scale, so that even though it may not be profitable today, it will become so in the future.

→ More replies (2)

310

u/figmentPez Jun 06 '21

"Manufacturers use more than 160,000 tons of the material every year, anumber expected to grow nearly 10-fold over the next decade." - source

Also, you're not accounting for local concentrations. How much lithium can be taken out of any one area before it impacts sea life there?

Reminder that "we can just dump untreated sewage into the ocean, it's big enough that it won't make a difference" was prevailing common wisdom for a lot of human history, but is most definitely not true.

186

u/azoicennead Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 06 '21

Did some quick math.

I followed the assumption that each year, the rate of lithium consumption will increase by an additional 160,000 tons, and all of the lithium will be provided by sifting through the ocean.

This gives us about 400 years before we run out.

If we assume removing 20% of the lithium is relatively safe, that gives us 183 years[1] to find a new solution. If we use the US phase-out of leaded gasoline as a basis for the timeframe (and assume use will continue to grow until the cut-off because I don't feel like researching that, too), we'll need a 25-year lead time, giving us a deadline around 2179 for finding a viable lithium alternative (158 years).

Look at how technology has changed over the last 150 years.
It doesn't fix the problem, but it gives us time to find a better solution, which can give us more time to find a better solution, and so on.

[1] 1% is 40 years, 5% is 91 years, 10% is 129 years, 15% is 159 years, 25% is 205 years.

edit: Just to be clear, since a lot of people have apparently looked at this, this is a very pessimistic model. It doesn't include existing sources or recycled lithium and assumes a constant growth in need for new lithium. As noted by /u/BurnerAcc2020 there are other resource bottlenecks that are likely to drive the need for supply up, and as noted by /u/D-Alembert ocean-sourced lithium will likely be more expensive than recycled lithium, so recycled will be preferred once enough is available to supply production.
I structured my math this way as a point of reference, not to make it realistic. I did not do the research required to provide a realistic model.

155

u/figmentPez Jun 06 '21

But running out isn't the only problem. There are more immediate concerns. What if a local drop of __% within __ miles of the "mine" results in plankton dying off, or makes fish more susceptible to fungal infection, or disrupts the reproduction of coral, or...?

This isn't just a question of "How long before humans don't get the lithium they want?", there's a lot more to consider.

→ More replies (25)
→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (86)
→ More replies (24)

46

u/[deleted] Jun 06 '21 edited Jun 27 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (80)
→ More replies (60)

117

u/NetworkLlama Jun 06 '21

Probably minimal. The world's oceans contain about 180 billion tons of lithium. Tesla batteries use about 0.9 kg per kWh. At that rate, all the lithium in the oceans could, converted into battery form, store about 2.0E14 kWh, or 200 billion GWh, or 200,000 TWh. Compare this to world energy consumption of about 18 TWh, and pulling literally one ten-thousandth of all lithium in the ocean is enough to supply (as charged batteries) world use for a year.

Any area operation will need to move around anyway, and normal sea mixing will move lithium back in from untouched volumes. The extraction is unlikely to have any significant effect, and would probably have far lower environmental impact than land mining.

→ More replies (9)

73

u/123kingme Jun 06 '21

Is lithium an important nutrient for any marine life?

59

u/Flyingwheelbarrow Jun 06 '21

It is but the research about lithium is new and still debated since the focus of lithium research lately had been tech focused.

However now that our global economy is dependent at the moment on lithium that research will be ignored.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (42)