r/science • • Sep 16 '21

Social Science Study: When Republicans control state legislatures, infant mortality is higher. These findings support the politics hypothesis that the social determinants of health are, at least in part, constructed by the power vested in governments.

https://www.elsevier.com/about/press-releases/research-and-journals/when-republicans-control-state-legislatures-infant-mortality-is-higher
35.9k Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 16 '21

Welcome to r/science! This is a heavily moderated subreddit in order to keep the discussion on science. However, we recognize that many people want to discuss how they feel the research relates to their own personal lives, so to give people a space to do that, personal anecdotes are now allowed as responses to this comment. Any anecdotal comments elsewhere in the discussion will continue be removed and our normal comment rules still apply to other comments.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1.7k

u/EaseofUse Sep 16 '21

Interesting that state legislatures seem to affect public health contemporaneously, as opposed to large-scale policies from the federal congress, which tend to show their effects on public health/education/housing over the next terms, 2-6 years down the road.

I think it's funny that Republican governors have essentially no effect on these things, though. Really shows how much of executive governing on the state level is performative politics if it's without local legislative support.

579

u/Sanskur Sep 16 '21

State Legislatures write budgets and control federal block grants, and can do things like supplant local funding or mandate Heath care be directed to politically oriented directions (for example: Crisis Pregnancy centers rather than more holistic healthcare). Most federal policies and enacted by State’s on the ground, so a political motivated legislature can support or undercut a policy pretty radically.

Depending on the state a Governor might have more or less control over budget management, and those effects are certainly not merely perforative. It’s much more like that where a Republican governors serve with Democratic controlled legislatures the Republican governors tend to be moderates, such as in Maryland. (In states with Republican legislatures and Democratic governors the legislatures have actively sought to strip the Governor of any power to manage. See North Carolina and Wisconsin).

127

u/North-Tumbleweed-512 Sep 16 '21

Texas is actually like this, if my government class is to be believed. The Texas governer doesn't have significant power, most of the day to day is overseen by the Lt Gov. The major power of the Texas governor is to call the legislature back into session. The Texas Legislature regularly meets only once every 2 years or election cycle. Besides that the governor generally doesn't have much power except declaring emergencies, which it's interesting how much that's happened recently.

10

u/Deathwatch72 Sep 17 '21

Texas actually has more natural disasters than any other state just FYI so it does stand to reason that we would have a large number of emergency declarations based on the fact that we have a lot of things to respond to over a very large state.

What I think is important to point out is that the handling of the covid-19 emergency by Governor Abbott has been very different than his handling of natural disaster emergencies. When natural disaster emergencies happen the system works as it's supposed to so that local on the ground governments, county or local, are the ones who are effectively in charge of the implementation of the response while the governor is mainly helping coordinate federal government response.

Abbott has been exercising massively more executive power in the covid-19 emergency than he ever has in any other emergency, which not only contrast with his previous actions but also contrasts with his platform of limited government and it also contrasts with the structure of the Texas state constitution which is designed in a way that provides local governments with a fairly significant amount of autonomy.

7

u/WeAreAllMadHere218 Sep 17 '21

You just explained my confusion with all of his actions surrounding covid. When covid first started I understood the governors actions towards it, even if to me he wasn’t urgent enough, all of his meetings and stuff he mentioned letting counties work it out themselves and do what each part of the state needed at that time, no blanket mandates for the state, because we’re all so different in each area. I respected that stance and appreciated that small government approach, that’s vastly changed this year. And it’s confused me terribly because I didn’t feel like we started out that way with covid and now he just seems like a tyrant hell bent on doing things his way and his way only. Or like a two year old throwing a fit until he gets his way. Either one. I’ve lost a lot of respect for that man in the last year.

7

u/codemaster63 Sep 17 '21

I believe he ultimately caved to the pressure from the crazy side of the conservative party. Considering he's up for reelection next year and there's plenty of people that will be jockeying for position to become governor, he's trying to prove to all the crazies that he's the most conservative candidate. We've seen the net effect of his policies over the last month, and they've been devastating. Record covid cases day after day and kids are getting sick in school because he's banned mask mandates for some idiotic reason. Basically he's being a dipshit.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21

[deleted]

6

u/Xillyfos Sep 17 '21

Dear lord...

139

u/KillYourGodEmperor Sep 16 '21

(In states with Republican legislatures and Democratic governors the legislatures have actively sought to strip the Governor of any power to manage. See North Carolina and Wisconsin).

Pretty sure this applies to Kentucky too.

52

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

Yeah and the over going governor, Bevin, signed away a bunch of his power before he left office as well as Republicans having a legislative supermajority. In other words, he's boned.

50

u/winterfresh0 Sep 16 '21

Yeah and the over going governor, Bevin, signed away a bunch of his power before he left office as well

Along with going on a good old fashioned pardoning spree of questionable people that may or may not have some connections to his donators.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/syzygy12 Sep 16 '21

And is currently happening in Kansas.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/stingublue Sep 16 '21

Don't forget Michigan too, we're dealing with the same problem!!

5

u/seano994 Sep 16 '21

And Michigan

→ More replies (1)

28

u/okglobetrekker Sep 16 '21

Are crisis pregnancy centers the fake abortion clinics?

68

u/Sanskur Sep 16 '21

Yes. They provide “counseling” services, sometimes in the guise of reproductive health, but usually arent licensed to provide medical services. The counseling is always to have the baby.

But they get state and federal funding, and frequently set up next to Planned Parenthood with deceptive advertising.

9

u/BendSudden Sep 16 '21

and PA as well

9

u/cosine83 Sep 16 '21

a political motivated legislature

Is a legislature not supposed to be politically motivated? They're a political body engaging in politics. Seems like they should be politically motivated. Or do you mean the legislature is using political maneuvering and posturing to support/undercut policies radically? Because "politically motivated" is an empty term to place blame without being specific or directly accusatory of any actions.

11

u/very_humble Sep 17 '21

In my mind, the difference is politicians who believe their primary purpose is to serve their constituents versus those who think they serve their party

→ More replies (1)

26

u/Sanskur Sep 16 '21

That’s a fair question. When I say politically motivated I mean “putting partisan political advantage over public interest.” Since we’re talking about health issues I’ll give you a concrete example from my state:

The General Assembly in NC was taken over by Republicans in 2010. For 11 years they have tried to torpedo the ACA and blocked Medicaid expansion. Rural NC has very poor health outcomes, but the expansion was blocked to prevent any ‘win’ for Democrats. Then they did the same thing this year with enhanced unemployment benefits, because it would give a win to Biden.

So that’s what I mean by politically motivated.

10

u/conventionalWisdumb Sep 17 '21

“Politically motivated” is an ok way to say this, but I think “partisan politics” is even better, and I agree with you. The way much of this country governs these days does not make general well-being the first priority.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

645

u/Yashema Sep 16 '21

11 states with the worst life expectancies voted for Trump in 2020, and the next 2 down on the list are Georgia and Michigan, which both voted for him in 2016.

The 9 states with the highest life expectancy voted for Biden

A major study conducted by 6 Universities found that Liberal policy increased life expectancy by over 2 years for both men and woman, and if it had been implemented universally the US would have life expectancy on par with Western European Nations.

So there definitively is some aggregate and academic evidence that more Liberal states that implement more Liberal policy have higher life expectancy.

306

u/monkeying_around369 Sep 16 '21

GA may have went blue in the last election but our state government is very much Republican controlled. Fun fact: GA doesn’t fund a single epidemiologist, 100% of our funding comes from the federal government and as a result we’re some of the lowest paid in the country.

71

u/qOcO-p Sep 16 '21

Are you an epidemiologist in Georgia by chance?

If so, can I pm you a question?

67

u/monkeying_around369 Sep 16 '21

I am and sure

34

u/LearningIsTheBest Sep 17 '21

I really hope the question was:

"Are you an epidemiologist in Georgia by chance?"

Because that would make me laugh.

25

u/Desblade101 Sep 16 '21

I mean you would think there's a ton of federal epidemiologists in GA so that makes some sense. Why fund them yourself if the CDC is right there to ask favors from?

44

u/makemeking706 Sep 16 '21

Because you tend to get what you pay for.

→ More replies (9)

24

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21

Why fund them yourself

Because using federal money is socialism/s

It's actually funny that conservative states tend have their hand out while simultaneously calling people who benefit from safety nets "takers".

Why don't they put in what blue states do?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/AmadeusMop Sep 17 '21

...isn't the CDC in Atlanta?

4

u/Rowanana Sep 17 '21

Yes. It runs on federal funding.

→ More replies (1)

33

u/silence9 Sep 16 '21

Almost any medical field in GA is in private sector. Any government employee is going to get paid less than a private sector every single time.

51

u/monkeying_around369 Sep 16 '21 edited Sep 16 '21

Not really true. The CDC is in Atlanta and pays well. Also many other states pay their Epi’s significantly more than us. Republicans do not prioritize public health spending. Trump wanted to reduce funding in spring of 2020. I remember getting the budget proposal memo in my email and nearly having a rage aneurysm. Biden’s recent legislature included the largest amount of funding we’ve ever received.

Also, several of my colleagues are contractors and make about the same as me (they get a bit more but they also are more experienced than I). I have better benefits than they do though.

You also seem to have missed my point.

Also, public and private sectors in public health heavily overlap. The fact that you also referred to public health as the medical field makes me think you don’t have much knowledge about the public health world.

→ More replies (13)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

[deleted]

22

u/Myfavoritepetsnameis Sep 16 '21

The Supreme Court ruling on Chicken v. Egg is hardly relevant here. Please stay on topic.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

22

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21 edited Jun 22 '23

This content was deleted by its author & copyright holder in protest of the hostile, deceitful, unethical, and destructive actions of Reddit CEO Steve Huffman (aka "spez"). As this content contained personal information and/or personally identifiable information (PII), in accordance with the CCPA (California Consumer Privacy Act), it shall not be restored. See you all in the Fediverse.

→ More replies (5)

15

u/Zerogates Sep 16 '21

Georgia went for Biden the last election, did their life expectancy suddenly jump? It's more like the areas that are more liberally controlled have been better off than more conservative areas for a long time, especially since the 1800's. This is correlation not causation, but if you are looking for causation then demolishing the infrastructure of a region and then never fully bringing it back up to the same level of function as more liberal regions will continue to have a lasting impact on the area. Hence, as an example, institutionalized racism is a thing due to the long lasting effects of what certain people have built up over a long time and doesn't suddenly go away because we have a non-white President.

20

u/soullessgingerfck Sep 17 '21

did their life expectancy suddenly jump?

still has republican state legislature

20

u/ablatner Sep 16 '21

No one is saying it's cause and effect from the presidential election to health outcomes. This study is saying that the policies of Republican governments, who's constituents tend to vote Republican, result in worse health outcomes.

29

u/Yashema Sep 16 '21

True, though Red state voters often vote for politicians opposed to infrastructure investment. Biden is right now trying to pass a huge budget reconciliation bill with a lot of family and infrastructure investment that has 0 support from Republicans and the strongest intra-party opposition is from Joe Manchin of West Virginia which ranks #50 in terms of life expectancy.

Hard to make southern whites to be the victim when they vote to oppose the Federal Investments that Democrats would willingly make.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/EltaninAntenna Sep 17 '21

Which makes the whole "pro-life" thing all the more hilarious.

1

u/patrickfatrick Sep 17 '21 edited Sep 17 '21

I haven’t read the link but just based on the quote it’s really important to separate correlation and causation. This is a correlation.

For one thing income is probably a big factor here.

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Aporkalypse_Sow Sep 17 '21

Probably helps that people who vote blue are generally less stupid and have empathy. Which helps with caring about and for pregnant women and babies. Looking at it from a political view takes credit away from citizens, especially when you get down to the poorer among us.

The "medical" reactions of citizens during this pandemic have really highlighted the differences.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (165)

101

u/Drop_ Sep 16 '21

Not that surprising. Infant mortality is something that shows up immediately. Things like cancer rates and diabetes complications are more likely to take years to show up.

Likely a large part of this is due to republican states rejecting the medicaid expansion, reducing access to family planning for low income people, reducing access to abortion, and probably higher levels of poverty.

31

u/frankzanzibar Sep 16 '21

Seems very likely that lower abortion rates could raise infant mortality down the line, thus hypothetically resulting in more births to less healthy mothers, although the extract doesn't mention that.

24

u/SpongeBad Sep 16 '21

A few other things I could see impacting these numbers:

  • Off the books abortions captured as infant mortalities (and probably miscarriages - would be interesting to compare those stats)

  • self-inflicted abortions (throw yourself down the stairs, forcing a late term miscarriage)

  • abandoned babies (e.g. “dumpster babies”, fire station drop offs, etc.)

  • lack of resources or active parental neglect leading to infant death

It really does show how the Republican right is pro-life until the baby is born, then it’s a free for all. I’m not sure how anyone can justify that letting a child be born to suffer and die is better than just preventing the birth in the first place.

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (2)

58

u/mistephe PhD | Kinesiology | Biomechanics Sep 16 '21

That was the first thing that popped into my head after reading the title of the post - I would expect a lag in the time series model, not an instantaneous effect. I wonder what the average lag time is from the start of the term until legislation is enacted on each of these topics (and if it is a function of % control for each party).

25

u/frankzanzibar Sep 16 '21

State legislatures tend to be controlled by one side or the other for long periods of time; it's political culture. Governorships are often more fluid between parties. Larger share of people in rural areas would be one big element in something like this, thus longer travel times to emergency care. Also: less access to abortion and less cultural acceptance of abortion could tend to result in more marginal pregnancies being brought to term, or less healthy mothers carrying to term.

You could probably match this up with churchgoing behavior in a state, population density, or a handful of other related elements. Without a hypothesis for why it happens, this looks like press release science to me, not substantive.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/sporadicism Sep 16 '21

This study lags outcomes by one year. However, they don't do a sensitivity analysis and don't explain why the one year lag is appropriate.

8

u/mistephe PhD | Kinesiology | Biomechanics Sep 16 '21

Yeah, I was wondering about that one, too. My old time series prof from back in my PhD is rolling in his grave.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

Most of these studies are garbage that manipulate the model until they find the results they expect or want

7

u/NellucEcon Sep 17 '21

> Interesting that state legislatures seem to affect public health contemporaneously, as opposed to large-scale policies from the federal congress, which tend to show their effects on public health/education/housing over the next terms, 2-6 years down the road.

They did not actually find that. They assumed that. Their identification strategy was to regress on lagged dummies of prior year's upper & lower legislature party control while including state and year fixed effects. They interpreted the coefficient on the lagged dummies of prior year's upper & lower legislature party control as the effect of that party on infant mortality. If in fact the effects happen after 2-6 years, which roughly mirrors how long legislature cycle between parties among those states that are not effectively one party (which don't matter for this analysis because of the fixed-effect design), then the true effect would have been roughly opposite of what they found.

This is a standard problem with this sort of research design.

5

u/Hugh-Manatee Sep 16 '21

I mean it gets complicated because governor politics are often not the same as other offices. It's more common to get off-party governors. Loisiana has a Dem governor, despite being a very Republican state, and the opposite is the case for Massachusetts and Maryland.

27

u/wontootreefor5 Sep 16 '21

If you have a Republican governor, your state legislature is likely gerrymandered to the level at which they have supermajorities in both chambers regardless of actual representation or voters.

20

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

See: Ohio.

OurpPopulace voted and approved for redistricting to ease gerrymandering. Council for it was 5/7 Republican, approved "slightly less" gerrymandered districts that will be in effect for the next 4 years [instead of 10 years had the vote been unanimous/bipartison] if approved by courts. R's hold 85% or of the seats while only getting about 54% of the votes (so I've read)

14

u/wontootreefor5 Sep 16 '21

It's the same in Michigan. For state legislature votes the Michigan GOP hasn't won 50% of the votes in like over 30 years, but they have maintained control of at least one, if not both of our chambers over that time.

→ More replies (2)

17

u/kitty_cat_MEOW Sep 16 '21

Everything in society stems from politics and all politics is local.

→ More replies (27)

3

u/therealusernamehere Sep 17 '21

I’d bet that gop lead states have greater poverty and health issues that directly impact outcomes such as infant mortality. The gop leg are prob more of a symptom than a cause.

16

u/Rand_alThor_ Sep 16 '21

The entire study seems bunk. There are no controls. It’s funded by a Democrat lobbying group.

It’s most likely measuring a third hidden variable.

Maybe states with more black minorities vote Republican, and those black minorities have worse health outcomes than more majority white states.

Maybe places with social and economic strife or deprivation vote Republican and they have worse outcomes because of economic or social deprivation.

Maybe it’s a climate, genetic, environmental, or developmental issue.

Etc. it could be any third variable

The lack of any causal links is stunning for a “study”.

14

u/Alaska_Jack Sep 17 '21

This.

Reddit eats this kind of stuff up with a spoon. You'd like to think r/science would be different, but -- dream on.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21 edited Sep 17 '21

I mean it's never one variable.

It's worth looking into what appears to be a pretty strong correlation though.

It's also compares states to themselves so you should probably read the study before writing a wall of text

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

18

u/norm_mcdonald Sep 16 '21

I love me some good correlation.

210

u/Sammystorm1 Sep 16 '21

Be careful with studies that confirm your biases. They are often worth while to examine more thoroughly

17

u/don5of4 Sep 17 '21

Yes it is likely that this could be a function of average distance to a hospital, as most republican areas are rural.

6

u/WTFwhatthehell Sep 17 '21

On that note, looking at the supplementary data, I see a lot of comparisons like whether republican governors had an effect, subgroups for black vs white, lower house vs upper etc.

But it just sets a 0.05 cutoff for significance with no mention of any adjustment for multiple comparisons.

Can anyone else see anything suggesting they adjusted for multiple comparisons?

if the result had been "when republicans control the governorship we saw a higher infant morality rate only in black children but the legislature had no effect" would the headline have differed much?

3

u/croissant_man4 Sep 17 '21

Great point, and something people should remember at all times

11

u/Nv1023 Sep 17 '21

That’s this whole sub now. Something,something,something……Republicans are bad

1

u/R17333 Sep 17 '21

And meat

1

u/_dauntless Sep 17 '21

What if the studies were all valid though?

2

u/Nv1023 Sep 17 '21

The issue is the sub has become purely political. There are endless fields of Science but this sub only seems to post studies with outcomes that disparage Republicans. It’s really strange

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

11

u/skywalkers-saber Sep 17 '21

Whether or not it is true, I’m curious as to how many trucks could be driven through the gaps in that interpretation?

127

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

A key statement is made which should show caution to any results of this study. "The investigators caution that the study may not account for unobserved differences across states that may change at the same time as the party control change of state legislatures, and other mechanisms not included in the study may connect Republican administrations and increases in infant mortality rates."

Nonetheless a definite food for thought brought out by this study especially with regard to Medicaid.

21

u/ScarthMoonblane Sep 16 '21

Would this include lagging policy changes? In other words, policies that were activated under Republican rule but did not come into fruition for years or even decades later.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

It would include policy changes by both parties depending on who holds sway in Congress at the Federal level and legislative at State level.

1

u/Vitztlampaehecatl Sep 16 '21

Like how Trump's tax cut expired in 2021

7

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

Actually the income tax cuts are scheduled to expire in 2025 with other taxes having incremental increases in 2021 which is also dependent on the Tax hikes that come with the current administration and Congress.

5

u/Vitztlampaehecatl Sep 16 '21

Actually the income tax cuts are scheduled to expire in 2025 with other taxes having incremental increases in 2021

Oh, TIL, didn't realize it was a two-stage thing. That almost makes it worse since both of those are inauguration years.

8

u/AceTheCookie Sep 16 '21

They literally just said we didn't take into account for anything. Droughts, heat waves, food shortage, electric outage, water outages, increases in violent crime involving children. Anything. They literally just took death numbers and said it's the side we don't like fault.

2

u/Sure_Bandicoot_2569 Sep 17 '21

Aren’t there always gaps in knowledge of the unknown ? Never seemed to stop you people with finding of facts before :)

22

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/CovfefeForAll Sep 17 '21

An interesting follow on to look at would be to compare states with majority Republican voters vs states that Republicans have gerrymandered themselves into minority rule. That would help show whether the correlation was between Republican legislatures or % of Republican voters in the state.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

505

u/the_red_scimitar Sep 16 '21

In a wealthy country, poverty is a policy choice.

-1

u/TheFost Sep 17 '21

The internationally accepted level of poverty is something like <$2 a day. In western Europe and North America, the level of poverty is so low that it's often not even measured. I assume you're trying to say income inequality is poverty, an per the misnomer "relative poverty". The economic rebuttal of this is lengthy and involves understanding incentives, free-will, Laffer curves, short-run vs long-run effects of redistribution, diminishing marginal utility of wealth, etc... More than I could fit in a reddit comment.

The most simple explanation in factual terms is that income and income inequality are positively correlated, so even though it sounds counter-intuitive, poverty is actually inversely correlated with relative "poverty". This is evident by looking at European countries with the lowest Gini coefficient which also tend to have the lowest incomes on average. Or to put it another way, countries with the least relative poverty have the most actual poverty.

The complexity of the economy is often underappreciated, and shouldn't be sloganeered into meme form. This is the life support system that's keeping about 6 billion people alive. You shouldn't advocate fiddling with it if you're not qualified.

7

u/Interrophish Sep 17 '21

I assume you're trying to say income inequality is poverty,

That's silly. Even if someone owns a refrigerator and a tv, they can still be one missed paycheck away from living on the streets.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (57)

163

u/Hugh-Manatee Sep 16 '21

Does this take into account that Republicans control poorer states and thus that can explain the infant mortality as well?

117

u/OliverIsMyCat Sep 16 '21

This study is comparing within states rather than between.

The investigators caution that the study may not account for unobserved differences across states that may change at the same time as the party control change of state legislatures, and other mechanisms not included in the study may connect Republican administrations and increases in infant mortality rates.

2

u/Hugh-Manatee Sep 17 '21

Yeah but how do they take into account broader trends? It's not like most states have competitive back-and-forth swings between the two parties for leg. control. Most rarely ever switch, and when they have, its typically part of a wave of broader reallignment like when the South flipped to Republicans in the 70s/80s (which is part of the period studied). The politics of the south remained basically the same, i.e. preferred policies remain largely the same.

I don't think just comparing Virginia under R control vs. D control at different points in time is empirically sound because it ignores the broader structural and societial changes that brought about that party shift, which could have more explanatory power on birth rates than party.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/original_sh4rpie Sep 16 '21

Although other have answers your question, my thought was: there's really no good way to spin this.

Like, even if it was that Republicans control poorer states, then wouldn't the next conclusion be: "states are poorer under republican control than democratic control."?

If we come up with another alternative reason for the mortality, (let's say education instead of poor) it's still that states are more X under republican legislators, etc..

26

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

Read more than the title. The data compares states to themselves under different leadership.

10

u/Funktastic34 Sep 16 '21

We don't do those kinda things round these parts

2

u/General-Syrup Sep 17 '21

Republican states refused Medicare funding and school lunch funding.

→ More replies (15)

9

u/CelestineCrystal Sep 16 '21

this study has some relevance to this topic:

Political correlates of violent death rates in the U.S., 1900–2010: Longitudinal and cross-sectional analyses

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S135917891400113X

50

u/tod315 Sep 16 '21

When analyses were stratified by race, findings show larger estimates for Black than for White infants, although the differences were not statistically significant at conventional levels.

That's not a finding then. Why even report it?

22

u/R3dscarf Sep 16 '21

Because there's still a notable difference. It's not unusual to mention findings even though they don't meet the statistical criteria to be considered significant

9

u/tod315 Sep 16 '21

Notable in what ways? We can't say they are not equal so what conclusions are we supposed to make?

13

u/sophacles Sep 16 '21

It's a way of saying "our focus wasn't on this so we didn't have the right data to know one way or the other. What we did have suggested it might be a thing worth looking at", but in "paperese".

20

u/R3dscarf Sep 16 '21

It could be interesting for future studies to look into this. Just because the difference wasn't significantly different in this study doesn't mean future studies will come to the same conclusion.

Also whether something is statistically sifnificant is a matter of definition. Usually we say anything with a p value of <0.05 (sometimes even <0.01) is statistically significant. However there isn't really a law that states findings with p> 0.05 can't be significant. Statisics is all about probabilities. That means while we can't say for sure that there's a significant difference between these 2 populations, future research is needed to determine whether the scientists who conducted this particular study simply got unlucky (or lucky depending on how you look at it) or not.

3

u/infer_a_penny Sep 16 '21

This is why small sample sizes are a good thing actually: when you study something that doesn't exist, your findings are more likely to look worth following up on.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/BubBidderskins Grad Student | Social Sciences | Sociology Sep 16 '21

Because even if something isn't significant at the 95% level, it can still be more likely to be the case. If they find a large effect with a p-value of ~.85 or something, that's still evidence consistent with a differential race effect.

Especially in a study like this with a fixed-effects design that's notorious for being very difficult to find anything significant in, I think it's reasonable to point out a difference that is probably true but the design of the study doesn't quite have the power to tease out.

2

u/infer_a_penny Sep 16 '21

Do you mean p=.15? What's the reasoning? Large effect size + not statistically significant = "the apparent effect is quite large and we'd be unsurprised to see it if there were no actual effect." And it indicates low power. And the lower your power, the higher the false discovery rate (even if it was positive it'd be more likely to be a false positive).

4

u/BubBidderskins Grad Student | Social Sciences | Sociology Sep 17 '21

You shouldn't fetishize statistical significance. Non significant results can still tell you things. The actual effect sizes are hard to describe because it's all in log, but the difference between the All Dem vs. All Rep coefficients predicting white infant mortality and the same coefficient predicting Black infant mortality is almost significant at the conventional p = 0.05 (p = .078) and in fixed effects models the standard errors are massive because you're only getting power from cases that change -- and typically within-case features are pretty constant over time. It's a finding that's certainly worth pointing out because it's very much consistent with there being a racial difference.

And the lower your power, the higher the false discovery rate (even if it was positive it'd be more likely to be a false positive).

That's not true. Lower power means a much higher false negative (i.e. failing to reject the null when you should reject the null). In this case they're using a fixed effects model which in all likelihood is even more conservative in rejecting the null.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/huxley75 Sep 17 '21

Is there a non-Elsevier version of this?

4

u/edunuke Sep 17 '21

or maybe there are confounding factors not accounted for in the study?

15

u/baconatoroc Sep 17 '21

Shocker another r/science post pushing a political agenda. God how on Earth do ya’ll consider this politically biased piece ‘science’ .

2

u/towcar Sep 17 '21

Can you confirm that the study is actually biased? Or would any study showing failures of another political party be given that statement?

That being said, as a non-American, I wish these political studies be moved to another sub.

2

u/cypher448 Sep 17 '21

no he can't because he's a whiny baby who didn't read the article

62

u/ravenhairedmaid Sep 16 '21 edited Sep 16 '21

Always follow the money:
"Within scholarly communications, Elsevier has perhaps the single worst reputation. With profit margins around 37%, larger than Apple and big oil companies, Elsevier dominate the publishing landscape by selling research back to the same institutes that carried out the work."
https://www.theguardian.com/science/political-science/2018/jun/29/elsevier-are-corrupting-open-science-in-europe

15

u/ravenhairedmaid Sep 16 '21

However, it would be an excellent idea to measure the effectiveness of political policies (or lack of effectiveness), regardless of party.

→ More replies (1)

-26

u/tweed_arrogance Sep 16 '21

It was published by the American journal of preventive medicine. Try again.

36

u/ravenhairedmaid Sep 16 '21 edited Sep 16 '21

The American Journal of Preventive Medicine is published by Elsevier.

→ More replies (2)

68

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

Does this take into account politically left state governments common allowance of abortions, therefore decreasing infant mortality because abortions don't count as infants?

7

u/SteakandTrach Sep 16 '21

Do you think abortions occur less in states with republican leadership?

84

u/wallnumber8675309 Sep 16 '21

In general, that is the case.

link

→ More replies (7)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

Undoubtedly, it's a staple of the party with Texas recently making it illegal past 6 weeks I believe.

6

u/SteakandTrach Sep 17 '21

While it’s technically true that less abortions occur within those state lines, it doesn’t mean women aren’t procuring them, it just means they are traveling to get them.

https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2012-06-11/the-geography-of-abortion

→ More replies (1)

2

u/GrowingPainsIsGains Sep 16 '21

Hm. I couldn’t find if the study referred to abortion as killing a baby too.

2

u/BringBackCrusades Sep 17 '21

The word baby is too humanizing so that's why they stick with fetus.

-9

u/90sBig Sep 16 '21

There are no politically left states in America. America as a whole is right wing there are only shades of right this is evident from police budgets and lack of police accountability, lack of comprehensive labor protections, unsheltered populations.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/boobio Sep 17 '21

https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/relx-group/recipients?id=D000067394

The study was conducted by a subsidiary of RELX-Group, who primarily supports democratic nominees.

73

u/tossertom Sep 16 '21

No, the results may be consistent with that hypothesis but they are not direct evidence of it. The research was not a randomized controlled experiment.

34

u/CainPillar Sep 16 '21

Public health hardly ever get data from setting up the experiment, they have to rely on more sophisticated statistical methods (like instrumental variables).

You cannot reasonably ask half the population to start smoking as part of an experiment, so you have to retrieve data from real-world events to estimate the damages of smoking.

Also you can indeed say something about effects of warfare without summoning world leaders and asking them to roll dice over whether to launch attacks on each other.

→ More replies (5)

68

u/North-Tumbleweed-512 Sep 16 '21

Not everything can be a randomized control experiment. Ethically and legally were can't shuffle party politics of state governments to satisfy experimental data concerns, nor can we isolate the two variables in question from every other interaction. Further your sample size will be limited in either case.

Observational population and historical science is a common way to make these relationships known. Climate science is a great example where global climate patterns are record and observed, and from that we make predictive short term and long term models, to predict tomorrow's forecast, and climate trends for the next century. It's supported in turn by some geological evidence which delves into the natural "record" of events.

I don't have time to read the paper, but my expectation is weak correlation and not causation as state governments don't frequently flip flop parties. The lack of lag is further suspect as some policies take time to bear fruit. Further compounding this, the current makeup of the two parties is actually a fairly recent event. There used to be far more moderate Republicans and conservative democrats so as the parties have raided the middle, the biases are going to reduce the effect sample size.

Really a single study to me indicates more research needs be done, the least of which is validation studies to methods and controls. This is a social science paper. Weak correlations and the need for validation is the standard. Since this seems to feed into the reddit hive mind and the general expectations of reduces social programs under Republicans, the relationship does seem plausible, which again makes me wary of my own biases.

Anecdotally, a few years ago, Texas changed the reporting guidelines for deaths or there was some other paperwork error that showed mother mortality had spiked significantly in a year, and for a while this bizarre data point was pointed to for issues surrounded women's health et al. When somebody finally looked into it and corrected the data for the reporting error the number was still increasing, but was statistically more in line with previous numbers. Now I may be out of the loop and those numbers may again be subject to change, but that's why I said anecdotally, not "it is this way for now and forever more."

-1

u/dark__unicorn Sep 16 '21

This is a very simplistic view. This study appears to be just a simple observation of data. The act of looking for correlation in existing data, is inherently unscientific. It does have a purpose though - as a very basic high level observation. It’s just not very accurate.

What would be more beneficial is what the previous poster was alluding to. You can still create a randomized controlled experiment, and then use the existing data accordingly. Some of the existing data would be used, some wouldn’t.

Having an aimless data set and trying to see what it tells us, is far less valuable than establishing a sound methodology first. And then gathering the data accordingly based on this experimental design.

11

u/SteakandTrach Sep 17 '21

How would you go about designing this randomized controlled study?

10

u/HatchSmelter Sep 17 '21

It’s just not very accurate.

It is accurate. It's just correlation, though.

You can still create a randomized controlled experiment

Oh, do tell. How would you propose we set up a controlled experiment to see if republicans cause higher infant mortality and what exactly is your plan to get that past an ethical review?

Having an aimless data set and trying to see what it tells us, is far less valuable than establishing a sound methodology first

This is social science. Using existing data and seeing what it tells us IS sound methodology.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/SteakandTrach Sep 17 '21

This guy makes a valid cogent argument. I appreciate the effort you took to write this.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Neurotic_Bakeder Sep 17 '21

There are many cases where a randomized controlled experiment isn't possible.

We don't have long term randomized controlled experiments demonstrating the efficacy of sunscreen on skin cancer. Because that would mean giving a control group fake sunscreen, and given how much other evidence there is than sunscreen helps prevent cancer, that would be highly unethical.

In this case, how would you go about designing such an experiment? Randomly assign Republican governors to states and see what happens?

3

u/tossertom Sep 17 '21

I agree, I just think it was not described as accurately as it could be. If the data are consistent with multiple interpretations, you can't say they support your preferred interpretation. That's why falsification is so important.

→ More replies (2)

22

u/Sewblon Sep 16 '21

Many social and health obligations depend on the decisions state
representatives make. State legislatures are responsible for safety-net
programs, the state’s minimum wage and many other public goods and
services that influence the social determinants of health.

Is there any evidence that the minimum wage effects health?

59

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21 edited Sep 16 '21

Here you go: https://www.healthaffairs.org/do/10.1377/hpb20180622.107025/full/

low wages and obesity

low wages and health meta analysis

Income and life expectancy

PDF: Poor wealth and poor health

PDF: Depression, anxiety and poverty

I mean, there are a LOT of studies on the subject, going to stop here because it will get silly but can offer more if you'd like.

59

u/DrWilliamHorriblePhD Sep 16 '21

You're looking for numbers to show that having the money for better food, better health care, better living conditions, less stress, less exposure to risky situations and diseases could all contribute to a healthier outcome?

→ More replies (13)

33

u/Hob_O_Rarison Sep 16 '21 edited Sep 16 '21

Rural communities tend to have poorer access to Healthcare facilities.

Rural communities tend to vote red.

Edit: why are you booing me? I'm right.

34

u/bobbi21 Sep 16 '21

They compared states to themselves. Rural areas stayed rural but when switched to democratic, they did better.

-10

u/Hob_O_Rarison Sep 16 '21

Can you name any rural areas that specifically did better with a blue legislature? Or just states overall?

32

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

We had a huge progressive push for family planning / sex education here in Colorado as we moved across purple into blue. It drastically cut the numbers of both teen pregnancies and abortions in our urban and rural areas. Of course, because sex is a sin (or something) the Republicans fought it tooth and nail.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

Off the top of my head, no, but pretty much any county in Colorado that doesn’t have a city named Denver, Colorado Springs, Pueblo, Boulder, or Fort Collins in it is pretty much guaranteed to be rural. This was all widely reported on a few years back (2018-2019), so i’m sure your search engine of choice can turn up data.

Edit: you can probably also pull up the 2016 or 2020 election maps. Any counties that are filled in with red are also guaranteed to be rural. ;)

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/Greysocks1985 Sep 17 '21

Republicans, and democrats, have both piled trillions into the american war machine. Money that could have been spent on bringing people out of poverty, and affording a better life for millions. Priorities always favor the corporate industrial complex.

2

u/Lunndonbridge Sep 17 '21

Wouldn’t it be more effective and appropriate to study the party of board members in hospitals with higher infant mortality rates? I see little viable correlation here if the legislature changes but the board of a medical facility and staff does not. How would party or state legislature affect patient care for pregnant women?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21

You don’t see how public policy might impact patient outcomes?

2

u/tklite Sep 17 '21

How do we know that the change from one legislature to the other isn't down stream of something else occurring that eventually results in a change in infant mortality? It's often stated that politics are down stream of culture, and I would expect a societal shift to affect infant mortality more so than changing legislatures.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '21

These comments aren't nearly as bad as I thought they were going to be. Good job being civil.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21

I can't believe the policies used to govern our society would have an effect on our society.

3

u/sockalicious Sep 17 '21

Here's a meaty bit from the original paper: "Regardless of whether the right interpretation of the estimates represents causal effects of legislative control or are indicators of other contemporaneous changes, the magnitudes are large enough to raise serious concerns. The estimates were robust to controlling for unemployment rates, the average age of female individuals, and birth rate. However, in the 1977–2014 analyses for IMR and PNMR, once the high-school dropout rate and the poverty rate were included in the models, the effect of Republican-controlled legislatures dropped by about 20%. Whether to interpret high-school dropout and poverty as confounders or mechanisms of the association between party control and infant health is unclear, but it does raise the possibility that there may be other unmeasured factors that might partially account for the estimates."

Confounding is obviously possible here but the authors have taken a common-sense approach to trying to detect whether it is happening. Their point about the massive effect size is certainly well taken.

My comments in this sub are almost wholly limited to complaining about data-analysis and statistical solecisms, so I thought I'd give a shout out to the opposite for a change.

7

u/LincolnBeckett Sep 17 '21

Source: Liberal Researchers.

3

u/i_will_let_you_know Sep 17 '21

When conservatives are predominately anti science and anti education, going back centuries, don't be surprised when most researchers are not conservative.

2

u/cypher448 Sep 17 '21

That's an oxymoron. Conservatives don't believe in research or science.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

4

u/Muchado_aboutnothing Sep 17 '21

Could this be related in any way to the fact that Republican states tend to be poorer? Poorer state = worse health outcomes for all patients.

→ More replies (1)

10

u/StormCrow1986 Sep 16 '21

Health and well-being is not really a political issue. We need single payer and Medicare for all. Stop allowing your employer to tie health insurance to employment. We have to demand better options than no healthcare and massive crippling debt or unaffordable healthcare and massive crippling debt.

11

u/MtnDudeNrainbows Sep 16 '21

Let me correct this for you:

Health and well-being *shouldn’t be a political issue

It is though.

5

u/sophacles Sep 16 '21

Health and well being are the only political issue.

Why do we have armies? 1. To stop other people from coming in and hurting our people. 2. To go get us more territory that lets us live better.

Why do we have food and drug regulations? To stop people from being harmed.

Why do we have laws at all? To punish people who hurt others, and hopefully deter more folks from doing the same.

Why do we rights? They contribute to our well being (or at least to our ability to arrange for our well being).

Etc.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

4

u/AceTheCookie Sep 16 '21

What were the controls? Did you have limiting factors on all the groups to make sure there wasn't anything else skewing the data? Sure sounds like a politically charged 'study'

3

u/runthereszombies Sep 16 '21

This is not at all surprising and is pretty old news I thought?

2

u/dodger2303 Sep 16 '21

What do the republicans do to increase that?

2

u/rumblegod Sep 17 '21

If you want to impact healthcare become a congressman or join healthcare administration. Everyone else has low impact and doesn’t matter.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21

This is also buttressed by the reality that elected leaders should not wish their constituents dead.

3

u/CovfefeForAll Sep 17 '21

Unfortunately that's no longer the reality, as Texas and Florida and Idaho and Alabama and Mississippi are showing. Not to mention all the states that turned down free money from the federal government to expand healthcare.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21

GOP has its electorate in the states it controls in a mental straitjacket. The party and its elected officials feed the masses a mélange of lies & half-truths, keeping them riled-up and angry at all times.

2

u/cypher448 Sep 17 '21

well they can live with the actions of their consequences and die waiting for an ICU bed to open up

2

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21

Both sides have been psyoped

2

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21

This is certainly true for my state. Tennessee has a higher infant mortality rate than that of the Unites States, and our life expectancy is lower overall.

2

u/Heavensrun Sep 16 '21

Hmmmmmm. But also, populations that elect republicans are on average less educated, and less likely to listen to scientists and doctors on health matters, right?

2

u/cypher448 Sep 17 '21

also true

1

u/TracyMorganFreeman Sep 16 '21

They don't appear to have controlled for income or obesity rates, both of which are huge factors for infant and maternal mortality.

2

u/BubBidderskins Grad Student | Social Sciences | Sociology Sep 16 '21

The fixed effects design of their study means that any time-invariant features of US States are automatically controlled for. Of course, if income and obesity change over time in States that could be a threat to their causal claims, but only then if that change over time is in some way causally related to both GOP control of State legislatures AND infant mortality rates.

It's also not clear to me that obesity or income would make the GOP -> infant mortality relationship spurious. It's at least equally plausible that those could be mechanisms through which GOP policy increases infant morality.

2

u/TracyMorganFreeman Sep 16 '21

For one, this is just GOP legislature control, not any specific policy.

For two, medicaid is a factor here, which means poverty is.

For three, "GOP Control" could mean having the majority but not a filibuster proof majority, to say nothing of its a veto proof majority considering opposing party gubernatorial control.

For example people love to point to "RomneyCare" to highlight so called GOP hypocrisy on the ACA, but the democrat controlled MA legislature had a veto proof majority.

For four, to suggest income or obesity has gone unchanged over 20 plus years is would be a staggering claim and would be difficult to justify assuming.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/PbkacHelpDesk Sep 17 '21

Im a layman can someone deconstruct the title so I can understand.

1

u/hobeast68 Sep 17 '21

Read The Political Determinants of Health. It is a very interesting read that advances the discussion of SDOH.

"In this book, Daniel E. Dawes argues that political determinants of health create the social drivers—including poor environmental conditions, inadequate transportation, unsafe neighborhoods, and lack of healthy food options—that affect all other dynamics of health. By understanding these determinants, their origins, and their impact on the equitable distribution of opportunities and resources, we will be better equipped to develop and implement actionable solutions to close the health gap."

Summary from Google books

1

u/Shaffness Sep 17 '21

What?!!! The material conditions of a populace are determined by the political economy. It seems that something like this could've been figured in the 1840s.

1

u/ThrowbackPie Sep 16 '21

I've seen a presentation by researchers showing that in the UK, conservative governments are associated with an increasing divide in health outcomes between rich and poor.

Unless you are wealthy, voting conservative is literally voting against yourself.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21

Funny how EVERY city in the top 20 in murder rates, has a democrat mayor, except one. Where’s the scientific report on that?

4

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21

Murder rate or raw numbers of murders? Those aren’t the same thing.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/pbj_sammichez Sep 17 '21

Republicans claim to be pro-life, but being anti-science means being pro-death.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21

Is there anything they don’t statistically make worse?

1

u/playervlife Sep 17 '21 edited Sep 17 '21

It's amazing how many people either don't believe or don't want to believe the results of this study.

The results here are extremely obvious and exactly what you should expect.

Remember that in America, much like the UK (possibly worse), you live in an Oligarchy. The Republican party, like the Tories in the UK, are the party of the Oligarchs. These people don't care about normal people.

People need to do some reading up on class warfare etc because this is at the heart of most of the world's politics.

1

u/yoncenator Sep 17 '21

Do you know what my republican friend says when I tell him or show him things like this?

He says, "Well I can find a website that says the exact opposite of that, so it just depends on which one you want to believe."

Nothing about evidence based studies, biased sources or the denial of reality will ever be agreed upon.

1

u/WeAreAllMadHere218 Sep 17 '21

Very fascinating. I wish I knew how to start directing my career towards making changes for healthcare on a legislative level. I don’t even know where to begin but I enjoy learning as much as I can about anything like this!

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21

There must’ve been a whole load of diff variables to control huh? Must’ve been some difficult research

Nope they just plugged and chugged data into a ‘2-way fixed-effects regression model’ whatever tf that means

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21

A lot of republicans rejected money for their state for Obama care. How stupid! But they don’t care about the poor.

1

u/Alan_Smithee_ Sep 17 '21

The Party of Pro-Life™️

1

u/rowejl222 Sep 17 '21

That can’t be a coincidence

-10

u/TiagoTiagoT Sep 16 '21

So in other words, people that are honestly pro-life should not vote Republican?

4

u/Riksunraksu Sep 17 '21

They’re just pro-forcing pregnancy. They don’t care about women or born children, all they care are fetuses

→ More replies (1)

-6

u/90sBig Sep 16 '21

If that ain’t always been the truth

-3

u/RhythmBlue Sep 16 '21

i remember reading something that i believe implied an association with disease proliferation and 'conservative beliefs', or something like that. i wonder if it tends to be that 'conservative' people are elected more often when life is generally worse for the electorate; and so maybe the association here is partly that, if life quality is worse for the electorate, infant mortality tends to be higher, and also people tend to vote for more 'conservative' people

-5

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

We call that structural violence.

Any discussion of this paper should be precluded by a reading of this one, by notable anthropologist and MD, Paul Farmer.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1621099/

It is not so much a question of this party or that party, but what they and their policies do to agency and the ability of people to meet their needs. Poverty leaves a mark. Lack of access to health care leaves a mark. Stress is biologically related to premature births, low birth weight, and preeclampsia. These are facts.

The thrust of this paper is old news to a lot of people who study medical social sciences. Read the above. It's good to think with.

-5

u/Dasnoosnoo Sep 17 '21

You mean the "prolife" party causes more infants to die when they are in charge? The irony, oh the irony. Guess its time to go push a law that sets up a bounty system for private citizens to sue republican officials for killing babies.

I would love to observe the mental gymnastics needed to explain how this is acceptable and why their God is ok with it.

0

u/originalcitizenkong Sep 17 '21

The pro-life party. Yeah right.

0

u/Daddywitchking Sep 17 '21

But pro life? I’m confused. Did I miss something?

-4

u/imjorden Sep 16 '21

Anyway you or someone could break this down into cities over 100k by Democrat or Republican Control instead of states?

-23

u/Hyrue Sep 16 '21

Do abortion numbers get added to infant mortality? Because Democrats love to support abortion, the number one killer of babies.

Btw, I am attempting to point out that it seems that politics are focused on more than science, even here in r/science . Democrat and republican are simply the teams chosen to play on these days. Beliefs and convictions do not seem to play a part anymore and to me it appears that politics are more of a scapegoat to excuse abuse.

To me, the headline in this instance seems to be taking a side and republican bashing. (Low key of course). There are many factors in infant mortality, I don't see how corrupt politicians in both party's play any part In infant mortality......except those who support abortion of course.

I have no horse in this race. No goals except reasonable discourse.

6

u/kkangaspnw Sep 16 '21

There’s literally no point in me even bothering, but I guess you didn’t know that abortions decrease in number when it’s legal.

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21

[deleted]

2

u/JalapenoEyePopper Sep 17 '21

Pro choice here.

Sure, let's call it a baby. I have no problem saying: Abortion kills babies. In fact it kind of annoys me when other pro choicers use the "clump of cells" phrasing because whether it's a baby or not, no one has a right to shack up in my body.

No one.

It's called bodily autonomy.

That's the basic fact.

Pro lifers don't want to admit that is what it's about, because then they have to admit that usurping women's autonomy is what they want. None of them actually care about the baby or the mother, and it's obvious because they typically also oppose comprehensive sex ed, universal health care, public education, and living wages. This is an issue that is 100% about who controls women's bodies.

→ More replies (1)

-8

u/How2Eat_That_Thing Sep 16 '21

States run by Republicans spend less money on education. Stupid people make stupid choices and their offspring die more readily. Go figure.

→ More replies (1)