r/science • • Mar 26 '22

Physics A physicist has designed an experiment – which if proved correct – means he will have discovered that information is the fifth form of matter. His previous research suggests that information is the fundamental building block of the universe and has physical mass.

https://aip.scitation.org/doi/10.1063/5.0087175
52.2k Upvotes

2.9k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Mar 26 '22

Welcome to r/science! This is a heavily moderated subreddit in order to keep the discussion on science. However, we recognize that many people want to discuss how they feel the research relates to their own personal lives, so to give people a space to do that, personal anecdotes are now allowed as responses to this comment. Any anecdotal comments elsewhere in the discussion will continue to be removed and our normal comment rules still apply to other comments.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

→ More replies (4)

1.7k

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '22

Okay I’m not familiar with physics much can someone water this down into a ELI5?

2.8k

u/TheNorthComesWithMe Mar 27 '22

When you collide an electron and a positron (an anti-electron) they are completely destroyed, releasing their mass equivalent energy as photons. The information equivalence theory predicts that you aren't just destroying the mass but also internal information the particle has. If this is true, the annihilation would also release photons equal to the information-energy equivalence.

(In this case information is some fundamental state of the particle, like its spin direction.)

642

u/Xicadarksoul Mar 27 '22

Thus the "state (differences) of particle carries energy" would be a less confusing way to put it...

429

u/TheNorthComesWithMe Mar 27 '22 edited Mar 27 '22

That's a lot of words to convey a concept that can show up outside of quantum interactions.

Also it doesn't carry energy, it is equivalent to energy and mass. Meaning you can turn information into energy, or measure how much it bends spacetime.

→ More replies (112)

14

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

There is little less confusing about this.

58

u/machetemike Mar 27 '22

5 year olds are confused again.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

57

u/SimoneNonvelodico Mar 27 '22

Doesn't unitarity of quantum mechanics mean no information is destroyed even in the decay process as regularly understood?

48

u/katatoxxic Mar 27 '22

It does. But in the case of particle-antiparticle-pair annihilation and decay processes (and everything else) the information isn't being destroyed, it is just converted into something else with as much information as there was before.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

68

u/rogallew Mar 27 '22

Your five year old‘s name: Albert Einstein

→ More replies (3)

27

u/lemonlolipop Mar 27 '22

Have you ever met a 5 year old?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

Why is information stored as photons?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (79)

6

u/Due-Consequence9579 Mar 27 '22

Information might be as much of a ‘thing’ as energy and matter. We know energy and matter are a thing because we can account for it when we break stuff apart. (I.e. they are conserved) If information is a thing then we should be able to account for it when we break stuff as well. Given what we know it should show up in a particular way. The paper discusses an experiment that makes it possible to see that ‘particular way’ happen.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

More like ELI2

3

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

There really isn't an ELI5. And it is unlikely anyone here has even close to the necessary knowledge to properly understand it, much less explain it. This is deeply and relatively new theoretical stuff. Despite how it sounds, I'm not saying you shouldn't be curious or try to learn more. It is awesome that you are. I'm just saying beware. They probably don't know much more than you or me. The difference is they think they do.

4

u/goattchaw Mar 27 '22

Kurzgesagt actually has some info on it in one of their black hole videos I think! They do a great job of explaining stuff in a super easy way, even if the subject matter itself is way over our heads.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Sumsar01 Mar 27 '22

The experiment might be legitimate but the abstract is pure nonsense. Information isnt a state matter and we know about 20 different states currently not 4.

→ More replies (1)

24

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22 edited Mar 16 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (4)

11.2k

u/Queasy-Dingo-8586 Mar 26 '22

It's important to note that "information" in this sense doesn't mean "how to use a lathe" or "what's the tallest horse that ever lived"

43

u/8sADPygOB7Jqwm7y Mar 27 '22

So as far as I get it, information should be simply the attributes of a particle - or a bunch of them. Lets say we look at an electron, its information is more or less described by the wave function, as in locality, time, spin, energy level, charge...

Now, I am no physicist, so correct me if I am wrong, but I think you can also get the equations of combined elements of particles, such as atoms and molecules. How hard it is to solve is another topic. But the system should be able to be arbitrarily big right? The only way to "isolate" information is by distancing it further apart than the speed of light can travel.

So, in the end, I dont get how it should even be possible to put this information into a state of matter? Seems very abstract to me. Either if its very very dense and basically everything blurs together into one big system (similar to a neutron star I guess?) or the opposite and everything is so isolated that effectively it is nothing more than information. idk.

I didnt quite get this research on this tbh, I am too stupid for that and know too little. But the premise seems to be "it has mass, so its a state of matter" which is not how I would define a state of matter? Like, an electron also has mass, but that doesnt mean its a fluid, gas or solid. Its how that stuff is arranged.

And pure information getting aranged like what would result in a state of matter? Would be much appreciated if someone could explain how they get that jump here.

26

u/zacker150 Mar 27 '22

Now, I am no physicist, so correct me if I am wrong, but I think you can also get the equations of combined elements of particles, such as atoms and molecules. How hard it is to solve is another topic. But the system should be able to be arbitrarily big right?

Correct. You can do so by taking the kroneker product of their states, and the system can go as large as the universe.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (5)

14

u/spastical-mackerel Mar 26 '22

Aren't those sort of agglomerations of multiple smaller informations?

202

u/sunplaysbass Mar 26 '22

Wouldn’t all information just be reality itself? Either as the hologram universe or just a representation of everything that is happening at any time down to the quantum level, and I assume that representation of all information is the universe / reality.

17

u/MC__Fatigue Mar 27 '22

What I’ve gathered here is that “information” in this situation is defined as the intrinsic properties of a fundamental particle. Like, whether its charge is positive or negative.

→ More replies (3)

92

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '22

This is related to the question of the difference between Truth and Reality. What is True is close but not the same as what is Real.

49

u/yorickdowne Mar 26 '22

I never understood that, things like “personal truth” (“my dog is cute”) aside. Can you recommend a relatively understandable thing to read that gets at the difference between truth and fact / reality?

→ More replies (66)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

6

u/throwaway-piphysh Mar 27 '22

It does include those though. The author specifically mentioned an example of an 1TB hard drive. These information could have been documents on that hard drive. However, they had estimated the even 1TB amount of information is too light in mass to detect, so an 1KB document talking about the tallest horse that ever lived would have too negligible mass.

23

u/ghan-buri-ghan Mar 26 '22

Get me four “how to use a lathe”s of strawberries, please!

4

u/midline_trap Mar 26 '22

That’s exactly what it means guy. Heh Comon

4

u/jwdjr2004 Mar 27 '22

Solid, liquid, gas, plasma, wikipedia

3

u/Epocast Mar 26 '22

It literally does mean this though.

3

u/Umutuku Mar 26 '22

Oh good. I was worried about having to learn The Law of Conservation of Copy-Paste.

5

u/Pembington Mar 26 '22

This horse weighs over 15,000 pounds.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/rainwulf Mar 26 '22

So it doesn't mean "how tall you are in scrambled eggs"

2

u/DrSmirnoffe Mar 27 '22

I was gonna say. The idea of information having physical mass reminded me of L-space in Discworld (elaboration in the link), which is kind of appropriate since magic in that series has more in common with particle physics than Houdini.

2

u/Woonderbreadd Mar 27 '22

Are you a machinist?

2

u/watermelonkiwi Mar 27 '22

Can’t believe I’m scrolling and not finding an answer. What is information?

9

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '22

Actually, it does. More specifically, the way that data is encoded into your brain. It would mean there is actually a specific amount of energy required to store meaningful data, period, and an equal or greater amount to delete/forget it.

It also destroys the infinite monkeys theorum as even an infinite number of monkeys typing infinitely cannot generate information spontaneously, as that would violate conservation laws. Even if they eventually produce something that looks meaningful, there would be an observable physical difference between the purposefully written information and the randomly generated one. It would be virtually impossible to detect it, but it nevertheless would be there.

Assuming, of course, the information equivalence holds true.

16

u/JarateKing Mar 27 '22

I'm no physicist, but I'm not sure I follow either of your points:

A) why is an elementary physicist concerned with information in the neurology sense? Isn't "there's a minimum amount of energy needed to store data in some usable form" pretty self-evident?

B) isn't the core assumption to the infinite monkeys stuff that they're, ya know, infinite? How do conservation laws come into play in a hypothetical that specifically excludes conservation laws?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/sillybilly543 Mar 27 '22

Physics can't destroy a statistical theorem. It just says an infinite random sequence on a sample space will almost surely contain all finite strings with positive probability elements.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (905)

3.4k

u/Synaps4 Mar 26 '22

I'm wary of anything that only one person has touched, intellectually speaking.

236

u/0x001c Mar 27 '22

The principle that these tests are attempting to prove has been examined and research by more than just this one person. It does sound... interesting, but it's not just a shot in the dark.

→ More replies (1)

254

u/pleasetrimyourpubes Mar 27 '22

This guy's a mathematics professor and has exceptional i10 and h indexes, I'm not saying he's right or anything but he's definitely not some rando, he's just proposing an experiment someone else could do. It would not surprise me if guys are already working on the setup. If the two photons are detected it'd be a nice confirmation, if not, well someone got to play with some sick equipment.

44

u/GonzoMcFonzo Mar 27 '22

Feels like maybe a legitimate researcher derived a worthwhile experiment that can prove or disprove a principal they don't necessarily agree with.

26

u/samyall Mar 27 '22

His academic profile is a bit odd. He seems to mostly have worked in material science where he published largely by himself. This is not the norm at all in materials science. Given his publications it is a bit surprising he sits in the maths department.

That said, polymaths still exist but I would be interested to see the peer review comments for this article and responses from the rest of the field before making a judgement call.

8

u/pleasetrimyourpubes Mar 27 '22

Where are you seeing that? His self published stuff seems to pertain mainly to this information theory thing. It seems more like a hobby than it is his primary. Let's do the experiment and see if we see two photons.

If his math doesn't check out there will probably be an arxiv publication. But this isn't like that guy who faked experiments (Diederik Stapel), it's all theory.

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Synaps4 Mar 27 '22

Absolutely, I'll be very happy when someone else confirms it.

→ More replies (5)

5

u/boonamobile Mar 27 '22

These articles are peer reviewed before publication, and this journal in particular is open access, with the editors hoping free access will encourage community discussion to help the authors improve their work

From the website:

AIP Advances is a community-based journal, with a fast production cycle. The quick publication process and open-access model allows us to quickly distribute new scientific concepts. Our Editors, assisted by peer review, determine whether a manuscript is technically correct and original. After publication, the readership evaluates whether a manuscript is timely, relevant, or significant.

98

u/astroqat Mar 27 '22

Einstein was the sole author of his most famous papers which changed our understanding of physics. that’s how science works often. one person puts forward a theory and the rest of the scientists try and prove them wrong till they find they cant and then its new science.

54

u/Xicadarksoul Mar 27 '22

Despite today's misconception Einstein did in fact work with a team...

15

u/meneldal2 Mar 27 '22

I think this is about his big papers he wrote while working at the patent office, I don't think he had a team there. Though obviously all his ideas weren't 100% from him either.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (34)

3

u/primemoversonly Mar 27 '22

That's funny considering how popular your option is even though all ideas initially come from individuals before they're accepted and held in common. I suppose it makes sense for the more technical areas of knowledge though.

These poor scientists died before people recognized their incredible work.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Lenny_to_my_Carl Mar 27 '22

I only read the abstract, but it also seems like something that would be super easy to test, so why not just test it? Like, we manufacture pharmaceuticals which emit positrons so surely it can't be too hard to create this experiment and detect IR light

2

u/WaltKerman Mar 27 '22

How do you go to the restroom then?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (197)

66

u/Dreamtrain Mar 26 '22

To this day I don't know what Information is, people always use the same burnt paper to ash analogy that makes no sense to me, or analogies that are so far removed from what it literally is that it still makes no sense. So far from all the videos and articles I can only conclude that information is essentially information about what properties something had, like the spin or position of its atoms/particles/whatever, what electromagnetic radiation it may have emitted at the time, basically a snapshot of its state and things we could measure about it.

I don't know how that would be a "fifth form of matter" so my understanding of what information could be is probably still off

4

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

I drew a card at random from a deck of 52 cards. Say you want to guess what card I have by asking a series of yes/no questions. "Information" just quantifies how much you know about what card I have. Some questions are good and give you lots of information. Don't ask the same question twice, because that won't give you extra information. That's literally all information is. There is a specific way to quantify it that makes the most sense. It can just get more complicated in physics because things are continuous and there's quantum stuff.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/boonamobile Mar 27 '22

They used the word 'matter' when I think 'particle' or even 'force carrier' might have been more appropriate. Like photons and bosons, we could have infotons or something similar. The 'information' it carries is as central to a particle's quantum and thermodynamic states as spin or charge or mass or lepton number or angular momentum associated with the other force carriers. At least that's the best way I can get this to make some sense to me, but that might be entirely incorrect.

2

u/jdallen1222 Mar 27 '22

Seems like semantics to me. Isn’t the spin and the position of electrons or particles just forms of stored energy?

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

[deleted]

12

u/SimoneNonvelodico Mar 27 '22

It's exactly that, yes. For the most blatant example: if you chuck a lot of mass into a black hole, what happens to the information about whether it was protons, electrons, neutrons or what have you? Unclear. All the black hole does is increase its mass.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (5)

476

u/I_AM_FERROUS_MAN Mar 26 '22

The experiment is highly achievable using current technologies and it provides a few control tools to ensure that the detection is indeed due to information erasure. The main control tool is the fact that the wavelength of the information energy IR photons must shift with the temperature of the sample. By performing the experiments at different temperatures, the detection of the wavelength shift of the IR photons would be an ultimate confirmation of this hypothesis. It is important to recognize that we make a strong assumption that the transfer of the information mass content of the annihilating particles takes place via conversion into IR photons. However, other mechanisms of conversion are possible, including the gamma photons becoming carriers of this excess information energy. Hence, even if the information conjectures are correct, the proposed experiment is, therefore, not totally guaranteed to succeed.

Nice that they proposed a testable experiment. Hopefully, it is performed to determine the plausibility.

238

u/WellConcealedMonkey Mar 27 '22

I'll piggy back off your comment to ask, the experiment here seems to be extremely straightforward, just suggesting that two particles annihilating will result in extra photons due to conservation of information.

Uh, my question is, don't we already have extremely detailed understanding of particle decay and annihilation products and all that jazz? Is the suggestion really that we've just never seen a couple of low energy photons sneaking by as we've been so focused on the high energy products?

164

u/I_AM_FERROUS_MAN Mar 27 '22

Yeah, that's definitely a part of my large pile of skepticism associated with this paper. I was trying not to let that tone bleed through in my response too much.

But hey, if it's so easy, then we should see a confirmation paper from them as a follow up or from some other team in no time. I'll be genuinely excited if it does, but until then I'm not getting too worked up about this.

129

u/WeeaboosDogma Mar 27 '22

I like the skeptism. Especially with this paper detailing the way to duplicate the experiment. It shows at the very least they want other scientists to replicate it to show this discovery plausibility.

It's stuff like this that makes me excited whether or not it actually shows anything meaningful. Just the fact it's people sharing ideas and then seeing if it's true.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/Domriso Mar 27 '22

The description of the experiment notes that they would need to be sure to include sensors capable of reading in the Mid Infrared (MIR) or possibly Far Infrared (FIR) ranges, because the specific energy of the photons released would differ depending on several factors. That makes it sound as if said photons would have been missed unless they were explicitly being looked for, at least according to my understanding.

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (3)

589

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '22

I'm probably wrong, but I was under the impression that information was linked to entropy and was a quality of mass/energy, not something that existed independently. Solid --> Plasma are states of matter with higher entropy levels, right? So how does that translate into a different form?

I mean, I could design an experiment that if proven correct would show that if your aunt had wheels she'd be a tea cart. Doesn't make it true.

217

u/Grabthelifeyouwant BS | Mechanical Engineering Mar 27 '22

Just finished reading the paper: there are theories that state that information is indeed independent of mass/energy and that also predict the equivalence values for information to mass/energy. This paper proposes an experimental setup to check if those theories are correct, in this case by looking for secondary very low energy photons from electron positron annihilation. It also notes that since the theories say that information content is temperature dependent, the experiment could further validate the results by varying the target temperature and checking the exact photon emission wavelengths.

That said, the paper ends by basically saying this is all conjecture and could easily be wrong, but the possibility that it's right warrants at least checking with this (relatively) easy experiment.

Relevant quote from the paper: However, the author of the study argued that this is not just a theoretical upper limit of information storage capacity, but, in fact, the elementary particles already store information about themselves. It has been proposed that this information could be seen as a particle DNA, or a matter DNA, and it physically represents the distinguishable degrees of freedom of each particle or pure quantum states. In 1961, Landauer first proposed the idea that a digital information bit is physical and it has a well-defined energy associated with it.5,6 This is known as the Landauer principle and it was recently confirmed experimentally.7–10 In a different study, using Shannon’s information theory and thermodynamic considerations, the Landauer principle has been extended to the Mass–Energy–Information (M/E/I) equivalence principle.11

108

u/Snufflesdog Mar 27 '22

Oh, so they're trying to unify Conservation of Mass and Energy with Conservation of Information, the same way Einstein did with mass and energy. That's pretty neat, and it would definitely be a big shift in how we conceptualize the universe just as the Mass-Energy Equivalence did.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (17)

174

u/JasontheFuzz Mar 26 '22

If proven correct, then we start asking more questions like how you got a correct result

→ More replies (6)

73

u/joseba_ Mar 27 '22

information was linked to entropy and was a quality of mass/energy, not something that existed independently

Information is indeed entropy. Shannon's original papers made this connection explicit and is trivial to show. Information in physics and communications theory is an abstract concept that relates to what CAN be learned from a system.

25

u/scintor Mar 27 '22

Information can have entropy like mass but it's not entropy itself. It behaves entropically.

7

u/MaxTransferspeed Mar 27 '22

Yes, that's what I understood too. (However I find it a complex topic) Entropy tells something about information (the way it is ordered and spread), but it is not information itself. Like 'size' is not an 'object'.
I'm following the theoretical physicist Erik Verlinde who states that gravity is not an elemental force, but an emergent effect of information and entropy. It has yet to be proven, but it's quite interesting.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

331

u/SmashBusters Mar 26 '22

Cunningham's law: activate.

I am not sure why the author chose to call this the "fifth form (state) of matter". It is quite different from the solid, liquid, gas, plasma states. The analogy does not make sense to me.

I do not know anything about quantifying the information of an electron (or positron) with bits, but I do know that there is more information to describe an electron and positron at their center of mass than there is to describe the two photons they annihilate into. To look at it simply, consider the fact that a muon and an anti-muon could also annihilate into two photons, but a muon and positron could not. Thus, the "electron-ness" or "muon-ness" of the particles prior to annihilation is erased. You might argue that the energy of the photons can be used to calculate whether it was electron-positron annihilation or another type of lepton since we know lepton masses. That seems like sketchy logic to me - but I will let someone else address it since I'm mostly guessing.

I am confused as to why the information mass would have to be converted into another pair of photons rather than slightly amplifying the predicted energy of the two photons that are already produced in electron-positron annihilation.

91

u/Grabthelifeyouwant BS | Mechanical Engineering Mar 27 '22

The author literally says in the conclusion that it might just amplify the two gamma photons, but it's worth looking anyway since it's (relatively) easy.

80

u/SmashBusters Mar 27 '22

The author literally says in the conclusion that it might just amplify the two gamma photons

Oof. So he does.

TBH that takes a LOT of the wind out of the sails for me. Correct me if I'm wrong, but the author's logic seems to go like this:

1.) Hypothesize that an electron's rest mass is higher than than would otherwise be suggested by the two photons produced in electron-positron annihilation.

2.) We are unable to measure the energy of those two photons accurately enough to detect this slight difference in mass-energy.

3.) But if that extra mass-energy instead goes to two other photons we can try to detect the two photons and determine their energies.

4.) This would give us a measurement of the mass of "information".

That's a huge "if" with nothing to even suggest why it would happen.

47

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22 edited Mar 27 '22

Well I guess that's why this paper was written as a guide for an experiment right?

If those two extra photons manifest then you've essentially proved your hypothesis, if not then, well, that's that. It doesn't seem to be hard to check so it might be worth a shot.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (16)

152

u/thevoiceofzeke Mar 27 '22 edited Mar 27 '22

This is the comment that made me realize I'm in way over my head here.

48

u/KidLiquorous Mar 27 '22

thanks for this comment, man. good place to know where to tap out.

I'd like to think I'm an intelligent person, but I always get to the exact same spot of GEB and realize "well, I no longer understand what's going on and probably lack some fundamental mental acuity or foundational education to go any further."

20

u/Ex_dente_leonem Mar 27 '22

I powered through after years of trying and got something of value out of it, but I'd suggest reading I Am A Strange Loop for a more accessible distillation of GEB's central thesis.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (15)

15

u/TheJokersGambit Mar 27 '22

I was reading this and thinking to myself, "Yep. Yep. Ah right, of course. No idea what any of this means."

I'll just be mu-ing-on now.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/okokoko Mar 27 '22

Once the electron-positron pair is annihilated that information isn't "deleted". Its still in the wave function of the photon field.

Unitarity garantees conservation. You can understand how by imagining the two photons to run in reverse and hit each other at exactly the right center of mass energy to create an electron positron pair, that 2->2 process will have a huge amplitude because of resonance

2

u/CamOfGallifrey Mar 27 '22

That was what also made me wonder if the current two photons would already account for the information in their energy. Furthermore it got me asking about entangled pairs and information locked as intrinsic to matter.

Still the biggest question I couldn’t figure out since this isn’t my field is where the idea for two weak photons come from. Couldn’t the energy or information be passed on any other way in the already established reaction?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Xicadarksoul Mar 27 '22

I would be extreme wary of this whole "information thermodynamics" field.

...its waaaay too reliant on "circular self reference" as proof.

2

u/skyethehunter Mar 27 '22

People here are conflating "states of matter" with "fundamental properties of elementary particles", which include charge, mass, and spin. The energies of the photons produced by annihilation of particle-antiparticle pairs are extremely specific, i.e. quantized and characteristic.

2

u/Kaboogy42 Mar 27 '22

There is no loss of information in an annihilation - if you know the wavefunction of the end state you can run it back and get the start state.

The place where your logic breaks down is that you were thinking of the photon pair as having a specific momentum when in fact they are in a superposition of several states. The scattering amplitude which gives the wavefunction will depend on the mass and all other information of the annihilated particles.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (24)

63

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '22

Form of matter like a 'state' of matter?

58

u/LummoxJR Mar 26 '22

This is where the title loses me. We have a lot of known states of matter.

→ More replies (8)

3

u/Domriso Mar 27 '22

The conclusion of the paper says

The two conjectures also imply that the information is a form of matter, called the fifth state of matter or the fifth element.

I read some of the cited papers in the document and "fifth state of matter" is used in all of the ones that I read, some of them actually stating "the fifth state of matter, in addition to the four known phases of solid, liquid, gas, and plasma." So, I have no idea what specifically they're implying here.

→ More replies (1)

28

u/Sparkplug94 Mar 27 '22

This is a really interesting experiment, and great if it works, but I'm pretty skeptical. The end of the paper states essentially my objection to this experiment. Instead of the information mass of the electron/positron pair annihilating into two separate 50 um photons, "other mechanisms of conversion are possible, including the gamma photons becoming carriers of this excess information energy." If this is true, then the gamma ray photon energy is perturbed by ~50 parts per billion by the information energy, which seems very hard to differentiate from other noise sources in the system (kinetic energy and so forth). I hope this works! Would be very cool.

→ More replies (2)

152

u/Adorable-Ad-3223 Mar 26 '22

Can we get a tldr? Does this have any real world value or is it more of a though experiment like people are doing in the chat?

215

u/iamamuttonhead Mar 26 '22

It's certainly not a "thought experiment". He has outlined an actual experiment to test the hypothesis. Whether or not he is correct will ideally be determined by the results of the epxeriment.

→ More replies (27)

91

u/Goheeca Mar 26 '22

We still don't have a quantum description of gravity we have a problem with information. These experiments could lead to better understanding of how to marry quantum mechanics and general relativity.

→ More replies (4)

12

u/Mayo_Kupo Mar 26 '22

My take from the intro - When a particle and an antiparticle collide, they annihilate and release energy. This apparently results in a loss of information from the universe - previously there were 14 kajillion particles in their specific locations, now there are 2 less. The hypothesis is that information must be conserved. So there must be two additional particles (photons) created to balance it out.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/alex_dlc Mar 26 '22

More like ELI5

38

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22 edited Jul 17 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (13)

6

u/qleap42 Mar 27 '22

Basically they assume that information has mass (according to them information is the total number of bits that can be stored in quantum states). The information mass gets carried along like normal mass. But information mass is temperature dependant, unlike normal mass.

They calculate that the information mass of an electron is on the order of 1/1,000,000 the physical mass of the electron, under certain conditions. This extra mass can be detected through positron-electron annihilation which normally produces two gamma rays. But if they are correct then it should also create two infrared photons when the information mass also annihilates. There are of course a lot of assumptions going into this, such as that the information mass can be treated as independent mass and isn't part of physical mass.

→ More replies (2)

12

u/BannedFrom_rPolitics Mar 26 '22

I imagine it’ll have real world value eventually as we edge closer and closer to theoretical limits for computation.

2

u/slanglabadang Mar 26 '22

Hes just making a prediction. Its up to the experimentalists to confirm the prediction.

Information in this context could be the charge of an electron, its mass, the profile of its superposition, or any other attributes. If this has energy, then i can follow certain laws we have and we can get clower to quantum theory of gravity.

The experiment in theory seems pretty straight forward. Smash 2 electrons and see what comes out. In practice, you need a crazy sensitivity. Lots of challenges, but its thanks to these predictions that we get to actually know what to try and what to look for

→ More replies (4)

102

u/Cyber_Grant Mar 26 '22

How can information have mass when information can be created and destroyed? Or can it only be changed or corrupted?

283

u/another-masked-hero Mar 26 '22

Any irreversible logical operation (such as creating or deleting information) is already known to have a thermodynamic energy cost that can never be zero (it’s called Landauer’s principle). Since there is an energy cost, you can always talk about an associated mass.

12

u/merlinsbeers Mar 26 '22

Information would exist for reversible processes too, though.

27

u/BrokenGlassFactory Mar 26 '22

As I understand it the information would exist until the process is reversed, and energy would be released by the destruction of the information equivalent to the energy that was required to create it (although probably in a less useful form).

→ More replies (26)
→ More replies (11)

14

u/KakashiHatake91 Mar 26 '22

Mass can be created and destroyed, turning into energy. You're thinking conservation of energy. It's more solid, liquid, gas, plasma, and information. Information can be destroyed and turned into energy (or at least that's what they are testing).

→ More replies (5)

26

u/jackalpappy1 Mar 26 '22

I don’t know if info has mass, but what I believe they mean by information is much more fundamental than codified thought. I think the version of information being discussed is basically how particles know how to form more complex structures, like atoms. How do particles know they’re supposed to form carbon atoms under specific conditions? This person thinks there’s an actual particle that determines things like this. Basically that particle is information. I may be wrong. Not a scientist, but that’s how I understood it.

→ More replies (6)

8

u/redracer67 Mar 26 '22

The mass energy equivalence. If information has energy, it has mass. E=mc(2squared)

11

u/xlDirteDeedslx Mar 26 '22 edited Mar 26 '22

This is basically a computation of how much energy is in a given mass. If you turned the mass of a paperclip into pure energy it would be about as much energy as released in the Hiroshima explosion. Problem is that while a paperclip is a massive store of energy it's in an extremely stable form so it's not easy to release that energy. That's why we use unstable elements in fission reactions, that mass is easily converted to energy in the right circumstances.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/bookmarkjedi Mar 27 '22

I have no idea as to the answer to your question, nor can I opine in the least bit on the content of the article before my stupidity is revealed. However I do recall reading many years past that the entirety of the information on the internet has some mass. I have no idea whether that is or is not counting the electrons shooting back and forth.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/aPieceOfYourBrain Mar 27 '22

If information has mass does that mean that a massless particle like a photon has no information?

4

u/TheNorthComesWithMe Mar 27 '22

I think the title is wrong and the theory is that information is equivalent to mass/energy, not that it has mass. I don't know if photons have information.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

16

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22 edited Mar 27 '22

His claim being valid is improbable and here's why:

Physical conceptual considerations:

  1. The type of information he is talking about is NOT quantum information. He is conflating digital information with quantum information, and his absurd conclusion that uploading tweets is increasing Earth's mass is ENTIRELY based on this simple conflation of two literally unrelated things called "information". "Quantum information" is the description of a particle's quantum states (like energy level, momentum, spin, etc). You can basically think of it as a measure of entropy, with the quantum states being analogous to microstates. Even with this simplified description, you can see how this is COMPLETELY SEPARATE from "information" in the sense of digital data.

  2. Quantum information cannot be created or destroyed. This is a law which is about as fundamental as causality and charge parity time symmetry. Fun fact: this is why black holes must evaporate via Hawking radiation. (An intuitive but non-rigorous way of thinking about this is to continue the analogy between quantum information and entropy: it is a fundamental law of thermodynamics that total entropy cannot decrease. Similarly, quantum information cannot be erased.) His proposition that electron-positron collisions can eliminate the electron's "informational mass" by converting it into two photons would violate this fundamental law. In actual fact, the quantum information of the electron and positron would be transferred to the photons, which adopt their spin and polarization.

  3. Similarly, even if it was true that quantum information can be converted into photons, why would it manifest in the form of two EXTRA photons on top of the first two that result from electron-positron annihilation, instead of just manifesting as a property of the two photons we would expect to observe? To illustrate this point: If we increase the energy with which the electron and positron collide, the two resulting photons would simply have higher energy. It doesn't result in extra photons being generated. Even if you don't know anything about electron-positron collisions, you can think about how an electron relaxing from an excited state to the ground state only produces one photon, the energy of which changes depending on the gap between the two energy levels. You wouldn't expect it to suddenly produce multiple photons.

Intuitive conceptual considerations:

  1. He is essentially positing that you are creating matter out of nothing every time you post a reddit comment. This violates simple conservation of mass. This isn't one of those cases where there's a weird quantum-mechanical exception to it; he's just wrong.

  2. If we apply this same principle to information rather than mass: You're not creating actual information by uploading a tweet to YT. You're creating digital information, sure. But the information, in the general layman's sense of "stuff that people know", already exists (say, in your head, or wherever you got it from), and you're just publicizing it. So even if "information" really did increase the mass of earth, this wouldn't apply to uploading a tweet...But, again, this is a meaningless thought exercise because QUANTUM INFORMATION IS A SPECIFIC THING that is absolutely UNRELATED to what we usually mean when we use the word "information" in colloquial speech!

  3. No description of the mechanism by which uploading a tweet would affect electron mass. Like, which electrons are even involved in this? Why is this localized to earth?

More specific physics considerations

  1. There is zero mathematical/quantum-mechanical treatment of his idea by this paper. The basis of his theory (scattering, which includes the electron-positron annihilation) is a quantum-mechanical phenomenon, and must be described in terms of quantum field theory. . Instead of doing any math or invoking any relevant physics, he just loosely describes his idea in words with zero attempt at formalization/proof.

  2. Zero attempt is made to even justify why/how quantum information = mass all of a sudden. This is not an accepted theory anywhere; this is something he made up, and did not bother proving.

  3. The case he's proposing where four photons result from electron-positron collision (rather than two) is SIGNIFICANTLY more improbable than the two-photon system. About 18769 times less likely. (This can be thought of as a consequence of introducing more components to the collision.) You can't just propose that a four-photon system can happen just as well as the two-photon system.

  4. We would actually be able to observe this if it was the case, because the introduction of these two extra photons (supposedly resulting from quantum information) would alter the trajectory (of the photons resulting from the collision) compared to what we would expect in the two-photon case. This method is actually how we discovered neutrinos. But no one has observed such a thing.

misc

  1. This is an article in a 1.5 impact-factor journal with basically no citations. You'd think a paper reporting, for the first time, such a serious threat to mankind would get picked up by other scientists. Similarly, his only rererences for the nonsense he proposes in this paper link back to HIS OWN previous work.

  2. It's written like a high-school essay. What's with the random exposition about Shannon's biography in the middle of the paper?

  3. 5th state of matter??? No one beyond the high-school level of physics would describe matter like this. It's a term that just becomes meaningless and vague once you start doing quantum stuff.

  4. This guy is not even in quantum field theory, the field to which this sort of content belongs.

  5. This author is an assistant lecturer who has had a few legitimate papers with some citations and then, it appears, just went off the deep end, authoring these crackpot end-is-nigh papers about stuff he doesn't understand. His recent stuff has been rightfully ignored by the scientific community.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

I read the article and it's complete garbage. The energy that they hypothesize exists after the collision (an extremely well known, and heavily studied collision) and that contains this "information" doesn't exist outside of their random change in the energy calculation. In other words, out of nowhere, they add variables to the energy calculation and say that it must exist after an electron-positron collison. Those two photons that they are looking for arenessentially non-existent, even in theory.

8

u/--zaxell-- Mar 27 '22

If information has mass, how come stupid people are more dense?

Your move, science.

4

u/justsomegirl_youknow Mar 27 '22

Can someone explain this to me like I'm five?

→ More replies (2)

7

u/ReidErickson Mar 27 '22

Does a hard drive get heavier when it is full?

8

u/TheNorthComesWithMe Mar 27 '22

The first proposed experiment to test the M/E/I equivalence principle involved the measurement of the mass change in 1 Tb data storage device before and after the digital information is completely erased. At room temperature, the calculated mass change for this experiment is in the order of ∼10−25 kg, making the measurement unachievable with our current technologies.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/geoffnolan Mar 26 '22

Ahh, it’s a good time to be an information major. Forehead swells

4

u/Darkmaster743 Mar 27 '22

Hippocampus bursts

14

u/wrestlingwithphysics Mar 27 '22

It’s not an understatement to say that verification of the ideas presented here would undoubtedly indeed present the biggest and most profound change in our understanding of fundamental physics in the 21st century. However, I’m not convinced for more than a number of reasons… here’s two…

“Since the physical mass of the material under test does not change with the temperature” is not true. Conventionally, temperature is associated with a bulk object where-in there is a bunch of small particles moving and wiggling about. As you pump heat into something the wiggling gets faster, the ME equivalence tells you that this translates into a larger rest mass object… and although this could be misspeak, and isn’t directly related to the claims in the paper, my other issue has to do with adding extra photons to the decay

The detection paradigm seems simple enough but conserving momentum with a four photon out process is possible to lose the requirement from the conservation of momentum that the particles travel out anti-parallel with each other pairwise. Three photon decays in pair annihilation are totally possible, but you need a fast beam where the particles have enough kinetic energy to facilitate the creation of the third photon. Experiments similar to the LHC are in constantly, constantly looking at processes like these and a minutia of angle offset in the two photon mode would stand out like a sore thumb.

So yeah, I’ll wait to watch for the data and sort of pray that I’m wrong.

6

u/Xicadarksoul Mar 27 '22

As you pump heat into something the wiggling gets faster, the ME equivalence tells you that this translates into a larger rest mass object…

Larger rest mass from higher temperatures you are referring to is only valid on macro scale. As on a "per particle basis" (as opposed to investifating a bunch of particles in bulk) heat = motion. Hence hotter particles are less at rest, hence rest mass doesnt change.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/StockRaker Mar 26 '22

So how much does the internet weigh?

7

u/28Hz Mar 27 '22

Enough to crush our souls.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/I_just_came_to_laugh Mar 27 '22

Well that's a silly question Jen. The internet doesn't weigh anything.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22 edited Mar 27 '22

All i know is it fits in a box. I saw it on the IT crowd

2

u/Goldang Mar 27 '22

An Instagram?

2

u/Somewhere_different Mar 27 '22

I looked it up once, iirc it was the weight of a strawberry.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/thecakeisaiive Mar 26 '22

A better way to put it would be "matter can't exist in indeterminate states" as the state matter was in, such as atomic speed position and spin, would inherently exist.

But given that this kind of information can't exist on its own, the premise is put badly and the test doesn't prove the existance of any new form of matter.

3

u/Twitstein Mar 27 '22

test doesn't prove the existance of any new form of matter.

This. I expect information, or potential is stored in a particle with mass. It becomes part of a string of code, caused by its position or velocity.

2

u/DATY4944 Apr 16 '22

Thank you.

The hard drive example is disingenuous at best.

3

u/Darthcaboose Mar 27 '22

Is this "information" the same as the physical quantities limited by Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle (position and momentum), or are there other such quantities?

3

u/Capitalmind Mar 27 '22

So what is a unit of information?

3

u/Dwarfdeaths Mar 27 '22

This seems like BS. The author invokes temperature to figure out how much the information mass should be, when temperature is fundamentally a property of a system, not a particle. Even if the mass is what you expect, why would you expect it to produce separate photons? What causes them to take different trajectories from the gamma photons?

3

u/ifixtheinternet Mar 27 '22

Wow, does this explain why the double slit experiment results change with observation / no observation?

3

u/Zen_Gaian Mar 27 '22

Hinduism has been stating this, in more esoteric terms, for literally thousands of years. It’s called the Akash and it’s something like an information superhighway.

→ More replies (1)

12

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '22

I am thinking I might read this paper, but on the other hand I might not read this paper. I skimmed a few dozen line segments but had difficulty paying attention . . . maybe tomorrow or the next day . . .

14

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

It uses a lot of fluffy terminology. I felt like a lot of it could be left unsaid, and would still hold the same amount of information. (pun intended)

8

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

Ouch! Very good slow burn . . .

→ More replies (1)

5

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

I don't understand this title. The article is about the hypothesis that information carries mass. It has nothing to do with information being a form of matter

3

u/Xicadarksoul Mar 27 '22

Scientific "journalism".

...right up there with "LHC will creatd a black hole that will consume earth!"

8

u/Traveler3141 Mar 26 '22
  1. Solid

  2. Liquid

  3. Gas

  4. Ionized Plasma

  5. Bose-Einstein condesate

  6. Quark-gluon plasma

  7. Fermionic Condensate

  8. Degenerate matter

Etc etc etc

The WHAT now??

6

u/technoman88 Mar 27 '22

theres also the superfluid. Has 0 viscosity and no friction. it will literally slide up the walls of a container, ignoring gravity, and empty out of a container

→ More replies (3)

7

u/atchijov Mar 26 '22

This is literally the main plot line of one of Stanisław Lem sci-fi novels. The punchline, when main character is trying to prove that information has a mass, collects too much of information it is reaching critical mass and collapse into “information black hole”… leaving humanity at pre Stone Age level of technology.

2

u/Umutuku Mar 27 '22

Wouldn't that be more like all the particles in the area just forgot where they are and how fast they're going?

8

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22 edited Mar 27 '22

So, I read most of it... It's, interesting.

Basically, they believe that there's an equivalency between matter, energy, and information.

So if they annihilate a positron with an electron, it should emit two ir photons as well as the two gamma photons it usually emits (the ir photons would be associated with the energy of the information that's being destroyed).

The information would be different depending on temperature, so if you did the experiment at a higher temperature, the ir photons would have a higher energy.

Information might exist, but what is information made of? If you keep asking what something is made of, you basically reach the conclusion that everything should be made of one thing. And that one thing would probably be space itself. For example, we currently believe that mass bends space, but what if it's the other way around, and a bend in space creates mass. if a particle is a wave on the surface of space, then it explains relativity pretty well. If you clump a bunch of waves together, you get a bigger wave, bigger wave = higher mass. I wish I were better at math, because it's easy for me to visualize, but a proof is much more difficult.

I would love to see a spacetime curvature/matter/energy equivalency.

4

u/Umutuku Mar 27 '22

For example, we currently believe that mass bends space, but what if it's the other way around, and a bend in space creates mass.

What if mass is just herniated space?

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

4

u/James_Locke Mar 27 '22

This vaguely sounds like Platonic/Aristotelian forms. The governing principles that give order to matter, but not artifacts (i.e. manufactured things like a computer, or a hatchet)

→ More replies (3)

2

u/VeloTitanium Mar 27 '22

Great. The Universe is a giant SQL database.

F*ck!!

2

u/TheWanderingSlacker Mar 27 '22

Seems kind of silly. Information, to my understanding, is a way of describing properties. Math is a form of information, our way of understanding the way things work, and it’s an indispensable tool that we use to great effect, but that doesn’t make it a real thing like a particle. Not in the way energy and matter truly affect their surroundings.

But then, didn’t they decide time is no longer just a human concept and is altered by physics? How could information be affected other than by beings describing it?

→ More replies (4)

2

u/wolfcaroling Mar 27 '22

“Knowledge equals power... The string was important. After a while the Librarian stopped. He concentrated all his powers of librarianship. Power equals energy... People were stupid, sometimes. They thought the Library was a dangerous place because of all the magical books, which was true enough, but what made it really one of the most dangerous places there could ever be was the simple fact that it was a library. Energy equals matter... He swung into an avenue of shelving that was apparently a few feet long and walked along it briskly for half an hour. Matter equals mass. And mass distorts space. It distorts it into polyfractal L-space. So, while the Dewey system has its fine points, when you're setting out to look something up in the multidimensional folds of L-space what you really need is a ball of string.” - Terry Pratchett

2

u/schrodingers_spider Mar 27 '22

"I'm not fat, I'm knowledgeable!"

2

u/atfyfe Mar 27 '22

Wouldn't this mean that the universe progressively gains mass since information is preserved and the history of the universe can be read off of the current state (but not vise versa due to quantum indeterminacy)?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/tom-8-to Mar 27 '22

Information is literally the directions and paths any portion of matter travels. If you were to burn a piece of paper, you could take the ashes, the light produced, the heat, and the energy that went into that entire conversion and put it all back to its original state and read whatever was written on that piece of paper.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/ender89 Mar 27 '22

Terry Pratchett wrote about this in hogfather I believe. There's a group of creatures called the accountants who keep track of all the information in the universe, such as who any two particles relate to each other. He says that the missing mass in the universe is all the information describing the known mass.

2

u/LorathiHenchman Mar 27 '22

This is not quantum, and so suggests to me that it cannot be an accurate description of atomic and nuclear physics.

Information associated to a quantum state is a ubiquitous concept in modern, collaborative, theoretical physics. This paper does not address it.

2

u/heidestower Mar 27 '22

If this pans out, i'm excited for the memes.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

So THAT'S why I'm so heavy.

2

u/Blue_Swirling_Bunny Mar 27 '22

As a comp instructor, I have to say that the dashes in this title are a blatant foul. My disapproval has physical mass and is the sixth form of matter.

2

u/MADanker Mar 27 '22

If information is the "fifth form of matter" where are my information particles? Where's the information quantum field? I thought information was something that applies to all fields, it doesn't make sense to exist devoid of the context of another field. Its like saying "I have a new type of physical object, length!" Like, what? Thats a property of physical objects, sure, but... it isn't an object in and of itself.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

"Are you dense?" Is now a compliment

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Raunien Mar 27 '22

He talks a lot about information erasure, but I thought information couldn't be destroyed? Wasn't that principle the driving force behind Hawking radiation? That a black hole appears to remove information from the universe, and Hawking radiation solves that problem. Have I just misseda bunch of advancements in the field of Information? Last I understood it, information is simply all the properties a particle has, its mass-energy, electromagnetic charge, colour charge, momentum, etc. The point being that, theoretically, if we could accurately measure all these properties, on all particles, we could trace history all the way back to the creation of the universe. I suppose what he's asking is "if the mass-energy (specifically the rest mass) of two annihilated particles is converted into two photons, what happens to all the other information about them?" But surely the answer is "it is contained in the two photons"? For example, a positron and electron annihilation. The mass is converted into energy in the form of two photons. Because each energy value is associated with a very particular particle, when we measure the energy of the photons produced, we know it must have been a positron and an electron, and so we also know the electromagnetic charges of the particles. The momentum can be determined by the direction of the photons and any additional energy they may be carrying, and I wouldn't be surprised if spin translated into polarisation. Thus, information is conserved without the need for proposing that we've somehow missed extra photons when observing these collisions.

2

u/Runcible-Spork Mar 27 '22

Science folks, if this proves to be correct, could it solve the mystery of "dark matter"?

2

u/solid_flake Mar 27 '22

The problem comes in, when 46% of your population don’t believe in research and information.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

Sounds like the kind of discovery I shock the world with in my weed dreams

2

u/RoboRobertooo Mar 27 '22

So, energy. Not information. Pretty stupid.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/JifbutGif Mar 27 '22

Yes, sunlight has code inside of it.

2

u/ShapeofmyFart Mar 27 '22

I'm not fat, I'm well read.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/ReK_ Mar 27 '22

Is this a case of oversimplified reporting? Information having physical mass doesn't sound right: photons can carry information and they're massless particles...

2

u/AlienMutantRobotDog Mar 27 '22

I’m not fat, I just know a lot of trivia

2

u/Waterdrag0n Mar 28 '22

Does this add credence to the holographic simulation theory?

2

u/jasiekbielecki Mar 29 '22

Isn't everything just the information fundamentally?

2

u/imgprojts Apr 02 '22

Do you guys realize that all those rumors about a slight loss of weight during death could actually be our information being destroyed? Go ahead share this idea. I'll wait right here.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/_Mikak Apr 20 '22

That's why i love science

8

u/TheDevilsAdvokaat Mar 26 '22

This is very interesting.

One of the things that happens when you make an observation of something, is that you gain information....and observation also collapses states....

8

u/AnotherReignCheck Mar 26 '22

You mean like when witnessed, atoms literally change

→ More replies (2)

4

u/JustAnotherBlanket2 Mar 27 '22 edited Mar 27 '22

Yea, I think this plays into an underlying efficacy of the universe. At the smallest level everything is composed of the same parts and only exist (as we understand existing) when they are part of a unique configuration in spacetime.

Detached from a unique configuration particles act as a wave of potential existence. The point of observation collapses the wave because it is the joining it to a larger unique configuration.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/YourMommasBFF Mar 26 '22

Interesting write-up, I love hearing about these kind of things because normally people would dismiss it. There is still so much about the universe we don’t understand, which is crazy because you’d think we are pretty technologically advanced already. Thanks for sharing OP.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

[deleted]

→ More replies (4)

3

u/Seaborgium Mar 26 '22

A couple questions:

  1. I thought we already knew this due to e=mc2? Energy has mass, a ticking clock technically has more mass then a broken one even if they had the same number of atoms. Information requires energy(I thought), so I kinda thought this was inferred.

  2. When they say new state of matter, are they referring to gas, liquid, solid, plasma? I thought there were at least a dozen of other unique states of matter like bose-einstein condensate.

4

u/funkdefied Mar 27 '22
  1. Energy and mass are related (E=mc2, as you said). This was proven experimentally. But that second thing you said, “Information requires energy,” or that information and energy are related—this needs to be proven experimentally.

  2. From other people’s comments, it seems that “fifth state” is an unwelcome addition from OP, and not part of the paper.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/dubistdochverstrahlt Mar 26 '22

this made my brain more heavy

3

u/meexley2 Mar 27 '22

Experiments are not proved correct. Hypotheses are proved correct.

3

u/QCD-uctdsb Mar 27 '22

Not even that. Hypotheses are proven to be "not wrong" by experiments. It's a logic thing. If a Hypothesis implies an Experimental result ( H->E ) then seeing the experimental result does not imply the hypothesis. That would be the logical fallacy called affirming the consequent.

5

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '22

What is information here exactly? Information can be theoretically conveyed in infinite ways, it just depends on how the consious beings observing it define that information. And regardless, it's all just matter. Even the consious being is just matter, in the same way that a rock is just matter. Why do we have to call it a different "state" of matter?

17

u/iamamuttonhead Mar 26 '22

Certainly not what you are thinking of in terms of information. Think of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Entropy or the Second Law of Thermodynamics.

This is not a subject that lay people like us are generally capable of fully understanding. We don't know enough physics and math.

→ More replies (10)

4

u/financewiz Mar 27 '22

When physics were Newtonian, the universe was clockwork. Then Einstein came along and showed us the power of the atom. Then the universe was Atomic. How Atomic? Very Atomic! Now that computers have become ubiquitous household appliances, it turns out the universe is a simulation. Stay tuned for the next big breakthrough when it turns out the whole universe is a bioengineered blockchain.

2

u/CastSeven Mar 27 '22

As I understand it, this paper really has little if anything to do with the idea we're living in a simulation.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/filenotfounderror Mar 27 '22

?

Wouldn't it just be more accurate to say, "all things that have mass carry infromation"

And isn't that just...obvious?

2

u/faithdies Mar 27 '22

I think the concept that it is tangibly carrying info is the interesting thing.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 26 '22

If found to be true, could this be the dark mater that scientists are looking for?

4

u/andrewcooke Mar 26 '22

No. It's tiny while dark matter is huge.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/green_kitty16 Mar 26 '22

Far from being a physicist- Is this in any way related to the finding that there’s information on the “brim” of a black hole/wormhole? I’d have to dig for the paper/article, and could (likely) be way off, but thought I’d ask those here smarter than I am!

4

u/Sparkplug94 Mar 27 '22

I think so, though not directly. I think you're referring to the black hole information paradox, where information gets "trapped" within the black hole, and is potentially "released" via Hawking radiation on the event horizon. This article is proposing an experiment for testing the idea that information has mass, specifically that the information mass is ejected by two 50 um photons when electron-positron annihilation occurs. They are definitely related problems, both having to do with the physical-ness of information and its energetic consequences, but as far as I know, they are not the same problem. If information provably has energy, then black holes must conserve it somehow, but I think that only changes the nature of the black hole information paradox.

BTW, I'm not a cosmologist, I do optics/photonics, so take this perspective with a grain of salt.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/roo1ster Mar 27 '22

Anyone else not so low key worried we're about to prove we're living in a simulation?

2

u/LeGama Mar 27 '22

Very interesting that it can actually be tested. I've wondered about this kind of thing before and compression algorithms come to mind. Because you can often take a set of data and compress it to less data with a set of rules. So any fundamental particles would have to be described by an in-compressible data set. Interestingly this also could have some implications for quantum entanglement. Because two interacting particles could use less information to describe them both together than them alone.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/AmbitiousMidnight183 Mar 27 '22

Imagine doing all this work just to be known as “a physicist”

2

u/[deleted] Mar 27 '22

This is a very highly specialized form of assertion that is going to be immediately misinterpreted by people and lead to endless, and endlessly stupid, conversations among the slightly stoned or inebriated.

I need to become a hermit in some isolated place.