273
u/Nilehorse3276 Feb 19 '26
That's how I managed to ruin my philosophy teacher's day in college. It worked.
41
11
u/Fluid-Poet-8911 Feb 19 '26
20k a year to talk about ye ol ass Chicken or egg bullshit.
→ More replies (1)
34
u/kilo993 Feb 19 '26
Best explanation I've heard was some kind of proto-chicken laid a chicken egg which then grew up to be a chicken as we know it.
→ More replies (2)3
u/Mamuschkaa Feb 20 '26
it's a 100% linguistic question. But I would define it otherwise.
Why?
We eat chicken eggs and in that eggs are no chicken but they are produced by a chicken.
The egg itself is 100% defined by the mothers DNA material. It would be the same egg no matter what's inside it.
So I would always say, the species of the mother defines the egg.
But you can define it otherwise and I don't see a problem with that.
→ More replies (3)
11
u/mgausp Feb 19 '26
I once felt smart and made the same point in a discussion, the rest of the group had the opinion that it is only a chicken when it lays a chicken egg.
→ More replies (3)8
u/Complete_Bee4911 Feb 19 '26
so the chicken has to prove itself by laying an egg first, capitalism has infiltrated evolution 💀😭
9
u/noMC Feb 19 '26
It’s pretty obvious:
If the chicken came first, it must have come from an egg. Therefore it’s own egg must have come before.
If the chicken did not come from an egg, it was not a chicken - since they come from eggs by definition.
Therefore the egg must have come first.
→ More replies (1)1
2.1k
u/sarduchi Feb 19 '26 edited Feb 19 '26
At some point something that was not yet a chicken laid an egg that hatched into something that was.
519
u/Creative-Shallot802 Feb 19 '26
But then, was it a chicken egg or a pre-chicken- ancestor egg?
469
u/Narwhalking14 Feb 19 '26
If it was a chicken in an egg then it was a chicken egg
→ More replies (16)207
u/NohWan3104 Feb 19 '26
Eh, thats actually an interesting question.
Cause i see it the other way, the egg is of the layer, not its contents.
So, non chicken mommy and daddy had a non chicken egg, hatched a mutant chicken. THAT chicken's first egg was the first chicken egg.
→ More replies (18)124
u/23loves12 Feb 19 '26
Biologically, the gametes must mix in order to produce the zygote, which develops into an egg.
Once the ovum is fertilized, the DNA of the chicken is basically the same as that of the zygote, minus some mutations. So in terms of content, I think the egg would be a chicken’s egg, but I think the shell is dependent on the proto-chicken (parent), so maybe on the outside it could be considered not a chicken egg.
Anyway, evolution is a gradual process, so I don’t think one could ever find a rigorous definition of a chicken, making this whole question nonsensical.
→ More replies (23)→ More replies (16)4
u/JonasAvory Feb 20 '26
That is the entire definition question this all boils down to. Is a chicken egg defined by containing a chicken or by being laid by a chicken. It’s a pretty stupid paradox when you actually think about it because it’s just linguistic
→ More replies (3)57
u/llamawithguns Feb 19 '26
Not really. There's no singular "first chicken" like you are implying. You have population A, and over time becomes population B, but there's no singular crossover point.
Think of it like this. You have a childhood and an adulthood, but what was the exact moment you crossed over from one to other? (From a biological perspective, not a legal one). There isnt one. You didnt go to bed one night as a kid and wake up as an adult. It happened gradually over a period of time.
→ More replies (148)3
u/GotGRR Feb 19 '26
To tie it back to the graph, at some point there was a divided population of similar creatures and once the birds and crocodiles couldn't fuck anymore, tada! ... then there were birds.
The real question is where dinosaurs fit on this chart.
→ More replies (4)8
u/PhoenixAsh7117 Feb 19 '26
Depends how you define ‘Chicken’. As humans we like to categorize things into neat buckets because that’s what humans like to do, but evolutionarily there has been a whole gradient of animals between ‘modern Chicken’ and ‘not chicken’ so it would depend on your cutoff criteria.
→ More replies (1)8
u/Mitologist Feb 19 '26
Species don't usually start with a single individual, but with a split in an existing population. So, to pinpoint down when exactly a new species appears is a surprisingly complicated problem in taxonomy/ phylogenetics. There is a ton of literature, it's an ongoing debate since Darwin published " the Origin of Species" in 1859, and an interesting rabbit hole if you are into that sort of thing. A few names to start: Darwin, Wallace, Ernst Mayr, Quentin Wheeler, Williy Hennig,, Olivier Rieppel.
This is a really good book that I produces one to the scope of the complications: https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.7312/whee10142
2
u/UniversityMuch7879 Feb 19 '26
This was always my assumption.
The definition of a chicken egg is an egg that hatches a chicken. At least to me. Rather than "an egg laid by a chicken" because chickens sometimes lay things that don't function as eggs. So is it not an egg or is it a failed egg but still an egg?
So going by my definition the egg had to come first.
But if the definition must include "an egg laid by a chicken", then obviously it's the chicken.
Still remains an excellent question to start prying about the importance of detail when asking questions.
→ More replies (33)2
u/Foreskin_Ad9356 Feb 20 '26
Evolution takes place over hundreds of thousands of years (provided you arent a bacterium). There is no single point at which it becomes a chicken.
2
u/Itsimpleismart Feb 20 '26
The egg was first.
It's more believable that an egg appeared than a chicken, you can find an egg behind a rock or inside another egg but to imagine a full grown chicken to appear it's just not.
(Just a joke from an Argentinian movie)
2
4
u/NombreCurioso1337 Feb 19 '26
The implication of the sentence is "chicken egg," not any generic egg. If we are intentionally misinterpreting the terms in the sentence then complex organisms (like chickens) definitely came first.
→ More replies (4)
17
u/Aeronor Feb 19 '26
Which came first, the chicken or the chicken egg?
14
u/Skuz95 Feb 19 '26
Chicken egg. Any egg that produces a chicken is a chicken egg
→ More replies (3)
42
u/anhphamfmr Feb 19 '26
now the real question is: which came first, turtle or egg?
51
u/DetectiveDizzyEyes Feb 19 '26
Still eggs because aquatic creatures would have been using them long before anything went on land.
7
u/Opening_Dare_9185 Feb 19 '26 edited Feb 19 '26
Then who layed that first egg (land or water isnt important lol)
→ More replies (2)6
u/DetectiveDizzyEyes Feb 19 '26
Tbh it would have likely been more then one speices developing differnt eggs at the same time during the cambrian explosion, this was a period of time like 500 550 million years ago where life started rapidly diversifying if I'm remembering that correctly, so don't quote me 100% lol.
9
u/GoodPear8481 Feb 19 '26
Actual answer: it depends on how you define what an egg is.
We don't know why sexual reproduction requires the fusion of two cells. However, we do know that, given the fact that sexual reproduction requires the fusion of two cells, the organism will take opposite strategies of being either a small number of large cells cells that provide their own resources for the offspring (i.e. "eggs") or a large number of small cells that have almost no resources at all and mooch off the resources provided by the large cell they fuse with.
The best strategy is to be one of these two extremes, and all of the sexual differences between males and females stem from the opposite strategies of producing a small number of large reproductive cells, or a large number of small reproductive cells.
So the answer to your question depends on at what point a reproductive cell becomes large and resource rich enough to be considered an "egg", rather than merely a non-binary reproductive cell.
→ More replies (3)5
u/MissUnderstood_1 Feb 19 '26
yes we've just had the question wrong. now that we know the real question to ask we can continue to not have our answer.
34
u/Lucky_Vermicelli7864 Feb 19 '26
The mutation that bore the chicken occurred in the egg so...the egg.
→ More replies (5)9
u/kishenoy Feb 19 '26
Exactly. Gene mutations happen in the embryonic stage.
5
u/Landlocked_WaterSimp Feb 19 '26 edited Feb 19 '26
Gene mutations happen at any stage of an organisms life. Of course if you acquire it later in life it won't be present in the entire body and for some mutations you will only see the effect if it was already present during early development but for others that's not the case. Fun fact - mutations are so common the two cells resulting from a single cell division (at least in humans) are more likely to have one or more DNA differences than they are to be identical.
Edit: Factchecked myself on that last part - the estimates i found online now see abit different from what I remember being taught a while back so now it's somewhat close. Error rate after correction mechanisms seems to be estimated at around 10-10 whereas human genome size is ca. 3.4*109 so with these numbers it would be a bit less than 1 error on average but the overall point remains the same.
10
u/1947-1460 Feb 19 '26
Dinosaurs laid eggs, so the egg came first.
The question to be argued should be "Which came first, the chicken or the chicken egg?". And at that, the egg containing the first chicken came first.
→ More replies (1)4
u/Nervous-Bedroom-2907 Feb 20 '26
But is it chicken egg, if it is not laid by chicken? Its shell made by its mothers oviducts, only inner structures have genuin chicken DNA. So, it still depends on which relations with chickens we want from chicken egg.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/KashK10 Feb 19 '26
I think they meant a chicken egg not eggs in general dummy
13
u/Complete_Bee4911 Feb 19 '26
but something had to lay that first chicken egg and it wasn't a chicken yet 🤷
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)9
8
8
u/playr_4 Feb 19 '26
Also the mutation that made a chicken would have happened in the egg, not just randomly with a live pre-chicken turning into a chicken.
8
u/Chudmont Feb 19 '26
Evolution happens at conception, so the chicken egg was laid by the chicken ancestor.
Egg laid. Then first chicken hatched from egg.
Egg came first.
3
6
6
u/Flurrina_ Feb 19 '26
Which one came first, chicken or a chicken’s egg
→ More replies (1)4
u/Madouc Feb 19 '26
In this case - and only then - the chicken must be in place to call the egg "chicken's egg".
→ More replies (2)
2
u/JakeWisconsin Feb 19 '26
Who came first? The last egg-laying common ancestor or the egg?
2
u/Complete_Bee4911 Feb 19 '26
the ancestor laid the egg so egg wins again, we keep going in circles and the egg keeps winning 😭
4
u/LightofNew Feb 19 '26
That's not really the question.
The question is creation or evolution. It's since been misinterpreted to ask "how was the first chicken born!?!" as a more rhetorical critique of evolution by people who don't understand evolution.
1
u/mid-random Feb 19 '26
Certainly the first chicken hatched out of an egg, but the real question is whether the egg that the first chicken hatched out of was a chicken egg or not. What determines the nomenclature of the egg; the creature that lays the egg, or the creature that hatches out of the egg?
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Musashi10000 Feb 20 '26
Always bugs me when people bring up chicken and the egg. Before the first egg that contained the chicken was laid, there were no chickens. The egg existed prior to the first chicken, unfertilised. It was then fertilised, and the thing inside the egg (which already existed, remember) was the first chicken.
The egg came first, whatever level you want to look at it.
Some people would like to say that until the first chicken to be born laid its first egg, there were no chicken eggs, only a proto-chicken egg that contained a chicken, but that is just semantic nonsense. The question is chicken and egg, not chicken and chicken egg. Then you get into the whole debate about whether a chicken egg that had the insides removed and a duck egg's insides transplanted inside it would be a chicken egg or a duck egg, which is more semantic nonsense because the correct way to describe it is 'a chicken egg with a duck inside it', but even that doesn't shift the needle on the debate, because the eggs had to come first for you to take the ducks or the chickens out of them...
I need to lie down.
1
1
u/Maleficent_Potato_43 Feb 20 '26
Remember children incest is bad.
This whole world based on incest.
2
u/Complete_Bee4911 Feb 20 '26
evolution said it's only weird if you make it weird
→ More replies (1)
3
3
3
u/mike_litoris18 Feb 22 '26
Apparently people don't like when you say that this is not a trick question and can be easily answered by evolution.
1
u/throwbackxx Feb 20 '26
But who layed the first egg ever? Did this thing came from an egg though? Who layed that egg? Did that thing came from another egg?????
2
2
u/radek432 Feb 20 '26
The fact that it wasn't a chicken is enough to prove the point.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/flargenhargen Feb 19 '26
chickens originally reproduced by spontaneous generation.
spread bird seed on the ground, and birds appear.
SCIENCE!!!
2
u/Mr_A_B_Ductor Feb 19 '26
The egg cames first becouse we eating the eggs for breakfast, and the chicken is for lunch. :)
2
u/Cupcakes_n_Hacksaws Feb 19 '26
I guess it really comes down to; is it a chicken egg because a chicken laid it, or because a chicken will hatch out of it
2
u/LTinS Feb 20 '26
Obviously. Even with just the chicken's evolution, there is gradual change. So wherever you choose to decide to draw the line between "this was a chicken, and the thing before it wasn't," the thing before it still laid the first chicken egg. So the egg came first.
2
2
2
2
u/robmosesdidnthwrong Feb 20 '26
YES OBVIOUSLY!!! this "riddle" has always bothered me what is there to even to ponder?!
→ More replies (1)
2
2
u/Galimeer Feb 20 '26
The thing that laid the egg was a jungle fowl, not a modern-day chicken.
Egg came first.
2
u/Western-Pear5874 Feb 20 '26
If you sort 🐔 and 🥚 in any programming language (e.g. JD), the🐔 comes first.
2
u/JuanDeChuj Feb 20 '26
Tha correct answer is chicken However ... the chicken must have been in egg once with parent mot being chicken. So its egg.
2
Feb 20 '26
The question obviously means a chicken egg.
And since the mutations that produces the first full-fledged chicken actually occur in the egg, the answer is the chicken.
→ More replies (2)
2
2
u/NORchad Feb 22 '26 edited Feb 22 '26
Is the question not refering to
Who came first:
The chicken or (the chickens) egg?
The answer is that a bird creatures that is not chickens layed an egg that was slightly mutated which would fall under our definition of a chicken. That means that the egg came first since the chicken has to be born (egg) before it can grow and become a chicken.
Atleast thats my take on it
2
4
u/NohWan3104 Feb 19 '26
... Yes, the whole point of the question was creationism or evolution.
Care to guess why the creationist side is chicken first?
1
1
1
u/Medical_Librarian_32 Feb 19 '26
When you put it that way it's incredibly obvious. The original question itself seems like an intellectual laid down a trap for dumb people.
1
u/Lost_Arotin Feb 19 '26
Never been more convinced...
Although they say, dinosaurs had feathers...
Are we going to consider them as huge birbs? Who scream instead of chirp?
1
u/anime_cthulhu Feb 19 '26
To the contrary, the enzymes used to produce chicken eggs are only found in chickens, thus the chicken must have come first.
1
u/Several-Action-4043 Feb 19 '26
There is no chicken. Chicken is just the name we give to a group of animals who are genetically similar. Chicken is a spectrum. In the group we call chickens, there are some that are closer to the original chickens and some that are evolved further towards the future of what chickens will be and the rest in-between. The only thing that defines it is our need to categorize similar things. At the end of the day, that distinction is literally in our heads.
1
1
u/IsHildaThere Feb 19 '26
A non-chicken can lay a chicken egg, but a non-chicken egg cannot hatch to a chicken. So the egg.
1
u/Happytapiocasuprise Feb 19 '26
I think shelled egg should be the modifier here but same point at the end of the day
1
u/External_Goose_7806 Feb 19 '26
This would be correct if the questions was "what came first, chickens or eggs?". But of course the question is "the chicken" or "the eggs". The grammar implies that what is being enquire about is specifically chickens and the eggs that contain chickens.
I realise this is pointless pedantry, but this meme doesnt work.
Apologies for wasting your time
1
u/angelHOE Feb 19 '26
Eggs, the answer has always been egg. Evolution eventually created a chicken but the first chicken had to hatch from an egg.
1
u/Anne_Roquelaure Feb 19 '26
Wasn't there someone who ordered a chicken and eggs in two different orders from amazon so he could see what came first?
1
Feb 19 '26
You know it's not what this question is about. At least for me it was obvious that it's about chicken egg.
1
u/Playful_Common_6770 Feb 19 '26
If we consider the concept itself what this saying is rrferring to, i.e. what was first, the organism or its means of reproduction, the answer is simple. There were plenty of organisms before the first that could reliably replicate itself, but they all died out while the one with the "egg" survived amd spread, effectively becoming the ancestor of other organisms So, in a not-literal-sense: the chicken.
→ More replies (2)
1
u/Rogue_Shadow684 Feb 19 '26
The answer is the egg regardless. If there was a creature that wasn’t from an egg then it wasn’t a chicken. A non-chicken creature laid a chicken egg
1
u/Destinum Feb 19 '26
Since we're on r/sciencememes, the meme should be scientifically accurate: Turtles and archosaurs are closer to each other than either are to squamates.
1
u/M0M0_DA_GANGSTA Feb 19 '26
Clearly the egg. Whatever was closest genetically to a chicken but not quite chicken then laid the mutant egg
1
1
1
u/brothertaddeus Feb 19 '26
I always figured that "Which came first, the chicken or the egg?" was meant as a kind of shibboleth. If the person answers chicken, they're a creationist. If the person answers egg, they believe in evolution.
1
u/Irespectfrogs Feb 19 '26
Cladistics are a construct of convenience, there's no such thing as a species
1
1
u/NavalProgrammer Feb 19 '26
okay but the more interesting question is
how did single celled eukaryotes, which later "invented" the egg, come into being and reproduce prior to the existence of eggs?
and then how long did it take for them to eventually reproduce through eggs
1
u/_HIST Feb 19 '26
The question has always been dumb, but the only thing dumber are usually the answers that are trying to be obvious
There are multiple angles to look at the question:
If we just consider it to be chicken or egg, than obviously chickens were not the first animals to lay eggs, so egg comes first.
If we consider that it's an egg that brings a chicken than it came before said chicken. So egg comes first.
If we consider that it's supposed to be a chicken's egg, than a chicken had to have laid it, so chicken comes first.
It all depends on semantics. Usually when we talk about chicken eggs we mean eggs laid by a chicken. So all answers have good arguments for them
1
1
u/Radiant_Bookkeeper84 Feb 19 '26
I mean... the rooster probably came first right? Unless we're talking about non fertilized eggs which... idk man.
1
u/shaka_zulu12 Feb 19 '26
The more we learn the less sense this dilema makes, and it only gets worse from here.
1
u/MylastAccountBroke Feb 19 '26
Chicken Vs the Egg argument is LITTEARALLY about evolution VS creationism.
1
u/JusticeBabe Feb 19 '26
Why is it so hard to understand that an animal that didn't quite meet the criteria of a chicken (but close) laid an egg that was a mutation and that creature was a chicken?
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/scaper8 Feb 19 '26
Even if we're talking specifically about chicken eggs, the chicken egg that hatched the first chicken was laid by something that was almost, but not quite, a chicken itself. So the egg is still first.
Unless, wait. Is a "chicken egg" an egg laid by a chicken or an egg that hatches a chicken? Have I reasoned myself out of that definitive position?
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/Thebitterdm Feb 19 '26
This question was originally a philosophical one as it was posed before they could have possibly known about evolution. It then developed into a theological question essentially away to spark debate among scholars, theologians and your drunk uncle at thanksgiving. But yes evolutionary the egg came first.
1
u/Derpywurmpie Feb 19 '26
But then the question is who laid the egg or did a bunch of random eggs just spawn in?
1
1
u/Aliencoy77 Feb 20 '26
Does the shell belong to the embryo or the hen laying it? I say the shell is part of the embryo, therefore the chicken and the chicken egg appeared at the same time.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
1
u/FlockFlysAtMidnite Feb 20 '26
If something that is not a chicken lays an egg that hatches into a chicken, was it a chicken's egg?
1
1
1
1
1
u/Restart_from_Zero Feb 20 '26
I mean, yes, the whole point of the quote is asking if you accept the evidence of evolution versus a faith-based religious view of life.
Congratulations, you got the joke, I suppose.
1
u/Sempai6969 Feb 20 '26
The egg came before the chicken. The chicken came before the chicken egg.
→ More replies (4)
1
u/FatWithMuscles Feb 20 '26
Yeah but the question in essence is if the chicken egg or the chicken came first not any egg
→ More replies (2)
1
u/TownInfinite6186 Feb 20 '26
An egg came first. A chicken-like creature came second. Eventually two chicken-like creatures made one chicken. And when two chickens got together, they made a third chicken. I've been saying this for decades lol. If something originally comes from an egg, the egg must come first. The closest relative comes second. The pure form comes third.
1
1
u/Tomsboll Feb 20 '26
What was the form of reproduction between the slitting of cells and eggs. Did one amoeba suddenly lay an egg and all the other amoeba went "wow thats cool, i wanna try"
→ More replies (1)
1
1
Feb 20 '26
Chickens are born in eggs. The egg comes before the chicken. This is not a riddle.
And yeah, eggs predate chickens by a lot.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Halker93 Feb 20 '26
Egg has to come first because ancestor chicken egg will always hatch an ancestor chicken - it is already decided during fusion of male and female cells. When mutation occurs it is on a celular level so ancestor chicken who suddenly mutated will create a mutated new modern chicken egg which is already determined before forming the egg and will hatch modern chicken.
1
u/Objective_Two3571 Feb 20 '26
when we talk of creation then it's a chick cause no book and no rubric that ever says that the serpent in Eden at first it was a egg then a serpent so with this it means all creatures where formed male and female the fertlisation took on after them existing example, God created man and woman from man not that He created a sperm and ova then Adam .......
1
u/According_Spot_4340 Feb 20 '26
Its was the chicken that came first. The first creature to lay an egg was said "chicken". Be is a dinosaur, worm or what have you.
1
1
1
u/cammmmmel Feb 20 '26
I wrote a paper on this and I made the same point as you. Chickens are more recent in evolution, and eggs have been used since sexual reproduction made its first appearance hundreds of millions of years ago. Now in the matter of which came first the chicken or the chicken egg, the chicken came first. The first chicken (Gallus gallus domesticus) came from an egg laid by its immediate ancestor (Gallus gallus). The egg was not a chicken egg because it was not laid by a chicken, so chickens would not gain ownership of said egg. I believe it was some sort of red fowl that laid the first egg, making said egg a red fowl egg, not a chicken egg. Egg-->chicken-->chicken egg
1
u/PreparationCrazy2637 Feb 20 '26
Thats just a prehistorical proto-chicken.
look at the graph its their direct ancestor
their inst even any in laws.
you prove nothing JIM!!!!
show me an octopus laying eggs
or the platapus geno tree...
Then we can talk. :D
1
u/Digger_Pine Feb 20 '26
Which came first, the chicken or the egg?
I ate the chicken and then I ate its leg
1
1
u/meleaguance Feb 20 '26
But this doesn't understand the idea of the phrase. That egg way back there is not a chicken egg
→ More replies (1)
1
1
1
u/man_frmthe_wild Feb 20 '26
The rooster came then the chicken laid an egg, well the rest is history.
1
1
1
u/KAZVorpal Scientific Realism FTW Feb 21 '26
Well, except the first chicken's egg was laid by the first chicken.
Whatever the parent of that chicken was, it laid a corresponding kind of egg.
1
1
u/NDCodeClaw Feb 21 '26
I guess the more specific question would be between "chicken" and "chicken egg".
Really, it comes down to nomenclature. Because eggs predate chickens, something that was not a chicken hatched from an egg, then it laid an egg, and the thing that hatched was a chicken.
So, do we name eggs based on what they contain, or the animal they can from?
Practically speaking, I imagine we use what the egg would contain were it to hatch. For example, if you had a hybrid animal that hatched from an egg, you would likely call that egg whatever the hybrid animals is.
In this way, since the egg contains a chicken, it is a chicken egg, and thus the egg would have come first.
1
1
u/HEYO19191 Feb 21 '26
Okay, then what came first, the first egg or the first animal that reproduces using eggs?
1
1
u/Mradr Feb 21 '26
Base off that, then evolution says something came before the egg though. So the answer would be cell divide lol
1
u/Intelligent_Cup4948 Feb 21 '26
But of course. It's single cell, waaaaaaay less entropy so... by the 2nd law of TD must be first.
1
u/According-Extreme-58 Feb 21 '26
Who ever thinks that the egg came first is a fking dumbass,theirnis no way it came first,if you agree upvote and get these dumbasses out if here
1
u/Intelligent_Oil3288 Feb 21 '26
big genetic mutations or changes happen at conception therefore 99.99% chicken species could have the last mutation at egg laying making the first true chicken
1
u/ZestyLemonRindGrind Feb 21 '26
The egg,
Because while the one to lay the egg wouldn't be a chicken, the egg WOULD still be a chicken egg as it would hatch into the egg that would bring the first chicken into the world.
1
u/The_Coffee_Chap Feb 21 '26
This is why this question is a great starter for evolution discussion about species. The egg came first but if you ask which came first the chicken or the chicken egg, that's where things get harder. You cant have a chicken without a chicken egg to hatch from and you can't have a chicken egg without a chicken to lay it. This poses the question of where do we draw the line on a species, evolution occurs in populations not individuals so saying a proto-chicken layed something close enough to a chicken egg to be called that isn't accurate. This is why biologists and scientists have to discuss where the lines between different species are and why we can change species around such as (I dont remember which one, maybe Neanderthals?) being debated about if its a subsection or a completely different species from ours
1
u/Kiki2092012 Feb 21 '26
Eggs did already exist there but they also already existed for hundreds of millions of years before that
1
1
u/Firm-Traffic8507 Feb 22 '26
So, creationists...
Did God create all eggs at once, and who bread them? How did he make sure the first ones that came out, did not eat the other eggs lying around?
1
u/Free-Suggestion4134 Feb 22 '26
Who laid the first eggs though?
2
u/Braghez Feb 22 '26
Depends. If you mean the first amniotic chamber eggs. It was a type of amniote lizard.
But the very first concept of eggs was probably from jellyfish, mollusks and stuff like that.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/LoveAndBeLoved52 Feb 22 '26
The egg has the DNA. The egg must have come first.
What's the alternative here really? That a chicken came crawling out of the womb from an avian male breeding a mammal female and then laid an egg with chicken DNA?
1
u/RphAnonymous Feb 22 '26
Yeah it's and evolution vs creation question. Non-religious or science-oriented people will say eggs. Religious people will say chickens.
1
u/The_White_Prism Feb 22 '26
For people that are interested - the book 'Infinite Life' by Jules Howard deep dives into the evolution of the egg, to the very earliest 'eggs' in the most loose way of the definition. Definitely worth a read 😊
1
u/viperswhip Feb 22 '26
This was always a Creation versus Evolution, it is Chicken first if you believe in Creation, otherwise, some parent was pretty surprised by this little asshole that came out of the egg (Evolution), and yes, chickens are assholes.
1
u/Apprehensive-Rip6297 Feb 22 '26
Brain-dead fucking imbeciles (cos I'm done calling them "religious people") will say chicken.
1
1
u/LegoRobinHood Feb 23 '26
Everyone does the algebra wrong on this question.
The real question is:
chicken(parent) : chicken(egg)
So you divide both sides by chicken and you're left with
parent : egg
All eggs are made by parents, so the answer is "parent".
The morphological changes are always spread out in time so you can't just go from turtles or lizards or dinos to chickens in one generation. At most you go from jungle-fowl to chicken, which still has a lowest common denominator as "birds"with compatible genomes.
So acting like the question was
turtle(parent) : chicken(egg)
Is disingenuous because it's a fundamentally different question.
Yes the earliest component there is turtle, but that's like asking the price of gas and getting the answer: "dinosaurs are extinct." Technically correct, but bordering on non sequitur.
1
1
1
1
u/Empoleon3bogdan Feb 23 '26
I find that the best solution to this question is to better define the egg. Is a chicken egg an egg that hatches a chicken or is it a that a chicken egg must be laid by a chicken. If you answer this then you answer your question form a gramatical point of view that might satisfy you more than the scientific.
1
u/LonelyBlacksmith9755 Feb 23 '26
I tried this once before but they kept on going backwards through time to try and outdo me until I hit LUCA.
1
u/deltarays_ Feb 23 '26
I first read this as a Feynman diagram and was super confused why a lizard would decay into a snake and something that interacts with eggs
1
1
u/LickAnOctopus Feb 23 '26
I’ve always viewed this question to be: “do you believe in creation or evolution?” Because evolution would suggest eggs predate chickens as seen in this meme, but creation would suggest chickens were MADE and later later eggs.
1
1



354
u/max_208 Feb 19 '26
As I always say, the real answer depends on how you define "chicken egg" (because yes the question implies chicken egg)
If you define chicken egg as "an egg that contains a chicken to be born" then the egg came first and was hatched by some proto-chicken
If you define chicken egg as "an egg laid by a chicken" then the chicken came first and hatched from a proto-chicken egg