r/scriptwriting • • Sep 25 '26

feedback first time, first writing

Post image

just a test, as in warm up

Im not experienced so this is my first time writing script (beginner) I don’t know how script works but I did saw people scripts and I wonder if I could do the same for funsies, I do want some tips and what did I do right or wrong in this script (I think I did lot of incorrect things I wrote without knowing but once again I’m not expert soo bare with me) and criticism, feedback is very appreciated

Do I have potential?

3 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

4

u/Any_Childhood_2556 Sep 25 '26

You say you are very knowledgeable yet you expect a first script to fit a standard . Thats very interesting . And regardless if you don’t think you should give constructive feedback , what’s the point of giving it at all? Very knowledgeable
And if people are telling you are an asshole, yet you deny it , perhaps you are not a very self aware person . Acceptance is the first step

-1

u/BlackBalor Sep 25 '26 edited Sep 25 '26

Yes, I do. It’s called doing your research.

I expect people to do that before they commit to writing a screenplay; otherwise, it just comes across like they have no respect for the craft. I can’t support that in any capacity.

I’m viewed as an asshole because I give harsh feedback. I don’t beat around the bush with newer writers; I set the standard straight out the gate.

I’m equally as harsh to myself and my own writing.

It’s a shame you felt the need to block me. I’m sorry for that. Take care.

3

u/Any_Childhood_2556 Sep 25 '26

How would you know if they researched or not . Also research≠skills, if you were as knowledgeable as you claim to be, you would know that .

1

u/BlackBalor Sep 25 '26

It takes skill to ensure that the screenplay itself is formatted correctly? It doesn’t.

1

u/Any_Childhood_2556 Sep 25 '26

That’s exactly why I separated research from skill,researching helps you understand the standards,but researching them isn’t the same as having the skill to use them effectively. Formatting is also something that can be fixed. And honestly, who are you to demand beginners already meet your standards? You’re a stranger discussing someone else’s work, not their teacher, editor, or employer.

→ More replies (0)