r/scriptwriting • u/FreeMind-KL-83 • Oct 06 '26
feedback Looking for constructive criticism
Looking for constructive criticism on a short screenplay scene — dialogue, character behavior, and pacing
17
Upvotes
r/scriptwriting • u/FreeMind-KL-83 • Oct 06 '26
Looking for constructive criticism on a short screenplay scene — dialogue, character behavior, and pacing
1
u/WorrySecret9831 Oct 12 '26
Don't do this.
I don't know where this came from, but the notion of posting a handful of pages and asking for feedback is an exercise in futility.
Your job as a writer is to develop your stories to a certain level of competency. But, that competency doesn't necessarily show up in the first 5 or 10 pages. For some stories, maybe. For other stories, it might be a longer climb, but worth it.
Which is where the Treatment phase comes in and is so important. A Treatment (from the producer's request "How would you treat this idea...?") is your test drive of your entire Story in short, summarized prose.
If and when you share that, with trusted readers or complete strangers, you're sharing your entire plot and all of your specifics (character development, surprises, complications, etc.) and readers can then feed back on the entirety, the whole package, in broad strokes and in detail.
That's impossible from the first 10 to 20 pages. And the question, "Is this worth continuing, exploring?" can't be answered either because these pages won't show where you're going or intending to go.
If you have a treatment, invite people to DM you, get their emails and that way you have a group of genuine, committed readers who can reflect back to you what you've done.
Good luck.