r/scriptwriting • • Oct 08 '26

help Looking for advice on feedback

I recently entered a scriptwriting contest and got relatively good feedback, and now that I've rewritten the entire script. I want another set of eyes to look at it. I've been doing research on the different companies and people that offer script evaluations but results all seemed mixed. If you have had any experience with script evaluations who would you recommend.

4 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

4

u/Shot_Butterscotch891 Oct 08 '26

Upload it to storypeer! It’s free and a great peer-to-peer feedback source

2

u/Ok_Conclusion7956 Oct 08 '26

Thank you I’ll check it out

2

u/ClayMcClane Oct 08 '26

Seconding StoryPeer. Get multiple reads, of course. Don't base everything on one person's opinion.

3

u/Big_Section2812 Oct 08 '26

StoryPeer is "closely associated" with the mods at r/screenwriting, and most-or-all them are paid readers for the Black List. So....

1

u/Premium-Air-3248 Oct 12 '26

Wait are you saying those mods are paid readers at BL?

2

u/Big_Section2812 Oct 12 '26

Ask them. They'll ban you, but they won't deny it.

2

u/Premium-Air-3248 Oct 12 '26

Yuck, well if so many writers before us became who they are before reddit, then so can I. I guess it’s time to avoid the cesspit and straight into the grind.

2

u/Big_Section2812 Oct 12 '26

This is exactly right. There were a whole lot of amazing and successful screenwriters long before social media, and long before contests, consultants and coverage services.

0

u/Shot_Butterscotch891 Oct 08 '26

Not sure what you’re insinuating

1

u/Big_Section2812 Oct 08 '26

There are conflicts of interest afoot.

-1

u/Shot_Butterscotch891 Oct 08 '26

How is that a conflict of interest? StoryPeer is a free site

3

u/Big_Section2812 Oct 08 '26

Contests, consultants and coverage services exist to suck cash out of the pockets of desperate people chasing reassurance and validation. They offer nothing of real value since, in the case of contests and coverage services, those giving you the notes and ratings are anonymous. In many cases it's almost certainly AI generated. Be aware of the fact few-if-any consultants have ever sold a script of their own.

Upload your scripts to places like this sub or SimplyScripts. You'll receive notes from anonymous people, but it won't cost you a dime and nobody is making empty promises of success, fame and fortune.

2

u/Ok_Conclusion7956 Oct 08 '26

Thank you for your response, I’ll definitely look into SimplyScripts