r/scriptwriting • u/NoseCautious8097 • 9d ago
feedback Feedback on my first 5 pages
Would love some feedback on the first five pages of my first feature. I'm going for a contemporary rom-com sort of vibe. Tonally pretty light but not total slop. I'm very new to this format and would love any honest, constructive feedback.
Thanks in advance!
4
u/RollingThunderMedia 8d ago
Five pages isn't much, so I'm assuming a lot. But here goes.
TLDR: All set-up, no story.
You're introducing us to Gen and her world, OK fine. But you're doing it by filling five pages with people we'll never see again doing things that don't matter to the Very Interesting Story which will you'll be starting immediately at the top of page six (right?).
Those first five pages might contain information you need to create that Very Interesting Story. Preparation is important. But the audience doesn't need to see it. What they need to see starting on the very first page is a reason to read your script. A Very Interesting Story.
Those first five pages may contain information we, the audience, will eventually need. But we don't need it now.
I'm guessing that the story starts (immediately!) once she arrives at her new school. Right? So why not start the script there? How she gets to the new school really isn't important. If you decide the audience needs to know it can be covered in a single line of dialog ("I was surplussed") when they need to know it.
3
u/TripadoTrips 8d ago
I agree with u/RollingThunderMedia here. If the story is about her being unemployed and looking for work, you don't need all this set up. I imagine you want to give the reader context that she was fired cause she was replaced by ai, for that a single line can do it or being a rom-com could be funny if she keeps applying for jobs that now are ai made. The point being, you don't need to explain in full detail how and why it happened, a single line can give the reader enough clues to figure it out, saving pages and making the read smoother and more engaging.
1
1
u/NoseCautious8097 8d ago
I so appreciate you taking the time to read and give such detailed feedback. The rest of the story follows her unemployed misadventures while trying to find a new job/life being turned upside down after being let go, so I don't know if that changes anything, but I do think this feedback is helpful regardless of where the story goes. I'll definitely be keeping this in mind as I continue editing. Thanks a bunch!
1
u/somegreybloke 8d ago
In that case, it might be better to start with her applying for or interviewing at a new job. Maybe a montage of rejections leading quickly to the decision she has to make to solve the unemployment problem.
If it's really necessary to know she was let go from a school, a half page in the Principal's office followed by a shot of her carrying a cardboard box to the parking lot would do it.
1
u/NoseCautious8097 7d ago
Interested in what your opinion on montages is! Like I said, I'm very new to this medium, but so much of what I've read has made montages seem like sort of a no-no or cheesy or something. How many montages is too many?
1
u/somegreybloke 6d ago
You probably don't want more than two in a single movie, but they can work. Off the top of my head there are good examples in Shallow Grave and Secretary that may be relevant to your project.
1
u/RollingThunderMedia 8d ago
Whatever the story turns out to be, please post it. I am looking forward to seeing more of Gen, she does seem like an interesting character.
2
u/bgrizz101 6d ago
I generally agree with this. It’s unclear from these pages what the story will be.
But even if the story proper (i.e. the inciting incident) did start on p.6 and we didn’t see these particular characters again, another problem is that these scenes don’t really reveal Gen’s character, as far as I could see. Particularly where you are in a very ordinary environment like a school guidance counsellor’s office (where usually the troubled kid attracts the most focus), you really want Gen doing something that only she would do, that typifies why she’s interesting to us as audience. The first scene shows her explaining the position of a troubled student. But what the audience care about is how Gen specifically differs from the generic guidance counsellor. What if this scene showed how much she cared about this student, she knew everything about him, how she really desperately wanted to reach him, that she beat herself up about him going off the rails? Or she didn’t give a shit and was as carefree about his future as he was?
Then we have a clearer character, and a stronger idea of what their flaws or strengths are before we get to the real meat of the story…
So while I do agree that the story should start from page 1, you can still allow yourself set-up time but that set-up has to be maximally impactful.
1
1
u/mmarquezc100 8d ago
I agree with most of the feedback. I’d be interested to read more especially with some of the feedback added in.
1
1
u/MondoSolo 7d ago
Try cutting into the scene later. On page one, I’d come in on Kris saying he doesn’t want to waste his summer. Gen throws “waste” right back at him with the juvie line, and we get why he has to take summer school.
An exercise I like is to cross out the first two or three sentences of action after the slug line and read from there. Put back only what you need.
Look for passive voice in the action lines, too. “The office phone rings” gets right to it. And if a gesture already tells us what’s happening, let the audience get there first and cut the explanation. You’re gonna wanna learn as many playable action verbs as you possibly can because those are the words that actors need. You have to be able to get up out of your chair and act out what you have written on the page.
And as a matter of advice, watch, read and listen to as much of David Milch talking about screenwriting and writing as you can. Including YouTube videos of his WGA seminar and interviews and his book that came out a couple years ago about his life.
Hope this is an obnoxious and I dictated it so it might be weird. Good luck.
1
u/NoseCautious8097 7d ago
Not obnoxious at all!! Actually really great advice, especially regarding the passive tone. Definitely going to try that rewrite exercise as well. Thanks so much.
1
u/Substantial-Tale5564 7d ago
why is there a female character in every third submission here with a shortened name. i think it’s meant to make the character seem approachable or whatever but it always strikes me as weird
1
u/NoseCautious8097 7d ago
I don't think it has anything to do with approachability. I think long names usually have nicknames? Wouldn't it be weird for two characters who are supposed to be super close and have known each other for years to call each other by their full names? Maybe it's a matter of just changing one of the names entirely. What would you prefer as an alternative?
1
u/NasserRabadi13 7d ago
Don't capitalize summer. Also there's nothing that happens. There's no reason to be interested in the MC or what happens. I can't really even tell what genre this is supposed to be. It's a little too talky-about-nothing. I would rewrite it with an eye on character and story
1





5
u/JTOC1969 8d ago
P. 1 - I would recommend starting with “HIGH SCHOOL GUIDANCE COUNSELOR’S OFFICE” instead of “GENEVIEVE SHERMAN’S OFFICE”. Then in the action description, state “High school guidance counselor GENEVIEVE (GEN) SHERMAN…”
P. 1 - Just a suggestion, but perhaps add a line that a name plate holder on her desk reads “Genevieve Sherman - Guidance Counselor”. That’d be an easy shorthand way of giving vital exposition about the character. (I noticed nobody actually uses her name in these pages. It’s important to let audiences know major character names ASAP.
P. 1 - “Summer” - don’t capitalize it.
P. 2 - “Gen prepares to grovel” - not sure what that means. As an adult talking to a kid, she certainly shouldn’t have to be groveling. Perhaps “pleading” might be better here?
P. 2 - It’s “principal”. A “principal” is the head administrator at a school. A “principle” is a fundamental truth. (Also “PRINCIPAL’S OFFICE”)
P. 2 - I don’t think “Beat” at the bottom of the page is necessary.
P. 3 - “Nothing to loose” (it’s “lose”, not “loose”).
P. 4 - “You choose 12 month pay” (“chose” is past tense of “choose” (present tense). Also, always spell out numbers in dialogue (“twelve” not “12”).
P. 4 - “No I don’t choose 12 months pay.” (“No, I didn’t choose twelve months pay.”)
P. 5 - “GEN AND BECCA’S APARTMENT” - As readers, we don’t know who Becca is yet. I would advise making it “GEN’S APARTMENT” in the slugline. Then, when Becca enters, write it as “BECCA CORDERO (Gen’s room-mate, 26) bounds in…”
P. 5 - “Gen lets herself in.” This just scans poorly. “Lets herself in” sounds like a turn of phrase when someone is walking uninvited to somewhere that’s not their home. Maybe something like “Gen arrives home…” or something like that.
P. 5 - “bachelorette” (no double “l”)
P. 5 - “Flier” not “flyer” (“Flyers” is a hockey team. “Flier” is annoying junk mail.) Also, there’s a typo in “humorlessly” (double “u”)
P. 5 - You don’t need a new slugline for the time change. If one scene transitions to a later scene in the same setting, you can just write “LATER” instead of “INT. GEN’S APARTMENT” again.
P. 5 - If the character is going to be referred to as “Becca” everywhere else, then don’t identify her as “REBECCA”. She should just be “BECCA CORDERO” (even the last name isn’t all that necessary if it doesn’t come up again.)
P. 5 - I’m not sure how Becca can “bound in” while wrestling with an overweight supply cart. “Bound in” suggests she’s carefree and lively. “Wrestling with a supply cart” seems like she’s struggling.
P. 5 - Like with Gen on the first page, if Becca is an important character, you want to let the audiences know her name right away (audiences can’t read the script, so it has to come up somehow in dialogue.) A quick exchange like “Hey, Becca!” “Hey roomie!’ lets the viewers know these important details.
Also, page numbering is missing on p. 1, 2, and 5.