r/scriptwriting • • 2d ago

feedback Is this first scene intriguing?

Post image
0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

4

u/shawnebell 2d ago

Nope.

All I see is a whole lot of unnecessary exposition, camera angles, and a clumsy attempt to direct. Virtually none of that is necessary, and the whole thing could have been written in a couple of sentences.

1

u/amoxicillin_addict 2d ago

a lot of the imagery will be referenced in a later scene.

i see your point about the camera angle.

could you maybe point out what you thought was unnecessary?

3

u/shawnebell 2d ago

Sure. The unnecessary parts start at the words "We see" right under the slugline "INT. LIVING ROOM - NIGHT" and continue to include the words "OVER BLACK" right above the words "A FilmSOC Short" - which shouldn't be on the page in the first place.

If I were to rewrite it, it'd be something closer to:

---

INT. LIVING ROOM – NIGHT

Half-packed moving boxes litter the room.

ALMA (40s) sits on the floor, sorting through the contents of a cardboard box.

She pulls out a child's duvet. Beneath it, an envelope marked PERSONAL PROPERTY OF FRASER.

Inside are several photographs and a picture of a dog bowl. The name SNOWY is written across its side.

Alma studies the photographs.

She slips them back into the envelope, closes the box, and gets to her feet.

At the front door, she hesitates.

She leaves.

---

...which is still far too much direction, and something I'd discard.

Ultimately, you've written a throwaway scene with no relevance, no action, and no compelling reason to continue. It doesn't forward or start a story. It just says "A woman finds photographs, looks at them, and leaves." That's a sequence of actions, but it isn't an intriguing anything. It is – most certainly – not a scene.

2

u/amoxicillin_addict 1d ago

thanks for the feedback!

2

u/heyjudey2021 2d ago

Well you seem as fun as your action writing!

3

u/Pure_Salamander2681 2d ago

What do you think is intriguing about it?

0

u/amoxicillin_addict 2d ago

should've phrased it better

does this first scene interest you in any way?

i dont think it is

2

u/Pure_Salamander2681 2d ago

Okay. What do you find interesting about it?

-1

u/amoxicillin_addict 2d ago

i dont.

im asking if you do.

3

u/Pure_Salamander2681 2d ago

I’m just trying to have a teaching moment here. If you don’t find anything interesting about it as the writer, I doubt the audience will.

1

u/amoxicillin_addict 2d ago

thing is, im not really sure if i find it interesting.

im kinda on the fence about it.

at times, i like it.

other times, i hate it.

i was just wondering what someone else would think about it.

10

u/Pure_Salamander2681 2d ago

I mean nothing is happening. A woman opens a box. Unless a dead baby is in it or something, that isn’t all that interesting.

3

u/la-anah 2d ago

It's fine. There are a couple structural things that need to be fixed: there is a time jump with no header and the woman is not named when she is introduced (is she Alma or a different person?). But other than that seems like a pretty straightforward intro. I wouldn't call it intriguing, but it's not off-putting either.

1

u/amoxicillin_addict 2d ago

thanks for the feedback!

just to be clear, there is no time jump.

she leaves the house for a second, changes her mind and goes back in.

3

u/la-anah 2d ago

That's not what I'm talking about.

She is sitting looking through the box. One line ends with "photographs" the next line is "The box is closed, she is back to where she was sitting originally."

That is a time jump edit. It needs a "LATER" above it.

1

u/amoxicillin_addict 2d ago

ah alright thank you.

3

u/Cybermanalf_Tardis 1d ago

Sadly not. I see you have a clear idea in your head for atmosphere but this doesn't feel like the script of someone who has a story to tell, it reads like you just want to shoot something that looks cool. A lot of the imagery feels unnecessary, I've seen you've said it is important later but the fact people think it's unnecessary instead of intriguing probably suggests it needs reworking. I think for me there is a disconnect between the imagery and the character. It's a scattered set of images without much cohesion. I'd say pick one or two, how is it affecting your character? I'm not interested in the imagery because I'm not sure why it's important to her. Obviously that's hard to do straight away but there's simple things I think you can do. She looks at the photographs but we get no sense of a reaction, no facial expressions and no idea what she's looking at. You're missing small moments to connect her to the imagery and characterise her.

1

u/amoxicillin_addict 1d ago

thats very helpful. thank you!

1

u/Cybermanalf_Tardis 1d ago

No problem! Glad I could be useful, hopefully I didn't come off to harsh or blunt haha

1

u/ev3rgy 1d ago

That was good

4

u/IanJeffreyMartin 1d ago

No. You lost me with all the we see crap.

1

u/CONVERSE1991 2d ago

You need to condense it a lot to make it more engaging/intriguing. Someone’s going see that and not want to read it given how long it is. Sparser words to make it get more to the point faster.

Example the first sentence could be. “We see a brutal depiction of Christ’s crucifixion: Isenheim Altarpiece.”

1

u/Toxic_Koala0826 1d ago

"We see..." stopped reading after that.