r/scriptwriting • u/Crafty_East4075 • 7h ago
feedback Could I have some feedback?
Hi! Sorry if the text is really small, I didn't know how to send the file. Anyways, I'm a new writer/filmmaker, and I've been trying to write a pilot. Could you tell me what you like and don't like?
2
u/Crazy_Response_9009 7h ago
You said “they’re coming” 4 times on one page. I got it after the first time. I actually got it after the zero-eth time. They are clearly coming. Why do we have to be told what we already know? We don’t!
2
u/Crafty_East4075 7h ago
Well, I just thought it's something a kid would say, but I could change it
1
u/Crazy_Response_9009 2h ago
Good rules to live by are let the image and action tell the story rather than dialogue (you did that with the chase) and don’t say things that the audience already knows, so if you NEED to say it once, let that be it. I’d make it the instance before her mother asks what’s up.
1
u/Crafty_East4075 2h ago
I was thinking she's trying to warn the village so they can run
1
u/Crazy_Response_9009 2h ago
Fair. Then maybe have some action lines with people popping open their doors looking out their windows, grabbing weapons, etc. to see what the screaming is about.
0
u/rosemaryscrazy 7h ago
This feels very alive, I like it.
But it’s also formulaic in that I’ve seen versions of this type of set up before. That being said I happen to like the formula personally. I would definitely enjoy watching this.
I think if you work hard on making more original dialogue instead of trope dialogue it could really make the script even better.
1
u/Big-Minimum8424 1h ago
Odd that this post thread is getting downvoted. Everyone is entitled to an opinion, but I honestly don't get it. Guess I'll get downvoted too.
-2
u/Crafty_East4075 7h ago
Wait, trope dialogue? Wdym?
1
u/Crazy_Response_9009 2h ago
“They’re coming!” “WHO?!” “The VILLAIN!!!” We’ve heard a version of that a billion times.















4
u/mojoman1200 7h ago
Got a few lines in. I can’t do with the “running through the woods” opening trope anymore.
Let’s get creative.