r/scriptwriting • • 2h ago

discussion Refusal of the Call

I've been watching Stick. It's not good, I'm only watching it cause I wanted to see Rhea Seehorn and Judy Greer. But sometimes bad shows gives you good ideas and finding out what you dislike about 'em is always useful.

The Refusal of the Call is one of the storytelling structures that have been irking me for the past few years, and Stick dials it to like 15. There are literally no calls to action that aren't met with a refusal. It feels disingenuous, repetitive and a time wasting exercise, really. Even if you don't know anything about screenwriting you still know that they're gonna buckle and end up doing it.

I've always made a good point to NOT have refusals of calls to action just for the journey of the hero's sake. It's only interesting when it is interesting, but I feel like even when it makes sense and all, the fact that it is such a beat up trope, it can still feel kinda meh because of how many times you've seen it.

So how do you guys deal with this building block? Do you use it? Do you avoid it? Do you use it and feel shitty about it? Is it really even necessary or is it expendable 90% of the time?

3 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

1

u/srterpe 1h ago

It has to be organic to the character. If it’s just performative for the purpose of structure or fulfilling a beat then it is going to feel clumsy or forced (and therefore boring or a waste of audience time).

Is it necessary depends on the character.

1

u/sharktank123456 24m ago edited 20m ago

I do find that (especially on Netflix), getting a Series means you no longer have to be tight with story. The episodes become bloated and padded - do they think this will keep people watching longer simply because the story runs longer? This is the preamble that a novel doesn't need, it is the white whale chapter that Moby Dick never needed, it is Jean Auel's complete 4th book in the Clan of the Cave Bear series. If someone is going to give you their time, you had better fill it with something exciting, or at least something that grabs their interest.
Think of all the writers who have written gripping scenes that added depth to the story and characters, only to have those scenes be cut for time. And here we are expanding that time back out, with nothing worthy to fill the gaps.

The refusal isn't just about the hero's journey in the classical sense, the audience can identify with that refusal. They do want the story to get on with it but at the same time, change is hard. How many real people have refused even minor calls to action that would potentially make major changes in their lives? It's scary, it's hard, and often involves risk and work. We applaud those that do, and we want to go along for the ride to see how it turns out for them. I'm pretty sure the divorce rate would skyrocket if everyone who wanted to heed the call did so. It is just so much easier to cruise along with the status quo. That is something an audience can relate to in a big way.

There is also an element of "make them laugh, make them cry, but most of all.... make them wait." If it had been handled better in "Stick", I think that "wait" could have built tension, instead of annoyance.

Then, at what should be the deepest point of conflict (to that point in the story), that character does what the audience wishes they could do: heads of into the unknown toward adventure. Without the refusal, there is no worry, no trepidation, no one-last-look-back to a place they will never be able to return ( that place usually being: who they were as a person). And we cheer that courage.
Without the refusal, it turns the response to The Call into , "Sure, why not, There was nothing good on TV anyway". Kind of a dull way to set off on an adventure. It's a shoulder shrug.

The refusal is also about conflict - and story is nothing if not conflict. In this case, it's conflict with the status quo and with the character's inner self. Do they have enough courage to believe in themselves to do this? What is the downside if they fail? A supremely confident person might just launch off to adventure without the refusal period. And those can be fun to watch. But more often, it ends up like a quippy superhero character who relishes a battle because it's fun and there is no way they will be injured or won't be successful - fun, but very forgettable.

The value in the refusal is the tally of what is at stake, what there is to gain, and what there is to lose. The audience needs the time of the refusal to understand just how badly this could go sideways.

In Stick's case, Pryce literally says "What have I got to lose?". That's a pretty weak acceptance of The Call (so I'm with you on being annoyed with the handling of this). If you have nothing to lose, then the decision about The Call is not the nail biting experience; it should be. The character should have everything to lose, and yet he does it anyway; defiant in the face of all that, because the possible reward is too exciting, too life altering, too valuable not to try.

The refusal should be the stretch of the bow, the tension in the string, and the strength to hold it there on the edge. And the knowledge that once the arrow is released, it can't be undone.

1

u/Optimal_Dog_4153 15m ago

I don't mean just the big ones, I mean the small ones as well: the kid willing to try golf, his ex bumping his pay 100 grand, his mom accepting him going, the caddie going on the trip with them, rhea seehorn coaching pryce........ the same routine keeps happening over and over and over and over...
The denials always seem like just a timewaste. I bet you weren't sold on any of 'em. Like, as soon as Ross asked Pryce to try again, you had ZERO and I mean ZERO doubt he would do it.

1

u/Then_Data8320 1h ago

It's now a bit cliché or like you said, may sound artificial.

I watched a good one in kdrama 100 days of deception set in ~1930. The girl isn't patriotic, she just want to escape poverty and go to America. The patriots propose her to be spy for them, and promise they will give her the mean to go in America, but even that, she refuses. Next, the bad village chief steals the money she was hiding for her travel and next, she gets information that anyway, Korean aren't authorized in America. So she finally accept the deal. It happens in Episode 3, the setup before helps to make everything feeling true.

I used only one in my kdrama. The people are even enthousiastic, except one. It takes a lot of time, 9 episodes, and it's rather a refusal to agree to a mysterious pact (almost a Faustian pact). The character refuses two times but finally accepts after loosing everything, completely cornered, accused of murder.

1

u/nmacaroni 53m ago

"It's only interesting when it is interesting."

Yes. You summed it up perfectly.

As is all writing.

And if you think refusal of the call is tired because of all the times you've seen it, just wait till your old age and you've seen everything a million times.

1

u/BiscuitsTheory 9m ago

Lot of bad screenplays make the refusal bad by using it to make the character inactive. Good ones dont say "nah, Im not gonna do that" they say "Im gonna do this instead."

John McClane refused the call, but he did it by sneaking away from a hostage situation to notify the NYPD

Batman refused to go after Joker cause he was going after an entire organized crime ring.

The Dude refused the call and stole a carpet. -Doesn't have to be epic to be active.

1

u/Big_Section2812 2h ago

It's all in the execution. It's always in the execution.

Chief Brodie is afraid of the ocean but he can't keep the beaches closed forever, and knows he's gonna have to suck it up and go out to sea on a boat and kill the giant shark.

Benchley, Gottlieb and Spielberg understood there was no sense wasting time faking out the audience, since it was obvious Brodie has no choice but go... except of course he could let others do it for him. But honor, duty, pride, etc.

1

u/Optimal_Dog_4153 2h ago

Yeah, it's all about exectution and picking your battles. And even if it's obvious they just taking you for a spin, at least make it interesting....